Traitor Blu-ray Review
Score: 54
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
While 'Traitor' boasts exceptional video and TrueHD audio quality on Blu-ray, it ultimately underwhelms with a predictable plot despite strong performances from Don Cheadle and Said Taghmaoui.
Disc Release Date
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 66
Traitor's Blu-ray presentation boasts a high quality 1080p transfer with exceptional detail in brighter sequences and lifelike textures, although some darker scenes show minor noise and less definitive resolution. Colors are generally accurate with bold primaries, deep blacks, and well-rendered skin tones.
Audio: 59
The Dolby TrueHD 5.1 soundtrack of 'Traitor' captures clear and prioritized dialogue amidst action sequences with substantial dynamic range, impactful explosions, and immersive surround quality, although it lacks some fine-tuned directionality and aggressive LFE support.
Extra: 23
The "Traitor" Blu-ray extras provide solid content, highlighted by a thorough audio commentary from Jeffrey Nachmanoff and Don Cheadle detailing the film’s production, casting, and technical elements. Two brief HD featurettes explore the stunts and filming locations. Additional value includes trailers and a digital copy, though lacking in extensive behind-the-scenes material.
Movie: 57
"Traitor" delivers a partially unpredictable plot enriched by Don Cheadle's strong performance, though it struggles with generic thriller clichés and underdeveloped secondary characters. The film's complex exploration of terrorism provides intrigue amidst typical genre conventions, especially for first-time viewers.
Video: 66
The Blu-ray presentation of "Traitor" delivers a commendable 1080p transfer, framed at 2.35:1, exhibiting clarity and detail reflective of modern films. The film's visual aesthetic utilizes overblown whites and deep shadows, reminiscent of other Middle Eastern-themed movies. The presentation captures this intent supportively, with primary colors appearing bold and accurate. Skin tones are well-rendered, maintaining a natural look that adds realism to character portrayals. Bright sequences showcase excellent sharpness and texture, though some luminous scenes suffer from slight over-saturation, washing out minor details. Nevertheless, this is a minor flaw in an otherwise stunning visual experience.
Darker scenes reveal deep, inky blacks and appreciable visibility in both uniform and uneven lighting conditions. Though there is a minor presence of digital noise in some shadow-laden segments, they retain strong dimensionality and visual penetration. The transfer reveals excellent texture in both close-ups and broader shots, bringing lifelike detail to elements like the worn exteriors of Yemen and the overhead views of cityscapes, such as Chicago's skyline in chapter nine. The film's grain structure further enhances its gritty atmosphere, contributing to an immersive viewing experience. Overall, "Traitor" on Blu-ray stands out with its striking contrast, impressive delineation, and meticulous attention to detail, making it a noteworthy addition for fans and enthusiasts alike.
Audio: 59
The audio presentation of the Blu-ray edition of "Traitor" offers a commendable Dolby TrueHD 5.1 lossless surround sound experience that effectively complements the film’s varied tonal and atmospheric demands. Dialogue is impressively clean, intelligible, and forward in presentation, ensuring every word is discernible even during intense action sequences. The dynamic range is robust, with explosions and gunfire delivering palpable impact and energy. The surround sound platform is utilized to excellent effect during the few but significant action sequences, creating an immersive soundscape with a balanced blend of deep bass energy and comprehensive 360-degree surround quality.
However, the track does have its limitations. While the front speakers successfully carry outdoor atmospherics such as blowing wind, chirping birds, and passing cars, there's a noticeable lack of fine-tuned directionality in some instances. Effects sometimes remain anchored to the front of the soundfield when a more dispersed sound would have been preferable. Nevertheless, rear speakers are effectively employed in interior scenes to generate convincing acoustics and dense ambience for open outdoor environments. Despite these minor issues, the Dolby TrueHD track overall does a praiseworthy job of enhancing the film's visuals and atmosphere. Though bass response isn't as aggressive throughout, select scenes like the Yemeni prison assault and construction site attack deliver satisfactory weight and presence, bringing action sequences to life with impressive authenticity.
Extras: 23
The Extras section of the Blu-ray release of "Traitor" provides a satisfying, if somewhat limited, behind-the-scenes look into the film's production. The highlight is the insightful audio commentary featuring writer/director Jeffrey Nachmanoff and actor Don Cheadle. Their engaging discussion covers the origins of specific scenes, filming locations, technical aspects, and cultural contexts, making it an informative experience. The release also includes two concise featurettes: "Action!" focuses on the film's stunts and special effects, while "International Espionage" gives a glimpse into the various shooting locations. Additionally, viewers will find several promotional trailers and BD-Live functionality, albeit with limited current availability. A digital copy is also included, although it lacks compatibility with Mac systems, detracting slightly from its overall value.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio commentary with Director Jeffrey Nachmanoff and Don Cheadle: Insightful discussion on the film’s production and cultural context.
- Action!: Overview of stunts and special effects.
- International Espionage: Examination of the film's shooting locations.
- Blu-ray Trailers: Promotional material for various Starz/Anchor Bay Entertainment films.
- BD-Live enabled: Server access expected to be active by release day.
- Digital Copy Bonus Disc: Standard definition version of the film for portable playback devices.
Movie: 57
"Traitor" is an international thriller featuring Academy Award® nominee Don Cheadle and Guy Pearce. Cheadle portrays Samir Horn, a former U.S. military operative and devout Muslim entangled in terrorism across the globe. Pearce's character, FBI agent Roy Clayton, investigates Horn, whose actions lead to numerous terrorist activities, culminating in a high-stakes plot targeting the United States. The film, directed by Jeffrey Nachmanoff, examines the complexities of covert operations and questions the motivations driving terrorism.
The standout performance by Don Cheadle anchors the film. His portrayal of Samir Horn is nuanced and compelling, embodying a character deeply conflicted and shrouded in ambiguity. This complexity is balanced by Said Taghmaoui’s notable performance as Omar, a moderately sympathetic terrorist. Both actors delve into their characters' psyches, allowing the narrative to explore the underlying motivations and emotional turmoil within a terrorist organization. Despite these strong performances, the film's plot remains somewhat predictable, relying heavily on conventional thriller tropes that undermine its potential for genuine suspense and unexpected twists.
While "Traitor" attempts to offer a grittier and more dangerous storyline compared to more formulaic spy thrillers, it falls short in several areas. Secondary characters, particularly the stereotypical baddies and the FBI agents portrayed by Pearce and McDonough, lack the emotional depth seen in Cheadle and Taghmaoui's performances. Consequently, Pearce and McDonough’s scenes feel flat and devoid of significant tension. Nonetheless, the film’s exploration of terrorism from a psychological standpoint provides intriguing moments that partly redeem its otherwise cliché execution. For viewers seeking a political thriller with robust character studies, "Traitor" provides an engaging watch albeit with familiar plot mechanics.
Total: 54
"Traitor" leverages Don Cheadle's outstanding performance to elevate what is otherwise a fairly predictable plotline. While the film's narrative starts strong, featuring a compelling build-up and intriguing scenarios, it loses momentum midway through. Once the central revelation is uncovered, "Traitor" transitions into a more conventional thriller. Despite its shortcomings, the movie retains enough interest to keep viewers engaged until the end, albeit without leaving a lasting impression.
The Blu-ray release of "Traitor" is commendable, showcasing an excellent video transfer that brings the film’s visuals vividly to life. The TrueHD audio track is proficient, delivering clear dialogue and immersive soundscapes. While the supplemental features on the Blu-ray disc are limited, they are concise, with the primary highlight being a somewhat uninspired commentary. This aspect may detract from the overall package but doesn’t significantly diminish the viewing experience.
In conclusion, "Traitor" is worth a watch, particularly on Blu-ray for its superior video and audio quality. However, due to its limited replay value and lackluster supplements, it might be better suited for a rental rather than a permanent addition to your collection. The film serves as a decent thriller that benefits from Don Cheadle's compelling performance but falls short of the psychological complexity it strives for.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 90
Many of the unkempt, dirty exteriors of Yemen seen early in the film absolutely sparkle with lifelike translation on 1080p Blu-ray; worn doors, broken tile, cracked mortar, and chipped paint, all make...
Audio: 70
There is not much in the way of rear-channel environmental support, though the front speakers carry a nice bit of outdoor atmospherics; blowing wind, chirping birds, and passing cars in the distance help...
Extras: 30
The pair is affable and interesting, describing the origins of particular scenes, the look the film employs, filming locations, technical details behind the filmmaking process, and more....
Movie: 60
It's far too predictable with only a few elements of genuine suspense and danger, but Cheadle plays his challenging role close to the vest, almost leaving audiences convinced that the plot twist really...
Total: 70
Once the film's big revelation is made known halfway through the film, Traitor loses steam and becomes a far-too-average thriller that is just good enough to keep audiences watching through to the end,...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Fans of the film should be more than pleased with the transfer, its quality, and the obvious upgrade it offers over the concurrently-released standard DVD....
Audio: 80
The rear speakers are tasked with quite a bit of activity and do a fine job of creating convincing acoustics for interior shots and dense ambience for more open outdoor environments....
Extras: 20
Granted, there isn’t a lot of behind-the-scenes material on the disc beyond an audio commentary, but the fact that the video content is presented in high definition is a plus....
Movie: 60
Better still, Taghmaoui’s deft performance as a mildly sympathetic mass murderer serves as a counterweight to every question the director and actor pose about terrorism and its converts, giving the film...
Total: 60
’Traitor’ never becomes the complex psychological thriller it desperately wants to be, but it does boast a pair of fine performances from Don Cheadle and Said Taghmaoui....
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 88
Images are rendered with excellent visual penetration, resolute sharpness and defining detail that is particularly striking during brighter sequences....
Audio: 86
This results in good quality sound that is both immersive and vigorous as it fills the room with a nice blend of deep bass energy and 360 degree surround quality....
Extras: 30
The stunts and special effects of Traitor – short featurette (HD) International espionage: An look at the shooting locations featured in Traitor - short featurette 3 Blu-ray Disc trailers from Starz/Anchor...
Movie: 60
When straight-arrow FBI agent Roy Clayton (Pearce) investigates a dangerous international conspiracy responsible for a prison break in Yemen, a bombing in Nice and a raid in London, all clues seem to lead...
Total: 66
Marantz DV7001 Universal Disc Player Denon AVR 5308CI THX Ultra 2 Preamp/Video Processor B&K Reference 200.7 Series 2 seven Channel amplifier Philips TSU9400 Pro Series Touch Panel Remote Control Canton...
Director: Jeffrey Nachmanoff
Actors: Don Cheadle, Guy Pearce, Archie Panjabi
PlotAn ex-U.S. Special Operations officer named Samir Horn is linked to a string of international bombings. He is first seen in Yemen, where he is arrested and imprisoned alongside Islamic militants. After escaping with these militants, Samir becomes deeply embedded with a dangerous terrorist cell. Following a bank robbery in London, where explosives are stolen, FBI agents Roy Clayton and Max Archer become intent on tracking down this elusive and mysterious operative who seems to have connections with various terrorist operations globally. As they dig deeper, they uncover evidence that suggests Samir is more than just a participant in these terror plots.
With each new lead, Clayton and Archer grapple with conflicting clues that indicate Samir might have internal motives unknown to them. As Samir's journey takes him across continents, from Europe to the U.S. and ultimately into the heart of potential attacks, questions arise about his true allegiances. The agents must determine whether he is a terrorist mastermind or an unwilling pawn. The conflicting evidence mounts while tension escalates with each new development, culminating in a revelation that forces everyone involved to question their assumptions and face the dire consequences of the global terror network they are up against.
Writers: Jeffrey Nachmanoff, Steve Martin
Release Date: 27 Aug 2008
Runtime: 114 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States
Language: English, Arabic