Mean Girls Blu-ray Review
Score: 55
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
High-end home cinema setup meets analytical 'Mean Girls' Blu-ray reviews, highlighting quality and wit.
Disc Release Date
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 57
Mean Girls on Blu-ray is vibrant with solid transfers, displaying a filmic quality, well-mixed audio, and colorful, detailed visuals. Occasional digital noise and softness, but overall impressive.
Audio: 56
Mean Girls' Blu-ray release offers above-average video quality with vibrant colors and sharp images, moderate grain for filmic texture, and a solid Dolby TrueHD soundtrack that, while front-heavy and occasionally bland, delivers clear dialogue, good music presence, and surprisingly active surround sound.
Extra: 47
Mean Girls Blu-ray boasts a fun commentary, insightful featurettes on high school dynamics and fashion, outtakes, deleted scenes, and HD trailer, all reflecting the film's blend of humor and social commentary.
Movie: 60
Raised by zoologists, Cady Heron navigates the 'jungle' of high school, challenging cliques and discovering the real mean girls, in a witty teen film reflecting universal teen experiences.
Video: 57
The Blu-ray presentation of "Mean Girls" delivers a commendable video quality that, while not at the pinnacle of catalog releases, offers a significantly bright and engaging viewing experience. With a 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 encode displayed at a 1.78:1 aspect ratio, the film exhibits an array of clean, well-saturated colors that faithfully represent the source material's vibrant aesthetic. From the excessively colorful palette, dominated by primaries and particularly pink, to the warm, buoyant tones throughout, the film's dynamic visual style is wonderfully preserved. Detailing is consistently sharp across high definition, capturing the intricate designs of high-dollar wardrobes, facial textures, and the various settings with adequate clarity. Although some scenes may showcase minor digital noise and occasional softness, these moments do not detract significantly from the overall solid transfer.
Flesh tones range from slightly reddish hues to more natural appearances, depending on the scene, maintaining stability throughout. Black levels and contrast are commendably rich and stable, enhancing the visual pop without leading to overemphasis or bloom out. Despite some visibility of grain, preserving the film's original texture, it contributes to its filmic appeal without undermining the high-definition experience. The presence of moderate grain and rare low-level digital noise on darker backgrounds is noted but remains a minor issue against the encoding's solid performance.
On the audio front, the Blu-ray features a Dolby TrueHD soundtrack that complements the video presentation well. Dialogue is crisp and full-bodied, largely focused on the frontal array but is nicely augmented by musical ambience from the surround channels. The pop-centric soundtrack benefits from a subtly applied low-frequency emphasis, enhancing the film's musical moments without overwhelming them. The blend of music, voices, and environmental sounds is rendered with clarity and satisfactory depth, ensuring an immersive auditory experience. While it might not push the boundaries of what Blu-ray can achieve in terms of audio dynamism, it effectively supports the visual presentation to create a cohesive and enjoyable viewing experience.
Audio: 56
The audio presentation of the "Mean Girls" Blu-ray, featuring a Dolby TrueHD 5.1 lossless soundtrack, performs admirably, displaying a level of sophistication that surpasses expectations for a film of its genre. With an English Dolby TrueHD 5.1 Surround track (48kHz/24-bit), it delivers crisp, full-bodied dialogue predominantly through the front channels, while also engaging the surround channels to create a more immersive experience during key moments, such as the vibrant party sequence. The soundtrack and score benefit from excellent dispersion and fun discrete effects that animate the film's environment, offering an enveloping soundstage that is both unexpected and delightful for a teen comedy.
While the mix might lean towards being front-heavy and arguably generic, it does justice to the film's dialogue-driven nature and its peppering of pop-rock music moments. The music emerges clear and loud, complementing the on-screen action with adequate support from the subwoofer, providing a sense of low frequency emphasis that enriches the pop tracks featured in the movie. This careful blend of voices, music, and sound effects through the front speakers is rendered with remarkable clarity, ensuring that every element remains distinct and engaging.
The technical merits of this soundtrack are further highlighted by its handling of dynamic range and bass levels, contributing punchy and supportive low-end tones that underscore the film's energetic moments without overwhelming its dialogue. Despite occasional hints of digital noise in darker scenes, which are minor at best, the overall encoding appears solid. The audio mix never sounds thin or dynamically starved, indicating a satisfactory reproduction of the movie's sonic elements. It demonstrates that "Mean Girls" not only looks good on Blu-ray but sounds better than necessary, making it a commendable audio presentation for a catalog title.
Extras: 47
The "Mean Girls" Blu-ray extras deliver a comprehensive behind-the-scenes glance, led by the engaging yet occasionally hectic audio commentary from Director Mark Waters, Tina Fey, and Lorne Michaels. Viewers can delve deep into the making and thematic exploration of the film through featurettes like "Only the Strong Survive" and "The Politics of Girl World," which provide insightful commentaries on the adaptation process, casting intricacies, and the social dynamics at play within high school settings. Moreover, "Plastic Fashion" offers a lighter take on the film's costume design, while "Word Vomit" presents a compilation of outtakes, adding a touch of humor. The inclusion of deleted scenes with optional commentary by Waters and Fey gives further depth, showing what could have been. Though all video content is in standard definition, except for the trailer in high definition, the collection encapsulates the essence of the film's production and social commentary.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: A track featuring Director Mark Waters, Tina Fey, and Producer Lorne Michaels sharing insights and anecdotes.
- Only the Strong Survive: A deep dive into the life of teenage girls and character integration within American high schools.
- The Politics of Girl World: Explores the importance of self-image and the issues that affect high school girls.
- Plastic Fashion: Looks at the significance of costuming in the film.
- Word Vomit: A compilation of outtakes offering comedic relief.
- So Fetch - Deleted Scenes: Nine removed scenes with optional commentary.
- Interstitials: Brief promotional pieces for the film.
- Theatrical Trailer: The film’s official trailer in high definition.
Movie: 60
As "Mean Girls" unfurls into the wildlife of American high school politics through the eyes of Cady Heron, played by a pre-controversy Lindsay Lohan, the film captures a rich, comedic landscape that mirrors the harsh yet silly reality of teenage social dynamics. Raised in Africa by her zoologist parents, Cady's transition from the literal jungle to the figurative one of public school introduces her to the Plastics—the apex predators of adolescent cliques. Director Mark Waters orchestrates this transition with a mix of humor and perceptive commentary on the social survival of the fittest, presenting a narrative that is as engaging as it is educative. The intelligent script by Tina Fey, based on Rosalind Wiseman's book "Queen Bees and Wannabes," deftly navigates the intricacies of high school hierarchies and the ensuing emotional tumult, delivering a story that resonates with both teenage and adult audiences.
The film stands out for its witty dialogue and memorable characters, particularly the Plastics, led by Rachel McAdams' Regina George. It successfully juxtaposes Cady's moral quandary—being swallowed by the very clique she aims to dismantle with her allies—against a backdrop of comedic set pieces and sharp one-liners that have cemented the movie's place in popular culture. The ensemble cast, including Tim Meadows and Fey herself, adds depth and hilarity to the high school setting, making "Mean Girls" a standout teen comedy of its time.
Despite its 2004 markers—fashion, slang, and social norms—"Mean Girls" transcends its era through universal themes of identity, belonging, and the painful but necessary growth pangs of adolescence. It captures the essence of high school life's trials and tribulations, resonating with audiences for its authentic portrayal of the sweetness and savagery of growing up. Moreover, its exploration of societal expectations and personal integrity, underscored by Lohan’s and McAdams’ potent performances, ensures that "Mean Girls" remains relevant and relatable, securing its place as a defining teen movie of the early 21st century.
Total: 55
The Paramount Blu-ray release of "Mean Girls" is a commendable amalgamation of high-quality visuals and sound, paired with a dose of nostalgia for longtime fans and a fresh appeal for new audiences. The video presentation shines on various high-end equipment, from the JVC DLA-RS20 1080p High Definition Front Projector to the more conventional Sony Playstation 3 Blu-ray disc Player, ensuring that the film's vibrant high school drama and colorful settings are crisply rendered with no detail overlooked. The audio, while not groundbreaking, delivers with accuracy across an array of setups, leveraging technologies like the Denon AVR 5308CI THX Ultra 2 Preamp/Video Processor and the robust output of B&K Reference 200.7 Series 2 seven Channel amplifier. Accessories like the Furman SPR-20i Stable Power Regulator and Wireworld audio/video cabling further enhance the viewing experience, making this Blu-ray a reliable choice for audiophiles and videophiles alike.
Moreover, this release distinguishes itself with a suite of entertaining supplements that complement the film's sharp, witty script and Lindsay Lohan's standout performance. The package serves as a testament to Tina Fey's clever writing, which remains as relevant and piercing today as it was at the time of its initial release. The film, much like its dark comedic predecessor "Heathers," offers a satirical yet insightful exploration into the dynamics of high school life, albeit with a less subtle approach to its social commentary.
In conclusion, the "Mean Girls" Blu-ray presents an exemplary case of how to balance technical excellence with content richness. It is particularly recommended for those who appreciate meticulous video and audio quality in their home cinema setup. With its engaging extras and stellar main feature presentation, this edition not only stands as a pinnacle of teen comedy but also as a must-have for enthusiasts seeking to elevate their collection with both visual and narrative depth.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 70
Mean Girls is another one of those transfers that looks just fine in high definition, but won't overly impress those that have seen dozens of other Blu-ray titles....
Audio: 70
A party sequence in chapter twelve is about as active and immersive as this one gets, with the soundstage filled nicely with the loud music....
Extras: 50
The Politics of Girl World (480p, 10:33) examines the importance of self-image to high school girls and the problems that plague campuses....
Movie: 70
She quickly comes to realize that life in a typical American high school is a jungle, where survival of the fittest takes on a whole new meaning as she discovers a world of separation and hatred, where...
Total: 70
While Mean Girls sees no gun play and bombs strapped to one's chest, the film does indeed show the very real and very damaging destructive power of all the high school faux-pas it rails against....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
A few scenes suffer a bit from being slightly dark, and there is the occasional soft patch, but overall 'Mean Girls' looks excellent for a recent catalog release....
Audio: 80
This isn't an action movie and there isn't constant atmosphere, but the overall 360-degree effect is in evidence far more than a teen comedy would suggest....
Extras: 40
It's all admittedly amusing (particularly a story on filming a mock "Girls Gone Wild" video and the various 'Saturday Night Live' player cameos), but I would have liked to hear more from Fey in particular,...
Movie: 60
From Damian doing a hilarious gay version of Christina Aguilera's "Beautiful" at the school talent contest to McAdams' pitch-perfect vocal inflections as the school bitch to end all school bitches, 'Mean...
Total: 60
Tina Fey's writing is sharp and witty, and Lindsay Lohan delivers perhaps her finest performance (seriously, I just said that)....
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 80
The blend of music, voices and sound effects through the front channel speakers was rendered with excellent clarity, limited but fair dimensional perspective and average depth....
Audio: 76
The blend of music, voices and sound effects through the front channel speakers was rendered with excellent clarity, limited but fair dimensional perspective and average depth....
Extras: 60
Commentary by Director Mark Waters, Writer/Actor Tina Fey, and Producer Lorne Michaels Featurettes: Only the strong survive - 24 minutes The politics of girl world - 10 minutes Plastic fashion - 10 minutes...
Movie: 60
But the law of the jungle takes on a whole new meaning when the home-schooled 15-year-old enters public high school for the first time and falls prey to the psychological warfare and unwritten social rules...
Total: 69
Marantz DV7001 Universal Disc Player Denon AVR 5308CI THX Ultra 2 Preamp/Video Processor B&K Reference 200.7 Series 2 seven Channel amplifier Philips TSU9400 Pro Series Touch Panel Remote Control Canton...
Director: Mark Waters
Actors: Lindsay Lohan, Jonathan Bennett, Rachel McAdams
PlotCady Heron, a 16-year-old girl who has spent her entire life being homeschooled in Africa, moves to the United States and enrolls in a public high school for the first time. This transition introduces her to the complex social hierarchies and cliques that define high school life. She initially struggles to find her place, befriending social outcasts Janis and Damian, who guide her through the school's social landscape. Together, they concoct a plan to infiltrate the school's most exclusive and ruthless clique, The Plastics, led by the charming yet manipulative Regina George.
As Cady becomes more integrated into the group, her initial intentions begin to fade, and she starts to absorb the group's superficial values and backstabbing behavior. Her newfound popularity strains her relationships with Janis and Damian, and she slowly starts to lose sight of her true self. The dynamics within The Plastics and the broader school community lead to escalating tensions, prompting Cady to reevaluate her priorities and the consequences of her actions.
Writers: Rosalind Wiseman, Tina Fey
Release Date: 30 Apr 2004
Runtime: 97 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States, Canada
Language: English, German, Vietnamese, Swahili