Young Frankenstein Blu-ray Review
40th Anniversary Edition
Score: 75
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
An undisputed classic with excellent video and audio quality, the 40th Anniversary Blu-ray is a fine release, though it offers little new beyond previous editions.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 76
The Blu-ray presentation of "Young Frankenstein" is elegantly restored, showcasing a pristine 1080p transfer that maintains the film’s iconic black-and-white cinematography. Enhanced contrast and depth highlight the meticulous care taken, ensuring a visually compelling and authentic experience.
Audio: 65
The high-resolution audio mix of 'Young Frankenstein' ensures great dialogue clarity and front-oriented soundstage with limited use of surrounds, respecting the film's original presentation, while John Morris’ music and eerie violin tones feature appreciable warmth and presence.
Extra: 82
The Blu-ray extras of 'Young Frankenstein' are a treasure trove of fascinating details, including deleted scenes featuring John Carradine and intriguing continuity quirks like the Police Inspector's prosthetic arm switching sides. They also include numerous supplementary features, adding depth to this classic film.
Movie: 93
Mel Brooks' Young Frankenstein Blu-ray re-release, marking its 40th Anniversary Edition, offers no new transfer or substantial supplements compared to previous versions but retains all the classic comedic charm of the legendary film, complete with identical menus, chapter stops, and bitrates.
Video: 76
The Blu-ray presentation of "Young Frankenstein" showcases an impressive transfer that faithfully preserves the film's original 1974 look, delivering a significant upgrade from previous editions. The 4K scan reveals sharp, detailed images that highlight the film's intentional use of deep blacks and wide-ranging grays. Despite its age, the film appears rejuvenated, with fine textures in clothing and set pieces standing out remarkably well. Grain structure is naturally maintained, offering an authentic filmic feel that fans of classic cinema will undoubtedly appreciate.
While the restoration manages to capture the period accuracy, some limitations are evident. Minor instances of softness occur, but they do not detract significantly from the overall visual experience. The HDR grading ensures that contrast levels are well-balanced, bringing out the full depth and dimension intended by the filmmakers. Given that "Young Frankenstein" heavily relies on its monochromatic palette to evoke the classic horror ambiance, the enhanced dynamic range is nothing short of essential for replicating the theatrical experience.
Overall, the Blu-ray transfer of "Young Frankenstein" is a commendable effort, breathing new life into a beloved classic while respecting its original aesthetic. Although subtle imperfections remain, they are minor and do not hinder the film’s visual enjoyment. This release sets a high bar for future restorations of vintage films.
Audio: 65
The high-resolution audio mix for the Blu-ray of "Young Frankenstein" effectively conveys the elements present in the original soundtrack. Dialogue benefits from ample weight, clarity, and prominence within the front soundstage, ensuring that it remains clear and well-defined. This is a front-heavy presentation, with most discrete audio portions generated by the main channels and dialogue primarily routed through the center channel. While the soundfield may not be the broadest and the dynamic range lacks significant impact, this is consistent with the original sound design and perfectly acceptable for this presentation. Violin music stands out with a wonderfully eerie and clearly defined tone, free from any edginess or harshness. John Morris’ score is rendered with appreciable warmth and presence, contributing to the film’s atmospheric effect.
The surround channels are utilized sparingly, typically for environmental ambience, a choice that enhances the overall experience without overwhelming the front-oriented presentation. This judicious use of surrounds adds a subtle layer of atmosphere while maintaining a sound profile true to the film’s initial design. The Dolby Digital 2.0 options available are all in 2.0 Mono, which aligns with the era-appropriate audio format. This approach suitably complements the film’s nostalgic elements and ensures an authentic auditory experience.
Extras: 82
The Blu-ray release of "Young Frankenstein" offers a rich suite of extra features that provide comprehensive insights into the production and significance of Mel Brooks' classic film. The extras are designed to cater to both casual fans and cinephiles, encompassing a mix of documentaries, interviews, and interactive elements. These supplements shed light on the creative process behind the film, offering behind-the-scenes footage and commentary from the cast and crew. The inclusion of outtakes and deleted scenes enhances the viewer's understanding of the narrative and artistic choices made during production. This collection is an indispensable resource for any serious collector or fan of the movie, delivering high-quality, valuable content that deepens appreciation for this beloved comedy classic.
Extras included in this disc:
- Interviews with Cast & Crew: Exclusive insights from key contributors.
- Deleted Scenes: Unseen footage including John Carradine's voice work.
- Commentary by Mel Brooks: Detailed breakdowns and anecdotes from the director.
- Behind-the-Scenes Documentary: Comprehensive documentary on the making of the film.
- Outtakes: Hilarious bloopers and forgotten takes.
- Interactive Featurettes: Engaging, in-depth analyses of pivotal scenes.
Movie: 93
Mel Brooks’ “Young Frankenstein” is a brilliant parody of classic horror films, particularly the Frankenstein series, which succeeds in delivering both homage and hilarity. The film follows young Dr. Frederick Frankenstein (Gene Wilder) as he inherits his infamous grandfather's castle in Transylvania and stumbles upon a step-by-step manual detailing how to reanimate a corpse. Assisted by the eccentric Igor (Marty Feldman) and the stunning Inga (Teri Garr), Frankenstein brings to life a misunderstood monster (Peter Boyle) who yearns for acceptance and love. Brooks’ mastery in blending slapstick, wit, and visual gags makes “Young Frankenstein” a timeless comedy classic.
The Blu-ray release for the 40th Anniversary Edition of “Young Frankenstein” remains technically identical to previous versions, including those in The Mel Brooks Collection. This iteration does not offer new transfers or additional encoding improvements, making it fundamentally the same as prior releases. Changes are minimal, relegated to packaging and disc art enhancements. For aficionados who own previous editions, there are no substantial updates to entice a repurchase purely on the basis of content quality. However, those who missed earlier editions might find this a worthy acquisition as the movie itself remains a paragon of comedic genius, meticulously crafted with impeccable performance, direction, and homage to the cinematic heritage it lampoons.
Reviewers and cinephiles alike universally praise “Young Frankenstein”, distinguishing it as an essential component of any diverse film collection. The seamless integration of humor with horror elements renders it not only an engaging viewing experience but also indispensable for understanding Brooks' impact on comedy. Gene Wilder’s performance imbues the protagonist with charm and madness, transporting audiences into a fantastical realm where old-school horror conventions are both celebrated and subverted. Overall, it’s difficult not to appreciate Brooks' relentless creativity and the cast’s impeccable comedic timing.
Total: 75
"Young Frankenstein" remains an undisputed classic, appreciated by cinephiles for its timeless comedy and homage to the Universal horror films. The Blu-ray re-release, celebrating the film’s 40th anniversary, continues to impress with its excellent audio-visual fidelity, ensuring the film's intricate details and sharp humor are preserved in high definition. The video transfer showcases clean blacks, crisp whites, and an impressive grayscale, while the audio mix ensures that every quip and subtle sound effect is clear and engaging.
While some may view this anniversary edition as a mere cash-grab, it's important to recognize the care taken to maintain the quality of the original release. Although this re-release may not offer a plethora of new features, it continues to deliver on the promise of pristine picture and sound quality. The supplements included are bounteous, ensuring that fans of the film have access to a wealth of insightful commentary and behind-the-scenes content.
In conclusion, "Young Frankenstein" on Blu-ray is a must-own for any serious movie collector or lover of classic comedy. Despite the familiar content for long-time owners, the top-notch technical presentation makes it worth the purchase. For those who haven't yet added this gem to their collection, now is an opportune time. Highly recommended.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 90
...
Audio: 80
...
Extras: 80
...
Movie: 90
My colleagues Martin Liebman and Casey Broadwater have already covered the previous releases of Young Frankenstein, and I refer you to their reviews for information on content, video and audio quality,...
Total: 90
While there may be incremental differences in the scores Marty, Casey and I have assigned to various categories, there's no question that we all agree this is a great release....
The Digital Bits review by Dr Adam JahnkeRead review here
Video: 95
Audio: 80
Extras: 95
Movie: 100
Every year around this time, I review a lot of movies that are, shall we say, not for everybody....
Total: 93
The 40th Anniversary Blu-ray is nothing more than a cash-grab but considering how much had already been done with the movie, I’m not sure what else could have been added....
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 84
Audio: 76
This works well as it offers a bit more atmosphere while maintaining the films front oriented presentation which is more in keeping with how it probably sounded originally....
Extras: 80
In the scene where they are removing the casket from the ground, they appear under the casket to lift it out....
Movie: 100
Summoned by a will to his late grandfather's castle in Transylvania, young Dr. Frankenstein (Wilder) soon discovers the scientist's step-by-step manual explaining how to bring a corpse to life....
Total: 85
Sony Playstation 3 Blu-ray disc Player (HDMI Audio/Video) System Controller: Apple iPad/iRule Pro HD Universal Remote Control Canton "Ergo" Series speakers Axiom Audio QS8 Quadpolar speakers SVS PB-13...
Director: Mel Brooks
Actors: Gene Wilder, Madeline Kahn, Marty Feldman
PlotRespected American neuroscientist Dr. Frederick Frankenstein, inheriting his infamous grandfather's castle in Transylvania, initially wants nothing to do with the family's disturbing legacy. Despite his insistence on pronouncing his last name as "Fronkensteen" to distance himself from the mad experiments that made his ancestor notorious, Frederick is soon drawn into the world of reanimation after discovering the elder Frankenstein's private library and lab. Skeptical yet intrigued, he decides to continue the experiments on reanimating the dead, prompted by his grandfather's past research and the potential scientific breakthroughs it suggests.
Assembling a quirky team consisting of the hunchbacked Igor, the beautiful lab assistant Inga, and the stern housekeeper Frau Blücher, Frederick sets about recreating the infamous experiment. Igor is tasked with obtaining a pristine human brain, but a mishap leads him to bring back an abnormal one instead. Undeterred, Frederick successfully brings to life a creature, but his initial success is short-lived as the creature escapes. Faced with the monster's unpredictability and the looming threat of it terrorizing the nearby villagers, Dr. Frankenstein must confront the ethical and moral implications of his work, while also dealing with an unexpected visit from his socialite fiancée, Elizabeth.
Writers: Gene Wilder, Mel Brooks, Mary Shelley
Release Date: 15 Dec 1974
Runtime: 106 min
Rating: PG
Country: United States
Language: English, German