Romancing the Stone Blu-ray Review
Score: 44
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
High-end home theater setup meets mixed-review 'Romancing the Stone' Blu-ray release.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 55
Romancing the Stone's Blu-ray impresses with vivid, detailed visuals and a clear DTS-HD soundtrack, though it has minor fluctuations in sharpness and black levels.
Audio: 31
Despite crisp visuals and rich colors in 'Romancing the Stone,' its audio disappoints with muffled, cluttered sound lacking bass and immersive atmospherics, failing to elevate the 1984 film's legacy.
Extra: 37
'Romancing the Stone' Blu-ray boasts a modest collection of extras: nostalgic featurettes, eight deleted scenes, and tributes, with a mix of HD and SD quality, reflecting fond recollections and the film's production journey.
Movie: 67
'Romancing the Stone' dazzles with its blend of adventure, romance, and comedy, elevated by the chemistry of Douglas and Turner, alongside DeVito's charm.
Video: 55
The Blu-ray presentation of "Romancing the Stone" offers a remarkable upgrade over previous formats, showcasing the film with an impressive level of clarity and detail that belies its age. The 1080p, 2.35:1-framed transfer brings out the vibrancy and texture of the film's diverse settings, from the sweat-glistened opening in a desert to the lush jungles and rustic mountain villages of Mexico. Throughout, images are largely crisp, with high-definition enhancing the minutiae of the film's world—from the knickknacks in Joan Wilder's apartment to the tassels and grime on a Colombian bus. Although sharpness dips occasionally and black levels are not consistently deep, leading to flat-looking darker scenes, the overall visual fidelity remains commendable. Colors are well saturated, displaying vivid hues and excellent depth without appearing overly dramatic, contributing to a cinematic feel that keeps the film engaging.
Despite its age, "Romancing the Stone" benefits from a transfer that maintains film grain without it becoming intrusive, ensuring a film-like aesthetic that fans will appreciate. Detail varies, with brighter scenes showing more defined textures and soft-focus techniques sometimes reducing image depth. However, these instances are not pervasive enough to detract significantly from the viewing experience. The master is generally clean, though occasional speckles and dirt are present.
Technical aspects of this Blu-ray edition have been handled with care, avoiding edge enhancement and compression artifacts that could mar the picture quality. This, combined with a DTS-HD lossless soundtrack that maximizes its source material for clear dialogue and well-integrated sound effects, provides an audio-visual experience that respects the original film while bringing it into the high-definition era. The use of ambient spatial cues in the surround channels enhances the environment without overwhelming, ensuring that "Romancing the Stone" sounds as fine as it looks on Blu-ray.
Audio: 31
The audio presentation of "Romancing the Stone" on Blu-ray, featuring a DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 lossless soundtrack, evokes mixed feelings due to its underwhelming performance. Despite the upgrade from the DVD's Dolby Digital 2.0 Surround, the transition to high-definition audio does not significantly elevate the aural experience. Dialogue is clear, crisper, and well-placed in the mix, ensuring that conversations are intelligible against the backdrop of action. However, the sound design feels constrained by its original elements; the dynamic range appears limited, with high ends not as expansive and low ends lacking depth. This results in a presentation that lacks the vibrancy and immediacy one might expect from a film with such adventurous locations and scenarios.
The sound effects and musical score do not benefit much from the upgrade, with the iconic 1980s techno-pop feeling somewhat muted and lacking the authoritative punch and clarity found in more contemporary recordings. Gunshots and action sequences exhibit volume but suffer from a lack of definition, causing these moments to feel less impactful than they could have been. Ambient sounds and atmospherics, crucial for immersing the viewer in the film’s diverse settings—from New York’s bustling streets to the dense jungles of Colombia—remain predominantly front-heavy, with surround channels failing to deliver a convincing sense of space or environment.
The use of surround sound channels is notably disappointing; rather than enhancing the experience with nuanced discrete effects or enveloping ambiance, they contribute little to the overall soundscape. Even in scenes that should thrive on atmospheric immersion, such as intense rainstorms or chaotic action sequences, there is a notable absence of spatial definition, leaving these potentially captivating moments feeling cluttered and overwhelming. The audio experience, while devoid of egregious flaws or artifacts, ultimately does not live up to the expectations set by the visual upgrade, leaving much to be desired in terms of immersion and engagement.
Extras: 37
The Blu-ray release of "Romancing the Stone" presents fans with a modest assortment of extras that, while echoing the offerings of its 2006 special edition DVD, brings a touch of nostalgia and added depth to the film's legacy. The eight high-definition deleted scenes expand on the jungle escapades and add intriguing elements, including an alligator encounter. "Rekindling the Romance: A Look Back" and the additional featurettes, despite their standard definition and brief runtime, provide insightful retrospectives from key cast members and a poignant homage to screenwriter Diane Thomas. However, the absence of director Robert Zemeckis in the extras is noticeably felt. This collection might not break new ground but serves as a fitting tribute to the film's enduring charm and the remarkable synergy among Michael Douglas, Kathleen Turner, and Danny DeVito.
Extras included in this disc:
- HD 8 Deleted scenes: Expanded jungle scenes and an alligator encounter.
- Rekindling the Romance: A look back featurette: Cast and crew reminisce about the film’s production.
- A hidden treasure: The screenwriter featurette: Tribute to Diane Thomas.
- Douglas, Turner, DeVito: Favorite scenes featurette: Lead actors discuss memorable scenes.
- Michael Douglas remembers featurette: Michael Douglas shares memories of the film.
Movie: 67
'Reromancing the Stone' on Blu-ray invites audiences to rekindle their affection for one of the 1980s' most delightful adventure-comedy films. Amid the burgeoning era of home theater and premium cable, this film emerged as a staple, engraving its mark on the hearts of those who cherished the blend of humor, romance, and thrills that defined the decade's cinematic landscape. An adroit convergence of action, comedy, drama, and romance propels 'Romancing the Stone' beyond its contemporaries, establishing a unique identity despite drawing inspiration from the 'Indiana Jones' series. The essence of its success lies in the seamless melding of diverse genres, delivering an experience that oscillates between exhilaration and heartfelt moments, buoyed by a script that navigates through perilous jungles and emotional landscapes with equal finesse.
Central to the film's enduring charm are Kathleen Turner and Michael Douglas, whose on-screen chemistry transcends traditional movie romances. Their portrayal of Joan Wilder and Jack T. Colton, two diametrically opposed characters thrown together under extraordinary circumstances, evolves from contentious interactions to a deep, genuine connection, radiating warmth and relatability that anchor the film's fantastical elements. Danny DeVito adds a commendable performance, enriching the narrative with humor and vulnerability that complement the leading duo's dynamic journey. These performances, coupled with Robert Zemeckis' direction and Diane Thomas' script, sculpt 'Romancing the Stone' into a cinematic treasure that balances action-packed sequences with the emotional depth of Joan's transformative quest.
Despite its release over three decades ago, 'Romancing the Stone' stands as a testament to storytelling that intertwines adventure with human emotion, humor with danger, and fantasy with reality. The film not only entertains but resonates, capturing the viewer's imagination through vibrant characters, witty dialogue, and a storyline that champions self-discovery and romance. Its position as a genre classic is well-earned, offering a spirited homage to vintage action serials while innovating within its blueprint for success. As it finds new life on Blu-ray, 'Romancing the Stone' remains as captivating and enjoyable as ever, a beacon of 80s cinema that continues to enchant audiences with its adventurous spirit and romantic heart.
Total: 44
The Blu-ray presentation of "Romancing the Stone" provides an interesting mix of highs and lows that both impress and disappoint. The film itself, a distinguished work from director Robert Zemeckis starring Michael Douglas and Kathleen Turner, remains a testament to 1980s cinema with its seamless blend of romance, action, and humor. Tested on a state-of-the-art home theater setup, including equipment like the JVC DLA-RS1x 1080p High Definition Front Projector and a myriad of high-end audio components such as Canton Ergo Series speakers and the SV Sound PB-13 Ultra, the Blu-ray transfer exhibits a high-quality video that unequivocally enhances the viewing experience. However, this release is somewhat let down by its audio quality which does not fully meet contemporary expectations, and the bonus material, which is scarce and leaves fans wanting more.
On a technical level, the visual aspects of this Blu-ray release are commendable, offering clear and vibrant imagery that honors the film's original allure. This is especially evident when viewed through equipment capable of showcasing the video transfer's strengths, such as the Panasonic DMP-BD30 Blu-ray disc Player or the Sony Playstation 3. Notwithstanding the visual fidelity, the audio presentation does not parallel this excellence, lacking the robustness expected from a modern Blu-ray release. Furthermore, for a film of its caliber and historical significance in American cinema, the supplementary features offered are underwhelming, lacking depth and failing to add substantial value to the overall package.
In conclusion, while "Romancing the Stone" on Blu-ray shines in its visual transfer, making it a worthwhile acquisition for collectors and fans keen on experiencing the film in high definition, it falls short in delivering a comprehensive auditory experience and offering enriching additional content. The Blu-ray is best recommended for die-hard fans or those previously without a copy in their collection. Despite its shortcomings, the film's enduring charm and the lead actors' palpable chemistry make it a title still worth considering for your home library, albeit with reservations concerning its value proposition at its current retail pricing.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 80
The tassels on the window curtains, the wear and tear on the seats, and even the grime as seen on the exterior of the vehicle all add their own small details to the film that bring it alive and create...
Audio: 40
The sound always comes across as undefined and lacking in clarity, perhaps a limitation of the original elements but is certainly more cluttered and jumbled than one might expect....
Extras: 40
A Hidden Treasure: The Screenwriter (480p, 3:15) is a brief look at the film's screenwriter, Diane Thomas, the novelty and groundbreaking aspects of her script, and her untimely death....
Movie: 80
The script's brilliant integration of styles, smartly-written characters, and classic love story mean nothing without just the right talent lending their skills to the picture, and in that regard, Romancing...
Total: 60
Featuring a fine ensemble cast, including a pair of headliners that share an on-screen chemistry as natural and refined as the best in Hollywood history, and plenty of charm, wit, and good old-fashioned...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
Black levels are strong, though contrast can be inconsistent -- I found the early city scenes a bit too washed out and fuzzy, though the image definitely picks up as the action moves to the jungle....
Audio: 40
Even the biggest action scenes feature only bursts of anemic discrete effects, and very little audible ambiance....
Extras: 20
Most of the material elongates the early jungle scenes between Douglas and Turner, but there are also a couple of fun later sequences (particularly one involving an alligator)....
Movie: 60
All the expected moments are here -- the meet cute between Jack and Joan, the wisecracking sidekick in Ralph, the breathless series of cliff-hanging action moments, and even a treasure map with a big "X"...
Total: 40
'Romancing the Stone' is a sexy and fun adventure yarn, one elevated by strong by direction by Robert Zemeckis and the great chemistry generated by leads Michael Douglas and Kathleen Turner....
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 84
The surround channels were used mainly for ambient spatial cues that provided a better sense of envelopment but not to the level of being engagingly immersive....
Audio: 72
The surround channels were used mainly for ambient spatial cues that provided a better sense of envelopment but not to the level of being engagingly immersive....
Extras: 60
(HD) 8 Deleted scenes Rekindling the Romance: A look back featurette A hidden treasure: The screenwriter featurette Douglas, Turner, DeVito: Favorite scenes featurette Michael Douglas remembers featurette...
Movie: 70
Timid romance/adventure novelist Joan Wilder (Turner) finds herself thrust into real-life adventures in South America as she learns that her sister is being held captive in Colombia by Ralph (DeVito) and...
Total: 72
Marantz DV7001 Universal Disc Player Denon AVR 5308CI THX Ultra 2 Preamp/Video Processor B&K Reference 200.7 Series 2 seven Channel amplifier Canton "Ergo" Series speakers Axiom Audio QS8 Quadpolar speakers...
Director: Robert Zemeckis
Actors: Michael Douglas, Kathleen Turner, Danny DeVito
PlotJoan Wilder, a shy New York City romance novelist, receives a mysterious map in the mail following her brother-in-law's murder. The map is said to lead to a priceless gemstone hidden in Colombia. Shortly after, she learns that her sister Elaine has been kidnapped in Colombia, and the kidnappers demand the map as ransom. Determined to save her sister, Joan heads to Colombia, setting off a chain of events that catapult her from her comfort zone into a treacherous, real-life adventure.
Upon her arrival in Colombia, Joan's journey quickly goes awry when she gets lost in the jungle and is ambushed by bandits. In a twist of fate, she crosses paths with Jack T. Colton, a cynical, rough-around-the-edges bird smuggler who reluctantly agrees to help her navigate the jungle and find the treasure in exchange for financial gain. Together, they embark on a perilous trek through the dense Colombian rainforest, dodging both natural dangers and the relentless pursuit of the kidnappers and local criminals desiring the map for themselves. Their journey becomes a test of survival and wits, forcing Joan to find the courage and resourcefulness she's written about in her novels but never believed she possessed.
Writers: Diane Thomas, Lem Dobbs, Howard Franklin
Release Date: 30 Mar 1984
Runtime: 106 min
Rating: PG
Country: United States, Mexico
Language: English, Spanish, French