Indecent Proposal 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Review
Score: 79
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Indecent Proposal's 4K release: a visually stunning, highly recommended masterpiece.
Disc Release Date
True 4K
HDR10
Dolby Vision
DTS-HD MA
Video: 88
Kino Lorber's 4K release of Indecent Proposal offers a majestic visual upgrade, preserving the film's atmospheric cinematography with superior detail, color, and clarity, supervised by director Adrian Lyne.
Audio: 83
This Blu-ray features English DTS-HD MA 5.1 and 2.0 audio with clear, detailed soundscapes, from dialogue to ambient casino noises, enhanced by John Barry's score, offering both dynamic range and subtlety.
Extra: 57
Director Adrian Lyne's archival commentary, filled with production insights and nostalgic moments from Indecent Proposal, is best suited for dedicated fans, featuring some quiet spots and primarily on both 4K and Blu-ray discs.
Movie: 77
Indecent Proposal's 4K release, a tale of love & temptation in Vegas, stirs debate and nostalgia with its blend of high stakes and romance.
Video: 88
Kino Lorber Studio Classics' latest release of "Indecent Proposal" on 4K UHD Blu-ray presents a significant upgrade over previous versions, benefiting from a brand new 4K master sourced directly from the original camera negative, prepared at Paramount Pictures under the supervision of director Adrian Lyne. This combo pack, featuring both 4K UHD and standard Blu-ray discs, showcases the movie in a light never seen before, with the 4K disc offering a visual feast that brings the original theatrical experience home. The film, shot by cinematographer Howard Atherton using Panavision cameras on 35mm film, retains its fairy-tale aesthetic with deliberate light diffusion and a possible bleach bypass treatment, resulting in a dreamy, silvery glow. This nuanced visual style is meticulously preserved in the transfer, which supports both HDR10 and Dolby Vision, enhancing the depth and richness of the image while maintaining the fine grain structure that gives the film its cinematic texture.
The 4K restoration accentuates the film's distinct color palette, from the amber and yellow glows of interior scenes to the vibrant neon lights of Las Vegas, achieving a heightened sense of realism and dimensionality. This is complemented by superior detail resolution in close-ups and textures, such as skin pores, hair, makeup, felt tables, and clothing fabric. The Dolby Vision grading excels in reproducing natural shifts in lighting and color temperature, offering superb delineation, clarity, and depth across varying locations and times of day. This results in an image that is as detailed as possible given the original cinematographic choices, without succumbing to unnecessary digital enhancements or alterations.
The overall stability and cleanliness of the image are remarkable, with no surface imperfections or signs of damage. Despite some minor fluctuations in fluidity due to the carefully balanced shifts in light and color, this release does not exhibit any problematic digital corrections. The Blu-ray disc, while presenting a dramatic improvement over its predecessor, confirms that the ultimate viewing experience lies within the 4K presentation, where the subtleties of Atherton’s cinematography and Lyne’s vision are fully appreciated. Enhanced black levels and contrasts on the 4K disc allow for more nuanced shadow details, making for an immersive viewing experience that is faithful to the filmmakers' intentions.
Audio: 83
The audio presentation of the "Indecent Proposal" 4K UHD Blu-ray offers an immersive auditory experience, featuring both English DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 and 2.0 mixes, accompanied by optional English SDH subtitles. Particularly notable is the film's soundtrack, composed by John Barry and supplemented with tracks by renowned artists such as Sade, Seal, and Roy Orbison, which shines through the lossless 5.1 mix. This audio track exemplifies clarity, depth, and an excellent balance, with dynamic intensity that does justice to the subtle nuances of the original music score. The Dolby TrueHD 5.1 track from the previous Blu-ray release also receives commendation for its solid performance, though the latest lossless mix elevates the auditory experience with its superior reproduction of dynamic contrasts.
On examining the specifics of the audio mixes provided, it becomes evident that the 5.1 option offers a discrete encoding that slightly enhances the surround sound effect by possibly incorporating decorrelation for a more enveloping feel, despite the original Dolby Stereo release. The focus of both mixes remains on the front channels, maintaining clear dialogue throughout. However, the 5.1 mix stands out for making environmental sounds from the Las Vegas setting – from the casino floor ambiance to the more nuanced sounds of slot machines and chattering crowds – distinctly more engaging.
For a film that leans heavily on dialogue and atmospheric sounds to build its narrative, this audio release meticulously handles every sonic element. With well-balanced dynamics, scenes set in Las Vegas are brought to life through carefully constructed soundscapes that capture everything from the low-end bass of vehicles and musical cues to the subtle sound effects that give a sense of place. Clean, clear dialogue ensures that no part of the film’s emotional or dramatic exchanges are lost, making for an overall satisfying auditory experience that complements this dialogue-driven movie exceptionally well.
Extras: 57
The 4K UHD Blu-ray extra presentation of "Indecent Proposal" notably includes a vintage audio commentary by director Adrian Lyne, previously available on earlier home video editions. In this commentary, Lyne offers a retrospective journey through the movie's creation, shedding light on its production, casting decisions, and musical score, with particular anecdotes about filming locations such as the old Hilton hotel in Las Vegas. Despite its insightful moments, the commentary is characterized by sporadic silence and is best suited for ardent fans, as it contains substantial stretches of minimal commentary interspersed with select production stories and observations. Additionally, the package is complemented by the original movie trailer, providing a glimpse into the film's promotional period.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: Archival commentary from director Adrian Lyne reflecting on the film's production and creative decisions.
- Trailer: The original promotional trailer for "Indecent Proposal.
Movie: 77
Adrian Lyne's "Indecent Proposal," a provocative tale of love, temptation, and a morally complex proposition, graces the 4K Blu-ray format with a release that elevates its cinematic experience. Courtesy of Kino Lorber, this edition shines with archival audio commentary from Lyne himself, providing deeper insight into the film's creation, alongside vintage trailers. This release is region-free and comes with optional English SDH subtitles, ensuring it is accessible to a broad audience. The film's story, revolving around a desperate couple and a billionaire's offer that tests their love, remains as compelling and divisive as when it first premiered. Its blend of romance and moral dilemmas has sparked intense discussions, highlighting its enduring relevance and the starkly different emotions it evokes among viewers.
"Indecent Proposal" not only reignited director Adrian Lyne's penchant for erotically-tinged narratives but also emerged as a box office success, grossing over $230 million worldwide. The film's allure lies in its exploration of forbidden themes, wrapped in the opulence of early '90s aesthetics. Starring Robert Redford, Woody Harrelson, and Demi Moore, it explores the complexities of love and the impact of financial desperation on relationships through impeccable performances. The nuanced portrayal of characters by Redford, Harrelson, and Moore elevates the narrative, drawing viewers into their emotionally charged journey. Accompanied by a seductive soundtrack featuring hits from Sade and Seal among others, and the exquisite cinematography by Howard Atherton, the film's presentation on 4K UHD Blu-ray promises an immersive viewing experience.
The technical prowess of the release is evident in its visual and auditory delivery, aiming to capture the movie's lush cinematography and iconic soundtrack with clarity and richness. This edition not only presents an opportunity for long-time fans to revisit the film in unparalleled quality but also introduces a new generation to its controversial yet captivating storyline. Through its detailed restoration, "Indecent Proposal" stands as a testament to the film's legacy and Lyne's directorial finesse. With this 4K UHD Blu-ray release, the morally fraught journey of David and Diana Murphy finds a new lease of life, reminding us of cinema's power to provoke thought and evoke deep emotional responses.
Total: 79
Indecent Proposal," the boundary-pushing drama that interweaves elements of romance, cynicism, and humor, receives a striking revival in its latest 4K UHD Blu-ray release. This release stands out primarily for its meticulous remastering. Sourced from a new exclusive 4K master crafted at Paramount Pictures, the film shines in stunning native 4K, lending a fresh breath of life into Adrian Lyne’s provocative narrative and the remarkable performances of its star-studded cast. Paired with some of John Barry's most notable compositions, which underscore the film's immersive atmosphere, this release elevates the viewing experience significantly. Additionally, the film's audio is enhanced with a crisp DTS-HD 5.1 mix, ensuring the soundtrack and dialogue are as impactful as ever.
While "Indecent Proposal" may still divide opinions today much like it did in 1993, this release by Kino Lorber, in collaboration with Paramount, is arguably the definitive version for fans and might serve as a noteworthy attempt to appeal to newer audiences. While its story arc might not sway detractors, the unparalleled visual and audio improvements stand as a testament to the enduring appeal of reviving classic films for contemporary home cinema technologies. It is, however, not without its limitations, offering scant in the way of extras, with only a vintage commentary track by the director adding depth to the behind-the-scenes perspective.
In conclusion, the 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "Indecent Proposal" brings forward a splendid visual and auditory experience that not only pays homage to the film's original allure but also underscores the value of high-definition restoration in appreciating cinema classics. It’s a must-have for aficionados and collectors aiming to experience the film in its most refined form yet. Despite some reservations about extras and the film’s polarizing nature, this release is a substantial step forward in preserving and enjoying older cinematic works in the current era of home entertainment.
Blu-ray.com review by Dr. Svet AtanasovRead review here
Video: 100
Please note that some of the screencaptures that appear with this article are taken from the 4K Blu-ray and are downscaled to 1080p....
Audio: 100
The lossless track was outstanding, but even on the previous Blu-ray release, the Dolby TrueHD 5.1 track was very solid....
Extras: 100
Mr. Lyne goes down memory lane and does his best to explain where and how various segments from the film were shot (for example, there are some quite interesting comments about the old Hilton hotel in...
Movie: 100
Initially, David and Diana reject the offer, but after a night of what-if scenarios change their minds....
Total: 60
In Indecent Proposal, romance, drama, humor, and cynicism are masterfully mixed to deliver R-rated entertainment of the kind that is now very much a lost art....
The Digital Bits review by Stephen BjorkRead review here
Video: 90
While there’s little information available regarding his work on the film, it appears that he may have applied a bleach bypass process to some or all of the negative—much of the film has the characteristic...
Audio: 85
Since the bulk of the mix is focused on the front channels, there’s not a huge difference between the two, but the surrounds do seem to be set at a higher level in the 5.1 version, making it feel a bit...
Extras: 60
He also offers some interesting tidbits about the choices that he made, and a few production stories as well, but there’s a lot of filler between those moments....
Movie: 60
After having made a name for himself with lushly photographed, erotically-tinged hits like Fatal Attraction, 9 1/2 Weeks, and Flashdance, he took a slight detour with the psychological horror film Jacob’s...
Total: 74
If you’re a fan, this is undoubtedly the definitive presentation of the film, and it’s a worthy replacement for the existing Blu-ray....
High-Def Digest review by Bryan KlugerRead review here
Video: 90
All in here, this is a giant upgrade from that previous Blu-ray release that had an old transfer and now everything is more vivid, and detailed, and has a greater color palette that matches the intentions...
Audio: 80
Other sound effects of the elements of a las Vegas strip and casino can be heard nicely through the surrounding speakers....
Extras: 20
There is only an old 2002 commentary track from the director here and is only recommended for big fans of the film as it runs a little dry....
Movie: 80
With the film's peccadillos in place and given the time period this film was released, the ending is sweeter than it should be, but then again, everyone loves a happy ending....
Total: 80
With an exquisite cast of big names, some great performances, and a ton of excellent camerawork, Indecent Proposal is still a lot of fun to watch, even if it feels cheesy at times, especially the ending....
Director: Adrian Lyne
Actors: Robert Redford, Demi Moore, Woody Harrelson
PlotA financially struggling young couple, David and Diana Murphy, head to Las Vegas with high hopes of winning enough money to secure their dream home. Despite initially doing well, fortune quickly falters and they find themselves down to their last dollar. As they ponder their uncertain future, billionaire John Gage offers them a chance to solve their financial woes with a controversial proposal: one million dollars for a night with Diana.
The couple faces a moral and emotional crossroads. Torn between their love for each other and the allure of instant wealth, they make a decision that will test the limits of their relationship. As the night unfolds, the repercussions of their choice begin to take effect, altering their lives in ways they never expected. The weight of the decision starts to strain their marriage, challenging the strength of their trust and love.
Writers: Jack Engelhard, Amy Holden Jones
Release Date: 07 Apr 1993
Runtime: 117 min
Rating: R
Country: United States
Language: English