Whisper of the Heart Blu-ray Review
Mimi o Sumaseba Studio Ghibli
Score: 66
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Whisper of the Heart is a visually stunning, universally appealing Studio Ghibli film that looks superb on Blu-ray. Highly recommended.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 68
Whisper of the Heart on UK Blu-ray offers a clean and sharp 1080p image with rich, well-balanced colors in a 1.85:1 aspect ratio, encoded with AVC. While some may debate the grain reduction, the film's background art retains its high-frequency detail, and the overall clarity is impressive, free of banding or aliasing.
Audio: 63
Whisper of the Heart on Blu-ray offers two DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 options: English and Japanese. Both tracks are well-balanced, though the Japanese track is quieter and more nuanced, leveraging Yuji Nomi's score to enhance the atmosphere. English center channel is clearer but both provide fine audio with minor caveats.
Extra: 61
Extras include fully integrated storyboards in picture-in-picture mode, a stunning gallery of surrealist Naohisa Inoue’s background artwork and paintings' progression, insights from English voice cast, and various Japanese TV spots and trailers, all in HD with subtitles where necessary.
Movie: 81
Whisper of the Heart excels in its portrayal of adolescent self-realization within a realistic, emotionally resonant narrative, supported by well-differentiated audio tracks and a variety of fan-centric extras, though debates over grain reduction on the Region B locked disc persist.
Video: 68
The Blu-ray presentation of Whisper of the Heart by StudioCanal delivers a 1080p resolution encoded with the AVC codec and framed within a 1.85:1 aspect ratio. StudioCanal's approach to grain reduction might divide purists: some laud the Japanese Ghibli releases for maintaining natural grain, while others recognize the noise in darker scenes. Nonetheless, StudioCanal manages to reduce heavy grain without erasing the image’s vitality. The background art retains its high frequency detail, showcasing texture in urban environments, such as road pits and wall cracks, effectively. Improvements are most evident in moving objects, which are more pronounced but slightly less integrated into the overall scene. The overall frame is lightened, affecting whites and reds differently; whites appear cooler and bluer, whereas reds lean towards pastel shades. While daylight scenes are considerably brighter, the film maintains remarkable clarity and sharpness without substantial banding or aliasing issues.
Studio Ghibli's exceptional animation style shines through in this Blu-ray release, with colors that are rich, vibrant, and balanced—never appearing overly boosted or plastic. The image is not static but dynamic, framed as a cohesive mosaic of crisp moving pictures rather than a series of stills. Significant denoising corrections were avoided, upholding the image's depth and texture. Apart from minor deviations in a few frames, the linework remains tight and clear, offering a stunning visual experience from start to finish. Stability is consistent throughout the film without any significant issues, producing a clean and beautiful picture that will undoubtedly appeal to both new viewers and long-term fans of Studio Ghibli's work.
Audio: 63
The Blu-ray release of "Whisper of the Heart" offers two DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 tracks, one in Japanese and the other in English. The Japanese DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track excels in creating a deeply immersive soundscape. It captures ambient sounds and noises that significantly enhance the film's atmosphere. Yuji Nomi's score integrates seamlessly into the track, enriching existing moods rather than jarring the viewer with overemphasis. Dialog clarity in the Japanese track is top-notch, presenting crisp, clean, and stable audio that is easy to follow. However, the surround effects are used sparingly but effectively to ensure an engaging auditory experience. The primary narrative-driven sounds are front-heavy, which may, at times, come off slightly flat due to the nature of certain film segments.
The English DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track, on the other hand, also brings a commendable level of quality to the table. Unexpectedly well-executed, the English version's lines occasionally match the intensity of their Japanese counterparts, though differences in acting depth are noticeable. The center channel in the English track appears slightly more balanced than usual for dubbed versions, with added vocals not overtaking the mix. Despite this, whispers and subtle effects are sometimes less prominent compared to the Japanese track where discreet noises add an extra layer of realism. Both tracks handle high and low frequencies well, particularly during musical sequences where electro-pop beats playfully pop around all speakers and stringed instruments hum with an almost tangible resonance. Overall, both audio tracks provide high-quality sound experiences, with minor caveats depending on user preference.
Extras: 61
The Blu-ray extras for "Whisper of the Heart" are substantial, offering a mix of visually stunning artwork and insightful behind-the-scenes content. The Storyboards feature allows viewers to toggle integrated storyboards on or off via picture-in-picture mode, providing a comprehensive look at the film’s artistic process. Naohisa Inoue’s 4 Masterpieces of Naohisa Inoue: From Start to Finish captivates with its detailed progression of paintings, offering a unique glimpse into the creative workflow. The Background Artwork from The Baron's Story segment showcases mesmerizing surrealist imagery set to music. Behind the Microphone involves discussions with notable English voice cast members, shedding light on the dubbing process. Additionally, Japanese TV spots and theatrical trailers offer cultural context and promotional insight, supplemented by a collection of trailers for other Studio Ghibli classics.
Extras included in this disc:
- Storyboards: Fully integrated storyboards viewable in picture-in-picture mode.
- Background Artwork from The Baron's Story: Conceptual drawings for fantasy sequences.
- 4 Masterpieces of Naohisa Inoue: From Start to Finish: Detailed progression of Inoue’s paintings.
- Behind the Microphone: English voice cast commentary on dubbing.
- TV Spots: Japanese television advertisements with English subtitles.
- Original Japanese Theatrical Trailers: Promotional trailers with English subtitles.
- Studio Ghibli Collection Trailers: Trailers for various Studio Ghibli films.
Movie: 81
Studio Ghibli's "Whisper of the Heart," directed by Yoshifumi Kondo and scripted by Hayao Miyazaki, is a captivating narrative deeply rooted in human emotions and everyday experiences. Diverging from the studio's typical fantasy elements, "Whisper of the Heart" is an eerily realistic coming-of-age story that resonates with both adolescents and adults. The Blu-ray release by Studio Canal boasts distinct features, including original Japanese theatrical trailers, conceptual drawings, and a making-of featurette. Highlighting the film's poignant musical score, the audio delivers a superb performance on both the Japanese and English tracks, though they offer different tonal experiences.
Narratively, "Whisper of the Heart" follows the protagonist Shizuku Tsukishima, a bright teenage girl who finds solace in books and embarks on an exploratory journey after encountering a mysterious boy named Seiji. This journey leads her to an antique shop owned by Seiji’s grandfather, where she becomes enchanted by a cat statue with dazzling eyes. As her friendship with Seiji deepens, Shizuku is inspired to pursue her burgeoning passion for writing, crafting a novel influenced by her real-life experiences and newfound self-awareness.
The characterization in "Whisper of the Heart" is notably exceptional. Shizuku represents an intricate blend of typical adolescent uncertainty and exceptional creative drive, making her a relatable and compelling character. Additionally, supporting characters like Seiji and Shizuku’s best friend are portrayed with layers of vulnerability and innocence, capturing the essence of youthful naivety. This multilayered storytelling, combined with vibrant visuals and an evocative soundtrack, ensures "Whisper of the Heart" stands as one of Studio Ghibli’s most mature and engaging offerings. Despite some debate over grain structure and color on the Region B locked disc, this release remains a valuable addition for enthusiasts of Kondo's artistry and Ghibli's legacy.
Total: 66
Japanese director Yoshifumi Kondo's Whisper of the Heart is a compelling entry from Studio Ghibli, renowned for its poignantly real storytelling. Combining the everyday challenges and aspirations of adolescence with the beauty of animation, the film achieves a unique level of relatability. The Blu-ray edition delivers exceptional visual quality, preserving the intricate details and vibrant colors that Studio Ghibli is known for.
The narrative remains engaging for both children and adults, reflecting universal themes of self-discovery and youthful ambition. The audio presentation on this Blu-ray is pristine, enhancing the clarity and richness of the film's soundtrack, which complements its tender narrative beautifully. For viewers capable of playing Region-B releases, Whisper of the Heart on Blu-ray offers an immersive experience that does justice to its heartfelt storylines and charming characters.
In conclusion, Whisper of the Heart on Blu-ray is an outstanding addition to any collection, thanks to its top-tier presentation and timeless appeal. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED.
avforums review by Mark BotwrightRead review here
Video: 80
This goes hand-in-hand with the lightening of the frame, which doesn’t necessarily bring with it a profound contrast boost....
Audio: 70
Things can be a bit flat and seem front heavy, partly due to the nature of certain segments of the film, but the score is a delight, popping around all speakers and the electro-pop beats hit the high frequencies...
Extras: 60
It plays out to music and in a 4:3 frame, but is still pretty stunning.4 Masterpieces of Naohisa Inoue: From Start to Finish – 1080p – 34:43A series of paintings, depicted in their various stages of completion...
Movie: 80
The Region B locked disc will cause some debate, with its grain reduction and lightened frame, but it’s very much a case of beauty being in the eye of the beholder, and I’d wager we could still see this...
Total: 80
Blu-ray.com review by Dr. Svet AtanasovRead review here
Video: 90
The image also has plenty of depth - the film does not look like a series of beautifully drawn postcards, but rather like a carefully put together mosaic of crisp moving pictures....
Audio: 90
For example, there are various unique sounds and noises that enhance the terrific atmosphere in the film very well....
Extras: 70
Background Artwork from "The Baron's Story" - a gallery of conceptual drawings used during the fantasy sequences In Japanese, with optional English subtitles....
Movie: 90
This is why she has developed a passion for reading - books allow her to enter a different world where she can see, understand and communicate with imaginary characters that are far more reliable and easier...
Total: 80
It tells a simple but beautiful story that is guaranteed to appeal to children of all ages as well as grown-ups....
Director: Yoshifumi Kondô
Actors: Yoko Honna, Issei Takahashi, Takashi Tachibana
PlotFourteen-year-old Shizuku Tsukishima is an inquisitive middle school student with a passion for reading and a desire to discover her own aspirations. During her summer break, she observes that many of the library books she borrows have been previously checked out by someone named Seiji Amasawa. Her curiosity piqued, Shizuku becomes determined to find out more about this mystery person. She stumbles upon an antique shop owned by a kind, elderly man named Nishi, where she encounters a peculiar cat statue known as "The Baron."
Drawn further into the world of this antique shop and the mysterious Seiji, Shizuku eventually meets him and learns of his dream to become a master violin maker. Inspired by Seiji’s dedication to his craft, she decides to pursue her own talents, despite feeling uncertain of her abilities. Throughout the journey, Shizuku learns valuable life lessons about perseverance, self-discovery, and the importance of following one's heart. The film beautifully weaves together themes of young love and personal growth, set against the backdrop of a vibrant and bustling Tokyo.
Writers: Hayao Miyazaki, Aoi Hiiragi, Cindy Davis
Release Date: 13 Dec 1996
Runtime: 111 min
Rating: G
Country: Japan
Language: Japanese