Magic in the Moonlight Blu-ray Review
Score: 60
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Woody Allen's 'Magic in the Moonlight' sparkles with whimsical charm, buoyed by Sony's excellent Blu-ray transfer, however its sophisticated script loses steam halfway through.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 68
Magic in the Moonlight's Blu-ray presentation boasts a faithful 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 transfer with top-notch contrast and clarity, showcasing a period-inspired sepia tone with occasional overcooked reds and greens. Although black levels and skin tones may vary, the lush colors and excellent shadow details enhance the film's scenic locales.
Audio: 70
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track for 'Magic in the Moonlight' is impressively nuanced, delivering clear dialogue and detailed ambient effects, while front-oriented music and subtle spatial dimensions enrich the cinematic experience without overwhelming the sound system.
Extra: 23
Magic in the Moonlight's Blu-ray extras feature insightful cast reflections on character and production in 'Behind the Magic,' candid moments from the L.A. premiere, and the original theatrical trailer, offering a concise but engaging enhancement to the film.
Movie: 67
Woody Allen's 'Magic in the Moonlight' offers a charming, well-acted period piece set in the Roaring Twenties with commendable performances by Colin Firth and Emma Stone. Despite its engaging dialogue and stunning cinematography, it falls short on narrative depth and chemistry between the leads, making it enjoyable yet ultimately forgettable.
Video: 68
The video presentation of the Blu-Ray for "Magic in the Moonlight" offers a visually engaging experience, leveraging a unique blend of period-inspired sepia tones while occasionally showcasing overcooked reds and greens. Detail levels are superb, particularly in center-frame and close-up shots where facial lines and fabric textures are rendered with filmic accuracy. While medium and long-distance shots can show some softness, overall fidelity is maintained. Black levels exhibit inconsistency, showing a light paleness or occasional crush, but the naturally occurring light grain enhances the film-like appearance without introducing compression issues or anomalies. Skin tones reflect the prevalent sepia overlay and maintain an appropriately vintage look.
Allen's collaboration with cinematographer Darius Khondji captures the French Riviera's essence with an infusion of joie de vivre. This 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 transfer stands out with excellent contrast and clarity, ensuring a consistently appealing filmic texture. The palette utilized in the transfer excites the senses with lush, liquid blues, bold reds, bright pastels, and verdant greens creating a visually immersive experience. Black levels are notably rich and deep while whites remain crisp without blooming. Shadow detail is handled excellently, avoiding any significant crush and allowing background elements to remain discernible. Close-ups are particularly effective at highlighting fine facial features. The absence of banding, noise, or visible digital manipulation ensures that the visual experience remains smooth and engaging throughout the film.
Audio: 70
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 lossless soundtrack of "Magic in the Moonlight" offers a mostly front-oriented auditory experience consistent with many Woody Allen films, while also stretching to include subtle yet immersive elements. The dialogue is impeccably clear, centrally focused, and exhibits crisp intonation that maintains clarity even during frenetic speeches. Surround activity is moderately used, primarily creating a subtle ambient backdrop that occasionally extends the depth of the sound field. Noteworthy ambient effects such as crashing waves, seagulls, and insects add essential atmospheric layers to the film.
Music in the track delivers a deliberately designed mood, often presenting a sepia-toned muddiness meant to evoke a specific era rather than challenge a sound system's capabilities. A notable exception can be found during an early magic show, where stringed musical accompaniment is remarkably clear and articulate, representing the most audibly enticing segment. As for musical fidelity, period jazz tunes by Bix Beiderbecke and Paul Whiteman display superior depth and warmth, filling the room with ease.
The dynamic range is solid, handling both high- and low-end tones without distortion, adding life to the film without reaching reference-quality activity. Expanded light countryside ambience and intense moments like the drenching rain and thunderstorm in chapter eight enhance the mix's engaging realm. It’s a well-rounded audio presentation that complements the film's intricate atmosphere without overwhelming its delicate narrative focus.
Extras: 23
The Blu-ray extras for "Magic in the Moonlight" offer a concise yet insightful peek into the film's production and reception. "Behind the Magic" provides an 11-minute deep dive into the cast's reflections on their characters, the supernatural themes, and the synergy fostered during filming, showcasing Firth's liberating experience portraying an unsympathetic character and Weaver's thoughts on the film's metaphysical elements. Meanwhile, "On the Red Carpet: Los Angeles Film Premiere" captures engaging banter from the cast at the premiere, touching on Woody Allen's directorial influence and meticulous style. These features, along with the original theatrical trailer, form an interesting but modest package for fans and film enthusiasts.
Extras included in this disc:
- Behind the Magic: Cast reflections on characters, supernatural themes, and working with Woody Allen.
- On the Red Carpet: Los Angeles Film Premiere: Cast impressions on Woody Allen’s direction at the film’s premiere.
- Theatrical Trailer: The original preview of the movie.
- Digital HD Copy: Digital version of the film for portable viewing.
Movie: 67
"Magic in the Moonlight" is a wonderfully charming addition to Woody Allen's extensive filmography. Set in the Roaring Twenties, this tale unfolds in the seductive backdrop of the Côte d'Azur, captured with impeccable attention to detail by cinematographer Darius Khondji. In the lead role, Colin Firth shines as Stanley Crawford, a magician steeped in rationality and skepticism, whose initial mission to debunk a young clairvoyant named Sophie Baker (Emma Stone) takes unexpected turns. Allen's mastery in blending character-driven drama with whimsical intrigue is on full display, inviting audiences into a world of make-believe and supernatural musings that challenge both the characters' and viewers' perceptions of reality.
Performances are engrossing across the board, with Firth delivering a nuanced portrayal that balances charm, vanity, and burgeoning belief. Stone, though slightly constrained by the meticulous script, showcases a mysterious allure that fuels the film's central enigma. The dynamic between Firth and Stone adds layers to the otherwise straightforward plot, driving the narrative while keeping the audience guessing about Sophie's true nature. Despite its simplicity, Allen maintains an engaging atmosphere punctuated by precise dialogue and period-perfect aesthetics. However, some viewers may find the chemistry between Firth and Stone lacking, primarily due to their notable age difference, a recurring trope in Allen’s work that here feels somewhat overused.
Ultimately, "Magic in the Moonlight" is an exploration of belief versus skepticism, with Allen skillfully using the medium to delve into deeper human themes. While it doesn’t pack the punch of some of Allen’s earlier works, it remains a delightful watch. It's a film that marries light-hearted romance with philosophical inquiry, wrapped up in a visually stunning package that only falters slightly in its narrative depth. For fans of Allen's signature style and character-focused storytelling, it is a welcoming return to form.
Total: 60
Woody Allen's "Magic in the Moonlight" is a delightful cinematic offering that oozes charm and elegance. Set against the picturesque backdrop of the Riviera, this romantic comedy showcases Allen's deft touch in crafting whimsical narratives. While the story and themes are lighter compared to his previous works such as 'Blue Jasmine,' the film still offers a hearty dose of clever witticisms and madcap lunacy. The cast's buoyant performances and the film's effortless photography and editing make for an inviting viewing experience. Although the script loses momentum in the second half, the film's enchanting atmosphere and Allen's masterful direction keep it engaging.
Sony's Blu-ray release does justice to the film's visual and auditory allure. The video transfer is sparkling, allowing the beguiling Riviera locations to shine through with vibrant clarity. High-end audio ensures that every nuance of the dialogue and soundtrack is captured with precision, enhancing the overall viewing experience. The Blu-ray also includes a couple of extras, which, while not extensive, offer a welcome addition for fans of the film and Allen's work.
In conclusion, "Magic in the Moonlight" may not be a groundbreaking masterpiece, but it stands as a testament to Woody Allen's enduring ability to enchant and entertain. With its lighter narrative, charming performances, and enhanced by Sony's commendable Blu-ray release, this film provides a pleasant escape into a world of romance and whimsy. Highly recommended for both Allen aficionados and newcomers alike.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 80
All that said, this appears to be a rather faithful transfer and a nice example of the power film -- not digital -- still holds within the medium as a legitimate, handsome canvas....
Audio: 90
Musical spacing, otherwise and understandably, is rather limited, but the track does expand to feature some light background countryside ambience and explode into a drenching rain and thunderstorm in chapter...
Extras: 20
Behind the Magic (1080p, 11:21): This piece examines character qualities, cast thoughts on the supernatural and a few metaphysical insights, cast camaraderie and performances, working with Woody Allen,...
Movie: 90
The entire cast is splendid -- Stone is also a standout, particularly later in the film when one can almost see the mental gears churning in her mind as she must choose between a suitor who promises her...
Total: 70
Though embroiled in scandal and media scrutiny, he's churned out another gem that's classic Allen in every way, a movie that's whimsically inviting, effortlessly photographed and edited, and beautifully...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Colors are gloriously lush - the liquid blue of the azure sea, bold reds, bright and airy pastels, and verdant foliage combine to create a seductive palette that excites the senses....
Audio: 80
Though all of Allen's typically marvelous dialogue is clear and easy to comprehend (except during some of Firth's more frenetic speeches) and all of the period jazz tunes performed by the likes of Bix...
Extras: 20
Weaver ruminates on the appeal of the supernatural, and believes Allen captured "the zeitgeist of the times," while the superfluous Linklater tries a bit too hard to be outrageous and witty....
Movie: 60
On the contrary, there's a lot to like about 'Magic in the Moonlight,' which often resembles an old-time romp in the vein of Molière, Oscar Wilde, or Noel Coward, but lacks enough fibers to stitch itself...
Total: 60
The antithesis of last year's 'Blue Jasmine,' 'Magic in the Moonlight' is almost too wispy in story and theme, but Woody Allen's latest romantic comedy delivers its share of clever witticisms and madcap...
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 86
Audio: 80
Surround activity is limited to subtle ambience that occasionally offered some spatial dimension that extended the depth of the sound field....
Extras: 40
On the Red Carpet: Los Angeles Film Premiere – 3 minutes (HD) Theatrical trailer Digital HD Copy...
Movie: 60
Chinese conjuror Wei Ling Soo is the most celebrated magician of his age, but few know that he is the stage persona of Stanley Crawford (Colin Firth), a grouchy and arrogant Englishman with a sky-high...
Total: 67
Sony Playstation 3 Blu-ray disc Player (HDMI Audio/Video) System Controller: Apple iPad/iRule Pro HD Universal Remote Control Canton "Ergo" Series speakers Axiom Audio QS8 Quadpolar speakers SVS PB-13...
Director: Woody Allen
Actors: Colin Firth, Emma Stone, Marcia Gay Harden
PlotIn the late 1920s, renowned illusionist Stanley Crawford, known on stage as Wei Ling Soo, is enlisted by his friend Howard Burkan to unmask a purported psychic named Sophie Baker. Sophie has been beguiling a wealthy American family on the French Riviera with her astonishing abilities, and Howard believes her to be a fraud. Skeptical and cynical, Stanley accepts the challenge and travels to the Côte d'Azur to expose Sophie. From his first encounter with her, Stanley finds himself baffled by Sophie's seemingly genuine powers. Despite his efforts to debunk her, each demonstration only heightens his confusion and fascination.
As he spends more time with Sophie, Stanley's rigid rationality begins to waver. He finds himself enchanted not only by her talents but also by her vibrant spirit and charm. The lush backdrop of the French Riviera and the friendly family members further envelop him in an atmosphere of warmth and intrigue. Yet, underlying Stanley’s growing admiration is his relentless pursuit to uncover the truth. As the line between illusion and reality blurs, Stanley faces an internal conflict that challenges his deep-seated beliefs about logic and magic.
Writers: Woody Allen
Release Date: 15 Aug 2014
Runtime: 97 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States, France
Language: English, French