Reap the Wild Wind Blu-ray Review
Score: 62
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
"Reap the Wild Wind" delivers mixed results with stunning visual quality on Blu-ray but lacks a consistent and engaging narrative, though fans of John Wayne and Cecil B. DeMille may find it worthwhile.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 66
Reap the Wild Wind’s Blu-ray debut from Kino Lorber offers a 1080p MPEG-4 AVC encoded presentation in its original 1.37:1 aspect ratio, featuring vibrant color reproduction and natural film grain. However, the transfer reveals dust and scratches, indicating limited restorative work but still marks a significant improvement over previous releases.
Audio: 81
The audio presentation in DTS-HD Master Audio mono offers exceptional dialogue clarity and a strong score, maintaining fidelity with minimal aging issues—likely the best possible on home video.
Extra: 26
The Extras of 'Reap the Wild Wind' Blu Ray feature a high-resolution Animated Image Gallery (16:25) showcasing nearly 200 black-and-white stills that offer an excellent behind-the-scenes glimpse, despite lacking chapter skip and music; includes theatrical trailer (2:17) and multiple KLSC promotional trailers in varying resolutions.
Movie: 51
Despite striking technicolor visuals and impressive special effects, 'Reap the Wild Wind' flounders with a draggy narrative and lackluster screenplay, failing to live up to Cecil B. DeMille's other works despite strong performances from John Wayne and Paulette Goddard.
Video: 66
The Blu-ray release of "Reap the Wild Wind" from Kino Lorber features a 1080p MPEG-4 AVC encoded high-definition transfer in the original 1.37:1 theatrical aspect ratio. The presentation retains the pillar-boxed opening credits while keeping the main film devoid of black bars, staying true to its original format. Notably, the color reproduction is quite commendable, showcasing the rich Technicolor photography effectively and keeping the image filmic, with a naturally preserved grain structure. However, the age of the scan is apparent, with occasional particles of dust and thin scratches marring the viewing experience, indicating a limited amount of restorative work.
Despite these minor imperfections, the HD transfer provides a marked improvement over previous home video iterations. Grain is consistently strong and organic, lending authenticity to the filmic experience. Technicolor hues are rendered faithfully, with minimal registry errors and fine details remaining intact. While not without flaws, the absence of excessive dirt, scratches, or tears speaks to a solid encoding effort. Thus, this Blu-ray presentation is likely the definitive version for home viewing, making it an essential acquisition for cinephiles and classic film enthusiasts alike.
Audio: 81
The audio presentation of "Reap the Wild Wind" on Blu-ray is delivered in DTS-HD Master Audio mono, offering a reasonably impressive soundtrack given the age of the source material. The dialogue reproduction is exceptional; voices are clear and strong, allowing for an engaging listening experience. While the music score by Victor Young may sound slightly thin and less pronounced than desired, it remains free from disruptive elements such as hiss, pops, or other audio defects. This balanced clarity is a significant advantage of the lossless mix.
Moreover, sound effects are robust and integrate well with the overall audio track, providing strong ambiance and fidelity without being overly intrusive. Notably, despite the film's historical background, the DTS-HD Master Audio track ensures that issues typically associated with older films—such as crackling, hissing, or distortion—are virtually non-existent. Optional English subtitles are also available, catering to diverse viewer needs and ensuring accessibility. Overall, this audio presentation marks a significant improvement over previous editions and likely stands as the definitive audio experience for this classic film.
Extras: 26
The Blu Ray extras for "Reap the Wild Wind" offer a comprehensive dive into the historical and production aspects of the film. The Animated Image Gallery, featuring nearly 200 high-resolution stills, provides an insightful behind-the-scenes look, although the lack of chapter skip functionality and musical accompaniment detracts slightly from the experience. Additionally, a selection of trailers, both for "Reap the Wild Wind" and other Kino Lorber titles, enriches the offering with contextual marketing materials. These elements collectively enhance the viewer's understanding and appreciation of the film's legacy.
Extras included in this disc:
Animated Image Gallery: High-resolution stills from production and promotional materials. Reap the Wild Wind Trailer: Original promotional trailer. Bonus KLSC Trailers:
- The Spoilers
- Pittsburgh
- Legend of the Lost
- Brannigan
- Panic in Year Zero
- The Premature Burial
- X: The Man With the X-Ray Eyes
Movie: 51
"Reap the Wild Wind," directed by Cecil B. DeMille, is a Technicolor adventure set in the turbulent Florida Keys of the 1840s. The story centers around Loxi Claiborne (Paulette Goddard), a headstrong woman running her family's salvage business, and the two men vying for her affections: Captain Jack Stuart (John Wayne) and Stephen Tolliver (Ray Milland). The plot revolves around shipwrecks, courtroom drama, and a memorable climactic battle with a giant squid, which showcases the film's impressive special effects—a factor that arguably earned it an Oscar for the same.
Despite the film's visually striking qualities, including lush cinematography by Victor Milner and rich production design by Hans Dreier, which received Oscar nominations, "Reap the Wild Wind" falls short in narrative execution. The screenplay by Alan Le May, Charles Bennett, and Jesse Lasky Jr. suffers from inconsistency and poorly developed characters. While DeMille's direction provides some grandeur, it is undermined by a sluggish pace and a lack of cohesive storytelling. The film's editing by Anne Bauchens exacerbates these issues, leading to a lengthy and often dragging middle section.
The cast delivers commendable performances, with Paulette Goddard embodying a fiery Southern belle and John Wayne stepping outside his typical western roles. Ray Milland adds depth as Wayne's romantic rival. However, these performances cannot fully compensate for the film's structural weaknesses. The costume designs by Natalie Visart also deserve recognition, adding a layer of visual appeal to an otherwise uneven film. Despite its flaws, "Reap the Wild Wind" remains a notable entry in DeMille's filmography for its technical achievements and larger-than-life production values.
Total: 62
Kino Lorber delivers a solid Blu-ray presentation of "Reap the Wild Wind," an adventurous spectacle directed by the legendary Cecil B. DeMille. Set amidst the high seas, the film showcases John Wayne, Ray Milland, and Paulette Goddard as they navigate a lush maritime narrative that is as captivating as it is visually striking. While some viewers may find portions of the film meandering and lacking in excitement until the climactic finale, the overall production shines through with its grandiose set pieces and characteristically lavish DeMille direction.
Audio and visual fidelity on this Blu-ray release are commendable, with Kino ensuring a crisp and vibrant transfer that honors the film's original Technicolor glory. Fans of classic cinema will particularly appreciate the attention to detail in the restoration efforts. The audio quality accentuates the film’s score and dialogue, delivering an immersive experience that resonates with the grandeur of Old Hollywood.
In conclusion, "Reap the Wild Wind" may not sustain peak excitement throughout its runtime, but it remains a valuable piece of cinematic history and a testament to DeMille's filmmaking prowess. This Blu-ray release is highly recommended for collectors, fans of John Wayne or Cecil B. DeMille, and those who appreciate classic adventure films with high production values. While it may not convert every modern viewer, it stands as an important and entertaining slice of 1940s Hollywood escapism.
Blu-ray.com review by Neil LumbardRead review here
Video: 70
The transfer frequently has particles of dust and thin scratches which appear on the print and are a minor distraction from the viewing experience....
Audio: 80
The soundtrack is reasonably impressive with excellent clarity throughout the presentation....
Extras: 20
Animated Image Gallery (16:25) presents high-resolution still photographs which are assembled from the production and which display behind-the-scenes materials, actor/actress portfolios, marketing materials,...
Movie: 40
The film also utilized a wide range of beautiful costume designs by Natalie Visart (Meet John Doe, The Story of Dr. Wassell) which showcase the many actresses in the film dressed in beautiful gowns: from...
Total: 50
While the film has plenty of beautiful actresses, a cute dog, and occasionally interesting moments, the end result feels like a chore....
Home Theater Forum review by t1g3r5fanRead review here
Video: 80
Film grain is strong and organic and the Technicolor hues are given a faithful rendering with minimal instance of registry errors present; fine details are also faithfully rendered with very few instances...
Audio: 100
There’s nary an instance of problems due to age (crackling, hissing, distortion, etc.), which means that this is likely the best the movie will ever sound on home video and an improvement over previous...
Extras: 40
Bonus KLSC Trailers – The Spoilers, Pittsburgh, Legend of the Lost, Brannigan, Panic in the Year Zero, The Premature Burial & X: The Man with the X-Ray Eyes....
Movie: 70
In his only film working for DeMille, John Wayne plays a character with a dark side to him, anticipating greater success further down the line with John Ford’s The Searchers (1956); The Duke apparently...
Total: 80
A hit both critically and at the box office, Reap the Wild Wind stands out as pure escapist entertainment and as one of Cecil B. DeMille’s best movies not named The Ten Commandments....
Director: Cecil B. DeMille
Actors: Ray Milland, John Wayne, Paulette Goddard
PlotSet in the mid-19th century along the southern coast of the United States, the film follows Loxi Claiborne, a headstrong and resourceful woman who manages a salvage business with her father. After a hurricane, Loxi and her crew rescue the survivors of a shipwreck, including Captain Jack Stuart. Stuart's ship, controlled by an unscrupulous shipping magnate, was wrecked in suspicious circumstances, leading Loxi to suspect foul play. As Loxi and Stuart grow closer, she decides to travel to Charleston to seek justice and clears his name. Her determination catches the attention of shipping magnate Stephen Tolliver, who is intrigued by her resolve but has his own motives.
In Charleston, a complex love triangle forms when Loxi finds herself torn between the courageous but impulsive Stuart and the principled yet ambitious Tolliver. Meanwhile, Tolliver begins to uncover a deeper conspiracy within the shipping industry that endangers everyone involved. As tensions rise, personal and professional conflicts come to a head. Loxi must navigate a treacherous path to not only uncover the truth but also reconcile her feelings and loyalties. The unfolding drama brings these characters into situations that test their courage and convictions, leading to unpredictable twists and life-altering decisions.
Writers: Alan Le May, Charles Bennett, Jesse Lasky Jr.
Release Date: 04 Jun 1942
Runtime: 123 min
Rating: Passed
Country: United States
Language: English