When Marnie Was There Blu-ray Review
思い出のマーニー Omoide no M�n�
Score: 80
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
'When Marnie Was There' is a visual and emotional masterpiece with impressive Blu-ray presentation, boasting superb video, audio, and meaningful extras.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 87
When Marnie Was There arrives on Blu-ray with a flawless 1080p transfer, showcasing precise, jitter-free animation, vibrant and nuanced colors, deep black levels, and impeccable detail rendering. This visually stunning presentation stands as a first-class Studio Ghibli release, perfect for demo material.
Audio: 77
When Marnie Was There features Japanese and English DTS-HD Master Audio 5.0 tracks, surprisingly performing well despite the absence of a subwoofer channel. Natural heft in intense scenes, clear dialogue, and immersive ambient effects ensure an engaging and lifelike auditory experience, albeit with an unusual mix.
Extra: 66
The Blu-ray extras of 'When Marnie Was There' offer comprehensive behind-the-scenes insights, including a 42-minute making-of documentary, storyboards of the entire film, and discussions with English voice actors. The package also contains trailers and a summarized version of the script paired with stunning artwork.
Movie: 91
"When Marnie Was There" is an emotionally resonant film from Studio Ghibli, notable for its elegant storytelling and breathtaking animation, which combines a nuanced study of depression and self-discovery with a touch of mystery, making it a compelling watch that deftly balances thematic depth and visual artistry.
Video: 87
The Blu-ray presentation of "When Marnie Was There" is a pinnacle of animation fidelity. The 1080p transfer provides an exquisitely clean and defined image, capturing every painstaking detail of Studio Ghibli's masterful artwork. With a color palette that is vibrant and nuanced—ranging from outdoor greens to multicolored attire—the film's visual splendor is fully realized. Each scene, whether depicting intricately rendered characters or beautifully layered backgrounds, showcases meticulous texturing, especially in support elements like trees and buildings. Black levels are deep and pure, devoid of artificial noise or banding, ensuring a pristine viewing experience. Motion across the board is seamless, devoid of jitters or aliasing, maintaining fluidity even during the most dynamic sequences.
Unwavering color fills, exact lines, and a remarkable illusion of depth are all features that elevate this Blu-ray transfer into a league of its own. Every landscape and vista is boldly rendered with stunning detail, reinforcing how integral Universal's flawless 1080p transfer is to appreciating the film's artistry. This disc achieves what few can by holding paramount every visual element—from defined lines to robust black levels—all while maintaining motion consistency without any imperfections such as double-vision or motion blur. This Blu-ray is not just a technical triumph but also a definitive representation of the film's artistic beauty, making it ideal demo material for enthusiasts seeking to showcase the limits of high-definition home entertainment.
Audio: 77
The audio presentation of "When Marnie Was There" on Blu-ray exhibits a pair of impressive lossless soundtracks, available in both Japanese and English DTS-HD Master Audio 5.0 tracks. While it is intriguing that neither track includes the usual LFE support channel, the sonic experience remains remarkably robust. Scenes with significant auditory demands, such as crashing thunder and turbulent waves, demonstrate a notable degree of natural depth and heft despite the absence of the sub-woofer channel. Particularly, chapter fifteen highlights the track's extensive range. The clarity is exceptional, and there is a remarkable transparency allowing sound details to seamlessly flow and immerse the audience in the atmospheric environment.
The ambient effects are plentiful and engagingly immersive, with musical definition presented across a broad stage, albeit with a slightly less critical surround support. Dialogue is centrally focused and crystal clear, enhanced by natural reverberation in specific scenes such as in chapter fifteen. It's important to note that the English and Japanese tracks are highly proficient, though not distinct beyond language variations. Users should be aware that switching between these tracks requires a menu adjustment, resulting in a movie restart. Interestingly, listeners can switch to the French track freely, regardless of whether English or Japanese is selected.
Although the 5.0 mix might initially seem peculiar, it effectively compensates for the missing sub-woofer support by distributing low-end heft through other channels during moments typically reliant on the sub. Surround effects beautifully capture the essence of the countryside; distant bird calls, howling winds during storms, and the gentle splashing of oars in water are all meticulously rendered. Dialogue maintains an impressive clarity, ensuring even subtle voice inflections are perceptible. In summary, despite the unusual lack of a .1 channel, the audio mix delivers a deeply satisfying auditory experience.
Extras: 66
The extras on the "When Marnie Was There" Blu-ray provide a comprehensive and insightful look into the making of this Studio Ghibli film. The highlight is "The Making of When Marnie Was There," an extensive behind-the-scenes featurette exploring the movie's place in Ghibli's history, storytelling intricacies, and the creative processes involved. Yohei Taneda's segment offers a unique juxtaposition of the film's narrative with actual artistic representations. The storyboard version of the entire film is a must-see for animation enthusiasts. Additionally, the English voice cast shares valuable insights into their characters. Fans will also appreciate the inclusion of various trailers and TV spots.
Extras included in this disc:
- The Making of When Marnie Was There: An in-depth behind-the-scenes featurette exploring the film's creation and Studio Ghibli history.
- Yohei Taneda Creates the Art of When Marnie Was There: A condensed retelling with real-life drawings and models.
- Feature-Length Storyboards: The entire film in storyboard form.
- Behind the Scenes with the Voice Cast: English voice actors discuss their roles.
- Foreign Trailers and TV Spots: Seven unique Japanese previews.
- US Trailer: The American trailer.
Movie: 91
"When Marnie Was There," directed by Hiromasa Yonebayashi and produced by Studio Ghibli, artfully explores themes of grief, sorrow, and self-identity with an emotionally gentle, yet deeply impactful storyline. The film centers on Anna, a talented but troubled 12-year-old girl struggling with self-hatred, anxiety, and asthma. Sent to the countryside to recuperate, Anna discovers an old mansion and meets Marnie, a mysterious blonde girl of her age. Their genuine friendship allows Anna to embark on a journey of self-discovery. This film’s narrative, noted for its accessibility despite tackling complex emotional issues, mirrors Studio Ghibli’s hallmark of blending contemplative storytelling with broad appeal.
The technical elements of "When Marnie Was There" are nothing short of masterful. Studio Ghibli excels once again with animation that is minimalistic yet richly detailed, allowing viewers to focus sharply on the story. The animation quality remains unsurpassed, producing frames that are beautiful enough to be artworks in themselves. This visual elegance enhances the film's enchanting atmosphere. Complementing this is a beautifully supportive score by Takatsugu Muramatsu, which enriches the narrative without overshadowing it. Combined with extraordinary voice acting across both Japanese and English versions, the film’s auditory elements seamlessly intertwine with its visual artistry to create a deeply immersive experience.
As the plot reveals its layers in the third act, Anna’s character complexity deepens, reflecting her profound internal and external struggles. Her sojourn in the countryside, surrounded by its metaphorically and literally fresh air, serves as a sanctuary aiding her emotional recovery. The movie is not just an introspective study into Anna's psyche but also a genre-bending mystery that leaves viewers pondering long after the credits roll. "When Marnie Was There" stands as a testament to Studio Ghibli's prowess in creating intimate, thought-provoking art that resonates on a deeply personal level while maintaining universal accessibility.
Total: 80
Studio Ghibli's "When Marnie Was There" is a captivating film that excels on multiple fronts. The animation quality is nothing short of spectacular, with intricate details and vibrant colors that draw viewers into its enchanting world. The story delves deep into themes of self-discovery and introspection, making it both emotionally compelling and intellectually stimulating. Furthermore, the narrative maintains a delicate balance, blending complex character development with an engaging storyline that remains accessible to all audiences. Universal's Blu-ray release complements the film's beauty with an impeccable transfer, showcasing every nuance of its stunning visuals.
The audio quality is equally impressive. The soundtrack enriches the viewing experience, perfectly complementing the film's emotional depth and visual splendor. Dialogues are crisp and clear, ensuring that every word carries weight and resonates with the audience. The mix handles subtleties in sound design with precision, creating an immersive auditory landscape that enhances the overall impact of the story. Additionally, the Blu-ray includes a robust set of extras; these supplementary features offer valuable insights into the production process and add significant value to the edition.
If "When Marnie Was There" is to be the final Studio Ghibli film, audiences couldn't ask for a better final farewell. The film is beautiful—emotionally, visually, aurally—and home to a satisfyingly deep yet approachable story of a person in search of answers about who she is and her purpose in life. It's a crowning achievement in dramatic storytelling and complex yet accessible character development blended with an inherently beautiful surface. Universal's Blu-ray release is equally impressive, boasting terrific video and audio alongside several worthwhile supplements. Highly recommended.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 100
Every line is straight and each detail commands the screen, whether nicely textures and layered backgrounds or the more complex character and environment moving parts in the foreground....
Audio: 100
There's a pleasant transparency to the track, essentially removing the speakers and allowing every sound detail to flow with a naturally lifelike posture through which the audience is effortlessly transported...
Extras: 60
Yohei Taneda Creates the Art of When Marnie Was There (1080p, 17:14): A condensed retelling of the movie in parallel with a look at real-life drawings and models that stand in for the animation....
Movie: 90
At the same time, there's a certain welcoming quality to the visuals, almost a warmth to them, not necessarily in the truest physical sense of the term when used in conjunction with video analysis but...
Total: 80
The film is beautiful -- emotionally, visually, aurally -- and home to a satisfyingly deep yet approachable story of a person in search of answers, of who she is and what purpose she serves in life....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 100
How the foreground and backgrounds mesh with each other creating the illusion of depth is amazing....
Audio: 80
So, something that's just a little strange here: neither the Japanese or English track feature actual channel support for the sub-woofer....
Extras: 80
A wonderfully in-depth look at Studio Ghibli, how this film fits into its rich filmography and the creative process that went into crafting the story and animation....
Movie: 100
On top of being an intellectual journey into the mind of mental illness, 'When Marnie was There' also happens to be a cracking mystery offering up a genre-bending story that's impossible to pigeonhole....
Total: 80
'When Marnie was There' is a mesmerizing film for so many reasons, from its splendid animation to its stark portrayal of a struggling mind....
Director: Hiromasa Yonebayashi
Actors: Sara Takatsuki, Kasumi Arimura, Nanako Matsushima
PlotA young girl named Anna Sasaki is struggling with loneliness and asthma in the city. Her adoptive parents decide to send her to a quiet coastal town to stay with relatives, hoping the fresh air will aid her recovery. In this serene environment, Anna explores the rural area and becomes intrigued by an old, seemingly abandoned mansion across a salt marsh. One night, she sees lights in the mansion and later meets a mysterious girl named Marnie. The two quickly form a deep bond, spending their days talking, playing, and sharing secrets. However, Marnie has a strange habit of vanishing without a trace, which leaves Anna puzzled.
As their friendship deepens, Anna starts to uncover clues about Marnie's life and the mansion's hidden history. The line between dreams and reality blurs as Anna becomes determined to understand who Marnie truly is. With the help of new friends and old memories, Anna embarks on a journey of self-discovery that reveals unexpected connections and personal revelations. Through her interactions with Marnie, Anna learns valuable lessons about trust, loss, and love, ultimately discovering more about herself and her place in the world.
Writers: Joan G. Robinson, Keiko Niwa, Masashi Andô
Release Date: 07 Aug 2015
Runtime: 103 min
Rating: PG
Country: Japan
Language: Japanese