From Here to Eternity Blu-ray Review
Score: 66
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
'From Here to Eternity': A timeless, superbly crafted film, now in stellar Blu-ray.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 70
The Blu-ray release of 'From Here to Eternity' boasts a pristine, highly detailed transfer with rich black levels and naturalistic textures, significantly surpassing previous versions.
Audio: 70
'From Here to Eternity' Blu-ray features a DTS-HD 5.1 audio that enhances iconic scenes with clarity and depth, maintaining the film's classic feel while offering a rich soundscape.
Extra: 46
The 1953 Best Picture 'From Here to Eternity' DVD extras delve into its making, censorship, casting, and director Zinnemann's vision, offering insightful commentary and rare behind-the-scenes glimpses.
Movie: 81
From Here to Eternity," a film that broke 1950s taboo with its adult themes, won multiple Oscars while exploring moral complexities through the lives of soldiers in pre-WWII Hawaii.
Video: 70
The 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "From Here to Etnernity" impressively showcases the film’s immaculate restoration, serving up a viewing experience that far surpasses previous home video editions, including DVDs. The 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 transfer delivers a spectacularly clean image, free from the nicks and marks that previously marred its presentation, thanks to meticulous scrubbing of the source material. This Blu-ray preserves the nearly framed 4x3 image, consistent with the film’s original theatrical exhibition ratio, which is thoughtfully presented with vertical black bars on either side of the 1.78:1 frame to maintain authenticity. The result is a striking video that balances beautifully between preserving natural grain—lending a rich, filmic texture—and ensuring clarity and sharpness in every frame.
Detail and clarity are indeed the stars here, with the transfer revealing intricate textures and nuanced differences in grayscale, enhancing the film's gritty, realistic photography. The grain structure is preserved, contributing to the film's realism without compromising on clarity, even in complex patterns or rough exterior scenes. Black levels are deep and inky, contributing to the film's visual depth, with only minimal instances of crush noted. Bright whites and neutral grays are handled impeccably, ensuring a vibrantly nuanced image that brings out previously unseen details, from the heavy creases in military attire to the unique textures of Hawaiian shirts and the distinct sharpness of raindrops in key scenes.
Critically, the application of Digital Noise Reduction (DNR) appears minimal and judiciously applied, eluding detection and avoiding the pitfalls of overprocessing. Consequently, this leads to a natural, smooth presentation devoid of digital artifacts, allowing for an authentic cinematic experience. "From Here to Eternity" on 4K UHD Blu-ray represents a significant upgrade over all previous versions, with its visual presentation setting a high benchmark for black-and-white films on the format. Fans and newcomers alike will find this release an essential addition to their collection, offering the best way to experience the film’s stunning visual storytelling.
Audio: 70
The 4K UHD Blu-ray audio presentation of "From Here to Eternity" with its DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track delivers an audibly enriching experience that simultaneously pays homage to its mono origins while embracing the depth and breadth modern technology affords. The restoration and expansion into a 5.1 surround setup breathe new life into the film’s sonic landscape, offering a balance between the front-and-center audio fidelity characteristic of its era and a more immersive, spatial sound environment. Key scenes gain a dynamic lift, particularly with the music’s wider, more robust spacings, while maintaining clear and honest clarity throughout. Dialogue remains anchored in the center, ensuring crisp and comprehensible exchanges, complemented by the atmospheric presence of ambient effects such as the subtle chatter in crowded scenes or the natural echo of marching soldiers.
The standout moments in audio presentation notably emerge during the film's climax, where the meticulously crafted sound design elevates the aerial attack sequences to thrilling heights. The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track excels here, with planes sweeping across the soundscape with palpable intensity, while the room-shaking rumble of explosions and crackle of rapid gunfire testifies to a well-tuned subwoofer performance. Beyond these climactic sounds, the track's attention to detail shines through in quieter, more nuanced moments—be it the distinct sound textures of tropical rain, everyday activities, or the lush renditions of the film's musical scores. The fidelity and tonal depth of these elements are impeccable, presenting a wide dynamic range that frees the audio from distortion. This enhancement and meticulous audio restoration not only celebrate but rejuvenate 'From Here to Eternity,' inviting contemporary audiences to experience the classic in a light that resonates with both purity and modernity.
Extras: 46
The 4K UHD Blu-Ray extras for "From Here to Eternity" offer a succinct yet insightful collection into the making and legacy of this iconic film. The "Eternal History: Graphics-in-Picture Track" stands out with its impressive assembly of new interviews, rare photos, and substantive trivia that enriches viewers' understanding of the film's journey from a controversial novel to an Oscar-winning masterpiece. The "Audio Commentary" by Tim Zinnemann and Alvin Sargent provides a deep dive into the filmmaking process, sharing behind-the-scenes stories, casting what-ifs, and the strategic decisions made to navigate censorship while preserving the story's core themes. Other features like the vintage "Making of From Here to Eternity," directed insights in "Fred Zinnemann - As I See It," and collectible lobby cards round out the extras, making this release an essential for fans and cinephiles seeking a comprehensive view into one of Hollywood's most enduring classics.
Extras included in this disc:
-
Eternal History: Graphics-in-Picture Track: A feature-length exploration of the film's adaptation from James Jones' novel, detailing casting, censorship, and its cultural impact.
-
Audio Commentary: Insights from Tim Zinnemann and Alvin Sargent, including detailed discussions on production challenges, casting alternatives, and on-set anecdotes, with multi-language subtitles available.
-
Making of From Here to Eternity: A brief vintage featurette focusing on casting, iconic scenes, and the film's significant Oscar recognitions.
-
Fred Zinnemann - As I See It: Personal recollections and filmmaking philosophy from director Fred Zinnemann, complemented by excerpts from his on-set film footage.
-
Lobby Cards: A set of five collectible lobby cards featuring iconic scenes from the movie.
-
Movie: 81
"From Here to Eternity," the film adaptation of James Jones' novel, is a cinematic marvel that still resonates decades after its initial release. Set against the backdrop of pre-WWII Hawaii, it delves into complex themes of morality, military life, personal integrity, and the human spirit under duress. The movie, considered controversial and ambitious for its time due to its adult themes and candid portrayal of life on a Hawaiian army base, masterfully blends romance, drama, and historical events, leading to an unforgettable narrative experience. Despite concerns about its suitability for the 1950s audience, the film's nuanced storytelling and compelling character arcs captured the hearts of both critics and the public, earning it numerous accolades, including eight Academy Awards.
Central to the film's narrative is Private Robert Prewitt (Montgomery Clift), whose refusal to conform to the expectations of his commanding officers sets off a chain of events that explore themes of rebellion, loyalty, and the price of integrity. Prewitt's story is a testament to the human spirit's resilience in the face of relentless adversity. His unwavering adherence to his personal code amidst military bullying and personal losses paints a poignant picture of individualism vs. institutional pressures. The performances are nothing short of stellar, with Clift delivering an iconic portrayal that cements his legacy as one of Hollywood's finest actors. The supporting cast, including Burt Lancaster, Deborah Kerr, and Frank Sinatra, adds depth and humanity to this multi-layered drama, each bringing their characters to life with sensitivity and finesse.
Technically, "From Here to Eternity" stands as a masterclass in filmmaking. Fred Zinnemann's direction is meticulous yet understated, allowing the powerful narrative and complex characters to take center stage. The film's pacing, though measured, serves to build anticipation and deepen the emotional impact of each character's journey. Moreover, the famed beach scene remains one of cinema's most iconic moments, symbolizing the film's enduring legacy as a groundbreaking exploration of love, loyalty, and sacrifice. In sum, "From Here to Eternity" is not just a film about the events leading up to the attack on Pearl Harbor; it is a timeless examination of the battles waged within the human heart against the backdrop of impending conflict.
Total: 66
"From Here to Eternity," a cinematic triumph of the 1950s, stands as a testament to an era when storytelling, coupled with a powerhouse of performances, rose to deliver an unforgettable film experience. Today, it might not stir the controversies it once did, but its impact remains undiminished, showcasing a seamless blend of compelling narratives and exceptional acting prowess. Sony’s 4K UHD Blu-ray release elevates this classic with outstanding video quality and immersive audio, complemented by an array of special features, including an innovative picture-in-picture experience that further enriches the viewing. The film, anchored by the stellar castings of Burt Lancaster, Montgomery Clift, Deborah Kerr, Frank Sinatra, and Donna Reed, offers nuanced portrayals that resonate as strongly now as they did over six decades ago.
Set against the dramatic tableau of Pearl Harbor, "From Here to Eternity" transcends its time with themes of emotion, vitality, and rugged individualism that captivate and engage. The delay in Sony’s Blu-ray release is soon forgotten amidst the film's superior technical presentation. Enhanced video and audio transfers breathe new life into this Oscar-winning gem, while the inclusion of five collectible lobby card reproductions offers a tangible connection to its historic cinema run. Known for its legendary beach scene, the film’s deeper messages and vibrant spirit are as compelling as ever, making the Blu-ray edition a must-have for aficionados and newcomers alike.
In conclusion, "From Here to Eternity" in its 4K UHD Blu-ray presentation reaffirms its classic status through a stellar combination of enhanced visuals, sound quality, and engaging extras. This release not only pays homage to the film’s legacy but also offers a comprehensive experience that transcends generations. Whether you're revisiting or discovering it for the first time, this edition warrants the highest recommendation for its technical excellence and enduring appeal.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 90
The approximately framed 4x3 image, retaining the picture's natural theatrical exhibition ratio and placing vertical black bars on either side of the 1.78:1 frame, looks immaculate, enjoying a pure, rich...
Audio: 90
The 5.1 presentation amps up a few key scenes and features more robust and widely spaced music but largely remains true to a classic front-and-center sort of feel....
Extras: 80
Audio Commentary: Tim Zinnemann, Director Fred Zinnemann's son; and Alvin Sargent, a longtime Zinnemann partner; talk in some detail about the picture, beginning with Sargent's initial ties to the film...
Movie: 90
From Here to Eternity, a fictional tale loosely based on his experiences in pre-World War II Hawaii, was once deemed impossible to film, not because of any sort of technically unachievable scope required...
Total: 90
It may not be so scandalous now as it was then, but it remains a near faultless cinema experience, blending together incredible storytelling, captivating narratives, and superb acting in what is certainly...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Gone are the multitudes of nicks and marks that littered the previous print, leaving a clear, vibrant image that sports excellent gray scale variance and a natural grain structure that enhances the film's...
Audio: 80
Though only minimal surround activity could be detected early in the film, mostly in the ambient effect category, the assault sequence kicks the mix into high gear, with speeding planes soaring overhead...
Extras: 20
In addition, we learn about alternate casting choices for key roles (Aldo Ray for Clift's part, Ronald Reagan for Lancaster's role, and Joan Crawford for the character played by Kerr); how Zinnemann got...
Movie: 80
Forget Michael Bay's bloated epic about the attack that finally sucked America into World War II; though 'From Here to Eternity' concentrates on character, values, ideals, injustices, and interpersonal...
Total: 80
This Best Picture winner uses Pearl Harbor as a stunning backdrop for a tale that brims with emotion, vitality, and a rugged individualism that sets it apart from other movies of the period....
Director: Fred Zinnemann
Actors: Burt Lancaster, Montgomery Clift, Deborah Kerr
PlotIn the days leading up to Pearl Harbor, Private Robert E. Lee Prewitt transfers to G Company at Schofield Barracks on the island of Oahu. An accomplished bugler and boxer, Prewitt is pressured by Captain Dana Holmes to join the company's boxing team. However, Prewitt steadfastly refuses to box due to a traumatic incident in the past. Captain Holmes, frustrated by Prewitt's resistance, subjects him to a regime of harsh treatment in an attempt to break his spirit and force him into the boxing ring. Meanwhile, Prewitt's friend, Private Angelo Maggio, faces his own challenges dealing with the aggressive and abusive stockade Sergeant 'Fatso' Judson.
Amidst the tension and military discipline, romances blossom. Prewitt becomes involved with a local club girl named Lorene, who dreams of a better life on the mainland. Simultaneously, Sergeant Milton Warden embarks on a risky affair with Karen Holmes, the unhappy wife of Captain Holmes, seeking solace from her troubled marriage. The relationship between Karen and Warden is marked by intense passion and the shared knowledge of their situation's precariousness. As the characters navigate personal conflicts and looming war, their lives become increasingly intertwined, setting the stage for dramatic transformations and confrontations that will alter their paths forever.
Writers: Daniel Taradash, James Jones
Release Date: 28 Aug 1953
Runtime: 118 min
Rating: Passed
Country: United States
Language: English