Only the Brave Blu-ray Review
Score: 73
from 4 reviewers
Review Date:
Only the Brave offers an authentic, powerful depiction of heroism with top-notch audio and video quality, despite some minor interpersonal dramatization.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 79
Only the Brave's Blu-ray excels with vibrant colors, razor-sharp clarity, and impeccable detail for its 1080p AVC encode, though some aliasing and lack of a 4K UHD edition—which would have benefited from sharper resolution and more intensive HDR—are notable shortcomings.
Audio: 76
Only the Brave's DTS-HD MA 5.1 track delivers impressive, immersive audio with a wide soundstage and dynamic range, capturing the intense roar of flames and clear dialogue, though some may miss the original Dolby Atmos mix.
Extra: 58
The Blu-ray of 'Only the Brave' features a range of insightful extras, including an audio commentary by director Joseph Kosinski and actor Josh Brolin, highlighting technical production details and authentic character portrayals. Additional featurettes focus on the real-life heroes and the rigorous training of the actors, complemented by Dierks Bentley's touching 'Hold the Light' music video.
Movie: 76
'Only the Brave' delivers a powerful portrayal of the Granite Mountain Hotshots, with exceptional performances by Josh Brolin and Miles Teller, balancing personal growth and professional heroism amid the intense backdrop of the 2013 Yarnell Hill Fire. Despite some scripting and directorial flaws, the film excels in authenticity and emotional depth.
Video: 79
"Only the Brave" manifests itself on Blu-ray with a 1080p MPEG-4 AVC encode and a 2.39:1 aspect ratio, delivering an impressive visual presentation that reflects the film's diverse environment and intense firefighting action. Shot with a Sony CineAlta F65 camera at a 4K Digital Intermediate, the video quality shines despite the absence of a 4K UHD release. From the opening scenes, the film showcases vivid primary colors: fiery reds, oranges against the dusky Arizona landscape, and lush forest greens, all rendered with remarkable depth and texture. Details are meticulously presented; viewers can discern individual dirt particles on characters' faces, fabric textures, and complex details of various terrains.
Black levels and shadow details exhibit strong performance, ensuring nighttime and indoor scenes maintain clarity, though occasionally, blacks appear slightly gray rather than inky. The daylight sequences feature razor-sharp clarity and vibrant colors, further enhancing the viewing experience. Flesh tones are accurate and robust, contributing to the overall lifelike presentation. However, it's worth noting that the Blu-ray does display some aliasing issues at times—roof lines and car grills exhibit shimmering artifacts that can occasionally distract from the viewing experience.
Despite minor flaws, "Only the Brave" is a stellar Blu-ray release that beautifully captures Joseph Kosinski's unique visual style. The high-definition transfer is nearly flawless, with every frame bursting off the screen and detail work that borders on reference quality, notwithstanding its minor imperfections. The lack of a 4K UHD release is disappointing, given the film's 4K origins and critical acclaim, but this Blu-ray iteration stands tall as a testament to the high-caliber visual feast that "Only the Brave" offers.
Audio: 76
The audio presentation of "Only the Brave" on Blu-ray delivers a compelling DTS-HD MA 5.1 track that surpasses expectations often reserved for higher channel configurations like Dolby Atmos. Despite being limited to 5.1 channels, this mix establishes a vibrant and immersive soundstage, beginning with the initial helicopter scene that impressively deploys ambient effects, such as the thudding rotors and wind whooshes, creating a palpable sense of realism. Dialogue remains consistently clear and well-defined, predominantly anchored at the front channels.
Throughout the film, particularly during the high-intensity fire sequences, the audio track shines with remarkable precision. The crackling flames and explosive LFE elements heighten the drama, shaking the room with deep, awe-inspiring sound. Scenes involving choppers and planes exhibit a tangible sense of space and dynamism. In quieter moments, ambient sounds like swarming bees and rushing water are meticulously detailed, contributing to the overall experience. Moreover, a key bar sequence showcases the track's ability to maintain dialogue clarity even in noisy environments.
For those keeping track of technical specifics, the DTS-HD MA 5.1 mix on "Only the Brave" averages a bitrate of 2.3 mbps, reaching up to 3.2 mbps during its most intense scenes. This ensures robust playback quality with substantial low-end support and immersive sound design that envelops viewers in a 360-degree audio field. While there's a minor disappointment regarding the absence of an original Dolby Atmos mix, the provided track stands as an exemplary audio presentation, making "Only the Brave" a premier choice for home theater enthusiasts seeking a deeply engaging and technically proficient audio experience.
Extras: 58
The extras on the Blu Ray of "Only the Brave" offer a comprehensive and engaging extension to the film, making this package a thoroughly enriching experience. The feature audio commentary by Director Joseph Kosinski and actor Josh Brolin stands out with its modest yet insightful discussion on both technical aspects and the narrative integrity of the production. The deleted scenes provide additional context, though their exclusion from the final cut is understandable. Featurettes explore the true stories behind the film, the rigorous physical training the actors went through, and the significance of accurately portraying real-life characters, enriched by contributions from both cast and crew. Additionally, Dierks Bentley's music video and a featurette on the song "Hold the Light" highlight the emotional impact of the story.
Extras included in this disc:
Audio Commentary: Insightful track with Director Joseph Kosinski and Josh Brolin.
Deleted Scenes: Two brief scenes adding minor context.
Honoring the Heroes: The True Stories: Reflections on the real Granite Mountain Hotshots.
Boot Camp: Becoming a Hotshot: Behind-the-scenes of actor training.
Behind the Brotherhood: The Characters: Focus on accurate character portrayals.
Music Video: "Hold the Light" by Dierks Bentley featuring S. Carey.
Behind the Song: Hold the Light: Discussion on the song's significance.
Movie: 76
"Only the Brave" is an evocative portrayal of the Granite Mountain Hotshots, an elite firefighting crew from Prescott, Arizona. This compelling film expertly re-creates the harrowing true events of the 2013 Yarnell Hill Fire, which resulted in the tragic loss of 19 out of 20 members. The movie follows Eric Marsh (played by Josh Brolin), who is determined to get his unit certified as hotshots, and his struggle to balance his consuming career with his personal life. The introduction of Brendan McDonough (Miles Teller), a recovering addict seeking redemption and purpose, further adds depth to the narrative. The film meticulously renders the characters with professional complexity, emphasizing their camaraderie and struggles beyond their firefighting roles.
The film's strength lies in its character development and emotional resonance rather than in presenting firefighting action sequences. Joseph Kosinski's directorial approach brings a palpable authenticity to the screen, though some reviewers feel it misses exploring deeper motivational complexities and tightly structuring the narrative. Notable performances include Brolin's portrayal of Marsh as a steadfast leader and Teller's transformative role as McDonough, whose journey from troubled past to meaningful brotherhood resonates strongly. The intimate portrayal of their lives underscores the emotional impact of the third act, where the impending tragedy of the Yarnell Hill Fire is both compelling and heart-wrenching.
Despite some criticisms regarding the script’s depth and development, "Only the Brave" effectively highlights the heroism and sacrifice of the real-life hotshots. Kosinski’s direction offers visually arresting sequences, especially in the fire scenes, projecting a blend of horror and beauty. The movie stands as a tribute to bravery, emphasizing family bonds, personal redemption, and the poignant reality of the firefighting profession. Its respectful depiction of these heroes' lives and sacrifices leaves a lasting emotional imprint, encompassing themes of love, duty, and loss within a gripping true story.
Total: 73
"Only the Brave" is a meticulously crafted film that presents an emotionally charged tribute to the real-life heroes who battled California’s catastrophic wildfires. Directed by Joseph Kosinski and written by Ken Nolan, the film features standout performances from Josh Brolin and Miles Teller. The narrative methodically focuses on the camaraderie and sacrifices of the Granite Mountain Hotshots, particularly through the lives of Eric Marsh and Brendan McDonough. The story avoids melodrama, opting instead for a genuine portrayal of heroism and commitment amidst relentless danger. While the film takes certain creative liberties in depicting interpersonal tensions among the crew, it remains largely faithful to the tragic real events, ensuring a gripping and heartfelt narrative.
Technically, the Blu-ray release of "Only the Brave" excels with superior audiovisual quality. The 2.39:1 AVC-encoded image offers crisp, detailed visuals that capture the harsh beauty and deadly intensity of wildfire scenes. Complementing this is the robust DTS-HD MA 5.1 audio track, which delivers immersive soundscapes that place the viewer in the midst of the action. The array of available subtitles—English SDH, French, Spanish, and Portuguese—ensures accessibility for a wider audience. Additionally, the supplemental content enriches the viewing experience by providing deeper insights into the making of the film and the real-life events it portrays.
In conclusion, "Only the Brave" is a powerful, emotionally resonant film that goes beyond mere entertainment to honor true heroism. Despite some minor drawbacks, such as its limited runtime insufficient for fully exploring each firefighter's story, it successfully conveys a poignant sense of camaraderie and sacrifice. The Blu-ray's high-quality presentation and informative extras further enhance its value, making it a highly recommended addition to any collection.
AV Nirvana review by Michael ScottRead review here
Video: 90
The movie opens up with the bright orange flames contrasting against the dusky brown and green tinged landscape of Arizona (although I’m suspicious this was shot partially in New Mexico, as I know the...
Audio: 90
The entire sound stage is wide and spacious, with the Arizona desert fires shifting rapidly around the room, and creating a 360 degree sound field that really is an amazing experience....
Extras: 60
• Deleted Scenes • Feature Audio Commentary with Director Joseph Kosinski and Josh Brolin • Featurettes: - "Honoring the Heroes: The True Stories" - "Behind the Brotherhood: The Characters" - "Boot Camp:...
Movie: 90
Still, most of what happens is fairly accurate, with director Joseph Kosinski having an amazing eye for recreating the scenarios down to the T. The Granite Mountain Hotshots’ base of operation was created...
Total: 90
Audio and video are superb on the Blu-ray, and the array of extras is quite revealing to what really happened, and just how accurate the movie really was in regards to these men’s final days on earth....
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 90
As it is, the image bears much fruit, yielding bountiful and brilliant colors reflected not only in hot fires but also diverse natural greens, red and yellow hotshots gear, and any other number of shades...
Audio: 90
Swarming bees, rushing water, raging infernos, and other high-yield sound elements enter the stage with potent delivery, wide berth, and total saturation, as well as pinpoint clarity even through the most...
Extras: 60
Honoring the Heroes: The True Stories (1080p, 8:08): Cast and crew reflect on their reaction to the real story as it developed, initial resistance to the project, the importance of getting the movie and...
Movie: 100
The film focuses on two characters, one a veteran of the fire world who finds himself caught between commitment to his profession and the men he leads and an increasingly uncertain future at home with...
Total: 80
It is indeed a powerful, unforgettable experience, not necessarily unique to cinema in that respect but nevertheless one of the most honest and complete depictions of man and heroism one is going to find...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Only the Brave fights its way through the smoky haze and on to home video with a 1080p MPEG-4 AVC encode that, if you followed this director’s work, unsurprisingly looks amazingly good....
Audio: 80
Now, I do have to start off with a small bone I have with this disc in general, because just like the video transfer, this was originally mixed in Dolby Atmos, yet we are still given this downmixed track....
Extras: 60
Behind the Brotherhood: The Characters (HD 7:20) – The importance of respecting the real-life characters is something that was actually held in high regard on this set....
Movie: 80
Usually, those stereotypes are only there to showcase the fact that this is a movie about firefighters or police officers....
Total: 80
Instead, it shows us a little window into these characters’ lives that also happen to be firemen....
Home Theater Forum review by Kevin EKRead review here
Video: 90
Only The Brave is presented in a 2:39:1 1080p AVC transfer (@ an average of 24 mbps) that does well with the variety of locations and lighting situations presented by a movie covering firefighters and...
Audio: 80
The disc also carries a Portuguese DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track, a French Dolby Digital 5.1 track and DVS tracks in both English and French....
Extras: 60
One is an expansion of a training situation for McDonough, where he gets badly blistered on his hands for trying too hard (possibly a metaphor for the movie…); the other is an expansion of the Amanda crash...
Movie: 40
Only The Brave once again benefits from that solid design and presentation, but simply doesn’t have much of a story to tell the audience....
Total: 40
It’s certainly earnest enough, and has a worthy story to tell, but without a strong script or a strong director, there really wasn’t any way that would happen....
Director: Joseph Kosinski
Actors: Josh Brolin, Miles Teller, Jeff Bridges
PlotThe story follows a group of dedicated firefighters known as the Granite Mountain Hotshots, an elite crew tasked with tackling deadly wildfires. Led by their supervisor, Eric Marsh, the team trains rigorously to earn their certification as Hotshots, a designation that would enable them to confront some of the deadliest fires in the nation. New recruit Brendan McDonough, a young man with a troubled past, joins the crew and becomes determined to prove his worth to the team and himself. The camaraderie and brotherhood among the firefighters grow as they engage in grueling training exercises and respond to increasingly dangerous fire situations.
As the team responds to various calls and wildfires, their bond is put to the test against the backdrop of personal struggles and the perils inherent in their line of work. Tensions rise as they balance their personal lives with the relentless demands of firefighting. With each mission, their resolve strengthens, and they learn invaluable lessons about bravery, sacrifice, and camaraderie. Their ultimate test comes when they face one of the most catastrophic fires in recent history, a challenge that will forge their legacy and determine their fate.
Writers: Sean Flynn, Ken Nolan, Eric Warren Singer
Release Date: 20 Oct 2017
Runtime: 134 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States
Language: English