Black Death Blu-ray Review
Score: 57
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Black Death: Entertaining with solid Blu-ray release, not a classic but worth a watch.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 57
'Black Death' on Blu-ray boasts an intentional, gritty aesthetic with grainy visuals and a desaturated palette, achieving a unique look that embraces its low-budget, though clarity and color consistency suffer.
Audio: 67
Magnolia and Black Death deliver engrossing audio experiences with DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1, balancing atmospheric ambience, precise dynamics, and immersive effects, despite occasional front-heavy scenes.
Extra: 36
Comprehensive series of extras for 'Black Death' including behind-the-scenes insights, interviews, and delving into production details with noticeable repetition and a focus on experience rather than extended depth or revelation.
Movie: 66
Sean Bean shines in 'Black Death,' a brutal, medieval thriller exploring faith and superstition amid the plague, with Eddie Redmayne as a conflicted monk.
Video: 57
The Blu-ray presentation of "Black Death" on its 1080p/AVC-encoded video transfer brings forth a particular aesthetic choice that stands out prominently: the film is intentionally shot on a very grainy film stock, translating into a gritty and sandpapery texture across the visuals. This decision reflects the film's thematic grimness and the lower-budget nature of the production. However, this stylistic choice leads to a variability in visual clarity, especially evident in night scenes which tend to appear softer, and in certain daylight sequences that, despite retaining the heavy grain, showcase more detailed and clearer resolutions. The image's color palette is notably bleak and desaturated, complementing the title's thematic elements with pallid skin tones and a persistent gray cast, accentuating the sparing vividness of bright red blood. Black levels are intense, occasionally subsuming shadow details, yet this effect seems intentional, contributing to the film's oppressive atmosphere.
Diving deeper into technical aspects, the Blu-ray sports a 1080p, AVC MPEG-4 encode, accurately translating the source material's aesthetic vision onto home screens. Despite this faithful rendition, the film suffers from inconsistency in visual quality due to its varied grain structure. Not merely confined to darker scenes, this inconsistency extends to random daylight shots where detail is obscured alongside instances of random softness. However, when the grain intensity stabilizes, the Blu-ray showcases impressive textures (excluding some flesh textures), remarkable detail levels, solid depth, and strong contrast. Unfortunately, an overlit aesthetic choice occasionally renders the film slightly unnatural in appearance.
Despite these challenges, "Black Death" on Blu-ray does not succumb to significant digital problems like banding, artifacting, or overcompression, maintaining a commendable quality of presentation. The intentional artistic choices and inherent inconsistencies in visual quality result in a Blu-ray experience that is faithfully gritty and thematically resonant, albeit not uniformly beautiful across every scene.
Audio: 67
The Blu-ray audio presentation of "Black Death" is graced with a robust DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround track, capturing the essence of its genre-blending nature with finesse. This competent audio mix excels in its rendering of the movie’s dynamic range, from the resonant clashes of swords to the haunting echoes of supernatural elements. The meticulously arranged soundscape boasts an immersive layer of ambient sounds - echoing chants, the crackle of fires, and the whisper of wind across the landscape, enhancing the auditory experience. Particularly noteworthy is the eerie horn that heralds the protagonists' approach to the village, a sound that masterfully utilizes the rear channels to create a chilling atmosphere, alongside a score that perfectly complements without overwhelming with unnecessary intensity.
In terms of audial execution, "Black Death" demonstrates a masterclass in balance and immersion, avoiding the pitfalls of clumsy audio mixing for a thoroughly engaging experience. The sound design employs deep bass with finesse, imbuing each scene with a palpable sense of atmosphere and mood rather than mere auditory shock. Dialogue remains crystal clear throughout, ensuring narrative coherence amidst the rich tapestry of background and action sounds. Dynamics are described as flawless, allowing for a full-bodied audio experience that keeps viewers anchored in its grimly intriguing world. However, it's noted that while the use of rear channels is frequent and mostly effective, there are moments where the soundscape feels front-heavy, detracting slightly from an otherwise enveloping surround sound experience.
On the whole, "Black Death" delivers an audio presentation that stands out for its precision, power, and atmospheric depth. With a thoughtful mix that leverages low-frequency effects for mood rather than mere spectacle and maintains dialogue clarity against a backdrop of meticulously crafted ambient and action sounds, it offers an exemplary auditory journey through its bleak yet captivating narrative landscape. The minor critique regarding occasional underutilization of the rear channels does little to tarnish what is otherwise an exceptional audio achievement on Blu-ray.
Extras: 36
The Blu-ray extras for "Black Death" offer a blend of behind-the-scenes perspectives and promotional content that, while somewhat standard, provide a deeper look into the creation and themes of the film. The standout feature, "Interviews with Cast and Crew," despite its somewhat constrained runtime, manages to give fans a closer look at the ensemble's insights and the film's thematic undertones, even if it treads over familiar ground. The "Deleted Scenes" offer a glimpse at what was left on the cutting room floor, though they don't significantly enhance the story. "Bringing Black Death to Live" and "Behind-the-Scenes Footage" serve as typical, albeit engaging, glimpses into the filmmaking process. The promotional content, including the "HDNet: A Look at Black Death" and "Theatrical Trailer," feels more like filler but maintains quality in high definition. Overall, these extras, while not groundbreaking, enrich the viewing experience with additional context and appreciation for the film's production.
Extras included in this disc:
- Deleted Scenes: Includes four short deleted scenes.
- Bringing Black Death to Live: A quick production documentary with interviews and behind-the-scenes footage.
- Interviews with Cast and Crew: In-depth interviews with director, producers, and actors.
- Behind-the-Scenes Footage: Additional on-set footage not included in the documentary.
- HDNet: A Look at Black Death: A promotional piece featuring a synopsis and short interviews.
- Theatrical Trailer: The official high-definition film trailer.
- Also From Magnolia Home Entertainment Blu-ray: Promotional content for other releases.
Movie: 66
Black Death," directed by Christopher Smith and starring Sean Bean alongside Eddie Redmayne, carves out its own grim space in the cinematic portrayal of the bubonic plague, a catastrophic epidemic that has seen scant exploration in film despite its historical significance. This isn't merely an attempt to stand alongside Ingmar Bergman's "The Seventh Seal," which looms large over any cinematic endeavor into plague-ridden landscapes; instead, "Black Death" ventures into a dark and brutal narrative enriched by a theological wrestle and a commendable authenticity in setting and character portrayal. The film, shot in Germany and anchored in the year 1348 - one of the plague’s deadliest periods - embarks on a gritty mission led by a band of mercenaries. They are tasked with uncovering the truth behind a village mysteriously spared from the plague's clutches, rumored to house a necromancer. This premise serves as the backbone for a story that merges historical context, horror elements, and a profound exploration of faith and superstition deeply embedded in its era.
Bean's casting as Ulric, the group's leader, along with Redmayne's Osmund - a young monk facing a crisis of faith - adds layers of depth to a narrative that could easily have been another forgettable medieval thriller. The characters, including Carice van Houten’s manipulative village leader, are sketched with nuances that elevate the plot beyond mere swashbuckling into a complex examination of belief systems at loggerheads. The film’s scathing critique of religious zealotry on both sides of the pagan-Christian divide, while not novel, is rendered with a freshness and intensity that keeps viewers engaged.
Visually, "Black Death" benefits from Smith's ability to do more with less. The bleakness of the 14th-century setting is convincingly portrayed amidst a backdrop of despair and decay, which amplifies the narrative's darker themes. What stands out is the film's commitment to a realistic portrayal of its characters' grime-coated existence, eschewing Hollywood polish for authenticity. Despite occasional pacing issues and a tendency towards heavy-handed symbolism, "Black Death" manages to carve out its niche. Its conclusion, which takes a tonal shift that might not sit well with all, nonetheless reinforces the chilling undercurrents of its central theme: the devastating consequences of unchecked zealotry masked as piety.
Total: 57
Black Death" emerges as an engaging, albeit not groundbreaking, addition to the genre of historical action with a supernatural twist. While it may not ascend to the ranks of cinematic masterpieces, it proceeds with a gripping narrative reminiscent of a darker, less whimsical "The Wicker Man." Its premise, weaving through the murky terrains of 14th-century religious zealotry and witch hunts, offers a compelling, if occasionally horrifying, backdrop. The Magnolia Blu-ray release honors this grim tableau with a faithful high-definition transfer that captures every nuance of the bleak medieval landscapes and the pulsating heart of its mystery. Complemented by a robust audio track and a modest selection of extras, this release respects both the material and its audience, providing an auditory and visual experience that is both immersive and satisfying.
The inclusion of Sean Bean adds a layer of gravitas to the film, his performance lending credibility and depth to the ensemble cast. Bean's portrayal, imbued with an almost timeless quality, elevates the narrative, seamlessly blending into the film's atmospheric setting. This Blu-ray edition's technical execution shines, offering viewers a seamless gateway into the film's darkly intriguing world. The picture and sound quality ensure that none of the film's nuanced tones are lost, from the eeriest whisper to the clashing din of battle.
In conclusion, while "Black Death" may not redefine its genre, it stands as a worthy addition to one's collection, particularly for aficionados of medieval narratives laced with elements of suspense and the supernatural. The Blu-ray release by Magnolia is executed with commendable fidelity to the source material, ensuring that both aficionados and newcomers to the film are treated to a viewing experience that is as immersive as it is entertaining. Its solid technical presentation, combined with a captivating premise and strong performances, especially from Sean Bean, makes this release not just a casual rental, but a recommended purchase for those drawn to the darker corridors of history and fantasy.
Blu-ray.com review by Casey BroadwaterRead review here
Video: 80
The downside is that clarity sometimes takes a hit�night scenes have a tendency to look quite soft�but this is all part of the film's aesthetic, and Magnolia's transfer represents it faithfully....
Audio: 80
The swordplay-heavy skirmish scenes have lots of hefty, clanging, metal-on-metal sounds, vaguely supernatural sequences are filled with skittering noises and ghostly disembodied voices, and the journey...
Extras: 40
Bringing Black Death to Live (SD, 11:35): A quick production documentary that brings us on set for interviews with the director and stars, and plenty of behind-the-scenes footage....
Movie: 60
It's no spoiler to reveal that Langiva is the devil-consorting priestess that Ulric's been after, and the remainder of the film becomes a battle of the faiths where both sides are clearly in the wrong....
Total: 60
Black Death's not quite as good as it could be considering its promising, religious-warriors-on-a-witch-hunt premise, but it is entertaining and occasionally scary, with a central mystery that plays out...
High-Def Digest review by Nate BossRead review here
Video: 70
Rather, random day shots are the problem, as detail cannot get through, and there's random softness that accompanies the spikes....
Audio: 90
The only thing is, as regularly employed and utilized as the rear speakers are, there are scenes that seem front heavy that shouldn't be, where too little sound creeps to the rears, to envelop you in the...
Extras: 40
Experience the film like you were there making it, witness takes from a different angle, or between cut conversations....
Movie: 80
When the village appears normal, perfectly calm, yes, the threat of danger stinks like something was stepped in, unavoidable, impossible to remove, but the apparent tranquility is disarming, to say the...
Total: 70
It is, however, a solid little action/suspense/supernatural flick, filled to the brim with some pretty awesome characters and settings....
Director: Christopher Smith
Actors: Eddie Redmayne, Sean Bean, Carice van Houten
PlotIn medieval Europe, the bubonic plague ravages the continent, bringing death and fear among the population. A young monk named Osmund prays for guidance, torn between his devotion to God and his love for a young woman. Seeking a sign, he volunteers to guide a group of mercenaries led by the battle-hardened knight Ulric. Their mission, decreed by the church, is to investigate a remote village rumored to be untouched by the plague. The villagers' supposed immunity is attributed to their rejection of God and the alleged resurrection of their dead by a necromancer. Osmund sees this perilous journey as an opportunity to reunite with his love, who he has instructed to wait for him in the forest.
The mercenaries, each driven by their own motives, journey through a landscape scarred by disease and death. Upon reaching the forest, a pivotal moment causes Osmund to lose his way, both in his path through the woods and in his moral compass. As the group continues, they confront the harsh realities of a countryside gripped by superstition and fear. When they finally arrive at the village, they encounter a community that appears idyllic and serene on the surface. However, under the guidance of a mysterious leader, the villagers harbor dark secrets. The mercenaries must confront their own beliefs and fears as they uncover the truth behind the village's eerie immunity to the plague.
Writers: Dario Poloni, Christopher Smith
Release Date: 11 Jun 2010
Runtime: 102 min
Rating: R
Country: Germany, United Kingdom
Language: English, Latin