Enemy Mine Blu-ray Review
Score: 59
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Enemy Mine's Blu-ray offers bright, clean visuals, strong detail, and immersive sound, though it lacks abundant extras and might appeal more to dedicated fans.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 62
Enemy Mine on Blu-ray boasts a 1080p transfer in a correct 2.35:1 aspect ratio, providing good detail, vibrant red hues, and strong black levels, though shadow definition and color saturation could see improvement. The image stability and lack of digital artifacts enhance the overall viewing experience.
Audio: 72
The audio presentation of 'Enemy Mine' on Blu-ray boasts a well-engineered DTS-HD MA 5.0 track with a reasonable surround mix, clear dialogue, and effective use of the five speakers for an immersive experience. However, the U.S. release utilizes an English DTS-HD Master Audio 4.0, differing in effects distribution while maintaining clarity and stability.
Extra: 31
The Blu-ray extras for 'Enemy Mine' include an extended scene in 1.33:1 VHS quality with English subtitles, a full-color 18-page booklet with an essay by Craig Ian Mann, the original U.S. theatrical trailer, an image gallery with an essay by Lee Gambin, and a reversible cover.
Movie: 56
Enemy Mine, directed by Wolfgang Petersen, presents strong drama and decent effects, though marred by a slow pace and a heavy-handed allegory that oversimplifies complex political and social messages, ultimately offering a space-set Sci-Fi buddy film that is more ambitious than its execution effectively delivers.
Video: 62
The Blu-ray release of Wolfgang Petersen's "Enemy Mine" delivers a visually engaging experience with its 1080p transfer, encoded using the AVC codec. Presented in a theatrically accurate widescreen 2.35:1 aspect ratio (notably 2.37:1 in some instances), the video retains impressive detail and texture. The skin of both human and alien characters appears realistic, with the sewn rags and space uniforms presenting discernible weaves. The hostile planet's landscapes, captured both on location and in sets, display commendable edge definition. The sunsets are particularly noteworthy, showcasing a rich palette of reds that add vibrancy to the scenes.
Brightness and contrast settings ensure robust black levels, enhancing night scenes and cave sequences with a palpable sense of depth. While shadow details add to the image quality, some darker footage sees a tendency for existing detail to collapse slightly. Despite these minor qualms, overall image stability is commendable. Colours remain stable, though further improvements in saturation and nuance could elevate the visual experience even more. There are no noticeable issues with compression, edge enhancement, or banding, preserving the film’s organic grain structure. The original print's condition is very good with only sporadic instances of damage, contributing to an authentic presentation of this classic sci-fi film.
Audio: 72
The Blu-ray release of "Enemy Mine" features an English DTS-HD Master Audio 4.0 track, which offers a robust and immersive auditory experience. While it may not boast the extensive bass capabilities of a 5.1 or 7.1 setup, the track effectively utilizes its four channels to deliver a well-balanced surround mix. Key sequences such as spacecraft dog fights, meteor showers, and mining operations are particularly noteworthy for their ability to fill the room with dynamic effects, placing the viewer right at the heart of the action. The audio track supports this immersion with a well-calibrated soundscape, and the enigmatic score is cleverly distributed across the speakers to enhance this effect.
Notably, dialogue clarity is another strong aspect, with clear, precise vocals that remain intelligible throughout without becoming overwhelmed by the other sound elements. Although there is no designated subwoofer channel in the 4.0 mix, the track does not neglect the lower end; explosions and spacecraft audio elements extend into the bass frequencies sufficiently to add depth, albeit not with superlative bass impact. The subtle but present bass contributes to a fuller auditory experience without drawing too much attention to its limitations. Optional English SDH subtitles are also provided, appearing within the image frame for those who need them.
Overall, whether comparing the DTS-HD Master Audio 4.0 on this release to the DTS-HD Master Audio 5.0 on the British Eureka Entertainment release, both tracks exhibit strong mixing and distribution of effects. Despite minor differences between them, each harnesses its respective configuration to elevate the film’s audio dynamics effectively, making either version a sound choice for experiencing "Enemy Mine."
Extras: 31
The Blu-ray extras for "Enemy Mine" offer viewers a engaging and comprehensive deep dive into the film’s production and legacy. They include an extended scene presented in VHS quality with supplementary dialogues that enrich character transitions, a detailed 18-page booklet featuring an insightful essay on the film’s history by Craig Ian Mann, and an original U.S. trailer that captures the film’s initial promotional essence. Additionally, enthusiasts are treated to a compelling image gallery paired with an essay by Fangoria writer Lee Gambin, and a reversible cover, giving collectors more display options. This array of extras enriches the "Enemy Mine" viewing experience, highlighting the film’s behind-the-scenes intricacies and enhancing its nostalgic appeal.
Extras included in this disc:
- Extended Scene: Additional dialogue in sickbay, in German with English subtitles.
- Trailer: Original U.S. theatrical trailer.
- Booklet: Full-color 18-page booklet with historical essay by Craig Ian Mann.
- Image Gallery and Essay: Exclusive stills and an essay by Lee Gambin.
- Cover: Reversible cover.
Movie: 56
Wolfgang Petersen’s "Enemy Mine" presents a compelling narrative set in a distant future where humans and an alien race known as the Dracs clash over galactic territories. The film follows Willis Davidge (Dennis Quaid), a fighter pilot who crash-lands on a hostile planet after an intense space battle. Stranded alongside his adversary, Jeriba Shigan (Louis Gossett Jr.), the two enemies are forced to collaborate for survival. Their initial animosity evolves into a bond characterized by mutual respect and shared experiences. The story takes a poignant turn with Jeriba's unexpected pregnancy—a biological trait of the Drac species—culminating in his death during childbirth and leaving Davidge to care for the orphaned child, Zammis.
While the film is visually appealing with strong dramatic elements and decent special effects, it suffers from a somewhat sluggish pace and a conventional screenplay. Despite these flaws, the acting is commendable, particularly the palpable chemistry between Quaid and Gossett Jr. The film ambitiously tackles themes of tolerance and comradeship but sometimes gets bogged down in melodrama, detracting from its overall impact. One can attribute some of the film's shortcomings to its troubled production history and significant studio interference.
The narrative pushes political allegory heavily, simplifying complex issues of tolerance, religion, and ideology, reminiscent of Cold War-era propaganda films. This didactic approach may render the film's message about coexistence and unity somewhat simplistic and heavy-handed to contemporary viewers. Although it aims to deliver a heartfelt and significant message pertinent to its time, the execution may come off as over-sanitized and overly earnest. Nevertheless, "Enemy Mine" remains an intriguing blend of science fiction drama with pressing social commentary, albeit one that arguably promises more than it ultimately delivers.
Total: 59
The Blu-ray release of Wolfgang Petersen's 1985 sci-fi drama "Enemy Mine" delivers a moderately satisfying visual and auditory experience. The film, which follows the story of two adversaries, human pilot Davidge and alien counterpart Jeriba, as they struggle to survive on a hostile planet, remains an engaging narrative with its themes of cooperation and mutual understanding. The picture quality is commendable, presenting a clean and bright image with good detail, appropriate coloration, and solid black levels. The 5.0 surround audio track is surprisingly immersive, enhancing both dialogue clarity and atmospheric soundscapes.
While the content on this Blu-ray set might not be extensive, it does provide some valuable additions. The extras include a trailer, an extended scene that offers substantial narrative enrichment, and a color booklet containing a well-researched essay on the film’s history. Notably, the Blu-ray distributed by Eureka Entertainment is sourced from the same Fox master used for the UK release, making it a viable option for North American fans due to its Region-Free compatibility. This could be a worthwhile addition to any sci-fi enthusiast's collection, especially if importing is feasible.
In conclusion, "Enemy Mine" on Blu-ray is a competent release, albeit with limited supplementary content. The visual and audio reproduction on this disc ensures that Wolfgang Petersen's poignant tale of camaraderie and survival shines through, albeit it offers slightly less than its full potential in terms of bonus features. Nevertheless, for fans of the genre or those who appreciate the film's thematic depth, this Blu-ray should be strongly considered for its technical presentation and narrative value.
avforums review by Simon CrustRead review here
Video: 70
The original print is in pretty good shape with only a few instances of damage visible, while the grain level never becomes too intrusive and adds to the organic nature of the film....
Audio: 70
Obviously there is no direct sub channel, but the track is not lacking in bass with the score, explosions and spacecraft all giving the sub something to do by filling out the lower end....
Extras: 30
Extended Scene – Just this one extra, with some additional dialogue while Davidge is in sickbay and between him and his fighter pilot friends that helps ease the transition between his rescue and subsequent...
Movie: 70
After the plan goes awry and he is captured, things start to look bad, but the timely interruption of a meteor shower sees the two desperate souls join forces with the express intention of survival....
Total: 60
Enemy Mine is a 1985 sci-fi drama from director Wolfgang Petersen telling the story of a cocksure human pilot, Davidge, and his alien counterpart, Jeriba, who are both forced to work together when they...
Blu-ray.com review by Dr. Svet AtanasovRead review here
Video: 80
While watching the film I felt that shadow definition, in particular, can be improved as some of the darker footage does have a tendency to collapse existing detail....
Audio: 100
I went back and forth between the two release to compare select sequences and it appears that the distribution of certain effects is different....
Extras: 40
Image Gallery and Essay - a gallery of exclusive stills and an essay from Fangoria writer Lee Gambin....
Movie: 50
The entire second act where the two enemies slowly warm up to each other and discover that they actually have a lot in common is filled with 'important' messages about tolerance, acceptance and solidarity,...
Total: 60
I think that it might be a good alternative for fans of the film residing in North America as it is Region-Free....
Director: Wolfgang Petersen
Actors: Dennis Quaid, Louis Gossett Jr., Brion James
PlotIn the distant future, two warring space pilots, human Willis Davidge and Drac alien Jeriba Shigan, crash-land on a desolate planet. Initially, their hostility towards each other mirrors the larger conflict between their races. Faced with the harsh conditions of the unforgiving environment, they are forced to cooperate in order to survive. Their mutual need for food, water, and shelter gradually transforms their contentious relationship into one of grudging respect. They begin to understand each other’s languages and cultures, realizing that their preconceived notions are misguided.
As time passes, their bond deepens, and they come to rely on one another not just for survival but also for companionship. Through shared adversity and profound personal interactions, they move past their enmity and form an unexpected friendship. They even partake in each other's rituals, symbolizing their growing connection. However, the arrival of a new challenge threatens to disrupt their fragile harmony, testing the strength of their alliance and forcing them to confront the deeper implications of their unlikely friendship.
Writers: Barry Longyear, Edward Khmara
Release Date: 20 Dec 1985
Runtime: 108 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United Kingdom, West Germany, United States
Language: English