Mortal Engines Blu-ray Review
Score: 81
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Mortal Engines impresses with its opening chase and exceptional Blu-ray quality, but lacks substance in characters and plot, making it more of a rental.
Disc Release Date
Dolby Atmos
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 90
Mortal Engines' Blu-ray boasts a pristine 1080p transfer, showcasing crystal-clear detail, vibrant colors, and deep blacks with minimal noise. Captured at 8K on RED Weapon Helium cameras and completed in 4K, it features lifelike saturation, exceptional contrast, and intricate detail, surpassing typical Blu-ray quality.
Audio: 85
Mortal Engines features a highly immersive Dolby Atmos soundtrack that effectively utilizes surround and overhead channels to draw listeners into its steampunk world, with clearly prioritized dialogue. The only shortfall is a somewhat lacking low-end intensity in the sound effects.
Extra: 71
"Mortal Engines" Blu-ray extras provide a rich, well-structured set of featurettes and commentary that delve into the film's characters, world-building, and production, particularly focusing on design intricacies and the benefits of filming in New Zealand. The content is thorough yet somewhat varied in engagement and depth.
Movie: 56
Mortal Engines, based on Philip Reeve's novel, showcases intricately designed mobile cities with seamless CGI, but suffers from familiar post-apocalyptic tropes, a crammed plot, and lackluster human characters; the standout becomes digital constructs rather than human performances.
Video: 90
Universal's Blu-ray transfer of "Mortal Engines" presents an impeccable video experience, leveraging the film's 1080p AVC-encoded resolution to stunning effect. Captured at 8K resolution on RED Weapon Helium cameras and finalized as a 4K digital intermediate, the transfer retains exceptionally well-saturated and lifelike colors that exhibit no blooming or bleeding. The color palette, ranging from steampunk hues to distinctive reds, shows perfect saturation and meticulously dialed-in contrast. Skin tones appear consistently flawless while the black levels are profoundly deep, with no crushing observed. Additionally, noise is minimal and there are no noticeable source or encode artifacts.
Detail reproduction is a standout feature of this Blu-ray. The intricacies of facial features, including scars and weathering, are rendered with remarkable clarity, showcasing the diversity among characters. The digitally constructed machines present an astonishing complexity in their moving parts, metal surfaces, and wear and tear—highlighting every dent and scratch with extreme precision. Terrain elements, whether depicting a barren world or tracks left by the machines, reveal every detail with rewarding sharpness. The remarkable contrast ensures that deep blacks retain solid shadow detail, enhancing the overall viewing depth and dimension. This disc stands as an exemplary instance of the Blu-ray format's capabilities.
Audio: 85
"Mortal Engines" on Blu-ray delivers an exceptionally immersive audio experience with its Dolby Atmos soundtrack. The surround sound is meticulously detailed, utilizing both the rear channels and overhead speakers to craft an enveloping acoustic presence. The sonic representation of the film’s steampunk world of colossal machinery and bustling cityscapes impressively engages the listener, particularly during action sequences where London devours smaller towns or aircraft dart across the skies. Subtle moments, such as public address announcements for new arrivals, also benefit from a well-integrated overhead audio component, enhancing spatial awareness and immersion.
Despite these strengths, some reviewers noted a relative lack of intense low-frequency dynamics. While the LFE channel does provide satisfactory thumps and floorboard-shaking effects, particularly from the pulsating engines within London, there were expectations for more profound depth and power in the low end. This includes heavier sounds of machinery and gunfire, which could have further elevated the track. Nonetheless, dialogue remains impeccably clear and precisely positioned front-center, ensuring it cuts through the mix without being overshadowed by the rich atmospheric sounds.
Overall, "Mortal Engines" features an aggressively active Atmos track that stands out for its comprehensive use of spatial audio. The sound design significantly enhances the viewing experience by pulling the audience into its complex world, although some improvement in low-end depth would have pushed it to unparalleled excellence.
Extra: 71
The Blu-ray edition of "Mortal Engines" offers an impressive array of extras that enhance the viewing experience with noteworthy depth and variety. Supplementary materials include insightful featurettes, character explorations, and a detailed commentary track by director Christian Rivers. While the commentary provides useful production insights, it does tend to lose momentum halfway through. The "Welcome to London" feature is particularly engaging, offering a comprehensive look at the construction of the massive moving city through five informative segments, hosted by Robert Sheehan. Additionally, character series delve into the backstories of pivotal characters, supported by behind-the-scenes footage and interviews. These extras collectively provide a well-rounded understanding of the film's creation and world-building aspects.
Extras included in this disc:
- End of the Ancients: A museum tour piece that fills in a little post-apocalyptic history.
- Character Series: Brief introductions to several of the film's main characters.
- Welcome to London: A five-part feature exploring the construction of London.
- In the Air: Insights into airborne cities and flying vehicles.
- Film New Zealand: Benefits of shooting in New Zealand.
- Audio Commentary: Discussions by Director Christian Rivers on the film's production details.
Movie: 56
"Mortal Engines" transports viewers to a visually stunning, post-apocalyptic steampunk world where cities traverse a dying Earth on massive steam-powered wheels. Based on Philip Reeve's 2001 YA novel, the film follows Hester Shaw (Hera Hilmar) as she seeks vengeance against Thaddeus Valentine (Hugo Weaving) for her mother's murder. Her quest intertwines with historian Tom Natsworthy (Robert Sheehan) and the enigmatic aviator Anna Fang (Jihae), adding layers of conspiracy and rebellion against London's predatory practices. Despite its grand visual spectacle, the film struggles to offer fresh story elements, often feeling burdened by its attempt to condense a complex plot into a two-hour runtime.
Technically, "Mortal Engines" excels in its seamless integration of practical and CGI effects. The film's standout visual achievements lie in the intricate designs of its mobile cities—especially London—with countless moving parts that lend a dynamic presence to action scenes. WETA Digital's craftsmanship ensures a captivating blend of live-action and digital constructs, while the imposing chase sequences and high-speed maneuvers provide gripping moments. However, the human characters fall short in delivering compelling narratives or emotional depth. The film peaks with digital performances, notably Shrike, played by Stephen Lang. Modeled after The Terminator, Shrike’s complex backstory and relentless pursuit offer more engagement than his human counterparts.
Despite the competent assembly of its visual and technical elements, "Mortal Engines" encounters challenges in distinguishing itself amongst prevalent post-apocalyptic tales. The script's derivative nature and overstuffed plot undermine its storytelling potential. While animated cities and digital characters captivate, the human narrative lacks resonance, rendering it a visually marvelous yet emotionally hollow experience.
Total: 81
"Mortal Engines" presents a visually captivating experience, particularly in its energetically charged opening chase sequence. This form of grand spectacle, however, is somewhat undermined as the plot unfurls, revealing a dependency on standard narrative components and underdeveloped characters. The movie is far from a catastrophe but struggles to deliver the franchise-launching momentum it was likely designed for. Poor box office numbers and lukewarm critical reception imply that its envisioned success was never fully realized.
Universal’s Blu-ray edition of "Mortal Engines" undeniably excels in technical aspects. The high-definition video presentation is top-notch, embodying clarity and dynamic range that highlight the movie's striking visual effects effectively. Likewise, the audio presentation boasts an immersive, well-balanced sound, enhancing the action and atmosphere of the film significantly. Additional features and behind-the-scenes content are included, offering fans a deeper exploration into the production process.
In conclusion, while "Mortal Engines" may falter in storytelling and character development, it is visually spectacular and technically sound. This Blu-ray is a solid acquisition for those who appreciate finely crafted cinematography and audio. Despite its narrative shortcomings, it deserves recognition for its ambitious scope and production quality. Rentable if you are curious about world-building and special effects; the Blu-ray provides an immersive home viewing experience.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 100
Facial features are striking across a fairly diverse-looking collection of characters, revealing deep scars, scruff, and various examples of weathering from a hard life in a harsh world with nearly infinite...
Audio: 90
Whether large-scale action scenes in which London absorbs smaller cities and aircraft zip about or less dramatic but no less sonically enticing moments when PA announcements direct new London arrivals...
Extras: 60
Character Series (1080p): Brief introductions to several of the film's main characters, built through interviews, behind-the-scenes footage, and clips from the film....
Movie: 50
Where the film finds its problem is that while its vision of the fantastic may be exclusive to it, audiences can only see so many films with their own take on the "fantastic" before it all begins to feel...
Total: 80
The movie is technically fine, but long gone are the days when spectacle and scope alone can carry a film, if those day really ever existed at all....
Home Theater Forum review by Todd ErwinRead review here
Video: 100
Detail is exceptional, with intricate weaves in fabrics and dents and scratches on the city’s armor replicated with extreme sharpness....
Audio: 100
When in the bowels of London, you can hear people mulling about all around you plus the sounds of the city’s engines pulsating and changing gears above you....
Extras: 90
Welcome to London (1080p; 26:19): A behind the scenes look at creating the mobile city, presented in five parts – Building the Beast, Levels of London, The Smallest Details, London Museum, and Medusa and...
Movie: 70
While the disappointing box office can be partially blamed on that poor timing, the real problem here is first-time director Christian Rivers and screenwriters Fran Walsh, Philippa Boyens, and Peter Jackson...
Total: 80
Mortal Engines is not quite the disaster the movie’s worldwide box office would lead you to believe, a slightly better film than what most critics gave it credit for....
Director: Christian Rivers
Actors: Hera Hilmar, Robert Sheehan, Hugo Weaving
PlotIn a post-apocalyptic world ravaged by a catastrophic event known as the Sixty Minute War, humankind has adapted to a new way of life on moving cities. These massive mobile metropolises roam the earth, engaging in a survival of the fittest paradigm known as "Municipal Darwinism," where larger predator cities hunt and absorb smaller traction towns for resources. On one of these behemoth roving cities, the great traction city of London, a young apprentice historian named Tom Natsworthy encounters a mysterious, scarred woman named Hester Shaw. Hester harbors a deep-seated hatred for Thaddeus Valentine, London's revered Head of the Guild of Historians, and attempts to assassinate him, leading to a tumultuous chain of events.
The chaos of the failed assassination attempt causes Tom and Hester to be expelled from the moving city, forcing them to form an unlikely alliance in the perilous Outlands, the vast static remains of the world that predated the roving cities. Together, they discover a conspiracy that threatens the very existence of their world. With the dangers of the Outland and vengeful parties in pursuit, they embark on a quest across the desolate landscapes, encountering disparate societies, and uncovering the relics of the ancient world that hold the secrets to a power capable of changing the future of civilization.
Writers: Fran Walsh, Philippa Boyens, Peter Jackson
Release Date: 14 Dec 2018
Runtime: 128 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States, New Zealand, Japan, China
Language: English