Heart of a Dog Blu-ray Review
Score: 69
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Laurie Anderson's 'Heart of a Dog' merges intellectual rumination with artistic brilliance, featuring excellent video/audio from Criterion—highly recommended.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 73
The Criterion Collection's Blu-ray of 'Heart of a Dog' presents a 1080p transfer in 1.78:1 aspect ratio, utilizing footage from various consumer-grade cameras. With purposeful visual tweaks by Laurie Anderson, the transfer preserves both the fine details and intentional imperfections, providing an eclectic and artistically faithful viewing experience.
Audio: 68
Heart of a Dog's audio presentation includes a DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track offering original HBO content with music and narration, and a lossy Dolby Digital 5.1 option without music. The mix, mastered using ProTools HD, highlights Anderson's clear narration front and center while subtly utilizing ambient effects, despite some variances from archival footage.
Extra: 61
Heart of a Dog Blu-Ray extras offer a compelling, in-depth conversation with Laurie Anderson and co-producer Jake Perlin, alongside whimsical deleted scenes, a unique 'Concert for Dogs,' and artistic inclusions like an illustrated booklet and semi-transparent parchment pages that enrich the viewing experience.
Movie: 76
Laurie Anderson's 'Heart of a Dog' is a poignant exploration of love and loss, blending surreal visuals, animation, and personal narratives within a stream of consciousness format, all underscored by the presence of her beloved rat terrier, Lolabelle. The Criterion Blu-ray offers a rich presentation with insightful extras.
Video: 73
The Criterion Collection's Blu-ray presentation of "Heart of a Dog" features a 1080p transfer in its original 1.78:1 aspect ratio, sourced from an eclectic mix of cameras including the Canon 5D Mark II, iPhone, GoPro HERO3 Silver Edition, and Parrot AR Drone 2.0. With a fully digital workflow and final color correction utilizing DaVinci Resolve 11, the transfer brings forth the film's distinct visual style with precision. This detailed and heterogeneous transfer underscores Laurie Anderson's artistic vision by accurately preserving the varied aesthetic choices, including grainy textures, animated sequences, and purposefully distorted imagery.
Despite a dense and intentionally diverse visual texture, the transfer manages to maintain a high level of detail where intended. Close-ups of animals showcase intricate details such as fur and blemishes, while some scenes exhibit deep color accuracy, especially in well-maintained grayscale presentations. However, not all segments maintain uniform sharpness—intentionally stylized footage often appears blurred or interlaced, introducing combing artifacts or slight upscaling issues. These visual decisions enhance the film’s emotive and experiential impact, creatively utilizing imperfections to convey its narrative.
Criterion's effort in presenting "Heart of a Dog" stays true to Anderson's artistry. The transfer leverages modern digital restoration techniques, ensuring both the flaws and flourishes of the source material are presented authentically. This balanced approach means that while viewers might encounter occasional blanched colors or stylistically altered aspect ratios, the integrity of Anderson's unique audiovisual tapestry remains intact, making this Blu-ray release a faithfully evocative representation of her work.
Audio: 68
"Heart of a Dog" features a DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 soundtrack, faithfully preserving the original HBO version with music and narration. An additional track in lossy Dolby Digital 5.1 presents the film without music, keeping other elements intact. The sound mix with music provides regular engagement of surround channels, though Laurie Anderson's voice remains predominantly anchored in the front and center, ensuring clarity and presence. Archival video segments introduce some minor variances in audio quality, yet fidelity remains robust with no evident damage or distortion.
Mastered from the original digital audio master using ProTools HD, this release's DTS-HD MA 5.1 mix reflects a meticulous audio presentation. Due to the varying sources used, including consumer-grade cameras and microphones, the mix intentionally integrates pops, cracks, and hiss to render a raw, authentic soundscape. Anderson's narration is consistently full-bodied and perfectly situated in the front speakers, ensuring her voice remains the focal point amidst ambient environmental effects. While not a fully immersive track with dynamic explosions or gunfire, Criterion’s careful production honors all of Anderson's artistic choices, making the audio landscape as compelling as it is unique.
Extras: 61
The extras included in the Blu-ray release of "Heart of a Dog" provide a rich, multifaceted exploration of Laurie Anderson's work and life. Particularly engaging is the 41-minute conversation between Anderson and co-producer Jake Perlin, which delves into her personal and professional journey. The deleted scenes, totaling three minutes, though brief, provide additional context to the main feature. Notably, the "Concert for Dogs" offers a unique auditory experience aimed at both human and canine audiences, reflecting Anderson's innovative spirit. Also included is a whimsical video of Lolabelle’s piano performance, further showcasing Anderson's creative breadth. The package is rounded off with a trailer for the film and a meticulously crafted booklet containing technical details and an essay by Glenn Kenny, supplemented by a fold-out program and a pictorial pamphlet.
Extras included in this disc:
- Retelling: A conversation between Laurie Anderson and Jake Perlin.
- Deleted Scenes: Two brief scenes excised from the final cut.
- Concert for Dogs: Footage of a concert performed in 2010.
- Lolabelle's Christmas Card: A whimsical piano performance video.
- Trailer: The film's official trailer.
- Criterion Booklet: A fully illustrated booklet and artwork pamphlet.
Movie: 76
Laurie Anderson's "Heart of a Dog" is an evocative blend of poetic introspection and striking visuals, reflecting her unique artistic style. Renowned for her ability to meld various art forms, Anderson crafts a stream-of-consciousness narrative that explores profound themes, underscored by her relationship with her cherished rat terrier, Lolabelle. Through animation, text overlays, and home video footage, Anderson ambitiously weaves in topics such as religion, reincarnation, government surveillance, and the harrowing aftermath of the 9/11 attacks. Lolabelle appears periodically, grounding the film in personal yet universally resonant reflections on love and loss.
What sets "Heart of a Dog" apart is its unstructured approach, eschewing traditional narrative frameworks for a more associative, almost dissociative flow. This method mirrors Lolabelle's whimsical nature and offers a genuine peek into Anderson's psyche. The film deftly transitions between memory and philosophy, heavily influenced by Tibetan spiritual texts, making poignant observations without lingering too long on any single subject. Anderson's narration guides viewers through these thematic explorations with a light touch, balancing the somber with the absurd and avoiding any implied pretentiousness.
Anderson's film demands an open-minded viewer ready to immerse in its eclectic array of ideas and visuals. While its subject matter may not appeal universally, "Heart of a Dog" is undeniably a labor of love, deeply personal yet widely relatable. For aficionados of Anderson's multidimensional artistry, the film offers a rich and satisfying experience, inviting audiences to ponder life's ephemeral nature and the enduring bonds we form with our beloved companions.
Total: 69
Laurie Anderson's "Heart of a Dog" is an evocative and deeply personal exploration of grief, memory, and love through the lens of her relationship with her dog, Lolabelle. Anderson employs her multifaceted artistic talents to create a film that defies traditional categorization, blending elements of documentary, memoir, and experimental cinema. The resulting work is a poignant rumination on life and death, enhanced by Anderson's signature intellectualism and mesmerizing narration.
Criterion Collection’s Blu-ray release of "Heart of a Dog" is exceptional, with immaculate visual and audio presentations that capture the film's intricate details and ethereal soundscapes. The supplements included in the release further enrich the viewing experience, offering insightful contextualization and expanding on the themes presented in the film. These features make the release particularly rewarding for longtime fans of Anderson's work and those with an appreciation for innovative storytelling.
Some Anderson fans may be aware of a 1993 documentary called "The Sensual Nature of Sound," which explored the lives and works of four New York-based female composers, including Anderson and Meredith Monk. Like Monk, Anderson stretches preconceived notions of media forms, and "Heart of a Dog" is a sweet yet melancholic meditation that may not conform to traditional definitions but offers profound intellectual substance. While this film isn't for everyone, those inclined towards its unique blend of freewheeling visuals and philosophical musings will find it deeply resonant. Criterion has provided a worthy release with excellent technical merits and compelling extras. Highly recommended.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 90
Though the presentation here is progressive, it's obvious that some of the footage was culled from an interlaced source and can have "baked in" combing artifacts, and some other footage looks upscaled,...
Audio: 80
That "perhaps unfortunately" hedges a bit because the track is rather unusual, whether it has music or not, in that aside from Anderson's near ubiquitous voice and some ambient environmental effects (which...
Extras: 50
Retelling (1080p; 41:10) is an interesting 2016 conversation between Laurie Anderson and co-producer Jake Perlin, which offers quite a bit of broader biographical and work data about Anderson....
Movie: 80
What has made Anderson such an enduring presence, though, is not just her often bracingly acute way of looking at things, but the fact that she doesn't seem to be taking herself all that seriously, at...
Total: 80
Like Monk, Anderson loves to stretch our preconceived notions of what a "movie", "video" or even a "concert performance" might mean, and Heart of a Dog is a kind of sweet but at times melancholic rumination...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Not to mention, Anderson uses a some filters and slight visual effects to hinder the detail and look of the film, meaning some segments are intentionally blurry, full of scratches and debris, and out of...
Audio: 80
Much like the video presentation above, this audio track is all over the place from the various amount of different consumer grade cameras and microphones....
Extras: 80
Criterion Booklet - There is a fully illustrated booklet that delivers information on the film, technical aspects, as well as an essay by Glenn Kenny....
Movie: 80
Anderson has poured her heart and soul out here in the only way she knows how, which is through the use of various forms art, and you can see, especially by the end of the film that Lolabelle has helped...
Total: 80
Anderson, being the brilliant artist she is in many mediums, utilizes all of her talents in this film to tell us what she feels about important subjects, as well as how much she loved her dog Lolabelle....
Director: Laurie Anderson
Actors: Laurie Anderson, Archie, Jason Berg
PlotThe film begins as Laurie recounts her experiences with her beloved rat terrier, Lolabelle. Through vignettes blending animation, home movies, and art, she delves into the themes of love, loss, and language. The narrative weaves between events in Lolabelle's life and broader cultural musings, reflecting on the post-9/11 world and the concept of surveillance. Meditative passages detail Lolabelle's surprising foray into painting and music after going blind, emphasizing the dog's resilience and adaptability. The relationship between Laurie and Lolabelle offers a poignant exploration of the bond between humans and their pets.
Intertwined with these personal stories are philosophical reflections influenced by Buddhist teachings and Laurie's mother’s death. As Laurie navigates grief, themes of memory and the afterlife surface, examined through a surreal and often poetic lens. The film shifts between dreamy, contemplative segments and more grounded, yet still evocative scenes ringing with nostalgia and introspection. The aesthetic blends multi-layered soundscapes with striking visuals, creating an atmospheric meditation on how we handle impermanence, mortality, and the lingering impact of our loved ones' lives—both human and animal.
Writers: Laurie Anderson
Release Date: 01 Mar 2016
Runtime: 75 min
Rating: Not Rated
Country: United States, France
Language: English