Silent Running Blu-ray Review
Masters of Cinema
Score: 61
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Silent Running's Blu-ray release by Eureka Entertainment in collaboration with Universal Studios boasts impressive visuals and sound, delighting classic sci-fi fans. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 58
Eureka's UK Blu-ray of 'Silent Running' offers a satisfying restoration, retaining a film-like texture with a fine layer of grain, minimal edge enhancement, and well-saturated colors. Presenting in 1080p MPEG-4 AVC within its original 1.85:1 aspect ratio, it shows impressive detail and clarity, especially in dark sequences.
Audio: 58
Eureka delivers a faithful DTS-HD MA 2.0 mix on the "Silent Running" Blu-ray, preserving the original audio without unnecessary enhancements. Dialogue is clear, special effects and Joan Baez's score are well-balanced, and subtle sounds like birdsong are crisp, ensuring an immersive listening experience.
Extra: 66
The Blu-ray extras for 'Silent Running' offer a rich, technical dive into the film's making, featuring an informative commentary track by Douglas Trumbull and Bruce Dern, a thorough 50-minute production documentary, multiple video interviews with Trumbull, and an isolated music track that highlights Peter Schickele's haunting score.
Movie: 71
Douglas Trumbull's 1972 'Silent Running' on Blu-ray showcases groundbreaking visual effects and an enduring environmental message, bolstered by Bruce Dern's compelling performance. Eureka Entertainment's release offers a polished transfer, insightful commentary, and enriching supplementary materials, making it a cult favorite.
Video: 58
Eureka Entertainment's UK Blu-ray release of Douglas Trumbull's Silent Running, presented in its original 1.85:1 aspect ratio, utilizes an AVC encode and boasts a meticulous HD restoration. Sourced from a 35mm interpositive made in 1996, further cleanup was executed using a combination of HD-DVNR, Phoenix, and MTI systems by Deluxe 142, London. This comprehensive process has admirably preserved the film's character without overly cleaning or sharpening it to the point of losing its original texture.
The high-definition transfer is particularly commendable for maintaining a fine layer of grain throughout, thereby preserving the filmic texture that enhances its nostalgic appeal. There are no noticeable issues with edge enhancement, smearing, or aliasing. Color reproduction is accurate and vibrant, with the costumes and sets showcasing rich, well-saturated colors. The foliage and fauna scenes are particularly striking, featuring detailed, organic colors. Some close-ups, particularly of Bruce Dern’s face, exhibit significant detail, with excellent skin texture and depth.
Despite these strengths, the transfer is not without its imperfections. Occasionally, mid-ground faces can appear too clean and smooth due to the noise removal process. Contrast levels are managed well, though there are moments of fluctuating blacks and minor vertical banding during specific scenes. These are minor distractions and do not detract significantly from the overall visual experience. The film's dark sequences maintain clarity without succumbing to blockiness or murkiness, and the disc adeptly handles bright flashes within the image. Overall, this Blu-ray release presents Silent Running with impressive detail and visual fidelity, faithfully capturing the essence of the original production while making notable improvements over previous home video iterations.
Audio: 58
The Blu-ray audio presentation of "Silent Running" has been executed with impressive fidelity, maintaining the integrity of the original elements through a DTS-HD MA 2.0 mix. Dialogue is exceptionally clear and discernible, capturing even the subtleties of Bruce Dern's distinctive accent and mumbling tendencies. Communication over ship-to-ship radios is devoid of distortion, ensuring clean and clear transmission. The ambient sounds, from the bleeps and whoops of the drones to more subtle effects like the flicking of switches or clacking of pool balls, are reproduced with precision and naturality.
Additionally, the score by Joan Baez benefits immensely from this mix, her voice resonating with power and grace while the music maintains a warm, immersive presence. Bass management is robust, keenly handling the exploding bolts, impacts, and the roaring journey through Saturn's rings—all while adhering to the space’s unique acoustic environment. The portrayal of quieter sounds, such as birdsong and rustling leaves within the spacecraft garden, enhances the experience, making it a strong transfer of a modest yet intricate sound design.
For audiophiles, there are two available tracks: an English DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 track and a Music & Effects DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 track. The lossless audio format ensures that special audio effects are enhanced and the overall sound quality is distinctly crisper and clearer. Notably, Joan Baez's vocal performance is richer and more rounded. Importantly, there are no discernible pops, cracks, or background hiss to detract from the viewing experience. Eureka Entertainment also provides optional English SDH subtitles for those who require them, rounding off a meticulous audio presentation that respects the original source material while enhancing its clarity and depth.
Extras: 66
"Silent Running" Blu-ray extras offer a comprehensive insight into the making of this eco-science fiction classic, blending detailed technical commentary with nostalgic reflections. Director Douglas Trumbull and actor Bruce Dern's audio commentary, recorded in 2000, provides a rich, technically skewed discussion on filmmaking freedoms at Universal in the 70s. The 50-minute vintage documentary, "The Making of Silent Running," details production intricacies, set design, and special effects, providing an extensive behind-the-scenes look. Two video interviews from 2001 with Trumbull provide depth on his motivations and career evolution. Bruce Dern's candid 11-minute interview offers personal anecdotes about working on set. Additional features like an isolated music and FX audio track and a stunning 48-page collector booklet enrich the experience, making these extras indispensable for fans and film historians alike.
Extras included in this disc:
- Commentary Track: In-depth technical and nostalgic discussion by Douglas Trumbull and Bruce Dern.
- The Making of Silent Running: Vintage on-set documentary focusing on production and set design.
- Silent Running by Douglas Trumbull: Detailed recollections from the director on making the movie.
- Douglas Trumbull: Then and Now: Insight into Trumbull's career and innovations.
- A Conversation with Bruce Dern: Personal reflections from the actor on his role and career.
- Trailer: Original theatrical trailer.
- Isolated Music and FX audio track: Enjoy Peter Schickele's score in DTS-HD MA 2.0.
- Lavish 48-page collector booklet: Comprehensive overview with photos and concept art.
Movie: 71
Douglas Trumbull's "Silent Running" (1972) is a seminal work in the landscape of science fiction cinema, notable for its environmental commentary and groundbreaking visual effects. With freedom granted by Universal, Trumbull harnessed his expertise from "2001: A Space Odyssey" to craft a film that, despite its flaws, has become a cult favorite. Bruce Dern delivers an intense performance as Freeman Lowell, an astronaut who rebels against orders to destroy Earth's remaining forests housed in domes aboard the Valley Forge. His descent into madness is both poignant and gripping, underlined by his interactions with three drones named Huey, Louie, and Dewey. The film's visuals, particularly the effects used to portray space and the lush domes, remain impressive and influential.
The script, co-written by notable future filmmakers Michael Cimino and Steven Bochco, balances its narrative with a powerful yet not overwhelming environmental message. The story's pacing is deliberate, fostering an atmosphere that mirrors Lowell's psychological unraveling as he grapples with isolation and his drastic actions. Despite some moments of unnecessary sentimentality towards the end, the film maintains tension and engagement. Dern's portrayal of Lowell’s Internal conflict keeps the viewer invested in the character's journey from peace-loving ecologist to desperate fugitive.
"Silent Running" also gains from its superb supporting elements. The multiple-amputee actors operating the drones add a unique layer of authenticity to their on-screen presence. Peter Schickele's soundtrack, featuring Joan Baez’s haunting melodies, enhances the film’s retro yet timeless feel. Coupled with a crisp image transfer and clear audio quality on this Blu-ray release, Trumbull’s directorial debut remains a visually and emotionally compelling experience that continues to resonate with contemporary audiences.
Total: 61
The Blu-ray release of "Silent Running," facilitated by Eureka Entertainment in collaboration with Universal Studios, successfully brings Douglas Trumbull's 1972 eco-centric sci-fi classic to a new audience with a level of care and detail befitting its cult status. The transfer quality is exceptional: the visuals are sharp, the colors vibrant, and the overall fidelity to the original film's aesthetic is impressive. This high-definition upgrade allows viewers to fully appreciate the film’s pioneering special effects and thematic depth. The restoration work ensures that both the space sequences and the naturalistic imagery retain their intended impact.
From an audio standpoint, this Blu-ray offers a richly layered soundscape that enhances the immersive quality of the film. The soundtrack, including Joan Baez's emotive songs, is crisp and clear, supported by a well-balanced mix that respects the original audio integrity while providing modern clarity. The enhancements extend to the ambient sounds of the spaceship and environmental elements, which are now delivered with improved precision and subtlety.
The included special features add valuable context, offering interviews with cast and crew, behind-the-scenes footage, and insightful commentaries that deepen appreciation for the film's innovative production and its environmental message. These extras not only celebrate "Silent Running"’s legacy but also give fans ample reason to revisit the film and newcomers a comprehensive introduction.
In conclusion, Eureka Entertainment’s Blu-ray release of "Silent Running" is a triumph, providing a definitive version of this classic sci-fi film. With superior audio-visual quality and a rich array of supplementary material, it meets and exceeds expectations. Fans of classic sci-fi cinema will be very pleased with this thoughtful and meticulous restoration. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED.
avforums review by Chris McEneanyRead review here
Video: 70
Costumes, hair and patterning on the drones, the sides of the spacecraft, the fabulous badges and patches all over Lowell's jumpsuit, and upon the sets boast bright primaries that can look a touch boosted,...
Audio: 70
Bass is appropriately handled in terms of the exploding bolts and grips on the domes, the odd impact and the roaring passage through the rings of Saturn and, of course, the big booms that, really speaking,...
Extras: 70
Naturally, it skews towards the more technical side of things, but we get to hear a lot about the sort of films that were being made by Universal back then, and the creative freedom that they had for this...
Movie: 70
The theme is poignant and well worth applauding even if the science is built on some seriously shaky foundations, and the message that the film seeks to deliver is just as relevant today as it was back...
Total: 70
Blu-ray.com review by Dr. Svet AtanasovRead review here
Video: 80
A light layer of grain is present throughout the entire film and there are practically no traces of edge-enhancement affecting the integrity of the image (the only extremely mild sharpening I noticed during...
Audio: 80
Not only are some of the special audio effects better enhanced, but generally the sound is also notably crisper and clearer (the birds in the domes, for instance, are a lot easier to hear)....
Extras: 70
The Making of Silent Running (1972) - this documentary film, directed by Charles Barbee and narrated by Scott Beach, focuses on the production history of Silent Running, the Essex-class aircraft carrier...
Movie: 80
After he takes control of Valley Forge, Lowell reprograms the three drones and gives them new names - Huey, Louie, and Dewey....
Total: 80
Silent Running, the first film to transition to Blu-ray as a result of this collaboration, looks and sounds very good, and I am convinced that fans of classic sci-fi cinema will be very pleased with the...
Director: Douglas Trumbull
Actors: Bruce Dern, Cliff Potts, Ron Rifkin
PlotIn a future where all plant life on Earth has perished, Valley Forge, one of a fleet of American Airlines space freighters, preserves the last remaining botanical specimens in vast geodesic domes as it orbits Saturn. Freeman Lowell, a passionate botanist, tends to these precious ecosystems, striving to maintain a semblance of the natural world. When orders come from Earth to destroy the domes and return the freighters to commercial service, Lowell rebels, driven by his dedication to ecology and conservation. He envisions a world where plants and animals can thrive once again, and he’s prepared to fight for that future.
Lowell commandeers Valley Forge, severing ties with Earth and his crewmates who do not share his environmental convictions. The narrative centers on Lowell’s solitary struggle to uphold his ideals in the face of isolation and the operational demands of the ship. Assisted by a trio of small, drone-like service robots he reprograms for companionship and help, Lowell embarks on a lonely vigil, tending his green charges amidst the stars. The film becomes a contemplation of sustainability, stewardship, and personal responsibility, posing profound questions about humanity's relationship with nature and the cost of progress.
Writers: Deric Washburn, Michael Cimino, Steven Bochco
Release Date: 10 Mar 1972
Runtime: 89 min
Rating: G
Country: United States
Language: English