Batman Begins Blu-ray Review
Limited Edition Gift Set Lenticular Cover Comic Book Postcards Prologue Booklet
Score: 70
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Despite some compression and DNR issues, 'Batman Begins' brilliantly explores Bruce Wayne's psyche, delivering a must-have BD for any serious collection.
Disc Release Date
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 63
Despite Batman Begins' Blu-ray offering adequate 1080p detail and good black levels, its bitrate limitation results in a subdued visual experience compared to the reference-quality prologue of The Dark Knight, missing the opportunity to fully leverage Blu-ray's superior capacity.
Audio: 68
The Dolby TrueHD 5.1 track on the Blu-ray of 'Batman Begins' offers adequate dialogue, orchestral sounds, and effects with deep LFE content that enhances action sequences, but it lacks the punch and dynamic realism seen in theaters, making it a polite yet underwhelming audio experience.
Extra: 74
The Blu-ray extras for 'Batman Begins' offer an array of detailed, engaging featurettes such as a reference-quality prologue from 'The Dark Knight', insightful PiP commentary, and behind-the-scenes footage highlighting the film’s technical achievements, despite some pacing issues and standard-definition limitations.
Movie: 70
The Limited Edition Gift Set of "Batman Begins" on Blu-ray is a must-have for fans, offering compelling memorabilia like a booklet with script pages, a comic adaptation, lenticular art, collectible postcards, and movie money for "The Dark Knight." The Nolan-Bale tandem effectively revitalizes Batman's origin with a dark, intense narrative.
Video: 63
The Blu-ray video presentation of "Batman Begins" presents a mixed bag for discerning viewers. Despite being touted as a flagship Warner release, the bitrate on this BD version matches that of its HD DVD counterpart, offering no significant upgrade in terms of capacity utilization. Consequently, the picture quality, while not inherently bad, fails to reach true reference standards. Particularly notable in scene comparisons, such as Bruce's sparring match on the frozen lake with Ducard, the resolution is inherently solid but marred by a thin layer of distortion likely due to the low bitrate transfer. This veiling effect leads to subdued details, making the visual experience somewhat constrained and less vibrant compared to pristine releases like "No Country for Old Men."
The Himalayan setting, which adds a tangible authenticity to the film's first half, underscores the location’s realism—even though it's actually Iceland—further enhancing the immersive quality. Yet, this authenticity falters in darker scenes where black levels and 1080p detail, albeit superior to DVD, lack the depth and lifelike quality expected from a high-quality BD. The night scenes, critical for a film heavy with shadow and darkness themes, perform adequately but ultimately feel somewhat lifeless. The notable inclusion of The Dark Knight's prologue on this BD starkly contrasts the compressed dynamics of "Batman Begins," emphasizing the missed potential in visual quality due to bitrate limitations.
Despite these drawbacks, the detailed and realistic stunt work, particularly in the Tumbler car chase scenes, shot with real vehicles at high speeds, stands out as a high point. The use of Arkham Asylum and the introduction of signature villains adds narrative depth and sets up future sequels effectively. However, the overall visual presentation falls short of exploiting Blu-ray's full capabilities, leaving it satisfactory but non-exemplary in the realm of HD viewing experiences.
Audio: 68
The audio presentation of "Batman Begins" on Blu-ray is delivered in Dolby TrueHD 5.1 at 16-bit, 48 kHz. Technically, this is akin to CD resolution and lacks the full potential of Blu-ray's capabilities, but it remains devoid of any audible distortion. Dialogues are clear, and orchestral elements, along with effects and explosions, resolve well. Low-Frequency Effects (LFE) are notably deep, significantly enhancing action sequences with commendable depth.
Highlighting dynamic scenes such as Batman's rooftop chase in the Batmobile reveals both the strengths and weaknesses of the audio track. While the sequence involving rapid ceramic tile destruction lacked the distinct and impactful sonics remembered from theater screenings, it wasn't poorly rendered. However, the TrueHD track failed to deliver the punch and extension that high definition formats could achieve if fully utilized, underscoring the missed opportunity by sticking to HD DVD standards.
In summary, while the Dolby TrueHD lossless mix is active and immersive with smooth staging and solid bass, it doesn't capitalize on Blu-ray's potential for higher bitrate content. It remains competent yet polite, falling short of the clarity and realism that could elevate it to the best in Blu-ray audio experience.
Extra: 74
The Blu-ray edition of "Batman Begins" offers a comprehensive array of supplementary material that will engage both casual viewers and die-hard fans. The highlight among these extras is undoubtedly the six-minute prologue of "The Dark Knight," presented in stunning 1080p resolution, showcasing an impeccably shot bank heist scene by The Joker. Other notable features include the "Picture-in-Picture" mode, offering intriguing behind-the-scenes insights despite occasional lapses in commentary, and multiple featurettes such as "Genesis of the Bat" and "Path to Discovery," which delve into the film's conception and production challenges. Christian Bale’s dedication to his role is displayed in "Shaping Mind and Body," while "Gotham City Rises" reveals the meticulous design efforts behind Gotham. Comprehensive attention to detail extends to the costume and vehicular design in "Cape and Cowl" and "Batman: The Tumbler."
Extras included in this disc:
- Prologue: High-definition scene from "The Dark Knight."
- Picture-in-Picture: Interviews, behind-the-scenes sequences, and commentary.
- Genesis of the Bat: Interviews explaining the movie's conception.
- Batman: The Journey Begins: Focus on casting key actors.
- Path to Discovery: Challenges of filming in Iceland.
- Saving Gotham City: Insight into action sequences minimizing CGI.
- Shaping Mind and Body: Christian Bale’s preparation for the role.
- Gotham City Rises: Design and construction of Gotham City.
- Cape and Cowl: Focus on the Batsuit's development.
- Batman: The Tumbler: Evolution of the Batmobile concept.
Movie: 70
"Batman Begins," directed by Christopher Nolan and starring Christian Bale, reinvigorates Batman's cinematic legacy through an enthralling origin story rooted deeply in the character’s darker motifs. The narrative follows Bruce Wayne’s evolution from a traumatized child to a determined vigilante. A striking opening sequence plunges viewers into the eerie visualization of young Bruce falling into a well swarmed by bats, immediately setting the tone. This backdrop of fear and loss becomes the catalyst for Bruce’s eventual embrace of Batman. Through meticulously crafted scenes, Nolan paints a picture of a Gotham City entrenched in economic depression and moral decay, necessitating a hero not just driven by justice, but by a more profound personal vendetta. The movie capitalizes on top-tier performances, notably from Michael Caine (Alfred), Liam Neeson (Henri Ducard/Ra's Al Ghul), and Cillian Murphy (Dr. Jonathan Crane), each adding depth and gravitas to Wayne’s journey.
Nolan’s rendering of Gotham is nothing short of visually compelling, utilizing a palette that juxtaposes the grimy urban decay with the sleek, technological sophistication of Wayne Enterprises. The plot deftly weaves Bruce’s external battles with his internal conflicts, portraying his transformation with both psychological complexity and physical intensity. Supporting characters like Lucius Fox (Morgan Freeman) provide crucial elements that ground Batman in tangible reality, enhancing the narrative's accessibility without sacrificing its darker themes. The interplay of high-stakes confrontation and personal growth is underscored by Hans Zimmer's and James Newton Howard's pulsating score, which augments the film's dramatic impact. "Batman Begins" doesn't merely reboot the franchise; it redefines it, combining compelling storytelling with technical excellence, thereby setting an impressive benchmark for superhero cinema.
Total: 70
The Blu-ray release of "Batman Begins" stands out as a must-have for any serious film enthusiast, combining impressive storytelling with robust technical attributes. Christopher Nolan's deft direction meticulously unravels Bruce Wayne's metamorphosis from a traumatized orphan into Gotham's relentless protector. Christian Bale delivers an outstanding portrayal, capturing the psychological complexity and underlying vulnerabilities of Bruce Wayne. While his initial portrayal of Batman seemed tentatively-paced, this nuance contributes to the character's authenticity and gradual development.
Visually, the Blu-ray of "Batman Begins" offers a respectable 1080p video quality. However, it's worth noting that while the transfer is good, it does not meet the superior standards set by more recent Blu-ray releases. Some compression artifacts and digital noise reduction are present, which may detract slightly from the overall viewing experience. Those who own the HD-DVD version may find minimal justification for an upgrade. Nonetheless, the dark, immersive cinematography combined with the detailed rendering of Gotham City's sets enriches the visual spectacle.
In summary, I can't decide whether the giftset or standard BD release is right for you--it depends on how much you appreciate comic books and memorabilia--but I hope everyone with a Blu-ray player understands that they need this film in their collection. Bale's vulnerabilities enhance the believability of his character, and the film excels due to Nolan's cohesive direction. Despite minor flaws and the residual effects of Warner's format strategy with BD and HD DVD, "Batman Begins" remains a stellar entry in the superhero genre. It is highly recommended for any collection, emphasizing both storytelling prowess and technical merit.
Blu-ray.com review by Greg MaltzRead review here
Video: 70
The most frustrating part of this observation is not just waiting more than a year for no significant bitrate improvement over the HD DVD, but in comparing Batman Begins to a six-minute prologue of The...
Audio: 80
When I saw the film in the theater, the wheels made a distinct sound as the Batmobile drove over each of these tiles, but the detail, impact and dynamic punch of this audio sequence was a bit lost on the...
Extras: 100
The interviews, behind-the-scenes sequences, and commentary are all quite interesting, but I would have much preferred that Warner focused its efforts on delivering the feature film in the best possible...
Movie: 90
Meanwhile, Alfred has declared Bruce dead, and Wayne Enterprises falls into the hands of its unscrupulous CEO, Earle (Rutger Hauer), who is taking the company public in an attempt to break all ties with...
Total: 90
Bale admitted struggling to get Batman's voice and other mannerisms, and this seems apparent, but this just makes the superhero more endearing and believable....
The Digital Bits review by Bill HuntRead review here
Video: 75
This is particularly helped by the Himalayan setting of much of the first half of the film (actually, it’s Iceland, but it passes as Tibet nicely)....
Audio: 85
The problem with that is that the encode doesn’t take full advantage of the added space on the BD-50 disc to maximize the compression, resulting in an image that’s just a little too soft looking and somewhat...
Extras: 90
Movie: 85
In fact, not since billionaire industrialist Thomas Wayne and his wife were murdered years ago, has there really been anyone willing to give back to the city – to stand up for what’s right, and act as...
Total: 84
On the whole, this Blu-ray is well worth an upgrade over the previous DVD release, though if you already own the HD-DVD, there’s little reason to replace it....
Director: Christopher Nolan
Actors: Christian Bale, Michael Caine, Ken Watanabe
PlotHaunted by his parents' brutal murder, Bruce Wayne travels the world seeking the means to fight injustice. His quest leads him to a mysterious group called the League of Shadows, led by the enigmatic Ra's al Ghul. Bruce trains under the tutelage of Ra's and his second-in-command, Ducard, in various physical and mental disciplines. However, Bruce rejects the League's ethos of meting out severe, fatal justice, which causes a rift leading Bruce to sever ties with the group. With his training complete, he returns to Gotham City, determined to clean up the corruption that has strangulated the metropolis.
Stepping into a new persona that preys on the fears of criminals, he begins his quest to restore balance to Gotham. With the assistance of his family's loyal butler, Alfred, and Lucius Fox, a resourceful company employee, he develops the tools necessary to fight the city's crime syndicates. As he battles the organized crime entities, he encounters the city's compromised legal system including the idealistic Assistant District Attorney Rachel Dawes and the honest but beleaguered police officer Jim Gordon. Bruce realizes that the corruption in Gotham runs deeper than he anticipated, and the appearance of a sinister new figure starts to throw the city into turmoil.
Writers: Bob Kane, David S. Goyer, Christopher Nolan
Release Date: 15 Jun 2005
Runtime: 140 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States, United Kingdom
Language: English, Mandarin