Hostiles 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Review
Score: 79
from 5 reviewers
Review Date:
Hostiles: A flawed, emotional western with stunning 4K visuals but a muted palette, worth experiencing for its depth and technical merits.
Disc Release Date
True 4K
HDR10
DTS-HD MA
Video: 79
Hostiles' 4K UHD release by Lionsgate dazzles with detailed, warm visuals & nuanced colors despite minor grain issues & a darker palette, preserving its cinematic essence.
Audio: 87
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track excels in clarity, dynamics, and immersive soundscapes, with lifelike effects and a music score that enhances the film's emotional and tense moments.
Extra: 66
Lionsgate's Ultra HD Blu-ray includes 'A Journey of the Soul: The Making of Hostiles,' a candid, comprehensive documentary with crew insights and behind-scenes, highlighting director Cooper's vision.
Movie: 74
Scott Cooper's 'Hostiles' explores the brutal realities of war through a nuanced western, led by Christian Bale, but suffers from pacing and narrative issues.
Video: 79
The 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "Hostiles" emerges as a notably exceptional presentation, particularly when viewed on state-of-the-art home cinema equipment. Lionsgate Films has gratified audiences by providing a disc encoded with 10-bit video depth, utilizing the HEVC (H.265) codec, and supporting both HDR and Dolby Vision, thereby ensuring that the wide color gamut and high dynamic range significantly elevate the viewing experience. Whether it's the nuanced portrayal of the barren yet beautiful Western landscapes or the intricate details in the costumes and facial textures, the image quality is largely impressive. However, it's pertinent to acknowledge the slight inconsistencies observed in grain levels, which occasionally detract from the overall image fidelity, presenting a minor blemish on an otherwise stellar visual feast.
Filmed on 35mm using Arriflex and Panavision cameras with anamorphic lenses and seeing completion as a native 4K Digital Intermediate, "Hostiles" benefits immensely from this treatment. The grain, present yet unobtrusive, contributes to the film’s organic and cinematic texture, with the anamorphic lenses providing a unique sharpness to close-ups while subtly softening the peripheries in specific lighting conditions. This nuanced visual approach aids in crafting scenes of compelling dimensionality and emotional depth. Nevertheless, viewers might encounter instances where the film appears overly dark, particularly in scenes reliant on natural light, leading to occasional loss of detail. This issue, although minor, hints at the delicate balance required in mastering for home viewing while striving to preserve the director's original vision.
The utilization of HDR enhances both the darkest shadows and brightest highlights without sacrificing detail, thereby offering a visual experience that is not only vibrant but also deeply immersive. The HDR grading amplifies the warmth of the film’s color palette, from the rich earth tones of the desert landscapes to the intricate patterns on characters’ attire, making every frame a testament to the meticulous attention to detail employed in the film's production. Despite some challenges with grain management and a darker presentation compared to its Blu-ray counterpart, the 4K UHD version of "Hostiles" stands out for its refined texturing, color accuracy, and overall cinematic character, undoubtedly elevating it to a superior viewing experience that is both authentic and visually striking.
Audio: 87
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track accompanying the 4K UHD Blu-ray of "Hostiles" excels in delivering a clear, dynamic range that superbly complements the film's intense narrative and expansive landscapes. Despite some audiophiles' hopes for an upgrade to Dolby Atmos or DTS:X, this audio track provides an excellent immersive experience. The soundstage is wide and spacious, ensuring dialogue remains crisp and intelligible throughout. The score is meticulously crafted, elevating the film's emotional weight and intensifying its combat scenes without overshadowing the subtler sounds that build its atmospheric backdrop.
Details in the audio presentation are strikingly lifelike, from the echo of gunshots across open landscapes to the natural ambiance of the environment—rustling leaves, bustling towns, and the soft patter of rain. The mix balances dialogue, effects, and Max Richter’s emotive score with a clarity and depth that draws the listener into the heart of the film's rugged setting. The surround channels are employed to subtle yet effective use, with smooth panning and atmospheric sounds creating a convincing audio environment around the viewer. Low-frequency effects add body and impact to the audio, making every gunshot and environmental noise palpably felt.
Although primarily a dialogue-driven film, "Hostiles" features an audio track that manages both to foreground its spoken word and deliver a rich, enveloping sound field that enhances its storytelling. The meticulous attention to detail ensures everything from the most delicate ambient sounds to the robust action sequences is rendered with exceptional clarity. Only occasionally does the mix stumble with softer-spoken dialogue, but this minor flaw hardly detracts from an otherwise beautifully modulated and immersive auditory experience. Optional English SDH and Spanish subtitles offer additional accessibility, ensuring a broad audience can appreciate the careful sound design and narrative nuance of this remarkable film.
Extras: 66
Lionsgate's 4K UHD Blu-ray of "Hostiles" enriches the viewing experience with its singular, yet substantial extra feature: "A Journey of the Soul: The Making of Hostiles". This feature-length documentary is meticulously divided into three insightful parts – Provenance, Removing the Binds, and Don’t Look Back, offering an in-depth look at the movie’s creation from various vantage points. Directly transferred onto the UHD Blu-ray, this documentary stands out by moving beyond mere promotional content, delving into Scott Cooper’s passion and vision for the film, underscored by contributions from both high-profile names like Christian Bale and Rosamund Pike, and those less in the spotlight. Highlighting discussions around avoiding Western clichés, focusing on character depth, and Cooper’s unique approach to storytelling, this addition becomes essential viewing for fans. Also included are a 1080p HD Blu-ray of the film and a digital copy code, ensuring fans have multiple viewing options.
Extras included in this disc:
- A Journey of the Soul: The Making of Hostiles: An in-depth, three-part documentary featuring insight from writer-director Scott Cooper and key cast members, behind-the-scenes footage, and exploration of themes and filmmaking process.
Movie: 74
Scott Cooper’s "Hostiles," a film reuniting him with Christian Bale, presents a poignant albeit sometimes disjointed reflection on the darkness of war and the quest for redemption amidst America's rugged terrain. The movie, set against the backdrop of 1892's dangerous journey from New Mexico to Montana, examines the psychological scars carried by its characters, particularly Captain Joseph Blocker (Bale) and Cheyenne war chief Yellow Hawk (Wes Studi). Through their perilous trip, accompanied by Rosamund Pike’s grief-stricken widow, they encounter numerous harrowing challenges that underscore the fragile boundary between adversaries and allies. Cooper's narrative embarks on a Malickian slow burn peppered with moments of shock violence, reminiscent but not quite matching the emotive power or character complexity seen in works by S. Craig Zahler or Terrence Malick.
"Hostiles" is visually stunning, making it particularly appealing for 4K UHD viewers who can appreciate its breathtaking scenery in high definition. The film, however, struggles at times to balance its ambitious thematic aspirations with the pacing and development of a traditional Western. It explores potent themes - from racial tensions to the psychological toll of violence - yet occasionally loses its narrative drive in contemplative introspection, risking disengagement despite its stunning cinematography and committed performances. Bale delivers a studied portrayal of a man burdened by his past, and alongside an ensemble cast, navigates a path toward tentative reconciliation and understanding, albeit through a journey marked as much by internal turmoil as external threats.
Despite these challenges, "Hostiles" stands out for its commitment to capturing the essence of its setting and era, along with its unflinching examination of humanity’s capacity for both violence and compassion. The story’s progression from entrenched animosity to grudging respect mirrors broader questions about identity, belonging, and healing, offering viewers a meditative take on the Western genre. While it might grapple with pacing issues and occasionally meander in its philosophical ambitions, "Hostiles" remains a visually arresting and thoughtfully crafted piece that beckons viewers into its stark, unforgiving world with the promise of nuanced storytelling and complex characters.
Total: 79
Hostiles," a film that treads through the emotionally charged and visually reserved terrain of the Old West, has been given a treatment on 4K UHD Blu-ray that is as meticulous as it is technically proficient. This release from Lionsgate presents the film in its best light, with a native 4K video transfer that, while not vibrant or eye-popping due to its intentionally muted color palette and dimly lit environments, still exhibits a high level of detail and depth. The movie's atmospheric audio is another high point, carrying over the superb quality from the 1080p Blu-ray release and providing an enveloping experience that complements the visual presentation perfectly. Notably, the package includes a feature-length Making-of Documentary on the Ultra HD disc itself, offering significant value to enthusiasts wary of regional lock limitations.
While "Hostiles" navigates a familiar narrative within the Western genre, it distinguishes itself through the complex emotions and moral convolutions of its characters more than its plot. The film delivers a raw examination of racial tensions—a theme that resonates with contemporary societal issues—wrapped in a narrative that some may find slow or self-important. Nonetheless, its technical presentation on 4K UHD blurs these narrative criticisms with its solid encoding, respectable blacks, good shadow detail, and sufficient resolution that respects the filmmaker's creative decisions. This release supports the film’s moody aesthetic and storytelling with a high-quality home viewing experience.
In conclusion, despite some narrative imperfections and a visual presentation that may not meet all viewers' expectations for vividness and sharpness, "Hostiles" on 4K UHD Blu-ray represents a significant achievement in home media releases. The careful balance of superior audio quality, thorough extras such as the comprehensive documentary, and a video transfer that stays true to the filmmakers' vision makes this version highly recommended for those seeking a deeply engaging film experience. This release underscores the potential of 4K UHD to enhance storytelling through meticulous technical craftsmanship, offering a compelling reason to consider importing for aficionados outside the U.S.
avforums review by Casimir HarlowRead review here
Video: 90
It's something of a relief to find this elegantly shot Western delivered in full fat 4K. Shot on good old 35mm, the movie benefits from a 4K pipeline, with little if anything in the way of VFX and a full...
Audio: 100
Dialogue remains firmly prioritised across the frontal array, given prioritisation where required, peaked by Comanche war cries during attack, whilst the effects lap up the thunderous gunshots that echo...
Extras: 70
Lionsgate thankfully port over the single solid, feature length Making-of Documentary extra onto the Ultra HD Blu-ray itself....
Movie: 70
It is still an impressive study of 19th Century PTSD, and Bale reminds us that he is a force to be reckoned with, leaving Hostiles ripe with great moments - touching scenes and bouts of unforgiving violence...
Total: 80
Lionsgate's US Ultra HD Blu-ray release of Hostiles affords the moody Western excellent native 4K video and superbly atmospheric audio as well as a hefty, feature-length Making-of Documentary which has...
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 90
Grain still looks slightly artificial to me throughout this presentation, especially against brighter backgrounds (watch, for example, toward the top of the frame in the opening sequence when blue skies...
Audio: 100
Some audiophiles may wish that Lionsgate had upgraded the audio to either Dolby Atmos or DTS:X, but the "standard" surround track does offer excellent immersion and fidelity, as I discuss in the linked...
Extras: 100
Lionsgate has ported over the sole (if lengthy) supplement from the 1080p Blu-ray, detailed in our Hostiles Blu-ray review....
Movie: 80
Hostiles reunites star Christian Bale with writer and director Scott Cooper in a tale of violence and salvation, and offers some of the most jaw dropping scenery of any relatively recent western, something...
Total: 30
Hostiles arguably makes a couple of missteps in its journey toward grace, as I discuss in the above linked review, but that really doesn't materially detract from an incredibly impressive effort that touches...
The Digital Bits review by Bill HuntRead review here
Video: 95
Grain is light and organic, and the anamorphic lenses give a crispness to close-ups while pulling the edges of the frame just slightly out of focus depending on the light....
Audio: 95
The surround panning is smooth and natural, with lovely atmospherics, and the LFE packs a punch with every gunshot....
Extras: 75
The documentary gives many of its cast and crew members a voice, not just the stars but the background players as well....
Movie: 85
Christian Bale plays Captain Joseph Blocker, a war-weary U.S. Cavalry officer assigned to escort a dying Cheyenne chief (Wes Studi) and his family back to their ancestral home in Montana in 1892 as a gesture...
Total: 88
This is a western with a somewhat familiar story, but its characters – and particularly their complicated and strongly conflicted emotions – drive the film forward more so than the plot would have you...
High-Def Digest review by David KraussRead review here
Video: 80
Natural light is often employed during nocturnal scenes and in dingy interiors, which tends to obscure fine details and produce numerous instances of crush....
Audio: 90
From crackling flames, babbling brooks, jangling chains, and footsteps crunching in the sand to chirping crickets, gentle breezes, piecing gunfire, and horse hooves galloping across the wild terrain, the...
Extras: 30
Cooper stresses he wanted to make Hostiles on his own terms, notes he wrote the script expressly for Bale, and points out the film is a western ”only in era and locale.”...
Movie: 60
The timeless message certainly bears repeating in our current climate, which is dominated by arguments over immigration, refugees, and discrimination, yet while Cooper hammers home his points, does he...
Total: 70
Writer-director Scott Cooper’s powerful, yet strangely numbing western adopts a self-important tone as it plods along and promotes its agenda, leaving the joys of the genre behind....
AVSForum review by Ralph PottsRead review here
Video: 80
A film like Hostiles has an aesthetic that features many low-lit environs, natural lighting, and chromatic schemes that won't result in the type of glossy, tack-like sharpness typically associated with...
Audio: 92
Extras: 60
...
Movie: 80
Making the harrowing and perilous journey from Fort Berringer, an isolated Army outpost in New Mexico, to the grasslands of Montana, the former rivals encounter a young widow (Pike), whose family was murdered...
Total: 78
This seems to coincide with the creative decisions of the filmmakers and results in stable imagery that lacks the eye-popping definition that some may expect from a newer film....
Director: Scott Cooper
Actors: Scott Shepherd, Rosamund Pike, Ava Cooper
PlotIn 1892, Captain Joseph J. Blocker, a seasoned and embittered U.S. Army officer, is given one final assignment before his retirement: he must escort the dying Cheyenne war chief, Yellow Hawk, and his family back to their tribal lands in Montana. Yellow Hawk, who is imprisoned in New Mexico for past battles against the U.S. government, has been granted a compassionate release by the President due to his terminal cancer. Reluctantly, Blocker assembles a small contingent of soldiers to accompany him on this perilous journey through hostile territory. The journey is fraught with tension and distrust due to Blocker's deep-seated hatred for Native Americans, a result of years of brutal warfare.
Along the path, the group encounters Rosalie Quaid, a grief-stricken woman who has lost her entire family to a brutal Comanche attack. Despite his prejudices, Blocker is compelled by his own moral code to bring Rosalie under his party's protection. The combined group encounters various external threats that begin to erode their mutual animosities, forcing them to rely on each other for survival. As they travel across the treacherous landscape, dealing with bandits, hostile tribes, and the mercilessness of nature, the group is confronted with the harsh realities and the moral complexities of frontier justice and warfare.
Writers: Scott Cooper, Donald E. Stewart
Release Date: 26 Jan 2018
Runtime: 134 min
Rating: R
Country: United States
Language: English, Cheyenne, French