Of Gods and Men Blu-ray Review
Des hommes et des dieux
Score: 66
from 4 reviewers
Review Date:
'Of Gods and Men' Blu-ray offers exceptional 1080p visuals and near-faultless sound, delivering a haunting, powerful story on faith and sacrifice; highly recommended.
Disc Release Date
Video: 69
The 1080p Blu-ray of 'Of Gods and Men' offers a pristine transfer with striking clarity, sharp detailing, and a faithfully preserved grain structure, framed in a 2.35:1 aspect ratio. The nuanced color palette and solid black levels enhance the film's aesthetic, making it an exceptional viewing experience.
Audio: 71
Despite being dialogue-driven and front-heavy, the DTS-HD MA 5.1 surround mix of 'Of Gods and Men' masterfully uses subtleties such as ambient effects, rich mid-range tones, and selective deep bass to create an immersive and well-balanced audio experience, enhancing the film's naturalistic and serene setting.
Extra: 43
The Blu-ray of 'Of Gods and Men' enriches viewer understanding with 'The Sacrificed Tibehirine: Further Investigation'—an 18-minute French documentary—and a 41-minute Merrimack College Dialogue with author John W. Kiser, offering substantive insights despite the dry presentation and low video quality.
Movie: 88
A stunningly crafted and thought-provoking film, 'Of Gods and Men' arrives on Blu-ray with an exceptional 1080p transfer and immersive DTS-HD MA 5.1 audio. This haunting narrative, grounded in the monks' internal and external struggles, is vividly brought to life through extraordinary performances and Beauvois’s nuanced direction.
Video: 69
"Of Gods and Men" arrives on Blu-ray with an exemplary 1080p AVC/MPEG-4 transfer framed in the original 2.35:1 aspect ratio, capturing the visual essence of Caroline Champetier’s cinematography. The transfer demonstrates exceptional refinement, exhibiting crisp details in close-ups and mid-level camera pans. The color palette, typically muted, aligns well with the film's tone, producing stable and natural hues whether showcasing the verdant landscapes or subdued indoor scenes. Skin tones are rendered with a natural texture, avoiding the artificial appearance often seen in Hollywood productions. Notably, black levels are deep and devoid of crush, though some darker interiors display a fine veil of grain, reflecting potentially faster stock usage. The image remains sharp without clinical overtones, and there is no evidence of digital tampering. Overall, this Blu-ray presentation is notable for its visual authenticity.
The production makes excellent use of its Moroccan settings with strong object detailing in foliage, monastic architecture, and village structures. Fine lines and textures, such as individual hairs and fabric weaves, are distinct and meticulously defined. While there are minor instances of haziness in some scenes and murky shadows in poorly lit interiors, these are sporadic and do not detract from the overall visual experience. The contrast is well managed with bright whites and stable blacks that contribute to a pleasing dynamic range suitable to the region's lighting nuances. The transfer is impressively free from common artefacts such as banding or blocking, ensuring a pristine visual presentation throughout the film.
In summary, "Of Gods and Men" receives a Blu-ray transfer that is both technically proficient and visually captivating, faithfully preserving the film's aesthetic integrity while providing an engaging viewing experience.
Audio: 71
The audio presentation for "Of Gods and Men" on Blu Ray offers an exceptional DTS-HD MA 5.1 surround mix that prioritizes clear and intelligible dialogue, particularly beneficial for a French-language film with English subtitles. The soundtrack's precision is evident in the way it handles dialogue via the center channel, allowing every word to be heard distinctly. The mix's effectiveness extends to its use of surround speakers, creating a rich, immersive environment with ambient effects, such as crowd noise and natural ambience like gently falling rain or distant bells. One of the highlights includes the monks' chants, which capitalize on the surround channels to deliver beautifully resonant harmonies inside the chapel. High-level details, including subtle sound effects and music, are exceptionally clear and well-defined.
The soundtrack's versatility stands out through its balanced integration of both serene and heavier sound elements. Atmospheric sounds envelop the listener, contributing to the film's immersive monastic setting. Heavier effects, like rumbling heavy machinery and the impactful thumps of helicopter rotors, inject depth and dimension into specific scenes. The mix also effectively juxtaposes quieter moments with sudden, dynamic sounds, enhancing the emotional range of the movie. Gunshots, for instance, add an extra layer of intensity to the narrative. Throughout these shifts, the DTS-HD MA 5.1 mix ensures stability in mid-range sound and offers sufficient low-end presence when required. Overall, this sound mix remains faithful to the source material, offering a well-balanced auditory experience that complements the film’s visual and narrative tones beautifully.
Extras: 43
The Blu-Ray extras for "Of Gods and Men" offer a robust yet concise complement to the main feature, providing in-depth insights and valuable context about the real-life events depicted in the film. The pivotal piece is "The Sacrificed Tibéhirine: Further Investigation," an 18-minute French documentary that affords a poignant exploration of the historical backdrop and real individuals portrayed in the movie, complete with English subtitles. Also notable is the "Merrimack College Augustine Dialogue IX," a 41-minute, straightforward yet informative discussion between philosopher George Heffernan and author John W. Kiser. This segment delves into theological reflections on Christian and Islamic coexistence, captured in low-quality video but rich in substance. Additionally, a theatrical trailer in HD efficiently introduces the narrative's core conflicts, piquing viewer interest.
Extras included in this disc:
- The Sacrificed Tibéhirine: Further Investigation: In-depth French documentary with English subtitles.
- Merrimack College Augustine Dialogue IX with Author John W. Kiser: Informative interview discussing the book on which the movie is based.
- Theatrical Trailer: HD preview of the movie's central dilemma.
- BD-Live enabled: Network feature for additional content.
- DVD Copy: Standard-definition version of the film.
Movie: 88
Xavier Beauvois’ 2010 Cannes Grand Prix winner, "Of Gods and Men," arrives on American Region free Blu-ray with an outstanding 1080p AVC/MPEG-4 transfer, framed in the widescreen 2.35:1 aspect ratio. The cinematography captures the subtle interplay of interior and exterior lighting, meticulously preserving realistic skin tones within a slightly muted color palette. The DTS-HD MA 5.1 surround audio delivers clear, crisp French dialogue, with English subtitles available. The surround sound effectively immerses viewers in the atmospheric effects, enhancing the film's emotional depth. The Blu-ray includes a short documentary, an in-depth discussion on the subject matter, and a trailer as bonus content.
"Of Gods and Men" narrates the poignant true story of nine French Trappist monks living harmoniously with their Muslim neighbors in mid-1990s civil-war-torn Algeria. Led by Christian (Lambert Wilson), the monks face existential threats from a local Islamic fundamentalist group after refusing to provide medical aid to wounded terrorists. The monks grapple with the decision to stay or flee, ultimately choosing to stay despite imminent danger. Beauvois' direction is masterfully understated, with the camera often stationary, allowing viewers to fully absorb the monks' daily rituals and inner turmoil. The film’s minimalistic yet potent storytelling emphasizes faith as a counter to fear, avoiding melodrama while delivering profound thematic content.
The film's contemplative nature is heightened by uniformly excellent performances. Lambert Wilson's portrayal of Christian is particularly noteworthy, capturing the deep inner conflict and steadfast dedication to faith. Xavier Beauvois' evocative direction showcases the monks' quiet lives without resorting to cinematic excesses, making "Of Gods and Men" a powerful meditation on moral courage and solidarity. This visually restrained yet emotionally gripping film stands as a testament to the seamless integration of narrative structure and thematic exploration in cinematic art.
Total: 66
Of Gods and Men is a profound exploration of human faith and resilience, meticulously directed by Xavier Beauvois. This film diverges from traditional cinematic norms, focusing keenly on storytelling rather than style. Beauvois crafts an engaging and impactful narrative, ensuring the exclusion of superfluous elements that could detract from the film’s powerful themes. The result is an emotionally charged and intellectually stimulating experience, although it is not always an easy watch. The film forces viewers to confront challenging themes head-on, making it a rewarding but intense journey.
The Blu-ray presentation of Of Gods and Men is exceptional, with pristine 1080p imagery that captures the film's visual nuances beautifully. The near faultless lossless sound further enhances the immersive quality of the film, ensuring that viewers are fully enveloped in the experience. Although the collection of extras on the disc is minimal, the overall quality of the audio and video presentations make this Blu-ray a worthy addition to any serious collection.
In conclusion, Of Gods and Men stands out as a testament to potent storytelling and dramatic cinema. Its emotionally engaging narrative, combined with strong performances and insightful direction, render it a must-watch. The high-quality Blu-ray release only amplifies this experience, making it highly recommended for cinephiles and those seeking a meaningful cinematic journey.
avforums review by AVForumsRead review here
Video: 90
We get solid blacks in the night shots and a very pleasing contrast range, reflecting the light of the region....
Audio: 90
The cutting together of scenes makes great use of going from a noisy scene to a quiet one and the surround speakers are used effectively to immerse us in the crowd noise or other ambient effect....
Extras: 70
This provides us with more detail surrounding the real life events depicted in the movie and goes into theological thoughts on Christian and Islamic faith in co-existence....
Movie: 90
As a movie, it’s a powerful piece of film making from director Xavier Beauvois based on the true story of a group of French Trappist monks living side by side with their Muslim neighbours in Civil war...
Total: 90
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 100
Colors are stable and natural, whether the greens and earthy hues as seen in many exterior shots or the more subdued shades of blue and gray seen inside....
Audio: 90
The track is very well balanced and while it might not be the first choice to demo that high-dollar sound system, listeners will nevertheless be more than satisfied with the track's faithfulness to the...
Extras: 40
The Sacrificed Tib�hirine: Further Investigation (480p, 18:37): A piece that examines both the real people portrayed in the film and the picture's role in keeping the works and memories of the monks alive....
Movie: 100
Both fear and faith are invisible humanly attributes manifested through partnerships with external, tangible elements and unseen yet equally potent symbols alike, one challenging the other for a man's...
Total: 80
This is far from a traditional motion picture in terms of both story and structure, but Director Xavier Beauvois has crafted an enthralling and altogether potent film that should be recognized as the champion...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
Filmmakers took great advantage of the beautiful Moroccan locations, and the picture quality here does fairly nice in delivering that beauty....
Audio: 80
The focus is, of course, on a well-prioritized and precise dialogue, which is excellently delivered from the center of the screen, making this lossless mix a rather terrific presentation for a very quiet...
Extras: 20
The Sacrificed Tibéhirine: Further Investigation (SD, 19 min) — A mournful conversation that looks back on the lives of the monks with many sad insights into the events which took place....
Movie: 80
The theme of faith and devotion is all too clear throughout, but it's also something that serves the logic of the characters, the reasoning behind their decision to stay....
Total: 60
With elegant direction by Xavier Beauvois and powerful performances by the cast, the film is also a poignant meditative morality tale on faith and devotion, showing the idealism of pacifism confronted...
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 86
There is little call for active surround activity and extended dynamics however there is frequent use of atmospheric sounds that utilize the entire soundstage in support of the beautiful vocal performances...
Audio: 84
There is little call for active surround activity and extended dynamics however there is frequent use of atmospheric sounds that utilize the entire soundstage in support of the beautiful vocal performances...
Extras: 50
The sacrificed Tibehirine: Further investigation - 18 minute documentary (French) Merrimack College Augustine Dialogue with author John W. Kiser- 40 minute Q&A (HD)...
Movie: 90
Despite the growing menace in their midst, they slowly realize that they have no choice but to stay... come what may....
Total: 78
THX Ultra 2 Preamp/Video Processor Sherbourn Technologies - 7/200 Seven Channel Amplifier Oppo BDP-93 Universal Disc/3D capable Blu-ray Player (HDMI Audio/Video)...
Director: Xavier Beauvois
Actors: Lambert Wilson, Michael Lonsdale, Olivier Rabourdin
PlotIn a remote monastery in the mountains of Algeria, a group of French Trappist monks live in harmony with their Muslim neighbors. The monks lead a life of simplicity, prayer, and service, providing medical care to the local community. As Islamic fundamentalist violence starts spreading across the region in the mid-1990s, tensions rise. The brotherhood faces increasing threats from a radical group, sparking internal debates about whether to stay and continue their mission or to abandon the monastery for their safety. The monks, led by Brother Christian, confront their faith and commitment, as each monk must reconcile his devotion to God with the very real danger they face.
As the violence escalates and external pressures mount, local authorities and the French government urge the brothers to leave for their safety. Despite these growing dangers, many of the monks insist on staying, rooted in their commitment to support and stand in solidarity with their Muslim neighbors facing the same threats. They dedicate themselves to their monastery's mission of peace and coexistence, becoming symbols of courage and conviction. Their deep faith and moral choices become a central focus, exploring themes of sacrifice, friendship, and communal ties amidst the increasing dangers surrounding them. The tranquility of their monastic life stands in stark contrast to the external chaos, leading to a poignant narrative that delves into the essence of faith and humanity.
Writers: Xavier Beauvois, Etienne Comar
Release Date: 25 Mar 2011
Runtime: 122 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: France
Language: French, Arabic