Operation Petticoat Blu-ray Review

The Blu-ray release of "Operation Petticoat" by Olive Films is delivered with an AVC encoded 1080p transfer in a 1.78:1 aspect ratio, offering a decent high-definition presentation. This release tends to favor a “hands off” approach, opting not to engage in extensive restoration, while also avoiding digital tampering or enhancement. The resulting image faithfully showcases the original film stock, presenting a clean yet detailed picture that captures the original film’s nuances. Grain is present throughout, with certain optical elements—such as dissolves and miniatures—becoming more noticeable due to the increased resolution. While the image stabilization and color saturation are generally stable, age-related wear and tear like scratches and blemishes are visible, adding a nostalgic touch for some viewers.

Regarding color reproduction, the overall palette tends toward the duller end, with faded colors and somewhat dingy hues. Flesh tones demonstrate a slight brown tint, which, though noticeable, doesn't heavily detract from the viewing experience. While blacks appear more gray and lack deep richness, they do not obscure detail significantly. The blue tint and occasional softness in some scenes may be attributed to the aging source materials and production-specific characteristics such as optical effects and stock footage insertions. Although these elements contribute to a less-than-pristine visual experience, the disc remains authentic to the film's original theatrical presentation.

Ultimately, the high-definition transfer aims at preserving the historical and visual essence of "Operation Petticoat,” satisfying purist cinephiles who cherish authenticity over modern visual perfection. While purists may relish the film-like quality, those expecting pristine Blu-ray visuals akin to recent restorations might find this release lacking. Nonetheless, it remains an engaging and faithful representation of the cherished classic’s original cinematic style.

The audio presentation of "Operation Petticoat" on Blu-Ray is delivered via a DTS-HD Master Audio lossless mono track. Overall, the quality is characterized by its cleanliness and clarity, particularly with respect to dialogue, which is crucial for a dialogue-heavy film. Importantly, the audio track is free from undesirable artifacts such as clicks, pops, and background hiss, ensuring a smooth listening experience. The score by David Rose, reportedly augmented by an uncredited Henry Mancini, is handled well, punctuating the narrative effectively without overpowering dialogue or sound effects.

However, while the dialogue intelligibility is commendable, some reviews noted a shrillness on the high end and a muddiness in other areas, suggesting that elements like machine guns and explosions could have benefited from more careful balancing. Despite these minor issues, the audio quality remains listenable and maintains a fullness in the lower ranges. The dynamic range is respectable, though not groundbreaking, reflecting the inherent limitations of a vintage mono track but still producing a surprisingly robust sound.

Overall, while the DTS-HD Master Audio mono track may not be an audio spectacle, it admirably preserves the original recording's integrity. The sound, though not as crisp as more modern mono tracks, remains problem-free and clear, making "Operation Petticoat" an engaging auditory experience despite some limitations.

The Blu-ray release of "Operation Petticoat" is disappointingly bare-bones, offering no additional content. Olive Films has maintained their characteristic approach of minimalistic releases, with this disc including no supplementary materials. This mirrors the absence of bonus features found on the previous DVD edition, leaving collectors and enthusiasts wanting more.

Extras included in this disc:

• None: There are no bonus features included on this disc.

Directed by Blake Edwards and released in 1959, "Operation Petticoat" brings together screen legends Cary Grant and Tony Curtis for an engaging naval comedy. The film opens with Rear Admiral Matthew Sherman (Grant) recalling his past through a wartime journal, leading us into a flashback set in December 1941, where the U.S.S. Sea Tiger sustains significant damage from a Japanese attack. Grant convincingly portrays the authoritative and determined Sherman, who refuses to surrender the barely year-old submarine to the scrapyard. His counterpart, Lt. Nick Holden (Curtis), initially appears as an inept officer but soon proves himself as a resourceful Supply Officer, employing unorthodox methods to salvage the required parts and supplies.

The film's humor extensively leans on the dynamic between the dedicated Sherman and the charismatic Holden. Their contrasting personalities generate numerous comedic scenarios, particularly when Holden ingeniously sources necessary submarine parts and even manages to bring five Army nurses aboard the sub. The second half of the film shifts focus to the amusing complications arising from this unexpected cohabitation in tight quarters. Edwards, who later became renowned for his slapstick approach in the 'Pink Panther' series, showcases his knack for physical humor and sight gags while keeping the tone sophisticated and witty.

Featuring a sharp script by Stanley Shapiro and Maurice Richlin, "Operation Petticoat" expertly balances elements of slapstick, romance, and action. The film's humor may be perceived as dated by contemporary standards due to its depiction of gender roles, but for its time, it was remarkably progressive in portraying women as competent and valuable crew members. With standout performances from Grant and Curtis, complemented by a supporting cast including Gavin MacLeod and Joan O'Brien, the movie remains a delightful artifact of 1950s Hollywood, capturing a blend of charm, wit, and lighthearted adventure.

"Operation Petticoat" on Blu-ray offers a delightful revisit to Blake Edwards’ engaging wartime comedy, where Cary Grant and Tony Curtis lead a charming ensemble cast. The film, a whimsical take on the war of the sexes aboard a bumbling submarine, is bolstered by delightful performances and an enduringly genial script. Despite certain outdated elements, the film’s warm atmosphere and comedic timing help it remain accessible and entertaining. While the Blu-ray’s transfer presents noticeable video artifacts, it still surpasses previous home video iterations in providing a clearer and more enjoyable viewing experience.

While catalog titles from earlier eras often face challenges in gaining modern viewership, this release could have benefited from more meticulous restoration efforts. It's evident that the studio relegated the film to a third-party distributor without giving it the attention it deserves, especially when considering its popular appeal and historical significance. The resulting product, although acceptable, could have been elevated further with better care. Olive Films’ typical lack of supplemental features feels like a missed opportunity, especially at the current price point.

In summary, "Operation Petticoat" holds its charm through strong performances and enjoyable humor, making it a worthwhile watch for fans of classic cinema. Despite some video issues and a disappointing lack of extras, the Blu-ray edition successfully brings this much-loved 1950s film into high definition. It stands as a relatively positive step in preserving historical cinema, yet it leaves room for improvement in future catalog releases. Recommended for those who appreciate vintage comedies and are willing to overlook minor flaws in visual quality.