Anatomy of a Murder Blu-ray Review

Criterion's Blu-ray presentation of "Anatomy of a Murder" showcases Otto Preminger's classic legal drama in a meticulously restored 1080p transfer. The film is presented in its original 1.85:1 aspect ratio utilizing MPEG-4 AVC encoding, based on a 4K restoration from a new 35mm fine-grain master positive. This restoration effort, supervised by Grover Crisp and color-corrected by David Bernstein, involved cutting-edge technology from Cinetech, Technicolor, and Reliance MediaWorks to optimize image quality and authenticity.

The results of this painstaking restoration are immediately evident. The high-definition transfer delivers spectacular depth and fluidity absent of any stability issues or distracting digital anomalies such as banding, aliasing patterns, or noise. Instead, viewers are treated to a consistently stable contrast with a rich grayscale variance that heightens the film’s immersion. Remarkably resolved light grain ensures a textured, film-like experience without coarse noise or problematic spots. Colors are lush and vibrant where appropriate, enhancing the illusion of sharpness while maintaining the natural aesthetics integral to Sam Leavitt’s black-and-white cinematography.

Image clarity is exceptional, providing vivid detail that enhances the film’s visual storytelling. From the intricate textures of characters’ clothing, like the weave of Biegler's tweed jacket, to the defined faces of courtroom spectators, every element appears crisper and more defined. Black levels are robust without any crushing of detail, and whites are luminous yet controlled to prevent blooming. The lack of digital enhancements such as edge sharpening or DNR underscores Criterion's commitment to preserving the film's original integrity. This dazzling transfer not only satisfies Criterion’s stringent standards but also offers an unparalleled viewing experience for both dedicated cinephiles and general audiences.

The Blu-ray release of "Anatomy of a Murder" features two expertly remastered audio tracks: English LPCM 1.0 and English DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1. The monaural soundtrack was meticulously restored at 24-bit from the original 35mm dialogue, music, and effects magnetic tracks by Chace Audio. The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track was also created at 24-bit from these same originals and the stereo music recordings. Common issues in older films, such as clicks, pops, hiss, and hum, were skillfully removed using Pro Tools HD and AudioCube's integrated workstation, ensuring a pristine auditory experience.

The English LPCM 1.0 track offers a surprisingly potent listening experience. Duke Ellington's renowned jazz score is rendered with exceptional brightness and clarity, injecting life and vibrancy into every scene. Dialogues maintain a crispness and stability that is rare for films of this age, with no background hiss or any of the minute defects typically found in older audio tracks. This track ensures that both dialogue and the iconic score seamlessly complement the visuals without distraction.

On the other hand, the English DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track extends the dynamic range, which is particularly noticeable during scenes where Ellington's score takes center stage. Although most audio remains front-centered, the clarity and fidelity of this multi-channel mix effortlessly envelop the room. Every line of dialogue, from nuanced whispers to heated courtroom exchanges, is delivered with impeccable precision. The surrounding atmospherics—be it courtroom murmurs or roadside hums—are well-integrated, enhancing immersion without overpowering the narrative. For audiophiles and jazz enthusiasts alike, this track offers a superior listening experience, preserving the purity of tone in Ellington's brass sections and avoiding any form of distortion or imperfection.

Criteria has included optional English SDH subtitles, offering an accessible yet high-fidelity auditory accompaniment that satisfies both purists and those seeking an enriched audio experience.

Criterion's comprehensive selection of supplemental materials for the "Anatomy of a Murder" Blu-ray provides a rich, multi-faceted exploration of the film and its cultural context. The curated extras include exclusive interviews with notable figures like Foster Hirsch, who discusses Otto Preminger's rigorous realism and legal battles against censorship, and Gary Giddins, who delves into Duke Ellington’s masterful jazz contributions. The package is bolstered by rare excerpts, newsreel footage, and insightful biographical segments, maintaining a consistent HD quality throughout. Collectively, these features offer extensive insights into the film’s production and legacy, reflecting Criterion's dedication to high-caliber presentation.

Extras included in this disc:

• Trailer: A hilarious original theatrical trailer.
• Foster Hirsch: Writer discusses director Otto Preminger's career.
• Otto Preminger: Excerpts from a 1967 TV show on censorship.
• Duke Ellington: Critic Gary Giddins on the jazz legend’s contribution.
• Saul Bass: Writer Pat Kirkham on Saul Bass's professional relationship with Preminger.
• Newsreel Footage: From the film’s set.
• Photos by Gjon Mili: Behind-the-scenes photographs by Life magazine photographer.
• Anatomy of Anatomy: Documentary extracts about the impact on the local community.
• Booklet: Illustrated booklet including essays by Nick Pinkerton and Ernest Havemann.

Otto Preminger's "Anatomy of a Murder" (1959), featuring a star-studded cast, brings a fascinating courtroom drama to the forefront. The film, based on John D. Voelker’s novel and superbly adapted by Wendell Mayes, depicts the trial of Lieutenant Frederick Manion (Ben Gazzara) who is accused of murdering a bartender who allegedly raped his wife, Laura (Lee Remick). Representing Manion is attorney Paul Biegler (James Stewart), a dedicated yet financially struggling lawyer. His courtroom adversaries include the local attorney Mitch Lodwick (Brooks West) and the formidable Assistant State Attorney General Claude Dancer (George C. Scott), under the watchful eye of Judge Weaver (Joseph N. Welch).

Preminger’s direction ensures that "Anatomy of a Murder" remains a benchmark in the genre by combining a starkly realistic portrayal of legal proceedings with moments of unexpected intensity. The language used within the courtroom, considered explicit in 1959, lends an air of authenticity and caused considerable controversy, contributing to its notoriety. Scenes unfold methodically, providing intricate glimpses of Biegler’s legal strategy and his struggle to navigate the flaws in the justice system. Both acts of the film are meticulously constructed; the first establishes character dynamics, while the second delves into courtroom manipulation with gripping twists.

The performances are exemplary; Stewart notably delivers one of his most natural performances, capturing Biegler’s blend of affability, moral integrity, and courtroom savvy. Remick's portrayal of Laura is both poignant and provocative, while Gazzara and Scott embody their roles with impressive ferocity. The film’s subtlety ensures that revelations emerge organically, avoiding sensationalism while maintaining suspense. "Anatomy of a Murder" masterfully blends drama with insightful social commentary, making it a timeless piece that still resonates for its narrative depth and technical execution.

"Anatomy of a Murder" is given a second life with a stunning Blu-ray release that brings Otto Preminger's once controversial courtroom drama into the modern age. The film, meticulously restored and remastered under the supervision of Sony Pictures Entertainment's Grover Crisp, has never looked better. While the provocative nature of its content has lost some of its edge in today's more permissive culture, the film remains an engrossing and thought-provoking examination of a scandalous homicide case. The gritty yet straightforward style of Preminger, supported by genuine performances from a stellar cast including James Stewart, Lee Remick, and George C. Scott, keeps audiences captivated throughout its considerable runtime.

The Blu-ray release not only impresses with its visual fidelity but also with its audio presentation, which faithfully honors Duke Ellington's enthralling jazz score. The transfer is as sharp as the trial scenes themselves, providing a richly detailed viewing experience. Complementing this are an extensive array of high-definition supplements that delve deeper into the film's production and legacy. Highlights include interviews with Preminger biographer Foster Hirsch and Gary Giddins on Ellington's contribution, as well as an incomplete but promising making-of documentary. A 1967 Firing Line episode, newsreel footage, behind-the-scenes photographs, and a booklet featuring essays by Nick Pinkerton and a 1959 Life magazine article about real-life lawyer Joseph Welsh further enhance the package.

In conclusion, director Otto Preminger's "Anatomy of a Murder" has been revitalized by this exceptional Blu-ray release. Its lasting relevance and quality are underscored by a top-tier restoration and a rich collection of supplementary materials. This release comes highly recommended for both dedicated film enthusiasts and those discovering this Hollywood classic for the first time.