The Naked Spur Blu-ray Review
Warner Archive Collection
Score: 70
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
A top-tier Western with stunning Colorado footage, flawless restoration, and robust audio; a must-own Blu-ray for fans of the genre.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 83
The Naked Spur shines on Blu-ray with Warner Archive's stunning 1080p restoration, boasting rich Technicolor hues, sublime clarity, and enhanced depth that showcase its 1.37:1 cinematography in remarkable detail, transporting viewers into the vibrant landscapes of Colorado with pristine color fidelity and minimal grain.
Audio: 77
"The DTS-HD 2.0 mono track of The Naked Spur delivers a robust audio experience, with crystal clear dialogue and impressive dynamic range. The brassy score, gunfire, and natural effects like river rapids and rockslides are expertly rendered, maintaining the original mix's integrity while enhancing the atmosphere."
Extra: 27
The Blu-ray of 'The Naked Spur' expertly includes remastered extras like Tex Avery's charming 'Little Johnny Jet,' alongside vintage features such as the droll Pete Smith short 'Things We Can Do Without,' capturing the spirit of the original theatrical experience with a 'Night At The Movies' approach.
Movie: 87
The Naked Spur emerges as a seminal Western, brimming with tension and character complexity, highlighted by James Stewart's gripping performance. Captured in stunning Technicolor and revitalized in a 1080p transfer, its engaging narrative and dynamic cinematography make it an enduring masterpiece of moral ambiguity and human conflict.
Video: 83
The Blu-ray release of "The Naked Spur" by Warner Archive showcases a remarkable restoration, capturing the full might of the original three-strip Technicolor presentation. This 1080p transfer offers superior clarity and color fidelity, immersing viewers in the breathtaking landscapes of Colorado and California. Presented in its original 1.37:1 aspect ratio, the film's transfer retains its intricate compositions, even within the constraints of height-impacted settings like cliffside sequences. The color palette's bold primaries and accurately rendered skin tones are a standout feature, with rich black levels maintaining depth without any perceptible crush. Additionally, the diligent manual cleanup ensures a pristine, theatrical presentation devoid of dirt and debris, perfectly preserving the film's natural texture.
Achieving this high level of detail without excessive noise reduction, the Blu-ray operates at a high bit rate on a dual-layered disc. This results in an image quality brimming with clarity and contrast, beautifully accentuating William Mellor’s acclaimed cinematography. Subtle film grain lends authenticity to the visuals, while fine details—such as the textures of rocks, costume weaves, and facial characteristics—are vividly distinct. Despite occasional softness, the visual presentation significantly surpasses any previous home video versions. With vibrant hues like bold reds and lush greens and an impeccable balance of rich blacks and bright whites, Warner Archive delivers another top-tier release, ensuring that "The Naked Spur" is experienced in all its original splendor.
Audio: 77
The DTS-HD 2.0 Master Audio presentation for the Blu Ray of "The Naked Spur" is noteworthy for its remarkable clarity and accurate reproduction of the original one-channel mix. Despite a few high-end strain points during the crescendos of Bronisław Kaper's orchestral score, the audio track excels overall. Dialogue is prioritized with exceptional clarity, ensuring conversations remain intelligible amidst the film’s intricate audio environment. Although some instances of ADR can be detected, they are generally non-intrusive. The mix makes admirable use of environmental sounds, particularly capturing the spatial depth through echoes following gunshots and other high-volume effects, enhancing immersion in the film's rich Western setting.
The track's strength lies in its ability to transport viewers into the rugged Rocky Mountain terrain, dramatized by realistic audio effects such as rockslides and rushing river rapids. The robustness of the soundscape is complemented by excellent fidelity; tonal depth effectively elevates both action scenes and Kaper's invigorating score. Furthermore, the dynamic range is commendably broad for a mono track, handling both subtle and explosive moments without succumbing to distortion. Viewers will note the absence of age-related imperfections such as hiss or pop, which speaks to the quality of this audio restoration.
In conclusion, this DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mono track is a surprising revelation, providing a palpable sense of atmosphere that draws audiences deeper into the film’s narrative. Optional English (SDH) subtitles are provided for the main feature, though regrettably not for additional features, ensuring accessibility while allowing viewers to appreciate every nuance of this evocative audio presentation.
Extras: 27
The Blu-ray release of "The Naked Spur" offers a well-curated selection of extras, which seamlessly complement the main feature. These vintage shorts and trailers are effectively presented in either SD or HD, providing a nostalgic glimpse into the era's cinematic offerings. "Things We Can Do Without" is a 1953 Pete Smith-narrated specialty short, delivering dry humor through its exploration of outdated household gadgets. The delightful "Little Johnny Jet," a 1953 Tex Avery classic, has been fully remastered, affirming its vibrant charm and slick animation. This cartoon previews the anticipated Tex Avery Screwball Classics, Volume 3. Completing the extras is the original theatrical trailer, capturing the dramatic allure of "The Naked Spur." These features not only enhance historical appreciation but also elevate the viewing experience by replicating a mid-twentieth-century theatrical showing.
Extras included in this disc:
- Things We Can Do Without: A comedic 1953 Pete Smith short on impractical gadgets.
- Little Johnny Jet: A 1953 Tex Avery cartoon about an aging B-29 bomber.
- Theatrical Trailer: Original trailer highlighting the film's dramatic themes.
Movie: 87
The Naked Spur (1953), directed by Anthony Mann and featuring the formidable James Stewart, is a masterclass in character-driven Western narratives. Set against the stunning Technicolor backdrop of Colorado's Rocky Mountains, the film follows bounty hunter Howard Kemp (Stewart) in his pursuit of fugitive Ben Vandergroat (Robert Ryan). As the drama unfolds, the dynamic between the five core characters—a group brought together under false pretenses and unsettling tensions—takes center stage. Stewart's role as Kemp is imbued with a mix of desperation and moral ambiguity as he seeks redemption through capturing Vandergroat. Ryan, portraying the cunning outlaw, delivers a performance marked by silent manipulation, sowing discord among his captors. The ensemble cast, including Millard Mitchell and Janet Leigh, perfectly complements the film's nuanced narrative, with each actor contributing to the film’s incredible dramatic tension.
Mann's direction brings a noir sensibility to the Western genre, transcending classic tropes with flawed characters and moral complexities. Cinematographer William Mellor's compositions elegantly capture both the vastness and intimacy of the rugged landscapes, pairing perfectly with Mann's vision. Despite not winning an Oscar for Best Story and Screenwriting, Sam Rolfe and Harold Jack Bloom’s script is rich with psychological depth as characters grapple with greed, loyalty, and trust. The seamless integration of action sequences, such as perilous river crossings and Native American confrontations, contribute to the suspenseful pacing and enrich the film's visual storytelling.
The Blu-ray release of The Naked Spur elevates this iconic Western to a new level of clarity with its superior 1080p transfer from original elements, offering an immersive viewing experience that highlights the film's lush Technicolor palette. This restoration corrects past video releases, ensuring that Anthony Mann's celebrated work retains its artistic significance for modern audiences and continues to serve as a testament to his partnership with Stewart.
Total: 70
Anthony Mann's "The Naked Spur" is a quintessential Western that stands out for its gripping narrative and compelling character development. This film, set against the rugged landscapes of the Colorado mountains, utilizes its picturesque scenery to enhance its authenticity and visual appeal. The cast, including James Stewart, Robert Ryan, and Janet Leigh, delivers standout performances that elevate the film's tension and depth. The powerful original score further accentuates the film's dramatic tones, making it a captivating watch from beginning to end.
The Blu-ray release by Warner Archive exceeds expectations, surpassing previous DVD versions with a newly restored, visually stunning Technicolor transfer and crisp, lossless audio. The presentation on this Blu-ray breathes new life into the film, preserving its vibrant color palette and bringing unparalleled clarity to both image and sound. The addition of period-appropriate short films as special features enriches this release, providing a glimpse into the era's filmmaking landscape.
In conclusion, "The Naked Spur" on Blu-ray is not only a top-tier presentation of a classic Western but also an essential addition for aficionados of the genre. With its high-quality restoration and thoughtful special features, it offers a comprehensive experience that ensures new appreciators and long-time fans alike will find immense value in this release. Highly recommended.
Blu-ray.com review by Randy Miller IIIRead review here
Video: 100
Fans will rejoice upon first sight of this stunning new 1080p transfer, which pushes format limits to the extreme with a gorgeous, purist-friendly appearance that highlights the stunning Colorado and California...
Audio: 90
The outstanding location footage offers plenty of room for subtle echoes that create noticeable depth after gunshots and other high-volume effects, while the occasional rumble of horse hooves -- mostly...
Extras: 30
Little Johnny Jet (7:04) - Appropriately enough, this Tex Avery short -- likewise released the same year as The Naked Spur, so one can assume it was also shown in theatres -- is fully remastered (as seen...
Movie: 90
Robert Ryan stands in great contrast here, playing a quiet and subdued adversary that's always thinking... but when his true colors emerge, The Naked Spur jumps into high gear and stays there through its...
Total: 80
Add in a terrific original score, gorgeous location footage in the Colorado mountains, and terrific dialogue, and you've got a film that still ends up being slightly more than the sum of its well-oiled...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Fine details like the dusty dirt on Stewart’s wool jacket, the contours and textures of rocks, the weaves of costume fabrics, faint smoke, and the fluttering foliage in the breeze are all wonderfully distinct,...
Audio: 80
The rushing river rapids, crackling thunder, rain, and - of course - gunshots and fisticuffs are crisp, and excellent fidelity and tonal depth heighten the impact of Bronislau Caper's rousing score....
Extras: 20
Things We Can Do Without (SD, 9 minutes) - This slapstick 1953 short, part of MGM's long-running Pete Smith Specialty series, examines the frustrations - and perils - associated with both "modernistic"...
Movie: 80
Mann, who cut his teeth in the murky world of film noir (do yourself a huge favor and watch T-Men and Raw Deal, the movies that put Mann on the cinematic map), was one of the first directors to buck the...
Total: 80
James Stewart and director Anthony Mann team up for another exciting western packed with thrills, dimensional characters, and plenty of substantive conflicts....
Home Theater Forum review by Timothy ERead review here
Video: 90
This transfer is a revelation since every earlier rendition on home video has suffered from poor contrasts and color as well as registration errors baked in from the original three-strip technicolor....
Audio: 80
Dialogue is always crisp and clear over music, sound effects, and the occasional sounds of running water....
Extras: 40
I always appreciate whenever Warner Brothers supplements their classic features(this one from MGM) with a “Night At The Movies” approach which includes short films that might have been seen with the feature...
Movie: 100
The dynamic of a charismatic prisoner trying to manipulate his escape has been done before and since, but rarely as well, and the actors’ performances and the screenplay make for an entertaining and fast...
Total: 90
The Naked Spur has never looked better on home video than it does on this Blu-ray disc, and the film shorts from the same era which are included as special features are a nice touch....
Director: Anthony Mann
Actors: James Stewart, Janet Leigh, Robert Ryan
PlotIn the aftermath of the Civil War, a bounty hunter named Howard Kemp journeys through the rugged Colorado Rockies on a relentless pursuit. His quarry is Ben Vandergroat, a wily outlaw wanted for murder. The reward for Ben’s capture is high, enticing Kemp to track him down with unyielding determination. Along the way, Kemp encounters an old prospector, Jesse Tate, and a dishonorably discharged Union soldier, Roy Anderson. Both men quickly realize Kemp's intentions and persuade him to join forces with them to track down Ben. Each man, driven by his own motivations, forms an uneasy partnership in the pursuit of capturing the elusive fugitive.
Their journey leads the trio into increasingly hostile and challenging terrain, where their fragile alliance is continually tested by mutual distrust and conflicting ideals. As they close in on Ben, they discover he is accompanied by a young woman named Lina Patch, complicating their capture plans. Deep into the mountains, tensions run high as unexpected challenges and changing loyalties threaten their mission. With greed and desperation clouding judgment, each character's true nature emerges under mounting pressure. The harsh wilderness and moral dilemmas weave a narrative of survival and betrayal, where the lines between justice and vengeance blur as the characters must confront their pasts while striving to make it out alive.
Writers: Sam Rolfe, Harold Jack Bloom
Release Date: 01 Feb 1953
Runtime: 91 min
Rating: Approved
Country: United States
Language: English