Coraline Blu-ray Review
Score: 74
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Coraline 3D excels with stunning visuals, engaging themes, and an immersive audio experience, making it a must-own for mature viewers despite minor drawbacks.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 72
Coraline's 3D Blu-ray is a technical marvel, offering a beautifully detailed and vivid 1080p 1.85:1 picture in both 3D and 2D variants. The 3D effects provide immersive depth without being gimmicky, although minor crosstalk and ghosting issues are noted. Colors are vibrant, and detail is breathtaking, making it a standout demo disc.
Audio: 76
Equipped with a DTS-HD MA 5.1 track, the Blu-ray of Coraline presents a highly dynamic and immersive audio experience, featuring expansive front soundstage, precise dialogue, well-realized ambient sounds, smooth musical integration, and responsive low bass—all enhancing the fantastical visuals perfectly.
Extra: 70
Featuring insightful commentary from Henry Selick, deleted scenes, and a 10-part making-of documentary, the Blu-ray extras for 'Coraline' are robust with behind-the-scenes content and technical details, including voice recording sessions and intricate animation processes, though some elements like the U-Control are notably absent in the 3D version.
Movie: 80
Henry Selick’s 'Coraline' is a visually captivating, darkly imaginative stop-motion adaptation of Neil Gaiman's novel, delivering stunning 3D presentation, rich sound, and thoughtful themes that walk the twisted line between fantasy and reality. Universal’s Blu-ray release excels with top-notch picture, sound quality, and informative extras.
Video: 72
The Blu-ray release of "Coraline" in 3D and 2D offers a stellar visual experience, presented in a theatrically correct widescreen 1.85:1 1080p format. The 3D presentation is particularly noteworthy for its depth and solidity; characters and objects possess a tangible presence, making them appear almost real. Scenes like Coraline's bed in her room and the introduction of the boarding house show an impressive sense of distance and layers. The tunnel behind the little door stands out as an exceptional 3D effect, extending deeply into the screen and inviting viewer interaction. The minor instances of crosstalk are rare and brief, generally not detracting from an overall immersive experience.
The 2D counterpart is equally spectacular, featuring stunning details and clarity. Textures, such as individual threads in clothing and strands of hair, are distinctly sharp and lifelike. The contrast is pitch-perfect, with wonderful visibility from close-ups to distant objects. Colors exhibit extraordinary pop, maintaining vibrancy even through the dimming lenses of 3D glasses. Whether depicting the drab real world or the vibrant, fantastical Other Mother's universe, the color accuracy and saturation are impressive. Blacks are deep and inky, adding to the visual depth and enhancing shadow details significantly.
Despite minor issues like limited ghosting and motion blur, the overall video presentation of "Coraline" on Blu-ray is exemplary. It offers a reference-quality showcase for both 3D and 2D formats, with detailed textures, vibrant colors, and impressive contrast levels. While some 3D scenes may not distinguish themselves overly from their 2D counterparts and a few moments lack standout effects compared to other 3D titles like "A Christmas Carol," the immersive depth and meticulous detail make it a must-have for fans and 3D enthusiasts alike.
Audio: 76
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track on the "Coraline" Blu-ray is nothing short of exemplary, showcasing a masterful balance that perfectly complements the film's stunning visuals. The front soundstage is extensive, providing crystalline dialogue reproduction with every nuance and inflection coming through clearly. It’s a highly dynamic mix, constantly engaging all six speakers with rapid steerage and precision. The stereo effects, seamlessly transitioning between the left, right, front, and back channels, create a three-dimensional auditory experience that mirrors the film's action impeccably. The atmospheric elements are implemented with near-clinical accuracy, enhancing scenes with chilling breezes and subtle house creaks that elevate the viewer's immersion into Coraline's dual worlds.
The soundtrack’s music is warm and inviting, encapsulating the listener in the fantastical world the film creates. The score by Bruno Coulais and They Might Be Giants utilizes the entire soundstage, with elements including guitar twangs and choir harmonies rendered with remarkable clarity. This rich soundscape is complemented by a pitch-perfect low end that is responsive without being overbearing. Bass tones are restrained yet authoritative, underlying scenes with an appropriate level of depth and energy when required. Exceptional imaging means that even the most aggressive effects traverse fluidly across the soundstage, effortlessly maintaining detail through the higher pitches without any degradation.
Moreover, the ambient effects and non-directional cues enhance both interior and exterior scenes with sharpness and fluidity, creating an eerily authentic environment. Surrounds add depth with subtle ambient noises and full-bodied acoustics that expand the listening area beyond conventional boundaries. The meticulously layered mix ensures that nothing is lost; from booming thunder to subtle pops, each sound is delivered with resounding clarity and precision. The lush sound design of "Coraline" stands as a reference-quality benchmark, truly bringing the fantastical elements of the film to life through an immersive and enchanting auditory experience.
Extras: 70
The extras included in the Blu-ray release of "Coraline" offer a comprehensive and engaging deep dive into the film's production and artistic endeavors. The Audio Commentary, predominantly by Director Henry Selick, with a brief contribution from Composer Bruno Coulais, is rich with insights into the adaptation process, character choice, and technical aspects of animation and 3D effects. Selick's enthusiasm and detail-oriented narratives make it a valuable listen despite its fast pace. The Making of Coraline is a thorough 10-part featurette detailing various elements, from story evolution to character design, voice acting, puppet creation, and set construction. Additional features include Deleted Scenes, each introduced by Selick, providing context for their exclusion, and Voicing the Characters, a closer look at the voice actors’ work. The Creepy Coraline segment focuses on animation techniques for the film’s more fantastical elements. Supplementary options like BD-Live and D-Box round out the offering.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: Insights from Director Henry Selick and Composer Bruno Coulais on the film’s production.
- Deleted Scenes: A collection of six excised scenes introduced by Henry Selick.
- Making of Coraline: A 10-part featurette exploring all aspects of production.
- Voicing the Characters: Behind-the-scenes look at voice recording sessions.
- Creepy Coraline: Examination of animation techniques and props.
- BD-Live: Online bonus content.
- D-Box: Motion control support for compatible systems.
Movie: 80
Henry Selick’s adaptation of Neil Gaiman's novel, "Coraline," masterfully combines elements of a children's fairy tale with atmospheric horror. The film is a poignant story about Coraline (voiced by Dakota Fanning), a young and curious girl who discovers a parallel universe that at first appears to be an ideal version of her own reality. As the seemingly utopian world reveals its dark underpinnings—with the unsettling presence of other-world parents having buttons for eyes—Coraline must summon all her courage and ingenuity to save herself and her family. The film effortlessly captures the eerie line between fantasy and reality, maintaining a thematic coherence that is both entertaining and thought-provoking for viewers of all ages.
The stop-motion animation is spectacular, richly detailed, and seamlessly executed, ensuring a visually engaging experience. The film's 3D presentation raises the technical bar even higher; the depth and sharpness in 1080p resolution add significant immersive quality to this already enchanting tale. Universal's Blu-ray edition excels in terms of clarity and sound quality, offering a mesmerizing lossless soundtrack that accentuates the eerie atmosphere. The inclusion of both 2D and 3D versions on a single disc, supplemented by DVD and digital copies, makes this edition future-proof and accessible across various media platforms.
Beyond its technical prowess, "Coraline" stands out as a modern-day fairy tale, blending the surreal and grotesque to compelling effect. While it's marketed as a children's film, its darker themes and visually intense sequences make it more suitable for older children and adults seeking a more nuanced animated experience. The narrative is conveyed without relying on heavy exposition; characters are organically developed through their actions and environments, ensuring a fast-paced yet deeply engaging storyline. This Blu-ray release includes valuable extras such as an insightful commentary by Selick, which offers a deeper understanding of the creative process behind the film's unique 3D effects and artistic choices.
Total: 74
"Coraline" delivers a beautifully dark and alluringly peculiar narrative, masterfully merging wonderful animation, well-developed characters, and profound themes on the importance of coping with reality. Henry Selick's direction, paired with Neil Gaiman's imaginative story, offers a film that is both visually stunning and narratively captivating. The excellent voice cast breathes life into characters that exist in a vividly detailed and hauntingly beautiful world, making the film a must-see for mature viewers who can appreciate its deeper messages within the context of its bleak yet mesmerizing visual presentation.
The Blu-ray 3D release of "Coraline" is technically impressive, featuring superb picture quality that maintains its allure despite a few minor drawbacks. The high-resolution audio enhances the immersive experience, ensuring that every detail, from the smallest whisper to the grandest musical score, is delivered with clarity and depth. The supplemental package, while missing U-Control and My Scenes, remains comprehensive and adds significant value to the release. This version stands out as an essential addition for 3D enthusiasts and fans of the film alike.
In conclusion, "Coraline" in 3D on Blu-ray is an outstanding package that combines a compelling story, stunning visuals, and an excellent technical presentation. While it may not cater to younger audiences due to its genuinely terrifying narrative, it provides a rich and rewarding experience for mature viewers. This release is highly recommended for those willing to explore the mesmerizing world of "Coraline" in three dimensions, offering an enriching cinematic experience that is both visually and emotionally profound.
avforums review by Simon CrustRead review here
Video: 100
I’ve hinted that there is a little crosstalk, but it is very limited, spotted very infrequently and never around long enough to cause distraction, the only exception being the other door in the depths...
Audio: 90
The frontal array plays host to the dialogue which is very natural sounding, each flex and nuance of the respective characters voices coming across without restraint....
Extras: 70
The whole thing starts off with an introduction from Selick, then heads off into The Evolution of the Story which has writer Gaiman and the director explain their friendship how the story was developed,...
Movie: 80
Selick's film is a horror fable wrapped up in a kids fairy-tale and whilst the message is clear it is not overstated and played with such gusto that not only does it entertain...
Total: 90
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 90
It's important to note that the film's style of animation and 2D presentation already yields one of the stronger images on Blu-ray and one that is itself of considerable depth; some scenes in the 3D version...
Audio: 90
Many of the more aggressive effects heard throughout the film seamlessly traverse the entire soundstage; imaging is exceptional and the track delivers an experience that seems to erase the boundaries of...
Extras: 90
Discussions also revolve around voice acting recording, the style of animation, constructing the 3D imagery and altering the perceptible levels of depth between the two worlds seen in the film, and plenty...
Movie: 90
Indeed, the mystery surrounding the events depicted in Coraline prove riveting by themselves, but the film generates enough visual eye candy, dramatic overtones, and exciting action and horror elements...
Total: 60
Great movie, stunning technical presentation, and now an honest and even, arguably, necessary assortment of extra content makes this a complete must-own package that's already one of the best among the...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Whether we're in the drab and drained real world or the vibrantly exciting universe of Other Mother's house, the diverse palette on display is vividly saturated and accurate....
Audio: 100
The DTS-HD Master Audio soundtrack arrives with resounding clarity, precision, and depth, the sound mix is impressive as it reaches the higher pitches without a loss in detail and an active surround presence...
Extras: 60
Porting over the same set of bonus features from previous releases, the offering remains of entertaining interest for adults and animation lovers....
Movie: 80
There is such a great amount of attention placed on the details that it becomes almost trance-like, and it all works to enhance the narrative....
Total: 80
Adapted from the novella by imaginative author Neil Gaiman, the film is a splendid and astounding visual delight with a narrative that's genuinely - and appreciably - terrifying, one that may not work...
Director: Henry Selick
Actors: Dakota Fanning, Teri Hatcher, John Hodgman
PlotAn adventurous young girl named Coraline moves with her parents to an old house that has been divided into apartments. While her parents, busy with their work, tend not to pay much attention to her, Coraline discovers a hidden door with a bricked-up passage. Driven by curiosity and feeling neglected, she returns to the door at night and is amazed to find a parallel world on the other side, where everything seems better than in her own reality. In this other world, her other mother and father are attentive and caring, and her dreams seem to come to life. This seemingly perfect parallel universe entices Coraline, offering her an escape from her mundane life.
However, as Coraline spends more time in this magical realm, she starts to notice that not everything is as perfect as it appears. The other parents and the enchanting inhabitants of the parallel world have a disturbing edge to them, and Coraline begins to sense that the heightened attention she receives comes with hidden strings attached. As this alternative reality reveals its darker side, Coraline must gather her courage and resourcefulness to protect herself and find a way back to her true home, realizing that this fantastical world may be a trap designed to lure her into a sinister fate.
Writers: Henry Selick, Neil Gaiman
Release Date: 06 Feb 2009
Runtime: 100 min
Rating: PG
Country: United States, Japan
Language: English, Russian