Surrogates Blu-ray Review
Score: 61
from 4 reviewers
Review Date:
Surrogates' Blu-ray impresses with top-notch video and audio transfer, though the film's intriguing premise sometimes falters, balanced by sufficient extras.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 65
'Surrogates' Blu-ray offers an excellent 1080p AVC/MPEG-4 transfer with striking 2.40:1 widescreen framing, deeply saturated colors, and effective use of contrast and black levels. Despite a few noise spikes in harsh lighting, the transfer maintains high-level detail, faithful to the original cinema experience, with distinct textures between humans and surrogates.
Audio: 65
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix of 'Surrogates' is dynamic and immersive, delivering crisp dialogue, robust LFE, and precise directionality. From intense action sequences to subtle ambient effects, the surround platform enhances every element with clarity and balance, providing a notably enveloping audio experience.
Extra: 51
The Blu-ray extras for 'Surrogates' offer a thoughtfully detailed audio commentary by Director Jonathan Mostow, exploring production aspects like casting and special effects, paired with intriguing featurettes on robotics and the graphic novel adaptation. However, the deleted scenes and the Breaking Benjamin music video are less compelling.
Movie: 56
'Surrogates' Blu-ray offers a solid 1080p transfer and dynamic DTS-HD MA 5.1 surround sound, though dialogue clarity occasionally falters. The film, featuring a compelling Bruce Willis performance and intriguing thematic elements, delivers a mix of action and philosophy. Extras include insightful commentary and featurettes.
Video: 65
"Surrogates" boasts an impressive 1080p AVC/MPEG-4 transfer framed in the widescreen 2.40:1 aspect ratio, capturing the striking visuals of the original cinematic release. The transfer delivers a deeply saturated color palette, notably the cerulean blues, jarring reds, and golden hues that define Oliver Wood’s cinematography. Details are aplenty across various scenes, with highlights including the intricate textures on James Cromwell's face. The film smartly incorporates grain to evoke a graphic novel texture, catering to both aesthetic and narrative fidelity. A velvety depth in black levels with visible gradation enhances low-light and night sequences, providing appreciable dimension and dynamic range.
The visual detail is meticulously showcased with punchy and clearly defined images that capture the essence of both the steely surrogate world and the warmer human segments. Skin tones differentiate distinctly between lifelike humans and intentionally waxy surrogates, reflecting superb textural accuracy. The fluctuating hues—glowing for human settings, cold for surrogate scenarios—are captured with clean precision, free from significant technical anomalies like artifacting or aliasing. However, sporadic noise and visual inconsistencies—especially under harsh lighting—do appear but do not detract significantly from the overall experience.
Overall, this Blu-ray edition presents director Jonathan Mostow's vision with commendable clarity and depth, immersing viewers in a vividly rendered dystopian world. Despite the inherent limitations of the film's visual effects, the transfer succeeds in preserving the integrity of the cinematic experience, making it a worthwhile addition to any collection.
Audio: 65
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track for "Surrogates" offers a dynamic and immersive sound experience that will certainly put any sound system through its paces. While the dialogue can occasionally seem muddy amidst the plethora of effects, the mix compensates with rich, detail-rich clarity and demanding use of the surround platform. From screeching car tires to sonically frying destructor weapons, the audio presentation leverages both subtle background sounds and aggressive LFE output to create an enveloping and action-packed auditory landscape. Composer Richard Marvin’s music score complements this intensity, seamlessly integrated into action sequences and quieter scenes alike, ensuring that the stereo pair are continually engaged.
The audio mix is not only bold and bombastic but also impressively dynamic, offering weighty and rewarding low-frequency effects and aggressive rear speaker activity. The surround mix excels in directionality, with roaring motorcycles, crashing helicopters, and flinging surrogates moving effortlessly across the soundfield. Factory machinery whirs in the distance, fleeing crowds dart in all directions, and off-camera cues are detectable with precision. The mix's atmospheric quality shines even in quieter scenes, maintaining crisp and clear dialogue that is well-prioritized within the front soundstage. This blend of immersive atmosphere and hard-hitting action sequences ensures a cohesive audio experience that enhances the film's enjoyment.
In conclusion, despite a minor critique regarding dialogue clarity during complex soundscapes, the DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix remains a robust and rewarding element of the Blu-ray presentation. It offers an engaging experience with precise directionality and substantial low-frequency effects, making "Surrogates" an exemplary audio spectacle. Audio options in French Dolby Digital 5.1 and Spanish Dolby Digital 5.1 are also included, along with subtitles in English SDH, French, and Spanish, providing a well-rounded audio offering for a diverse audience.
Extras: 51
The Blu-ray edition of "Surrogates" presents a robust collection of high-definition extras that provide valuable insight into the production and thematic elements of the film. Noteworthy is Director Jonathan Mostow's engaging and thorough audio commentary, which delves deep into various aspects of filmmaking, including casting, lighting, and special effects. The featurette "A More Perfect You: The Science of Surrogates" explores real-world advancements in robotics and technology that echo the film's themes. "Breaking the Frame: A Graphic Novel Comes to Life" highlights the transition from comic book to screen, albeit too briefly. The selection of four deleted scenes, though not essential to the storyline, grants additional context to the film's narrative. Lastly, the music video "I Will Not Bow" by Breaking Benjamin rounds out the extras.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: In-depth insights from Director Jonathan Mostow.
- A More Perfect You: The Science of Surrogates: Exploration of robotics and technology.
- Breaking the Frame: A Graphic Novel Comes to Life: Transition from graphic novel to film.
- Deleted Scenes: Four additional scenes providing extra context.
- I Will Not Bow Music Video: Performed by Breaking Benjamin.
Movie: 56
"Surrogates" on Blu-ray delivers an engaging yet somewhat underwhelming sci-fi actioner. The 1080p AVC/MPEG-4 transfer, framed at 2.40:1, faithfully replicates the graphic novel's vivid colors with added grain for texture, offering a visual treat. The DTS-HD MA 5.1 surround track, while dynamic with ample surround effects and a powerful score, occasionally suffers from muddied dialogue. Director Jonathan Mostow's commentary and additional featurettes provide insightful behind-the-scenes content, rounding off the Blu-ray package.
The film presents a compelling narrative where robotic surrogates allow humans to avoid the dangers of real-life interaction. Bruce Willis stars as FBI agent Tom Greer, who investigates deaths linked to surrogate destruction, leading him to navigate a world divided between pro- and anti-surrogacy factions. Although the premise is fascinating, exploring themes of isolation and identity, the execution often sidelines these philosophical questions in favor of conventional action sequences and a convoluted whodunit plot.
Mostow's direction shines in some aspects, but "Surrogates" misses opportunities for deeper exploration. The discrepancy between Greer's real-world appearance and his surrogate is underutilized, and the film's era-specific setting detracts from its believability. Despite competent performances from Willis, Radha Mitchell, James Cromwell, and Ving Rhames, the film's visual effects sometimes break immersion due to their artificial look. Ultimately, "Surrogates" entertains but falls short of harnessing its full potential, making for an above-average rental rather than a standout addition to any collection.
Total: 61
Disney's Blu-ray release of "Surrogates" delivers a mixed bag, offering high-quality technical presentation alongside a narrative that might not fully engage all sci-fi aficionados. Visually, the Blu-ray boasts an excellent video transfer, preserving the film's flashy aesthetics and delivering a crisp, detailed image true to the source material. The DTS-HD Master Audio track is a standout, providing a dynamic and immersive auditory experience, ensuring that action sequences resonate with power.
In terms of content, "Surrogates" navigates intriguing premises about identity and technology, but occasionally falls short by not fully exploring its thematic depth. The film offers just enough to maintain interest with notable performances, particularly by Ving Rhames, whose portrayal adds unique flavor to the otherwise standard procedural action narrative. The supplemental package includes several exclusives; however, they tend to be more average than exceptional, contributing minimally to the overall package.
In conclusion, while "Surrogates" may not reach the iconic status of earlier Bruce Willis films like "12 Monkeys" or "The Fifth Element," it stands as a competent and engaging piece of sci-fi entertainment. Its impressive technical aspects make it a worthwhile addition to any Blu-ray collection, particularly for those looking for a visually and aurally captivating experience. Sci-fi fans might find it falls short of its potential, but for an evening of mindless entertainment with high production values, "Surrogates" on Blu-ray is a solid choice.
avforums review by AVForumsRead review here
Video: 80
Some people may be offended by the appearance of grain in a recent release, but when you can see it has been done for a reason - and it works - then that's okay....
Audio: 70
There's plenty here to test your sound system, from screeching car tyres to the sound of the destructor weapon as it sonically fries your listening room....
Extras: 70
Audio Commentary Director Jonathan Mostow flies solo here as he provides a great deal of in depth information about considerations made for the production in terms of casting, lighting, the use of wide...
Movie: 70
The DTS-HD MA 5.1 surround track will give your sound system a workout with plenty of surround effects and powerful score, although the enveloped dialogue was muddy in a few places....
Total: 70
Blu-ray.com review by Kenneth BrownRead review here
Video: 80
Surrogates may not be the most attractive dystopian cautionary tale on the market, but its strong 1080p/AVC-encoded transfer is faithful to Mostow's vision, basking in director of photography Oliver Wood's...
Audio: 90
Directionality is precise as well -- motorcycles roar from channel to channel and surrogates fling across the soundfield, while factory machinery whirs in the distance and fleeing crowds dart in every...
Extras: 50
A More Perfect You: The Science of Surrogates (HD, 15 minutes): An intriguing featurette in which the cast and crew (along with a number of experts) chat about the production, dissect the film's themes,...
Movie: 70
While his vision comes up short for a number of reasons, it clings to the comic's fascinating premise: a dark future in which society's 21st Century obsessions -- youth and beauty, online avatars and robotics,...
Total: 70
Surrogates is an entertaining, occasionally mindless exercise in fulfilled potential and missed opportunities; an action-oriented procedural that cashes in on a handful of intriguing questions, but sometimes...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Plus, the movie is chock full of unconvincing visual effects, with digitals effects (there's a lightning effect that looks like it was lifted out of 'Ernest Goes to Jail'), prosthetic effects and the post-production...
Audio: 80
What's nice about this mix is that even the quieter scenes (which, granted, are few and far between) are awarded the same intense precision as the muscular action sequences....
Extras: 40
This track is actually fairly strong and engaging, with Mostow proving to be an exuberant and intelligent tour guide through the world of 'Surrogates,' providing a great deal of insight into the development...
Movie: 40
This is a real shame, both because the mechanics of the plot suggest so much more, and because Mostow, as an incredibly savvy conductor of above average genre material, really could have invested in the...
Total: 60
Everyone else who is bored and wants an above-average episode of 'Outer Limits,' well, you've come to the right place....
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 88
Dialogue is firmly planted in the center channel and clearly renders voices and effects with appropriate distinction and balance within the front soundstage....
Audio: 90
Dialogue is firmly planted in the center channel and clearly renders voices and effects with appropriate distinction and balance within the front soundstage....
Extras: 50
The science of Surrogates - 15 minute featurette (HD) Breaking the frame: A graphic novel comes to life - 6 minute feature (HD) 4 deleted scenes (HD) I will not bow music video by Breaking Benjamin...
Movie: 50
Greer and his partner, Agent Peters (Radha Mitchell), are called in to probe the mysterious death of a college student, whose life ended when his surrogate was destroyed....
Total: 70
THX Ultra 2 Preamp/Video Processor Sherbourn Technologies - 7/200 Seven Channel Amplifier Oppo BDP-83 Universal disc/Blu-ray Player (HDMI Audio/Video)...
Director: Jonathan Mostow
Actors: Bruce Willis, Radha Mitchell, Ving Rhames
PlotIn a future society where humans live in isolation and interact through surrogate robots, a murder disrupts the artificial peace. FBI agents Tom Greer and Jennifer Peters are assigned to investigate the rare homicide of a college student connected to the creator of the surrogates. The murder is notable because the death of the surrogate resulted in the death of its user, breaking the perceived safety barrier between humans and their avatars. As they delve deeper, they uncover a conspiracy that threatens the very foundation of the surrogate-dependent society.
Greer, forced to abandon his own surrogate, ventures into the real world, experiencing life without robotic mediation for the first time in years. This new vulnerability forces him to confront the reality of human existence and the profound effects of technology on human relationships. As he struggles to solve the case, he discovers a revolutionary organization led by a mysterious figure known as The Prophet, who opposes the widespread use of surrogates. The investigation leads Greer to question not only the murder but the moral fabric of their society, ultimately threatening to upend the world’s reliance on surrogate robotics.
Writers: Michael Ferris, John Brancato, Robert Venditti
Release Date: 25 Sep 2009
Runtime: 89 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States
Language: English