Knives Out 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Review
Score: 85
from 7 reviewers
Review Date:
Knives Out: A delightful whodunit by Rian Johnson with stellar 4K Lionsgate release.
Disc Release Date
2K Upscale
HDR10
Dolby Vision
Dolby Atmos
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 83
Knives Out's 4K UHD presentation impresses with organic, film-like visuals, rich colors, and detailed textures, despite its upscale from a 2K DI.
Audio: 83
Knives Out's Dolby Atmos mix excels in subtle, immersive audio with restrained bass and clever use of channels for ambient effects and dialogue clarity, enhancing its drama without overpowering.
Extra: 89
Knives Out UHD features rich bonuses including two commentaries, detailed documentaries on filmmaking, deleted scenes with commentary, a Q&A, and lively marketing materials, all reflecting a deep dive into the movie's creation.
Movie: 87
Knives Out rejuvenates the whodunit genre with a star-studded cast, clever script, and a nostalgic yet fresh approach that blends mystery with social commentary, standing out in a sea of generic blockbusters.
Video: 83
Knives Out" arrives on 4K UHD Blu-ray with an exceptional 2160p Dolby Vision transfer that, despite being upsampled from a 2K Digital Intermediate, presents a meticulously crafted image that is both a technical achievement and a visual treat. Shot digitally using Arri Alexa and Panavision PSR cameras at 3.4K and finished at 2K, the transfer benefits from advanced upscaling techniques and specialized algorithms developed by cinematographer Steve Yedlin to emulate the texture and warmth of 35mm film. This effort results in an impressively organic and film-like presentation, where the added grain and color grading contribute to a rich, cinematic experience. The disc, encoded using the HEVC (H.265) codec and boasting a BD-100 layer for enhanced quality, showcases fine details and textures with remarkable clarity, from the intricate patterns of the Thrombey mansion’s interiors to the natural beauty of its exterior landscapes.
The HDR implementation enriches the visual experience further, with the Wide Color Gamut (WCG) and Dolby Vision enhancing the vibrancy and depth of colors. The film's palette benefits from this treatment, making the greens of the outdoor scenes more lush and the interior reds and golds more vivid, without sacrificing natural flesh tones. Although blacks are deep and rich, providing excellent shadow detail that adds dimensionality to darker scenes, there are moments of slight imperfection where halos or edge enhancement becomes noticeable. However, these instances are minor and do not detract from the overall impressive quality of the presentation. The increased resolution and depth allow for an elevation in detail across the board, from facial textures to clothing weaves, ensuring that every frame captures the viewer's attention.
This 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "Knives Out" exemplifies how upscale transfers can offer a significant improvement over their standard counterparts, presenting an image that is not only cleaner but also more dynamic in its rendering of light and color. The combination of filmic aesthetic with the technological advantages of Dolby Vision HDR culminates in a viewing experience that is both immersive and visually stunning. Despite the limitations posed by its 2K DI origin, this transfer stands out as a testament to what can be achieved through careful post-production work, making it a must-have for both cinephiles and fans of the mystery genre alike.
Audio: 83
The Dolby Atmos audio mix for the 4K UHD Blu-ray of "Knives Out" is a testament to audio subtlety and precision, eschewing bombastic soundscapes in favor of a more refined and plot-centric sound design. The film utilizes the Atmos setup to its advantage, employing overhead channels sparingly yet effectively for score enhancement and to pinpoint specific environmental and plot-relevant effects like the nuanced thumps and the discreet rustling of debris. This meticulous use imbues the film's various settings with a distinct atmospheric depth, from the constricted tension in Harlan’s attic study to the expansive ambiance of the Thrombey's library, ensuring that each location is as characterful audibly as it is visually.
Dialogue is rendered with crystal clarity, placed at the forefront to capture the nuanced performances and sharp exchanges fundamental to the film's narrative drive. Vocal directions are judiciously utilized to enhance spatial awareness, with sounds seamlessly panning across channels to mirror on-screen movement, such as a character's transition from one side of the scene to the other, thereby heightening immersion. Even in its quietest moments, the mix is alive with a background of subtle sounds, maintaining an active surround sound environment that draws the listener into the on-screen world. The balance between dialogue, music, and ambient effects is meticulously managed, ensuring no element overwhelms another, with low-frequency effects employed with restraint to add just enough weight to actions without detracting from the overall auditory experience.
The technical sophistication of "Knives Out" extends beyond its clever use of Atmos capabilities, with an audio presentation that respects and elevates the source material. The soundstage is both expansive and intimate, crafted with layers that unfold with precision. Environmental ambiance and directional audio create a compelling auditory space that places the viewer firmly within the narrative surroundings. Subtitles and alternative language tracks are provided in English SDH, French, and Spanish, catering to a diverse audience. In essence, this audio presentation is a carefully orchestrated complement to the film's intricate storytelling and character dynamics, achieving an immersive experience that is both subtle and engaging.
Extras: 89
The 4K UHD Blu-ray edition of "Knives Out" is crammed with an engaging array of extras that collectively deepen the appreciation for the film’s craft. Lionsgate has furnished this release with an impressive compendium of special features, notably including two commentary tracks that offer invaluable insights from writer/director Rian Johnson, cinematographer Steve Yedlin, and actor Noah Segan. The primary highlight is the comprehensive "Making a Murder" documentary, spanning over an hour and dissecting every facet of the production with engaging detail. Additional perks like the humorous "Meet the Thrombeys" viral ads, detailed featurettes on film's costume and production design, and the "Rian Johnson: Planning the Perfect Murder" segment further enrich the viewing experience, making it a must-own for fans and cinephiles alike. Note, while menus on the 4K disc boast HDR, the special features are presented in 1080p HD and SDR, ensuring high-quality visuals throughout.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: With writer/director Rian Johnson, director of photography Steve Yedlin, and actor Noah Segan
- In-Theatre Commentary: With Rian Johnson
- Deleted Scenes: Two scenes with optional commentary by Rian Johnson
- Making a Murder: An eight-part documentary covering various production aspects
- Rian Johnson: Planning the Perfect Murder: A featurette focusing on the screenplay's structure
- Director and Cast Q&A: From a 2019 screening in Westwood, California
- Marketing Gallery: Including teaser, theatrical, and final trailers
- Meet the Thrombeys Viral Ads: A series of promotional clips
Movie: 87
Knives Out" emerges as a meticulously crafted homage to the classic murder mystery genre, a refreshing divergence from the saturated market of CGI-driven blockbusters. Director Rian Johnson revitalizes the whodunit narrative with a modern flair, without sacrificing the essence that makes mystery tales enduring. Set against the backdrop of a wealthy crime novelist Harlan Thrombey's mysterious death, the film unfolds through an intricate web of deceit, familial discord, and clever misdirection, anchored by the enigmatic Detective Benoit Blanc, portrayed with a Southern charm by Daniel Craig. The ensemble cast delivers with aplomb, each character vividly etched and contributing to the film’s tangled plot. Notably, Ana de Armas stands out in her portrayal of Marta Cabrera, adding depth and complexity to the narrative.
The film's aesthetic choices are deliberate, capturing the essence of its narrative with a visual style reminiscent of mystery classics but injected with contemporary relevance. The sprawling Thrombey mansion, rich in detail and character, serves as more than just a setting; it's a character in its own right, reflecting the thematic undercurrents of generational divide and class commentary. Johnson’s script is sharp and layered, rewarding attentive viewers with Easter eggs and callbacks that enrich the viewing experience on subsequent watches. "Knives Out" not only entertains but provokes thought, addressing social themes through its diverse cast and their interactions, making it a standout in its genre.
Technically, "Knives Out" is a triumph. The 4K UHD Blu-ray presentation showcases the film’s vibrant cinematography and meticulous production design in stunning clarity and depth. This format enhances the viewing experience, ensuring audiences can appreciate the subtle details and textures of Johnson’s carefully constructed world. The film's pacing is masterful, deftly balancing suspense with comedic elements, ensuring momentum builds steadily towards its satisfying conclusion. "Knives Out" is an exemplar of genre filmmaking, demonstrating Johnson’s adeptness at storytelling and his ability to engage and surprise his audience. This is not just a movie but a cinematic experience that pays homage to its roots while carving out its own identity, making it an essential watch for fans of the genre and cinema lovers alike.
Total: 85
Rian Johnson's Knives Out, a brilliant amalgamation of classic whodunit charm and contemporary flair, delivers an unparalleled entertainment experience that captivates from start to finish. Lionsgate's 4K UHD Blu-ray release not only serves up this masterful narrative in stunning visual and auditory quality but elevates the entire viewing experience to Collector's Edition status. The film’s transfer boasts a meticulously upscaled 4K image that presents natural filmic visuals teeming with keen details, rich coloring, and robust blacks. Complemented by an English Dolby Atmos audio track, the surround sound optimally utilizes environmental effects and an engaging score, ensuring an immersive experience. Additionally, the release is laden with an array of extras that are as informative as they are entertaining.
Echoing the essence of Agatha Christie mysteries and Hitchcock thrillers, Knives Out reinvents the murder mystery genre with its sharp writing, suspenseful plotting, and a dynamic exploration of interpersonal relationships. The ensemble cast’s performances add depth to the narrative, bringing color and intrigue through their interactions, thereby enhancing the film’s appeal. Technical merits shine in this 4K presentation, offering a vivid palette and striking detail that brings the story’s vibrant elements to life. The supplementary package is both generous and enjoyable, providing fans with ample behind-the-scenes content and insights into the film’s creation.
In conclusion, Lionsgate's 4K UHD Blu-ray release of Knives Out is an indispensable addition to any film lover's collection. Distinguished by its exceptional video and audio quality and a comprehensive suite of extras, this release not only honors Rian Johnson’s cinematic achievement but also provides a rich, engaging experience for aficionados of the murder mystery genre. Whether for the genre enthusiast or the casual viewer looking for exceptional entertainment, Knives Out, with its unique blend of mystery, drama, and humor, secured as a must-own title, comes highly recommended.
avforums review by Simon CrustRead review here
Video: 80
Detail is well catered for, skin has good texture, while clothing has discernible weaves, the ornate nature of the Thrombey household, with its rich tapestry of wall coverings, carpets and furniture all...
Audio: 80
The Dolby Atmos surround track, by the very nature of the film, is not a full on sonic attack, indeed the score is the main recipient of the overhead channels; though some delicious effects, such as the...
Extras: 80
Making a Murder – This has a set of 8 featurettes, titled: Premeditation: Inspirations & Origins, Gathering the Suspects: The Cast, Dressed to Kill: Costume Design, Scene of the Crime: Production & Design,...
Movie: 80
Director Rian Johnson gives a deliberate pace to the film, the beginning exposition, narratively stifled, in the great Agatha Christie style, is measured and slow, but as soon as the twist with Marta is...
Total: 80
The package from Lionsgate is pretty good As a 4K UHD set, the package from Lionsgate is pretty good; the up-scaled 4K image has been processed to give a very natural looking filmic image with keen detail...
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 80
Otherwise, though, this is a really great looking presentation that has clear upticks in fine detail that are especially noticeable in things like the sweaters, scarves and gloves that some characters...
Audio: 90
The Atmos channels are sporadically engaged, typically for ambient environmental effects, but in two notable instances to clearly document some overhead "thumps" that are clues as the story progresses....
Extras: 90
Both the 1080p and 2160p discs contained in this release commendably sport the same slate of supplementary material: Audio Commentary with Writer / Director Rian Johnson, Director of Photography Steve...
Movie: 90
And in fact as the film progresses, two policemen, Lieutenant Elliott (Lakeith Stanfield) and a trooper named Wagner (Noah Segan), seem consigned to accepting that premise, despite the fact that the Thrombey...
Total: 70
The film kind of reminded me in a way of Gosford Park, in that while the central murder mystery keeps things clicking along at an agreeable pace, it's really the interpersonal relationships that give the...
The Digital Bits review by Bill HuntRead review here
Video: 95
It was finished as a 2K Digital Intermediate at the 1.85:1 aspect ratio, upsampled and graded for high dynamic range (both Dolby Vision and HDR10 are available here and the DV has the clear edge—that extra...
Audio: 95
There’s a genuine sense of scale and ambience here—the Thrombey’s library has a spacious quality, while Harlan’s attic study feels more intimate and closed in....
Extras: 95
Note that the 4K menus have HDR, but the actual special features are all in 1080p HD and SDR....
Movie: 95
And someone has hired a private investigator to get involved, the famed Benoit Blanc (Daniel Craig), who suspects that things are more complicated and sinister than they appear....
Total: 95
Rather, every aspect of the production simply works perfectly together... and much the same can be said of this production too....
DoBlu review by Matt PaprockiRead review here
Video: 80
Dolby Vision adds flair, emboldening contrast as light filters through windows, and keeping interiors uncomfortably dim....
Audio: 80
Small ambiance fills positional channels on occasion, and the house is spacious enough to add in an echo....
Extras: 100
The grand highlight is the eight part, 114-minute documentary titled Planning the Perfect Murder....
Movie: 80
During a party, the Thrombey’s bicker over contemporary politics, chastising immigration and one point, calling Marta over to ask her opinion, but demeaning her status by handing Marta a dish to wash....
Total: 85
While the mystery’s final reveal is deflating in its simplicity, Knives Out succeeds in taking a western view of a rich/poor dynamic....
High-Def Digest review by Matthew HartmanRead review here
Video: 100
While a native 4K DI would have been incredible, this transfer is a rousing success in a large part because of cinematographer Steve Yedlin's work behind the scenes to write special algorithms to replicate...
Audio: 100
While a 5.1 mix probably would have been just fine, Atmos really helps give each room of the house a distinct feel....
Extras: 80
Rian Johnson: Planning the Perfect Murder (HD 6:17) Director and Cast Q&A (HD 42:09) Ode to the Murder Mystery (HD 1:43)...
Movie: 100
I was going into this film having seen only the briefest of trailers hoping for another Clue or Murder By Death that takes the tried and true Agatha Christie mold and spins it around a bit for some fun....
Total: 100
Featuring a beautiful 4K transfer with Dolby Vision HDR as well as a subtle but effective Atmos mix, Knives Out is packed to the scabbard with a variety of terrific worthwhile bonus features that'll keep...
AVSForum review by Ralph PottsRead review here
Video: 92
Whether it be the finest minutia in physical features or rough textures on the surfaces of the stone buildings, streets, and the interior of the Thrombey mansion or the vistas surrounding it, the imagery...
Audio: 86
The music score is subtly mixed over the platform so as to add natural depth to its orchestrated elements without drawing attention away from the thematic details of what is transpiring onscreen....
Extras: 90
Disc 1: Knives Out Ultra HD Blu-ray Review Disc 2: Knives Out Blu-ray • Audio Commentary by Writer-Director Rian Johnson, Director of Photography Steve Yedlin, and Actor Noah Segan • In-Theatre Commentary...
Movie: 80
From Harlan's dysfunctional family to his devoted staff, Blanc sifts through a web of red herrings and self-serving lies to uncover the truth behind Harlan's untimely death....
Total: 87
It comes to Blu-ray from Lionsgate Home Entertainment featuring excellent overall audio/video quality which includes Dolby Vision HDR/Dolby Atmos sound, and a fan friendly supplemental package....
Why So Blu? review by Brandon PetersRead review here
Video: 90
Hitting natural levels is obvious (Matching the matte lines easily), but also there is much more details, textures and patterns held in place and visible....
Audio: 90
There isn’t a lot to go crazy about from the overhead channel as the movie keeps it to only things that would be pertinent, with maybe the biggest highlight being the piece of the of debris that Ana de...
Extras: 90
Audio CommentaryWith Writer / Director Rian Johnson, Director of Photography Steve Yedlin and Actor Noah Segan In Theater Commentary With Rian JohnsonDeleted Scenes with Optional Commentary By Rian Johnson...
Movie: 90
Now, its not a throwback film or retro in any kind of regards, its just something we once took for granted and now feels extra special in the sea of constant CGI blockbusters and safe storytelling affairs....
Total: 90
Lionsgate releases it with a handsome presentation in both audio and video while giving us a nice wealth of extras that are educational, fun and not too overwhelming or tiresome....
Director: Rian Johnson
Actors: Daniel Craig, Chris Evans, Ana de Armas
PlotThe story begins with the apparent suicide of wealthy crime novelist Harlan Thrombey, found dead in his mansion on the morning after his 85th birthday. The Thrombey family gathers to mourn, but the atmosphere is fraught with tension and old grudges. Everyone within the household seems to have a motive for wanting Harlan dead, from his dependent children and their spouses to his cutthroat business associates. On the periphery of the family drama is Marta Cabrera, Harlan's devoted nurse, who appears to have a special bond with the deceased writer.
A debonair private detective, Benoit Blanc, is anonymously hired to investigate Harlan's death. He sifts through a web of lies and red herrings, interviewing the eccentric family members and staff. As Blanc delves closer to the truth, relationships unravel, secrets are revealed, and the façade of the respectable Thrombey family starts to crumble. Marta, inadvertently caught in the investigation, must navigate her own moral compass while under the piercing gaze of the enigmatic detective.
Writers: Rian Johnson
Release Date: 27 Nov 2019
Runtime: 130 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States
Language: English, Spanish, Hindi