High School Musical Blu-ray Review
Remix Edition
Score: 50
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Tech-laden home theater endures 'High School Musical,' blending agony with joy & meticulous setup for family delight.
Disc Release Date
Video: 53
Disney's HSM 3 Blu-ray shines with high-quality video, vibrant colors, and exquisite detail. The original HSM, though limited by budget, benefits from a clean transfer and improved colors, pleasing even the most discerning fans.
Audio: 52
Disney's 'High School Musical' Blu-ray boasts detailed PCM 5.1 audio with strong music focus, yet some find the surround sound and dialogue presentation lacking, reflecting varied listener experiences.
Extra: 47
The Blu-ray and DVD editions of 'High School Musical' offer exclusive features including sing-along mode, cast profiles, deleted scenes, bloopers, featurettes, and digital copies, though the content's quality varies, appealing differently to fans.
Movie: 43
High School Musical ignites tween enthusiasm with catchy tunes and dances, despite adult critics' disdain for its prefab Disney formula.
Video: 53
Disney's release of High School Musical on Blu-ray demonstrates a commendable effort in presenting a film that, despite its modest origins, shines in high-definition. The video quality is notable for its vibrant color palette and detailed imagery, bringing an added level of enjoyment to the viewing experience. The AVC MPEG-4 encode maintains the film's original aspect ratio of 1.78:1, providing a clean and faithful representation of its televised debut. While the presentation showcases deep and inky blacks, the reds seem slightly overstated, leading to minor instances of color bleeding in scenes with various shades present. This minor flaw is offset by the overall clarity and depth of the image, which excels in texture and tonal quality, particularly in complexions.
Despite its limitations due to the source material's originally intended format for The Disney Channel, the Blu-ray transfer does an admirable job. The 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 transfer does justice to the film’s visual aesthetics, even if it can't completely overcome the inherent blandness and budget constraints of the first installment in the High School Musical series. Colors, while less vibrant compared to later sequels, are still pleasing and contribute to a wholesome visual experience. Shadow details and contrast may not be as pronounced, giving it a somewhat flat TV movie appearance, yet the encode remains very clean without noticeable artifacts.
Viewers, especially the younger demographic, will likely be enamored with the improved visuals and widescreen format, perhaps without delving into the technical specifics that enthusiasts appreciate. The Blu-ray version of High School Musical manages to balance technical improvements with maintaining the original charm of the film. It's a testament to Disney's commitment to quality, ensuring that even with a production that has its visual quirks and limitations, the end result is something fans of all ages can enjoy on their home entertainment systems.
Audio: 52
Disney's dedication to providing high-quality audio experiences continues with their Blu-ray release of "High School Musical", showcasing its commitment through the inclusion of DTS-HD Master Audio as the default option. This selection offers an impressive audio quality that, while not overly aggressive, adeptly handles the demands of this musical's soundtrack. The mix advantages from a considerable front-loaded focus that enlivens the musically driven narrative and basketball choreography, thanks to its well-weighted and clear dialogue presentation primarily through the center channel. While bass frequencies don't delve into very deep sub-bass territories, they exhibit an extension that supports the soundtrack effectively. The overall balance leans towards the front, yet the set pieces and ambient effects create a vibrant atmosphere that resonates well within an immersive aural space.
Upon inspection, certain limitations become apparent, possibly rooted in the original production's budget constraints. Music takes precedence in the mix, with surround usage appearing conservative, resulting in a soundstage that sometimes feels constrained. This approach might underline the musical elements at the expense of a fully enveloping surround sound experience. However, the PCM 5.1 Surround soundtrack (48kHz/24-bit) showcases an admirable effort to deliver the best possible audio quality under these conditions. Despite some criticisms regarding flat dialogue scenes and a noticeable lack of surround dynamics apart from basic stereo separation and occasional low bass support, the soundtrack manages to rise above these shortcomings when focusing on music delivery.
Listeners will find the audio presentation to strike an effective balance between clarity and warmth, especially in its handling of musical numbers. While there is an acknowledgment of some underwhelming aspects—such as a modest surround effect and occasional muffled tones—the soundtrack still succeeds in providing an engaging listening experience. The musical sequences shine with excellent stereo separation and a pleasingly expansive high-end, ensuring that the core essence of "High School Musical" is conveyed with energy and precision. The outcome is a soundtrack that serves its purpose, making it an enjoyable aspect of the overall Blu-ray presentation for fans and audiophiles alike.
Extras: 47
The Blu-ray release of "High School Musical" offers an abundance of extras, catering to fans' desires for behind-the-scenes content and interactive features. The extended version of the film includes high-definition cast profiles and deleted scenes, bringing fans closer to the production process. Notably, the sing-along mode and dance-alongs provide an engaging way to experience the film's catchy musical numbers. However, some extras like the Hollywood Premiere and certain featurettes may feel underwhelming due to their brief duration or lack of depth. The inclusion of music videos adds value, allowing viewers to enjoy key musical moments separately. Despite some content being presented in standard definition, the overall package enhances the viewing experience, especially for avid fans eager to delve deeper into the world of "High School Musical."
Extras included in this disc:
- Extended Version of the Movie: A longer cut of the film for more singing and dancing fun.
- New Cast Profiles: HD-quality introductions to the beloved characters.
- Senior Awards: A quick, fun presentation from the cast and crew.
- BD-Live Experience: Interactive Blu-ray feature for more engagement.
- Deleted Scenes with Director Introduction: Get insights into what was cut and why.
- Bloopers: Enjoy hilarious mishaps during filming.
- Night of Nights Featurette: A deeper look into one of the film’s key events.
- It's All in the Dress Featurette: Discover the secrets behind the stunning costumes.
- Cast Goodbyes Featurette: Heartfelt farewells from the cast.
- Sing Along Mode: Belt out your favorite tunes with on-screen lyrics.
- DisneyFile Digital Copy Bonus Disc: Downloadable standard definition version of the film.
- A Separate DVD Copy: Enjoy the film in another format.
- Bringing It All Together: Behind-the-scenes featurette.
- A High School Musical Reunion: Catch up with the cast in this reunion featurette.
- Learning the Moves/Disney Channel Dance-Alongs: Detailed dance instructions from the film's choreographer and cast.
- The Hollywood Premiere: Clips from the film’s premiere event.
- Music Videos: Enjoy popular songs from the film in music video format.
Movie: 43
The phenomenon of "High School Musical" on Blu Ray, directed by Kenny Ortega, has managed to capture the hearts of its target audience with its enchanting mix of drama, romance, and musical flair. Featuring the beloved Wildcats in their senior year, the movie presents an array of engaging storylines from a high-stakes basketball championship to the emotional turmoil of prom and the lively spring musical. The original cast, including Zac Efron, Vanessa Hudgens, Ashley Tisdale, and others, return with commendable performances, alongside newcomers who add fresh dynamics to the well-known narrative. With exhilarating dance numbers and memorable new music, the film transcends its franchise's boundaries, appealing to both die-hard fans and newcomers.
Despite being marketed aggressively as a tween magnet, the film has been critiqued for its straightforward plot and somewhat lackluster production qualities attributed to its TV movie origins. The Blu Ray presentation does little to hide these imperfections, evident in some of the dance sequences and set designs that betray the movie's modest budget. However, the charm of the lead actors and the energetic musical numbers manage to keep the spirit alive, making it an enjoyable experience for its intended audience. The innocence and light-hearted nature of the plot, coupled with catchy songs, ensure that it remains a staple in many young viewers' collections.
Critically, "High School Musical" might not strike a chord due to its predictable storyline and manufactured pop tunes that lean heavily on Disney's formulaic approach to tween entertainment. Yet, it's undeniable that this cultural milestone has introduced a new generation to the joys of musical theatre, albeit through a glossy, sanitized lens. Regardless of its cinematic shortcomings, the movie's influence on popular culture and its role in rekindling interest in the musical genre among young viewers cannot be overlooked. While adults may find it easy to dismiss as pop fluff, the undeniable replay value for kids and its status as a generational touchstone suggest that "High School Musical" will continue to be celebrated by its fans for years to come.
Total: 50
The Blu-ray presentation of "High School Musical" under scrutiny in a high-end home theater setup incorporating equipment such as the JVC DLA-RS20 1080p High Definition Front Projector, Oppo 970HD, and Panasonic DMP-BD55K Blu-ray players, among a host of other premium devices, provides a unique viewing experience that spans a broad spectrum of audience reactions. Technical prowess aside, the film itself polarizes opinions, yet it undeniably shines in delivering a polished audio-visual experience. The setup breathes life into the musical, enhancing its appeal, although it might not suffice to sway the skeptics. For dedicated fans of the franchise, the sheer joy of experiencing the movie in such high fidelity is unparalleled. Stephanie's elation, representative of the movie's target demographic, underscores the value of this Blu-ray as a conduit of joy for enthusiasts.
Critically speaking, while "High School Musical" might not challenge cinematic boundaries, its Blu-ray presentation is commendably executed. It showcases decent video and audio quality that, even if not groundbreaking, satisfyingly serves its purpose for the intended audience. This highlights an essential aspect of the Blu-ray discourse: the technical merits are somewhat overshadowed by the film's inherent appeal or lack thereof among viewers beyond its core fan base. Therefore, while aficionados will find all reasons to celebrate this release, others may remain indifferent, underscoring the movie's divisive nature amidst technological competence.
In conclusion, our scrutiny reveals "High School Musical" on Blu-ray to be a spectacle of particular interest to fans and a testament to the capabilities of high-end home theater systems. Though it may not convert detractors into fans, it solidifies its status among its youthful admirers through enhanced audiovisual qualities. This edition might fall short of being a quintessential high-definition experience yet succeeds in capturing the essence of the musical's charm for those who hold it dear. This dichotomy between technical achievement and subjective film reception serves as a pivotal consideration for potential purchasers: for enthusiasts and young viewers, it's an unequivocal delight; for others, it's an experience that might require tempering expectations or simply acknowledging it's not tailored for them.
Blu-ray.com review by Ben WilliamsRead review here
Video: 60
There's not much to crow about here, but Disney has done the best that they could, considering the source material....
Audio: 70
"Let me have the remote," was her only comment, one that indicated her obvious displeasure at my delaying the start of the movie....
Extras: 30
Channel Dance-Alongs" -"The Hollywood Premiere" -Music Videos Stephanie was thrilled at the "sing-along" feature and spent an unholy amount of time replaying her favorite numbers from the film while belting...
Movie: 30
One warning to those who might interfere with the viewing of High School Musical: don't even think about bothering a kid while they are in the throws of miming the film's dance moves and singing along....
Total: 40
Stephanie, on the other hand, was overjoyed with being given yet another opportunity to experience her favorite movie on a big screen with surround sound....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
Color saturation is not as robust as the future 'HSM' sequels, with less vibrant primaries and little of the over-the-top sparkle....
Audio: 60
Stereo separation is excellent, there is clear and smooth attenuation to the soundtrack, and low bass adds some nice, hefty kick....
Extras: 40
Featurette: "A High School Musical Reunion" (SD, 6 minutes) - More interviews, here with the cast, but again there isn't enough perspective on the 'HSM' phenomenon to offer much of interest....
Movie: 40
Long before Disney really knew what it had, it produced 'HSM' on a relative shoestring for The Disney Channel, and the only thing that really shocks in watching the original now is how little faith the...
Total: 60
It's not really a great "Remix Edition" as a high-def experience, but I'm sure the target audience will hardly care....
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 98
Images onscreen has impeccable depth, resolute sharpness and perfectly balanced contrast/brightness that drew out the finest details regardless of the lighting or camera's perspective....
Audio: 86
The presentation had more of a frontal balance however when the entire system was utilized the aural environment within the room came alive and bristled with the sounds of the musical set pieces, as well...
Extras: 80
Extended version of the movie Blu-ray Disc Exclusives: (HD) New Cast profiles - 13 minute feature (HD) Senior awards - Cast/crew fun presentations ( 2 minutes) BD-Live experience (HD) 8 deleted scenes...
Movie: 70
Reprising their roles as fellow Wildcats and devoted friends, from the first two Disney Channel Original Movies, are Olesya Rulin, Chris Warren Jr., Ryne Sanborn, Casey Stroh, Bart Johnson and Alyson Reed....
Total: 84
Marantz DV7001 Universal Disc Player Denon AVR 5308CI THX Ultra 2 Preamp/Video Processor B&K Reference 200.7 Series 2 seven Channel amplifier Philips TSU9400 Pro Series Touch Panel Remote Control Canton...
Director: Kenny Ortega
Actors: Zac Efron, Vanessa Hudgens, Ashley Tisdale
PlotAt a New Year's Eve party at a ski lodge, two high school students from different circles - Troy, a popular basketball team captain, and Gabriella, a shy, academically gifted newcomer - discover a shared passion for singing when they are unexpectedly forced to sing together during a karaoke contest. Despite their initial hesitation, the experience sparks a connection between them, and they exchange numbers before parting ways. As the holiday ends, they return to their respective lives, not expecting to cross paths again.
However, as fate would have it, Gabriella transfers to Troy's high school, disrupting the social balance. Their unexpected reunion reignites their mutual interest in music and each other, leading them to secretly audition for the upcoming school musical. Their decision to break out of their stereotypical cliques and pursue roles in the musical stirs controversy among their peers. The school's reigning queen of the drama club sees Gabriella as a threat to her lead role, while Troy’s basketball teammates fear that his participation in the musical could jeopardize their championship hopes. As auditions approach, the pair must navigate the challenges of peer pressure and expectations, questioning whether their newfound passion and potential romance are worth the upheaval they're causing in their school's rigid social hierarchy.
Writers: Peter Barsocchini
Release Date: 20 Jan 2006
Runtime: 98 min
Rating: TV-G
Country: United States
Language: English, Spanish