Ip Man Blu-ray Review
葉問 | Collector's Edition
Score: 58
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Ip Man delivers a captivating story and impressive action sequences with strong performances, though Blu-ray's video quality presents inconsistencies.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 55
Ip Man's Blu-ray presentation in 1080p/AVC showcases a mixed visual experience. Pre-war scenes feature vibrant colors and detailed clarity, whereas post-invasion visuals shift to desaturated gray tones, though detail in low-light scenes remains strong. Occasional issues include overly-sharpened edges and slightly washed-out blacks.
Audio: 55
The DTS-HD MA 5.1 soundtrack of 'Ip Man' generally excels with clear, impactful audio and well-integrated sound effects, despite some issues with original language synchronization and occasional overpowering bass and music; it offers a dynamic and engaging home theater experience.
Extra: 60
The Blu-ray and DVD extras for 'Ip Man' offer a comprehensive dive into the film's production with highlights including an 18-minute 'Making Of' featurette, deleted scenes, various trailers, and extensive interviews with key cast and crew members, providing technical insights into the creation and authenticity of the period piece.
Movie: 73
Ip Man is a masterfully crafted film that combines breathtaking fight choreography and historical depth, portraying martial arts not just as combat but as a disciplined way of life. Donnie Yen delivers a stellar performance, and the Blu-ray's visual quality and authentic 1930s China recreation enhance the cinematic experience.
Video: 55
"Ip Man" presents an intriguing visual style in its 1080p/AVC-encoded Blu-ray transfer, set in a 2.35:1 aspect ratio. Before the war, the film's visual presentation bursts with vivid colors, highlighted notably in scenes within the restaurant where shades of blue, yellow, and green from stained glass windows, along with purple and red-gold table settings, are particularly notable. Post-invasion, however, the palette deliberately shifts to more desaturated tones, dominated by grays and muted blacks. This change profoundly enhances the film’s thematic depth. The warm lighting provides detailed, nuanced texture in both clothing and exteriors, especially visible in busy street scenes. However, the digital cleanup of film grain pre-war leads to a lack of texture in faces, occasionally causing movement to appear smeared.
The transfer exhibits mixed performance. While offering strong contrast that enhances whites and grays without washing out details, the blacks occasionally seem washed out but remain gradationally revealing. Although certain scenes suffer from overly-sharpened visuals and edge enhancement, evident particularly in the second half of the film, the overall detail stands out in well-defined objects and skin textures, maintaining a high level of detail in low light and shadowy backgrounds. Fleshtones remain natural against the primarily desaturated chroma.
Despite some occasional technical drawbacks such as stray vertical lines and grain inconsistencies, "Ip Man" largely delivers a visually compelling high-definition experience. The final fight sequence notably returns to vibrant pre-war hues with bright reds and whites from the Japanese flag, emphasizing the dramatic visual narrative arc. However, videophiles might still yearn for an updated release that addresses these issues comprehensively for a truly pristine presentation.
Audio: 55
The Blu-ray audio presentation of "Ip Man" delivers a compelling auditory experience shaped by the DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 lossless soundtrack. While there are multiple audio options including Cantonese, Mandarin, and an English dub, the original Mandarin frequently suffers from synchronization issues. This anomaly seems intrinsic to the master and isn't directly correlated to the present encoding. Despite challenges with the dubbing quality, the Cantonese version offers a more authentic feel although synchronization can still be problematic. What stands out is the high-resolution DTS-HD Master Audio surround mix that imbues a sense of depth and clarity to the film's soundtrack. Sounds associated with hand-to-hand combat, such as breaking objects and Kenji Kawai's orchestral music, are rendered with exceptional fidelity, allowing for immersive spatial effects that strategically utilize the entire sound system for an engaging experience.
Action sequences benefit from extended dynamic range, delivering a definitive impact that heightens the film's physical and emotional intensity. While the track maintains a solid low end and exhibits powerful bass response, some effects, like body hits, may feel overstated and unrealistic. Surround channels are used with subtlety, offering a mix of immersive ambient noir and localized sound effects that truly come to life during intense fight scenes. Dialogue is generally crisp, and well-centered across the front soundstage, though it occasionally dips in volume, impacting clarity. Imaging is precise, creating an enveloping soundscape where listeners can discern sounds moving across channels—a blade slicing through the air or the vivid sound of a gunshot from the rear speakers adds to this immersive experience.
While not without flaws, particularly in terms of synchronization and occasional distortion in music during fight sequences, "Ip Man's" DTS-HD MA 5.1 mix excels in delivering an intricate blend of detailed sounds and room-filling dynamics. Its effective use of spatial and localizable effects during pivotal scenes ensures a rich home theater experience that complements the visual tempo and thematic elements of the film.
Extras: 60
The extras section of the "Ip Man" Blu-ray collector's edition offers a comprehensive behind-the-scenes look that martial arts enthusiasts and cinephiles will appreciate. The Blu-ray disc boasts high-definition (1080p) features, including an 18-minute "Making of Ip Man," which covers the film’s detailed physical preparations, Donnie Yen’s exceptional performance, historical research, casting insights, and Sammo Hung’s choreography. There are three deleted scenes providing additional context, and trailers for both the Chinese and U.S. audiences. On the accompanying DVD, viewers will find standard-definition (480p) materials with a five-minute "Shooting Diary," three "Behind the Sets" segments, and extensive interviews totaling nearly 90 minutes with key figures such as director Wilson Yip, action director Sammo Hung, consultant Ip Chun, and prominent cast members.
Extras included in this disc:
- Making of Ip Man: Detailed featurette on film creation and cast preparation.
- Deleted Scenes: Additional scenes adding narrative insights.
- Trailers: Both Chinese and U.S. versions.
- Shooting Diary: Behind-the-scenes promotional short.
- Behind the Sets: Focused looks at Cotton Mill, Ip Man's home, and streets of Fo Shan.
- Interviews: In-depth discussions with the director, cast, and crew.
Movie: 73
"Ip Man" delivers a highly engaging, meticulously crafted narrative set against the grim backdrop of the Sino-Japanese War in Foshan, China. Directed by Wilson Yip and starring Donnie Yen, the biographical tale centered on Wing Chun Grandmaster Ip Man is defined by its immaculate choreography and compelling story. The movie highlights Ip Man's internal struggle as he balances his profound martial arts prowess with a devout sense of humility and nonviolence. The conflict escalates dramatically when he faces off against General Miura, culminating in high-stakes, masterfully executed fight sequences that capture both elegance and brutal realism. The seamless blending of cinematographic excellence and thematic depth ensures that "Ip Man" is not merely an action spectacle but a thoughtful exploration of honor, discipline, and the philosophical essence of martial arts.
Moreover, "Ip Man" immerses viewers in the vibrant yet harrowing reality of 1930s-occupation-era China. The meticulous production design effectively distinguishes between the pre-invasion vibrancy of Foshan and the oppressive desolation following the Japanese occupation. Donnie Yen's portrayal of Ip Man is nothing short of extraordinary; his nuanced performance adds layers to the character, embodying a calm, cerebral approach to conflict that propels the narrative's emotional core. Even amid gravity-defying action sequences and amplified sound effects, the film's dedication to realism and historical context keeps it grounded. Although some elements may strain believability, they do not detract from the poignant storytelling and profound character arcs.
In essence, "Ip Man" is a cinematic triumph that marries electrifying martial arts choreography with deep-seated thematic richness. It pays homage to the true-life story of a man who upheld his principles against overwhelming adversity. The balance between kinetic action and reflective moments creates a compelling biopic that not only entertains but also imparts critical lessons on the judicious use of power and the nuanced relationship between violence and peace.
Total: 58
The Blu-ray release of "Ip Man" is a standout offering for fans of martial arts cinema and quality home entertainment. This film, built on strong themes of self-reliance, self-restraint, and friendship, is bolstered by a captivating story, remarkable production design, and Donnie Yen's stellar performance. The fight choreography, overseen by renowned action director Sammo Hung, is second to none, providing both entertainment and thoughtful commentary on the place of action in society.
Well Go USA delivers a commendable high-definition presentation of "Ip Man" on Blu-ray. The audio quality is robust, enriching the dynamic fight sequences and maintaining clarity throughout dialogue-heavy scenes. However, the video quality is somewhat inconsistent, with some scenes lacking the sharpness and crispness expected from a Blu-ray release. Despite this, the overall experience remains engaging, thanks to the gripping narrative and top-tier performances.
Extras included in the Blu-ray release are a definite highlight, with behind-the-scenes content and extended featurettes that exceed the length of the movie itself. These additions provide invaluable insights into the making of the film and further enhance the viewer's appreciation of the technical prowess required to produce such an outstanding piece.
In conclusion, "Ip Man" on Blu-ray is a highly recommended addition to any film enthusiast's collection. Despite minor inconsistencies in video quality, the exceptional audio, compelling story, and comprehensive extras make it a worthy purchase. This release not only celebrates the cinematic brilliance of "Ip Man" but also serves as a fitting tribute to the legendary martial artist behind the story.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 70
Most evident is the overly-sharpened appearance and the presence of occasional edge enhancement; Ip Man never looks completely filmic or natural, but the high definition presentation is still well-detailed...
Audio: 70
The picture's opening music can sound a bit cramped -- as can a few other selections throughout the film, all clearly absent the more general smoothness and seamlessness of superior tracks -- but clarity...
Extras: 50
Behind the Sets (480p): A look at the construction of the Cotton Mill (2:33), the Streets of Fo Shan (2:00), and Ip Man's Home (2:03)....
Movie: 90
As the invasion commences, however, the bright colors and fanciful sets give way to a lifeless, cold, inhospitable atmosphere that's the physical representation of not only suppression and repression,...
Total: 70
Ip Man is a fantastic movie that's built on strong principles of self-reliance, self-restraint, friendship, and what it takes to survive in both the good times and the bad....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
During the occupation, detail is evident in the low-light scenes where the Chinese and Japanese fight....
Audio: 60
In contrast to the Chinese tracks, the effects on the English seem mixed a tad louder and have more bass, but the ambiance isn't as strong like in the scene where Ip agrees to train Quan's workers....
Extras: 80
Behind the Sets (SD, 6 min) - Three short pieces focusing on the Cotton Mill, Ip Man's Home, and the streets of Fo Shan....
Movie: 60
Opening in 1935, the city of Fo Shan is known for many martial arts schools, but the most talented man appears to be Master Ip, played by Donnie Yen, who not only does a very good job meeting the physical...
Total: 60
'Ip Man' is an entertaining movie and tells the story of a man who deserves to be better known even though only part of that story is presented here....
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 88
Blacks are slightly washed out but gradationally revealing which combines with excellent detail in low light and shadowy backgrounds to provide a strong sense of dimension....
Audio: 90
The sounds of breaking objects, hand to hand combat, and Kenji Kawai's beautifully orchestrated music is reproduced with sparkling clarity....
Extras: 60
Shooting diary Behind the sets - Cotton mill, Streets of Fo Shan, Ip man's home Interviews - Director, Action Direction, Members of the cast...
Movie: 80
Set in Foshan, China, during the Sino Japanese War, Ip Man vividly brings to life the brutality of the infamous Japanese occupation, where once proud men are forced to fight till their death for a precious...
Total: 80
THX Ultra 2 Preamp/Video Processor Sherbourn Technologies - 7/200 Seven Channel Amplifier Oppo BDP-83 Universal disc/Blu-ray Player (HDMI Audio/Video)...
Director: Wilson Yip
Actors: Donnie Yen, Simon Yam, Siu-Wong Fan
PlotIn the 1930s in Foshan, Guangdong, martial arts schools are in abundance, with the city known across China for its wealth of talent in the fighting arts. Amid this backdrop lives a quietly prosperous and unassuming Wing Chun master, widely regarded as the most skilled fighter in the city, though he chooses to live a low-profile life and avoids taking students. His peaceful existence is deeply rooted in his family life and his belief in practicing martial arts for its artistry and moral values, rather than for glory or financial gain.
However, the master's world is turned upside down when the Japanese invasion of 1937 reaches Foshan, drastically changing the fabric of life in the city. The occupation forces not only destroy the economy but also dismantle the societal structures that allowed martial arts to flourish. Facing a critical turning point, he must navigate the challenges of life under occupation while protecting his values and the people he cares about. This period of turmoil forces him into a position where he must make difficult decisions between staying true to his principles and adapting to the harsh realities of a war-torn land.
Writers: Edmond Wong, Tai-Lee Chan
Release Date: 12 Dec 2008
Runtime: 106 min
Rating: R
Country: Hong Kong, China
Language: Cantonese, Mandarin, Japanese, Chinese, English