Alive Inside: A Story of Music and Memory Blu-ray Review
Score: 65
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Alive Inside is a profound and provocative documentary showcasing the transformative power of music therapy, earning high recommendations from critics.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 66
Alive Inside's Blu-ray offers an AVC encoded 1080p transfer in 1.78:1 with clear and stable images, accurate colors, and occasional quality variations due to different shooting conditions. While not a showcase of high-definition brilliance, the video remains sharp and devoid of major artifacts.
Audio: 66
Featuring a richly mixed DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 option, 'Alive Inside' delivers an emotionally resonant experience through Itaal Shur's underscore, achieving excellent fidelity and clear dynamics despite challenging recording environments, with the surround channels offering enhanced musical immersion.
Extra: 51
"Alive Inside: A Story of Music and Memory" Blu-ray bonus features offer extensive, thorough, and engaging insights, including a heartfelt and insightful director’s commentary, expanded interviews, in-depth discussions on music therapy, and a detailed soundtrack analysis. However, the absence of subtitles is a notable shortcoming.
Movie: 86
'Alive Inside: A Story of Music and Memory' is an uplifting documentary showcasing the profound impact of music on individuals suffering from Alzheimer's and dementia, with the emotional transformations of the elderly captured beautifully in a minimalistic narrative style; the Blu-ray presentation maintains excellent 1.78 widescreen MPEG-AVC quality, enhancing the film's poignant subject matter.
Video: 66
"Alive Inside: A Story of Music and Memory" is presented on Blu-ray with an AVC encoded 1080p transfer in a 1.78:1 aspect ratio. The verit� style of the documentary means it doesn't often feature the vibrant "pop" typical of high definition content, but the image remains clear and stable with accurate colors. There are occasional differences in quality throughout various segments, likely due to varied shooting conditions or the use of different cameras. While some banding is visible, notably in scenes with harsh fluorescent lighting, there are no significant artifacts that impact the viewing experience.
The high-definition video is consistently excellent, with picture quality varying based on the filming environment. Much of the documentary is shot within the artificially lit confines of hospitals, resulting in less uniform and less crisp images compared to the more controlled interview shots of musicians and doctors. Despite this, there are no noticeable distortions or artifacts that detract from the content. The documentary also integrates stock footage and other graphics, which naturally vary in quality but do not affect the high-definition transfer's overall integrity. The end result is a visually sharp and engaging documentary that leverages modern high-definition capabilities appropriately.
Audio: 66
The audio presentation of the Blu-ray for "Alive Inside: A Story of Music and Memory" employs DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 and LPCM 2.0 soundtracks that deliver exceptional fidelity. The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 clearly stands out, providing a more spacious and immersive experience, especially in delivering Itaal Shur’s compelling score. This choice significantly enhances the film's emotional impact, with surround channels being effectively utilized to evoke responses akin to those felt by the characters on screen. Despite the inherent challenges in recording natural dialogue in acoustically less-than-ideal environments, the audio quality remains clear and dynamic throughout.
Ambient environmental effects subtly blend into the narrative, enhancing the immersive experience. Dialogue, which can sometimes be murky or mumbled due to the nature of the settings and circumstances, is well-balanced against the music and narration. The presentation achieves impressive clarity despite these logistical challenges. The soundtrack, provided as a supplement, offers a comprehensive auditory experience, underscoring Shur’s work which serves as an essential part of the film's emotional fabric. This attention to detail in sound mixing ensures no distractions from fidelity, maintaining a consistent and engaging audio experience without any reported issues.
Extras: 51
The extras in the Blu-ray of "Alive Inside: A Story of Music and Memory" provide an insightful and extensive deep dive into the documentary's impactful subject. The Director's Commentary by Michael Rossato-Bennett is comprehensive and emotionally aware, striking a balance between detailed insights and respect for the film's poignant moments. The Deleted Scenes enhance the narrative with expanded patient stories and further interviews. Dan Cohen’s segment, Ask Dan Cohen, gives a practical perspective on reintroducing music to the elderly, while the Michael Rossato-Bennett Interview covers broader thematic discussions without chapter stops. The Alive Inside Soundtrack featurette delves into the film’s music, detailing its composition and influences. Furthermore, the Trailer effectively encapsulates the documentary’s essence, featuring exclusive snippets.
Extras included in this disc:
- Deleted Scenes: Extended interviews and patient stories.
- Ask Dan Cohen: Practical perspectives on restoring music.
- Michael Rossato-Bennett Interview: In-depth thematic discussion.
- Alive Inside Soundtrack: Analysis of the film’s score.
- Trailer: Effective encapsulation of the film.
Movie: 86
"Alive Inside: A Story of Music and Memory" is an emotionally resonant documentary that showcases the transformative power of music for individuals whose cognitive functions have been severely compromised by age or medical conditions such as Alzheimer's, dementia, and multiple sclerosis. Directed by Michael Rossato-Bennett, this film follows social worker Dan Cohen's heartfelt mission to reintegrate music into the lives of nursing home residents through his nonprofit organization, Music & Memory. The documentary juxtaposes the bleak and often dehumanizing environment of long-term care facilities with moments of profound connection as these individuals become animated and invigorated by familiar tunes played through headphones.
The film's effectiveness stems from its unembellished yet deeply moving narrative. Rossato-Bennett skillfully avoids heavy-handed narration, allowing the visceral reactions of the elderly to music to speak louder than any scripted commentary. The camera work captures touching scenes where those who have been languishing in silence and stillness suddenly sing along, dance, or simply exhibit joy—a testament to music's power as a "backdoor to the mind." Furthermore, with minimalistic yet potent montages of photos and home videos synced to the music heard by the subjects, the director ensures a balance between informing viewers of musical therapy's neurological basis and focusing on observable emotional transformations.
Technically proficient, the Blu-ray presentation is clean and visually engaging, maximizing the impact of both the intimate interviews with experts like Dr. Bill Thomas and the poignant personal moments. The film offers a mix of audio experiences: at times you hear the faint strains of music through the residents' headphones, adding authenticity to their reactions; at other times, the music is played in full fidelity, inviting viewers to share in the auditory experience. This documentary isn't just informative—it's a stirring call to recognize and better utilize music's underappreciated therapeutic potential within our healthcare system.
Total: 65
"Alive Inside: A Story of Music and Memory" is an emotionally compelling and intellectually stimulating documentary that delves into the transformative power of music on individuals living with dementia. Directed by Michael Rossato-Bennett, the film explores the concept of music therapy and its profound effects on patients' memory and mood. It offers a poignant glimpse into the lives of several elderly patients who come alive when listening to their favorite tunes from the past. The film seamlessly blends scientific insights with heartwarming personal stories, making it an engaging and thought-provoking work.
The Blu-ray release of "Alive Inside" is technically superb, ensuring viewers experience the highest quality visual and auditory presentation. The video transfer is sharp and clean, with excellent detail and contrast that enhance the viewing experience. The audio mix, especially for the featured musical segments, is well-balanced and immersive, allowing the audience to fully appreciate the therapeutic impact of the music on the subjects featured in the film. This high-quality production further elevates the documentary's powerful message.
Many of us are dealing with either parents or grandparents who are in retirement communities or nursing homes, and for those who are, "Alive Inside" is a rather provocative examination of how something so apparently simple as music can make such a major difference in peoples' lives. Heartfelt and profound in its own way, "Alive Inside: A Story of Music and Memory" is a very worthwhile documentary and comes Highly recommended. The title “Alive Inside” accurately applies both to the patients involved in the music therapy, as well as how most audiences will feel after viewing. It would be unfair of me to burden this documentary with any further excessive praise, especially since it’s already been well-received by other critics, but needless to say, it is highly recommended.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 80
Aside from some occasional banding that can occur in things like harsh fluorescent lighting, there are no artifacts of any major import....
Audio: 80
There's a very appealing underscore by Itaal Shur which receives a much more generously spacious accounting in the DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 option than in the LPCM 2.0 iteration....
Extras: 50
...
Movie: 80
The irony of an overpriced health care system doing little while the relative ease with which providing music to those in distress offers older folks at least some kind of palliative is not lost on director...
Total: 80
Many of us are dealing with either parents or grandparents who are in retirement communities or nursing homes, and for those who are, Alive Inside is a rather provocative examination of how something so...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Other visuals make us of stock footage and other graphics, which naturally vary in quality but have nothing to do with the quality of the high definition transfer....
Audio: 80
Considering the logistics of mixing in natural dialogue (sometimes murmured or mumbled) in a less than acoustically ideal environment, along with a music played back through headphones, voice-over narration,...
Extras: 60
Bennett provides a commentary which is extensive, thorough and insightful, with many compliments given (justifiably) to the people onscreen, including caretakers, musicians and activists....
Movie: 100
Mr. Cohen actively demonstrates what is essentially a healing power of music, and his cause draws attention to the social castigation and personal deterioration of the elderly and the disabled....
Total: 80
It would be unfair of me to burden this documentary with any further excessive praise, especially since it’s already been well-received by other critics, but needless to say, it is highly recommended....
Director: Michael Rossato-Bennett
Actors: Dan Cohen, Louise Dueno, Nell Hardie
PlotA social worker dedicated to improving the lives of elderly patients in nursing homes embarks on a journey to demonstrate the profound effect of music on people suffering from memory loss and dementia. He introduces personalized music playlists to these individuals, carefully selecting songs that hold personal significance from their past. As the music reaches their ears, some patients, who have been unresponsive or withdrawn due to their conditions, begin to exhibit remarkable signs of joy, engagement, and memory recall. Their transformations provide compelling evidence of music's unique ability to rekindle lost connections and evoke vivid memories.
The social worker's innovative approach also serves as a critique of the current state of elder care, where patients often suffer from neglect and a lack of stimulation. As he visits various institutions and interacts with healthcare professionals, families, and caregivers, he advocates for a more compassionate and personalized care model. This journey is documented through heartfelt interviews and captivating footage, underscoring the emotional and psychological benefits of music therapy. The story powerfully illustrates the deep, enduring bond between music and memory, offering hope and inspiration to all those affected by dementia and other memory-related conditions.
Writers: Michael Rossato-Bennett
Release Date: 18 Oct 2014
Runtime: 78 min
Rating: Not Rated
Country: United States
Language: English