Oldboy Blu-ray Review

The Blu-ray presentation of "Oldboy" delivers a significant upgrade in video quality, showcasing the film's original 2.35:1 aspect ratio in 1080p using the MPEG-4/AVC codec. Notably, this release offers a substantial improvement over previous DVD formats, including the R3 Tartan release and the Tartan Collector's Tin. It manages to capture the film's unique visual style with more clarity and fewer artifacts, particularly in dark scenes where previous editions suffered from pixelation and noise. The color representation is commendable, with bold primaries where intended, and an intentional lean towards greens and reds, echoing the director-approved Starmax edition's palette. Despite its strengths, some technical shortcomings persist, including heavy grain, digital noise in darker scenes, and a variable sharpness that can detract from the overall experience.

The film's distinct blend of vibrant and muted tones is captured excellently on this Blu-ray edition. Scenes range from the richly colored confines of Oh Dae-su's initial imprisonment to the more desaturated flashbacks and the sleek, almost clinical environment of Lee Woo-jin's apartment. This transfer does an admirable job of maintaining color integrity without bleed, even in scenes with challenging lighting conditions. The detail in outdoor and well-lit sequences is particularly remarkable, adding depth to the high-definition viewing experience. However, some artistic choices such as post-bleaching and added grain along with a green tint contribute to a unique visual narrative that may not align with traditional high-definition expectations.

Despite these enhancements, the Blu-ray transfer does display some inconsistencies that could detract for purists. Issues including some overly crushed blacks and slight image wobble have been noted – the latter possibly an intentional directorial decision to enhance thematic elements of instability. While these may be indicative of source material limitations or artistic choices rather than transfer flaws, they highlight the delicate balance between preserving a film's original aesthetic and adapting it for high-definition formats. Overall, this release represents a marked improvement over previous editions, offering fans a closer look at "Oldboy's" compelling visual storytelling albeit with some minor caveats regarding visual fidelity in low light scenes and certain stylistic decisions.

The audio presentation of "Oldboy" on Blu-ray offers an immersive and high-fidelity experience, primarily through its original Korean DTS-HD Master Audio 7.1 surround track, which, despite a slightly reduced core bitrate of 768 kbps, compared to the standard 1.5 Mbps, does not compromise on delivering a robust and dynamic auditory experience. This mix stands out with its deep, bass-rumbling precision, enhancing the film's intense scenes and atmospheric depth, from the hauntingly repetitive score to meticulously designed sound effects that bring each moment to life. The dialogue remains crystal clear and perfectly balanced within the soundscape, with every channel employed to full effect, creating a convincingly immersive environment that extends well beyond the visual elements of the film.

Alternative audio options include a Korean Dolby Digital-EX 5.1 surround mix and a basic Dolby Digital 2.0 Stereo track. Each provides a decent auditory experience, though they cannot match the fullness and spatial depth of the DTS-HD track. The Blu-ray also caters to English-speaking audiences with a Dolby Digital 5.1 surround and a Dolby Stereo option. However, these dubs significantly lack the coherence and immersive quality of the original tracks, with the English voiceovers feeling disconnected and occasionally out of sync with the characters' emotions and lip movements, diluting the overall auditory experience.

For purists and fans seeking the most authentic and engaging audio experience, the Korean DTS-HD Master Audio 7.1 mix is unequivocally the prime choice. Its capacity to marry intense bass with precise clarity ensures that every element, from the subtlest of whispers to the most aggressive soundscapes, is rendered with exceptional detail. The rear channels are employed aggressively, pulling the audience into a living, breathing world, culminating in an auditory experience that is as integral to the storytelling as the visual components. While the inclusion of a PCM track would have been appreciated for an ultimate uncompressed audio experience, the existing mixes make 'Oldboy' a compelling demonstration of how effectively sound can enhance and elevate film narrative.

The Blu-ray edition of "Oldboy" offers an abundance of special features that cater to both fans and newcomers alike, securing its status as a comprehensive package despite the absence of some material from previous releases. The inclusion of three insightful commentaries led by director Park Chan-wook, along with key cast and crew, enriches the viewing experience with detailed discussions on the film's production, thematic elements, and visual style. A notable addition is the standard definition bonus disc featuring behind-the-scenes documentaries, cast and crew interviews, and a special featurette on the Cannes Film Festival experience. Although some fans may miss the 3-hour documentary and the 200-page graphic novel from earlier editions, this release doesn't feel lacking. The blend of technical insights, personal anecdotes from the cast, and a look into the film's reception provide a well-rounded exploration of "Oldboy's" creation and legacy. The mix of both engaging and technically dense material ensures there is something for everyone, underscoring the film's enduring appeal.

Extras included in this disc:

• Director Commentary: Park Chan-wook provides a comprehensive account of making "Oldboy".
• Director and Cast Commentary: Insights from the cast alongside Chan-wook.
• Director and Cinematographer Commentary: In-depth discussion on visual style and filming techniques.
• Deleted Scenes: Ten scenes with optional director commentary.
• The Making of Oldboy: A concise overview of the film's production process.
• Production Design: Insights into the visual design aspects of the film.
• The Music Score: Musicians discuss their contributions to the film's score.
• CGI Documentary: Behind-the-scenes look at the CGI used in "Oldboy".
• Flashback: Q&A session with director and cast.
• Cast & Crew Interviews: Interviews covering various roles within the production.
• Tartan Asia Extreme, New Releases: Trailers for Tartan releases, including films from the 'revenge trilogy'.
• The Grand Prix at Cannes: Documentary featuring the director and cast at Cannes Film Festival.
• Original Trailer: The theatrical trailer for "Oldboy".

"Oldboy," a South Korean film directed by Park Chan-wook, emerges as a riveting narrative that dives deep into the themes of revenge and the complexities of human emotions, wrapped in a shroud of noirish aesthetics reminiscent of a Polanski meets Tarantino style. The story follows the life of Oh Dae-su (Choi Min-sik), an everyman who finds himself imprisoned in a makeshift cell for 15 years without any explanation. Upon his release, armed with nothing but a new suit, a cellphone, and a pocketful of cash, he sets out on a relentless quest for vengeance against his unknown captor. This darkly twisted tale is not just about the quest for revenge but also delves into the psychological warfare that ensues between Oh Dae-su and his adversary, making it a deeply immersive experience for the audience.

Technically, "Oldboy" stands out for its staggering performances, particularly by Choi Min-sik, whose transformation from a hapless drunkard to a determined avenger encapsulates the sheer breadth of human resilience and rage. The cinematography and haunting audio complement the film's intense narrative, creating an unforgettable visual and auditory experience. The extreme imagery and unconventional plotlines push cinematic boundaries, engaging viewers with its manga-inspired gore and a dense script that keeps unraveling complex layers of the story.

As part of Park Chan-wook's esteemed Revenge Trilogy, "Oldboy" explores various facets of vengeance, juxtaposing Oh Dae-su's physical vendetta against the calculated psychological retribution by his nemesis, Woo-jin (Yu Ji-tae). This interplay between the characters uncovers broader themes of anger's persistence and the irrationality of emotions. Anchored by compelling performances and bolstered by a meticulous script, "Oldboy" offers a gripping exploration of vengeance, wrapped in a morality tale that warns of its corrosive effects. The film's ending is deliberately ambiguous, leaving the audience to ponder its implications long after the credits roll. It's a cinematic experience that is as disturbing as it is entrancing, demanding contemplation on the nature of revenge and its impact on the soul.

The Blu-ray presentation of "Oldboy," Park Chan-wook's iconic entry into his celebrated Vengeance Trilogy, offers an immersive foray into one of Korean cinema's most provocatively inventive and psychologically complex films. Despite the inherent limitations of the film's original processing which somewhat impacts the video quality, the Blu-ray release manages to elevate the visual experience with a grit that befits the film's raw thematic essence. This edition bolsters the viewing experience with a formidable DTS-HD Master Audio track that impeccably complements the fine acting, intricate and deceptive storyline, and exceptional scoring. These elements collectively not only engage viewers but actively involve them in the narrative's emotional and psychological rollercoaster.

However, "Oldboy" is not without its caveats, presenting barriers that might not appeal to all. The usage of the Korean language and reliance on subtitles can be challenging for some, potentially detracting from its accessibility. Moreover, the film delves into dark, unsettling territories with its vivid depictions of vengeance, violence, and shocking plot twists, which could be off-putting for viewers unprepared for its intensity. Yet, for those fascinated by cinema that pushes boundaries with its bizarre imagery and audacious narrative developments, this Blu-ray release is undeniably appealing. It is further enhanced by an extensive array of supplements that provide deeper insights into its making and thematic explorations.

Conclusively, the Blu-ray of "Oldboy" is a commendable purchase for aficionados of Park Chan-wook, Korean filmmaking, and audiences with a penchant for films that daringly confront and redefine the limits of genre and narrative. While its visual transfer suffers slightly due to source material constraints, it remains an essential addition to the collections of those who appreciate cinema that is as intellectually stimulating as it is visually compelling. The added technical quality of sound and the comprehensive bonus features make this edition a significant means through which to experience and appreciate the depth and complexity of "Oldboy's" cinematic journey.