The Battle of Jangsari Blu-ray Review
장사리: 잊혀진 영웅들
Score: 63
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
"Despite solid technical merits, The Battle of Jangsari suffers from a haphazard presentation and lack of emotional resonance, making it a rental-worthy film."
Disc Release Date
Video: 76
"The Battle of Jangsari" on Blu-ray delivers a satisfactory 1080p transfer with strong colors and excellent detail, despite some noticeable banding in darker scenes and a sickly yellow color grading for certain segments, maintaining a professional and engaging visual presentation.
Audio: 81
The 5.1 DTS-HD Master Audio track for 'The Battle of Jangsari' delivers a robust and immersive experience with perfectly balanced dialogue, powerful LFE bursts, and dynamic surround effects, capturing the chaos of war through vivid gunfire, explosions, and aircraft sounds.
Extra: 16
The Blu-ray extras, including a concise 'Making Of' featurette and multiple trailers, are seamlessly authored to play consecutively, exemplifying Well Go USA’s commitment to an immersive viewing experience despite the brief runtime and automated trailer sequences.
Movie: 51
The Battle of Jangsari unearths a crucial but often forgotten Korean War episode, drawing significant parallels to Saving Private Ryan in its depiction of youth soldiers in harrowing combat. Despite compelling battle sequences and historically rich narrative, limited emotional depth and cultural specificity may inhibit broader resonance.
Video: 76
The Battle of Jangsari Blu-ray, distributed by Well Go USA, is a visually compelling presentation, thanks to a proficient AVC encoded 1080p transfer in a 2.39:1 aspect ratio. The film incorporates distinctive color grading strategies that aim to evoke the era's ambiance, particularly within the American base and ship scenes, which are intentionally drenched in a sickly yellow hue reminiscent of the Vietnam and Korean wars. In contrast, the outdoor beach and battle sequences maintain a more neutral palette, creating a stark visual differentiation that enhances the narrative's emphasis. Colors are robust, predominantly skewed towards earth and dark tones, which effectively augment the war film's gritty realism.
Technically, the Blu-ray presentation excels in delivering fine level details, especially during brightly lit daytime scenes. The intricacies of beach sand and the grim details of injuries are conveyed with impressive clarity. However, some darker scenes do suffer from noticeable banding and a slightly murky appearance, particularly exacerbated by grading towards darker blues. Yet, aside from these minor compression anomalies during opening sequences, the transfer remains largely devoid of any significant technical flaws. The overall quality is consistent with the expected standards for modern Blu-ray releases, providing an immersive visual experience that respects the film's historical setting.
Audio: 81
The DTS-HD MA 5.1 Korean track on the Blu-ray of "The Battle of Jangsari" delivers a robust and immersive audio experience, especially fitting for a war film. The audio presentation is largely in Korean with brief sequences in English featuring George Eads and Megan Fox, accompanied by optional English subtitles. The action scenes are packed with dynamic sound elements including gunfire, explosions, and the ominous shrieking of planes dropping bombs overhead. Dialogue remains perfectly balanced and clear amidst the chaos, with no noticeable dropouts, distortion, or damage.
The sound design ensures that the cacophony of warfare is effectively channeled through the surrounds and mains, providing an enveloping and intense auditory environment. The LFE is particularly powerful and deep, with plenty of low-end moments shaking into the low 20 Hz range, adding to the visceral impact of the scenes. The opening shipboard sequence features a low-end thunk that is so profound it might even challenge one's comfort levels. Ambient environmental sounds are strategically placed in the surround channels, further enhancing the immersive quality of the experience.
Extras: 16
The Extras section of "The Battle of Jangsari" Blu-ray provides a concise yet insightful look into the film's production and promotional materials. The "Making Of" featurette, though brief, offers behind-the-scenes footage that highlights the efforts and coordination required to bring the battle scenes to life. Three trailers, each in 1080p resolution, present different marketing angles, including a U.S. version. Notably, the "Making Of" feature serves as a de facto "Play All" button, seamlessly transitioning into subsequent trailers and promotional content for other Well Go USA releases. This automatic sequencing enhances user experience by providing uninterrupted access to supplementary materials.
Extras included in this disc:
- Making Of: Behind-the-scenes footage.
- Trailer A: Original promotional trailer.
- Trailer B: Additional promotional trailer.
- U.S. Trailer: American market trailer.
Movie: 51
"The Battle of Jangsari" provides a raw and visceral portrayal of a lesser-known but pivotal event during the Korean War. Centering on a battalion of youthful soldiers—averaging just 17 years old—the film recounts their arduous mission on Jangsari beach, directed as a diversionary tactic to support General MacArthur's larger "Operation Chromite." The narrative vividly captures the brutal realities of war, with scenes of soldiers stepping into treacherous waters under heavy fire. Despite its earnest attempt to pay homage to these young heroes, the film often feels derivative, drawing significant visual and thematic parallels to "Saving Private Ryan." This results in a somewhat predictable and emotionally detached viewing experience for those unfamiliar with Korean history.
The film's attempt at cross-cultural appeal through the inclusion of Western actors like Megan Fox and George Eads feels somewhat contrived. Fox's portrayal of a character based on renowned war correspondents Margaret Bourke-White and Marguerite Higgins lacks the intended gravitas, rendering her scenes both sporadic and unconvincing. Additionally, the plot's frequent shifts between different perspectives, coupled with cliché-ridden American segments, detract from its overall coherence. While the battle sequences are executed with commendable intensity and technical proficiency, they fail to foster a deep emotional connection with the audience due to insufficient character development.
Ultimately, "The Battle of Jangsari" serves as a notable historical piece that sheds light on a crucial yet often overlooked event in the Korean War. It's clear that the film aims to evoke patriotism among South Korean viewers by spotlighting the sacrifices of these young soldiers. However, for Western audiences, the emotional impact may be diluted by the film's episodic structure and its heavy reliance on familiar wartime tropes. Despite its shortcomings, the film remains an interesting watch, particularly for those with a keen interest in Korean history and military strategy.
Total: 63
"The Battle of Jangsari" on Blu-ray presents a technically proficient package but falls short in delivering a compelling narrative. The film centers around the heroic yet tragic account of young, ill-prepared cadets endeavoring to liberate South Korea from a perceived threat. While the subject matter possesses raw potential, its execution falters with a disjointed presentation and underdeveloped emotional impact. The historical context may also prove confusing for international audiences, further undermined by the awkward incorporation of English-language scenes.
On the technical front, the Blu-ray excels with a 2.39:1 AVC aspect ratio and immersive DTS-HD MA 5.1 audio that captures the intensity of battle sequences effectively. Accompanying subtitles are well-synced and enhance accessibility for non-Korean speakers. Despite solid performances by actors like Minho Choi and Myung-Min Kim, the minimal screen presence of Megan Fox and George Eads—emphasized mainly for U.S. marketing—adds little to the film's substance.
In conclusion, "The Battle of Jangsari" is an effort marked by good intentions and commendable technical efforts but marred by a muddled storyline and lackluster emotional engagement. This release will appeal to war history enthusiasts and those interested in high-definition audio-visual experiences, yet may leave others wanting more in terms of narrative cohesion and emotional depth. Given these aspects, it would be prudent to consider this as a rental before committing to a purchase.
Recommendation: Rental
AV Nirvana review by Michael ScottRead review here
Video: 80
There’s several different color grading schemes going on here, with the American Base scenes, and the scenes inside the troop transport ship being very heavily bathed in that sickly yellow look that’s...
Audio: 90
Dialog is still well placed and perfectly balanced, while the cacophony of death and destruction rips through the surrounds and mains....
Extras: 20
...
Movie: 60
It may resonate more powerfully with it’s intended audience in South Korea, but as a westerner I had a very difficult time connecting some of the emotional dots, and the American scenes just felt a bit...
Total: 70
If you watch the international trailers, Megan Fox and George Eads aren’t even mentioned, and barely seen, but the U.S. Blu-ray cover and the trailer have their names and faces plastered all over it....
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 90
Aside from what is now the expected flurry of banding during Well Go USA's opening masthead, there aren't any major compression anomalies of note, and the film, while kind of weirdly graded toward kind...
Audio: 90
The battle scenes offer a glut of whizzing and panning bullet effects, with other ambient environmental sounds regularly dotting the surround channels....
Extras: 20
Note: As often tends to be the case with Well Go USA Blu-ray releases, the supplements have been authored to follow one another automatically (so that clicking on the Making Of featurette is essentially...
Movie: 50
It's kind of interesting in a way to watch the three trailers included on this Blu-ray disc as supplements to see that the film was obviously marketed differently for audiences in Korea and the United...
Total: 50
Unfortunately, the film is too haphazard in its presentation, and the actual history is going to be a bit muddled for many American viewers at least, with the few English language expository scenes coming...
Director: Tae-hun Kim, Kyung-taek Kwak
Actors: Megan Fox, George Eads, Lee Jae-wook
PlotDuring the Korean War, a small and inexperienced group of student soldiers embarks on a crucial but dangerous mission to Jangsari Beach. Tasked with diverting enemy attention from the ongoing Incheon Landing Operation, the young and undertrained troops face overwhelming odds as they struggle to complete their mission with limited resources. Their journey is fraught with challenges from the onset, including harsh weather, lack of proper equipment, and the daunting realization of their precarious situation. Despite their fears and doubts, they rally together, understanding the significance of their sacrifice for the greater good.
As they land on Jangsari Beach, they encounter fierce resistance from the enemy, resulting in intense and harrowing combat. The young soldiers must summon all their courage and resourcefulness to fight back, relying on their camaraderie and sheer determination to push forward. Meanwhile, a war correspondent sheds light on their plight, drawing international attention to their bravery and the dire circumstances they face. The initial phase of their mission sets the stage for a grueling battle for survival, highlighting both the horrors of war and the resilience of the human spirit.
Writers: Brian Chung, Cory Gustke, Man-Hee Lee
Release Date: 11 Oct 2019
Runtime: 104 min
Rating: Not Rated
Country: South Korea, Hong Kong, United States
Language: Korean, English