Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Review
Score: 76
from 6 reviewers
Review Date:
Grindelwald fumbles in plot but dazzles in 4K; more setup than story.
Disc Release Date
True 4K
HDR10
Dolby Vision
Dolby Atmos
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 80
The UK Ultra HD Blu-ray release of 'Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald' dazzles with its native 4K presentation, HDR, and Dolby Vision, offering an unparalleled visual feast that sets a franchise benchmark.
Audio: 83
The Dolby Atmos tracks offer an immersive, dynamic audio experience with clear dialogue, enveloping soundscapes, and varied enactment across films, though some lack punch in low frequencies.
Extra: 71
The UK release of 'Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald' outshines the US with a physical Extra Disc featuring an Extended Cut and Atmos track, alongside substantial Blu-ray extras diving deep into Rowling's world, with scene breakdowns and cast interviews highlighting the magic.
Movie: 51
The Crimes of Grindelwald struggles with excess plotting and lackluster crescendo, yet harbors moments of magic and charm amid its ambitious visuals.
Video: 80
Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald" elevates its visual storytelling through its 4K UHD Blu-ray presentation, which showcases a native 3840 x 2160p resolution, benefitting from a comprehensive use of HDR, WCG, and Dolby Vision, encoded using HEVC (H.265). This release fully exploits the capabilities of the Arri Alexa 65 camera system, originally capturing the imagery at 6.5K before being mastered to a full 4K digital intermediate. The resulting image clarity and detail is beyond reproach, giving life to the textures and depth of the film's intricate production design and costume detail. Close-ups and wide-angle shots alike reveal a staggering amount of detail, with the movie thriving in both brightly lit exteriors and dark, shadow-drenched sequences thanks to its dynamic range.
The color grading of "The Crimes of Grindelwald" employs a reserved but effective palette that supports its period setting with finesse, allowing its more vibrant moments to stand out. HDR enhances both the subtle and bold uses of color, deepening blacks and enriching contrast to bring out the best in both mundane scenes and those filled with magical spectacle. Scenes like the opening chase, Newt Scamander's animal sanctuary, and the finale's fiery confrontation are visually arresting, demonstrating both the film's skilful use of CGI and the 4K format's ability to convey a rich, immersive world. Despite some issues of black crush and noise in darker scenes, which can slightly detract from the viewing experience, the overall clarity and depth of the image remain unaffected.
The technical prowess of this 4K release cannot be overstated. From capturing the intricate designs of Paris and London to rendering the most delicate features of magical creatures and spell effects, every frame benefits from an enhanced level of detail that feels almost three-dimensional. Although not without its technical shortcomings such as occasional softness in CG-heavy scenes and minor artifacting, these are far outweighed by the spectacular visual fidelity offered across the board. With flesh tones that appear natural and textures that pop from costumes to creature designs, "The Crimes of Grindelwald" in 4K is a testament to how high-definition technology can elevate a film's visual impact, making it a must-own for both film aficionados and fans of the wizarding world.
Audio: 83
The Dolby Atmos soundtrack accompanying the 4K UHD Blu-ray of "Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald" delivers a captivating audio experience, ensuring that the spellbinding visuals are matched by equally stunning audio. Designed to immerse the viewer within the magical realm through a High Definition 3D Object-based track, it offers a richly layered audio environment. From the swirling spells to the bustling crowds of the wizarding world, the soundscape is meticulously crafted to envelop you, providing a satisfying depth through effectively utilized LFE channels and well-prioritized dialogue. The soundtrack excels in creating a sense of 360-degree immersion, especially during crowd-based sequences and spell-casting moments, leveraging the full potential of the surrounds and letting each magical moment resonate with clarity and depth.
Despite its strengths, some reviews note that the mix could benefit from a more aggressive approach to its low-frequency effects to match the on-screen action's intensity, which occasionally feels underwhelming. Nevertheless, specific sequences make excellent use of the Atmos setup, with discrete effects and atmospheric sound objects adding layers to the film’s orchestration and enhancing the overall narrative tone. The sound stage remains active throughout, balancing quieter moments with dynamic action scenes, while ensuring dialogue clarity against the backdrop of James Newton Howard's enchanting score, which seamlessly integrates with the film's thematic elements.
Interestingly, while the track boasts significant surround activity and adept use of ceiling channels for its height effects, some find the rear activity reserved compared to its predecessor, slightly detracting from the immersive potential in quieter scenes. Despite these criticisms, the audio presentation maintains an engaging half-dome soundstage, with precise imaging and clear mid-range separation. Vocals remain intelligible amidst wizarding chaos, and while the low-end might benefit from added power, it still provides enough weight to energize key scenes. This Dolby Atmos soundtrack manages to capture the essence of “The Crimes of Grindelwald,” offering both subtlety and complexity in its audio delivery, making it a commendable component of this home theater experience.
Extras: 71
The extra presentation of the 4K UHD Blu-ray of "Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald" differentiates itself by the inclusion of a third disc in the UK version, offering an Extended Cut with an Atmos track, a feature notably absent in its US counterpart where the Extended Cut is available only via digital download. This additional cut, although marginally lengthening the film, represents a commitment to delivering content that fans will appreciate. The bulk of supplemental material is hosted on the standard Blu-ray disc, which encompasses a range of featurettes and deleted scenes that dive deep into the making of the film. Highlights include intimate interviews with J.K. Rowling revealing her story crafting process, insightful discussions around the portrayal of young Dumbledore by Jude Law, and an extensive six-part documentary ("Unlocking Scene Secrets") covering key scenes' production intricacies. For enthusiasts seeking a comprehensive behind-the-scenes look, these extras, including a detailed exploration of visual effects and character motivations, offer a satisfying delve into Rowling's expansive universe, though the extras predominantly maintain a promotional tone.
Extras included in this disc:
J.K. Rowling: A World Revealed: Rowling discusses the storytelling process and the expansion beyond Hogwarts.
Wizards on Screen, Fans in Real Life: Ezra Miller and Evanna Lynch offer personal insights and fan perspectives.
Distinctly Dumbledore: Jude Law and others explore the younger version of Dumbledore and his portrayal.
Unlocking Scene Secrets: A collection of six featurettes breaking down key scenes and sequences from the film.
Deleted Scenes: Ten clips offering additional content not included in the theatrical release.
Movie: 51
The Crimes of Grindelwald, the sequel in the Fantastic Beasts saga, ambitiously expands the Wizarding World with a crowded ensemble and a narrative richness that teeters between intricately captivating and undeniably overwhelming. Directed by David Yates and serving as the tenth installment in J.K. Rowling's expansive film saga, this narrative picks up with the dark wizard Grindelwald's (Johnny Depp) dramatic escape, setting a swift pace with high stakes. While the film boasts commendable performances from Eddie Redmayne as the endearing Newt Scamander, Johnny Depp, who brings a sinister charm to Grindelwald, and Jude Law as a younger Albus Dumbledore, their efforts are encumbered by a script that grapples with excessive subplots and an overly ambitious attempt to weave complexity into the Wizarding World lore. The narrative attempts to juggle too many character arcs and magical concepts, at times veering into convoluted territories that detract from the central plot's urgency.
Despite being visually resplendent and featuring several momentous sequences that hint at a grander narrative ambition—such as the thrilling opening with Grindelwald's escape—the movie often feels bogged down by its sprawling narrative and an apparent reluctance to steer its wealth of characters towards a cohesive endpoint. The inclusion of beloved elements from the Harry Potter universe provides a nostalgic touch, yet it occasionally feels like an overreliance on past triumphs rather than fostering a distinct identity for the Fantastic Beasts series. Moreover, while the movie seeks to delve into darker themes, mirroring the maturity trajectory of the original Potter series, it sometimes struggles to balance its tone, veering between somberness and magical whimsy without finding a steady footing.
In essence, The Crimes of Grindelwald emerges as a visually stunning yet narratively overstretched chapter in the Fantastic Beasts series. Its ambition to lay groundwork for future installments is palpable, embarking on a more interconnected narrative that seeks to deepen the franchise's lore. Nonetheless, the execution falters under the weight of its own complexity, leading to a piece that, while fascinating and enriched by strong performances, ultimately feels like a preparatory gesture—a setting of the stage for future tales—rather than a fully satisfying adventure on its own. The series promises more, and this film, despite its shortcomings, leaves an open door for the magic, mystery, and character development that fans of Rowling's universe so deeply cherish.
Total: 76
Review of "Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald" 4K UHD Blu-Ray Presentation
"Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald" brings us back into the enchanting yet tumultuous world of magic with its second installment, surprisingly brimming with both visual marvel and narrative convolutions. This 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray release from Warner Brothers Home Entertainment boasts an exceptionally pristine video quality that elevates the viewing experience with its Dolby Vision-enhanced 4K visuals. Coupled with an immersive Dolby Atmos soundtrack, the technical presentation is designed to engulf the audience into the wizarding world’s chaos and charm, far beyond what the standard Blu-ray edition offers.
However, the film itself does not seem to live up to the high standards set by its technical prowess. Overstuffed plots and a plethora of characters, half of whom struggle to captivate, lead to an experience that feels more tedious than magical. This entry appears as a bridge, potentially crucial for setting up future installations but failing to forge its defining essence. Despite this, the film shines through its special effects and core performances, holding onto moments of genuine enchantment amidst the narrative clutter. The UK edition particularly stands out by going a step further to include an Extended Cut on a third Blu-ray disc, considerably enriching the package for die-hard fans and completists.
Conclusion
"The Crimes of Grindelwald" may falter in narrative ambition, caught between trying to expand the beloved universe and preparing the ground for its future lore. Yet, this 4K UHD release emerges as an essential collectible, primarily due to its unparalleled audio-visual experience and insightful supplementary materials. Whether it warrants an immediate purchase or a wait-and-see approach until the series further unfolds, depends largely on individual allegiance to the franchise. Nevertheless, for those seeking the utmost fidelity in home cinema, it's a marvel not to be overlooked.
avforums review by Casimir HarlowRead review here
Video: 90
Higher than 4K capture, 4K pipeline, native 4K disc, HDR, WCG and Dolby Vision as the pearlescent cherry on top Technically, this is just about as good as it gets - higher than 4K capture, 4K pipeline,...
Audio: 100
The Atmos track is an equally excellent affair Those familiar with this universe - as you should likely be given this is the tenth film - will know full well what to expect, with the magical realm rife...
Extras: 80
The Extended Cut is only a few minutes' longer, and hardly helps the already bloated narrative, but since the US package purportedly only allows viewers access to a digital download copy of this second...
Movie: 60
This might be more forgivable if it was the first film, but Crimes of Grindelwald has started the ball rolling with the main threat - unleashing Depp's antagonist on the world, and leaving the magical...
Total: 80
It's poor plotting, robbing tension with every one of the myriad side-plots that help fill its over-indulgent runtime, and it's ultimately more interested in setting up the potentially taut and memorable...
Blu-ray.com review by Randy Miller IIIRead review here
Video: 90
The latter is boosted significantly by the full benefits of HDR, which go a long way in bringing rich and interesting colors out of dark backgrounds -- of which there are plenty -- while effects-driven...
Audio: 90
The Dolby Atmos presentation (which unfolds to a Dolby TrueHD 7.1 mix if you're not set up for Atmos) is equally impressive, as there's a great deal of surround activity and presence on display from start...
Extras: 90
In this short piece, the author (and screenwriter/producer for The Crimes of Grindelwald) talks about moving beyond Hogwarts, the challenges of adapting a more complex story, editing down and revising...
Movie: 60
Overall, The Crimes of Grindelwald is clearly a step down from its predecessor but, thanks to the performances and visually ambitious atmosphere, it's still worth at least a once-over if you enjoyed the...
Total: 60
As a franchise, I'm not the biggest Fantastic Beasts fan -- more from lack of long-term experience than personal preference -- but even within those boundaries, it's obvious that The Crimes of Grindenwald...
DoBlu review by Matt PaprockiRead review here
Video: 60
The change is subtle and slow, clever really, paralleling an animated film in total control over its look and ensuring mood is appropriate....
Audio: 80
Activity never dulls, and even in conversation, there’s focus on keeping things moving away from the center....
Extras: 80
Pop that in and start with A World Revealed, which sits down the J.K. Rowling for 10-minutes as she discusses her idea for this story....
Movie: 40
Here, the Ministry of Magic is hopeless – it’s not illegal to be a bigot, and law lacks recourse to save people from themselves....
Total: 65
Crimes of Grindelwald jumbles a number of storylines with heavy exposition and little charm in this darker entry of the series....
High-Def Digest review by M. Enois DuarteRead review here
Video: 90
Individual hairs and the threading in the costumes are more distinct, and the various small objects decorating the background of many homes are plainly visible in the distance while facial complexions...
Audio: 80
The effects discretely pan between the surrounds and encircle the listening area effectively, and some of that activity occasionally travels overhead with the Circus Arcanus sequence and the climactic...
Extras: 40
Digital Copy Exclusive Extended Version (HD, 142 min): The longer version adds seven minutes to the original runtime with previously deleted scenes and commences with a brief intro....
Movie: 40
With each entry to the Harry Potter saga, the franchise felt as though it was swelling and developing to a legendary epic, building towards a grand climactic showdown as every new story expanded and improved...
Total: 60
Without a printed source to work from, Rowling conjures an original tale meant to expand the Harry Potter universe, but the plot fumbles about trying to keep one too many spells and charms in order, ultimately...
AVSForum review by Ralph PottsRead review here
Video: 92
Wide angle shots and the contrasting cinematography, going from brightly lit exteriors to the variety of dark, shadowy sequences look great in Ultra HD....
Audio: 88
In listening to the Dolby Atmos surround mix I found it to be of the moderately active variety that made steady use of the platform....
Extras: 60
Disc 1: Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald Ultra HD Blu-ray Disc 2: Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald Blu-ray • J.K. Rowling: A World Revealed • Wizards on Screen, Fans in Real Life...
Movie: 60
Facing unforeseen dangers, Newt must find a way to stop Grindelwald, whose plan for pure-blood wizards to rule over non-magical beings threatens to divide the entire wizarding world.”...
Total: 75
This film doesn’t have the narrative depth of the first film, feeling more like a bridge that leads up to the next...
Why So Blu?Read review here
Video: 100
The camera and characters move with such confidence and smoothness through a spacious arena in every frame....
Audio: 100
From the quiet moments to the loud rushing action, this track is plenty loose, free and loudly consuming....
Extras: 80
Its mainly led by Rowling, Yates and Heyman but members of the cast and crew show up to give thoughts throughout (And yes, Johnny Depp does show up and its pretty fascinating to see their process in getting...
Movie: 50
In keeping us from this reveal, we are given a big red herring through the journey of this film that winds up in one of the most over-expositioned, convoluted explanations I’ve ever seen put into a major...
Total: 70
Overall, its solid entertainment, but is it a one-time view kinda entertainment or one that you can continue to return to as most of this series has been....
Director: David Yates
Actors: Eddie Redmayne, Katherine Waterston, Dan Fogler
PlotDark wizard Gellert Grindelwald escapes custody, intent on gathering followers to raise pure-blood wizards up to rule over all non-magical beings. Albus Dumbledore, unable to move against Grindelwald directly, enlists his former student, Newt Scamander, who is unaware of the dangers ahead. As Newt agrees to help, unaware of Grindelwald's true agenda, he sets off on a quest that leads him to Paris. Along the way, Newt encounters a spectrum of characters both new and familiar, each with their own motives and secrets. Among them are Newt's former love, Leta Lestrange, and his estranged brother, Theseus, who is engaged to Leta.
In Paris, Grindelwald's influence grows as his ideology attracts a following, stirring tension within the wizarding world. Newt's mission becomes increasingly perilous as he learns more about Grindelwald's past, his connection with Dumbledore, and the divisive path they both share. With the wizarding world becoming more divided, Newt and his allies face a series of challenges that test their loyalty, courage, and love. They must navigate the complex web of alliances and enmities, all while trying to fend off Grindelwald's expanding influence before it engulfs the world in chaos.
Writers: J.K. Rowling
Release Date: 16 Nov 2018
Runtime: 134 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United Kingdom, United States
Language: English, French