The Adventures of Baron Munchausen Blu-ray Review
20th Anniversary Edition
Score: 49
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
'Baron Munchausen' intrigues yet lacks full engagement; a visually pleasing, well-supported disc for fans.
Disc Release Date
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 49
Sony's remastered Blu-ray of 'Baron Munchausen' enhances its visual charm with vibrant colors and detail, while gracefully handling its age and source limitations.
Audio: 44
The Adventures of Baron Munchausen's Dolby TrueHD 5.1 soundtrack shines with clarity and whimsy despite showing its age, offering the best mix yet, though lacking modern soundfield dynamics and depth.
Extra: 56
The 'Baron Munchausen' Blu-ray dazzles with its rich extras, including engaging commentary, a peek into tumultuous production via a documentary, storyboard sequences, and intriguing deleted scenes, despite missing some Criterion features.
Movie: 56
Despite initial skepticism, 'The Adventures of Baron Munchausen' reveals itself as a niche, whimsical fantasy under Gilliam's unique direction, celebrating imagination over reason.
Video: 49
Sony's restoration efforts on "The Adventures of Baron Munchausen" have culminated in a 1080p/AVC-encoded transfer that breathes new life into this visually ambitious film. With its 1.85:1 framing, the transfer highlights the movie's vibrant color palette and intricate details, from the deep reds of the Baron's jacket to the nuanced textures of the practical effects and costumes. The restoration process has admirably preserved the film's original charm and aesthetic, respecting the inherent limitations of the technology available when it was made in 1988. Grain is consistently present, maintaining the cinematic feel, but can become heavier in scenes relying on special effects or at longer distances, revealing the age and original conditions of the print.
Despite being a film that initially struggled at the box office, Sony's meticulous restoration showcases an impressive range in black levels, strong contrast, and revealing shadow details that were once lost in standard definition versions. Details are so sharp that viewers can discern individual wrinkles, stitches, and hairs with unprecedented clarity. However, this increased level of detail also inadvertently highlights some of the movie's previously unseen flaws in set pieces and prosthetics. Moreover, while colors are rendered beautifully, resulting in some scenes looking as if they were filmed in the present day, the video quality does suffer from issues endemic to older sources. These include spiking grain fields, noisy nighttime shots, crushed blacks, and occasional picture instability—factors that occasionally detract from the overall enchanting visuals of this fantastical narrative.
The high-definition transfer of "The Adventures of Baron Munchausen" on Blu-ray represents a significant improvement over previous releases, demonstrating Sony's commitment to preserving the film’s artistic integrity. Fans will appreciate the efforts to maintain the film’s original look and feel while enhancing visual clarity and color vibrancy. However, while the restoration offers a much richer viewing experience, it is not without its imperfections—reflective of both the source material’s age and the technological constraints of its time.
Audio: 44
The audio presentation of "The Adventures of Baron Munchausen" on its Blu-ray edition, featuring a lossless high-definition Dolby TrueHD 5.1 soundtrack, showcases a distinct dichotomy of audio quality that oscillates between enchanting clarity and aged limitations. The score resonates with a magical clarity, enveloping the listener with the orchestra's live presence—particularly effective in scenes bustling with music, where the surround sound actively immerses the viewer within the film's audacious escapades. However, the track's fidelity to its original mix brings with it a certain antiquation; the opening battle scenes and various action sequences, while ambitious in auditory scope, occasionally betray a muffling and lack of the crisp definition expected in modern soundtracks. The dynamic range shows restraint, with low-frequency effects and rear channel utilization offering more in ambiance than the aggressive punch found in contemporary sound designs.
Despite these shortcomings, the TrueHD track on "The Adventures of Baron Munchausen" marks a significant improvement over previous incarnations. Dialogues are meticulously cleaned, ensuring clear and distinct delivery devoid of prior prioritization issues, which marred the intelligibility of some lines. The music—a critical component of the film's whimsical and fantastical tone—benefits greatly from this surround treatment, with instruments like trumpets piercing through the mix with newfound clarity, and percussions adding depth to the soundscape. Yet, transitions of sound effects across channels can be jarring, a remnant of the original sound design that occasionally pulls the listener out of immersion.
In sum, while the Blu-ray's audio mix of "The Adventures of Baron Munchausen" might not compete with the robustness and enveloping nature of modern blockbuster soundtracks, it nevertheless offers a significant auditory enhancement from its standard definition releases. Its strength lies in the improved handling of musical elements and dialogues, presenting a balanced soundscape that alternates between vivid orchestral presentations and moments where its temporal limitations become apparent. Fans of the film will appreciate the effort to elevate its auditory experience into the lossless realm, acknowledging both its achievements and inherent aged characteristics.
Extras: 56
The Blu-ray extras for "The Adventures of Baron Munchausen" provide an immersive and detailed exploration into the film's complex production, highlighted by Gilliam's engaging commentary and the comprehensive documentary "The Madness & Misadventures of Munchausen". The commentary, featuring director Terry Gilliam and co-writer/actor Charles McKeown, is candid and filled with insightful discussions on the film's creation, its challenges, and the duo's reflections on their work and the industry. This, along with the documentary's behind-the-scenes look at the tumultuous production process, offers fans a thorough understanding of the film’s journey to the screen. Additionally, unique storyboard sequences and deleted scenes offer further insights into the creative process, making the entire package a treasure trove for cinephiles who appreciate the art of filmmaking. Although some desired extras from previous releases are missing, this compilation remains a must-have, providing an exceptional look at the artistry and adversity faced during the making of this iconic film.
Extras included in this disc:
- Filmmakers' Commentary: An engaging commentary track with director Terry Gilliam and co-writer/actor Charles McKeown providing candid insights.
- The Madness and Misadventures of Munchausen: A comprehensive, three-part documentary exploring the film's production challenges.
- Storyboard Sequences: Expansive sequences featuring introductions and vocal performances by Gilliam and McKeown.
- Deleted Scenes: Four unseen scenes that add depth to the film’s narrative.
- Marvelous World of Munchausen: A trivia track offering behind-the-scenes tidbits and directorial thoughts.
Movie: 56
Terry Gilliam's "The Adventures of Baron Munchausen" emerges as a hallmark of cinematic eccentricity and splendor, embodying the director's known disregard for conventional storytelling and visual effects limitations. Set in a 17th-century town beleaguered by Turkish forces, the narrative unfolds with a young girl named Sally Salt rescuing the legendary Baron Munchausen, played with aplomb by John Neville. What follows is a fantastical journey featuring a cast of characters with extraordinary abilities, from Berthold’s unmatched speed to Adolphus's sharpshooting. Their quest, ranging from celestial bodies to oceanic depths, not only challenges the constraints of reality but also explores themes of faith, imagination, and the human spirit amidst the so-called age of reason. Despite being overlooked upon its release, the film stands as a testament to Gilliam’s relentless creativity and vision, assuredly more appreciated on Blu-ray for its intricate detail and grandiose set pieces.
Gilliam's direction transforms "The Adventures of Baron Munchausen" into a visual spectacle, utilizing practical effects to craft scenes of whimsical fantasy that evoke his Monty Python roots, yet on a scale imaginable only in his boldest dreams. The ensemble’s adventures through Gilliam’s dreamscapes—filled with giant sea monsters, headless demigods, and super-powered heroes—are portrayed with such ingenuity and artistry that they regularly eclipse the need for coherent storytelling or character development. This film is less about narrative precision and more an ode to the boundless creativity of its maker, inviting viewers to revel in its delightful absurdity.
However, "Baron Munchausen" is not without its criticisms—its pacing can be erratic, and its plot occasionally veers into tangential musings that might distance those unfamiliar with Gilliam's style. Yet, these elements underscore the film's inherent challenge to audiences: to surrender to the wonders of imagination over the rigidity of logic. As a part of Gilliam’s unofficial '80s Dreamer Trilogy, "Munchausen" might not reach the narrative heights or thematic coherence of its counterparts, but it brilliantly encapsulates the struggle between fantasy and the age of reason, urging a reevaluation of the boundaries between adult cynicism and the childlike wonder we're too quick to abandon. Through "The Adventures of Baron Munchausen," Gilliam crafts a vivid reminder of cinema's power to enchant and inspire, making it a valuable addition to the Blu-ray collection of anyone yearning to recapture a sense of awe in the face of disbelief.
Total: 49
"The Adventures of Baron Munchausen" Blu-ray presentation is a testament to the film's enduring charm and the dedication to preserving its legacy. The video quality of this release is commendable, particularly for a movie of its vintage. While certain scenes betray the limitations of the era's special effects, they are far from diminishing the overall experience. The audio quality does justice to the original production's ambitious sound design, ensuring that the whimsical and dynamic score complements the visuals effectively. Sony's effort in remastering this title for high definition is noteworthy, offering a significant upgrade over previous DVD versions that suffered from various issues.
Supplemental materials included with the disc provide both aficionados and first-time viewers an enhanced appreciation of the film's intricate details and the creative process behind its creation. This release not merely serves as a worthy addition to a collector's library but also as an inviting entry point for those yet unacquainted with Baron Munchausen's fantastical exploits. The balance between maintaining technical quality and offering enriching extras demonstrates Sony's commitment to delivering a product that respects the film's original vision while embracing the advantages of modern home entertainment technology.
In conclusion, "The Adventures of Baron Munchausen" Blu-ray represents a solid investment for enthusiasts and novices alike. Its presentation strikes a fine balance between preserving the film’s artistic integrity and embracing the enhancements possible through current technology. While not without its minor flaws, these do not detract from what is overall a delightful cinematic experience paired with a comprehensive suite of extras. This release is highly recommended for those looking to delve into Terry Gilliam's unique filmography or anyone seeking to upgrade their collection from the old DVDs to a more refined and visually satisfying Blu-ray version.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 80
While the presentation cannot hide all of the film's warts, it does bring out the best elements of the look of the film, and the end result is a pleasant, satisfactory, though not eye-popping transfer....
Audio: 70
In one early scene, when the Baron sends Berthold to retrieve the wine, quite the ruckus erupts in the listening area, filling the room with loud and powerful sound, somewhat muffled and undefined (like...
Extras: 60
Next is Caught in the Act (480p, 16:50), a shorter piece that examines more of the controversies that surrounded the making of the film, and the exhaustion, doubt, and anger that was widespread before...
Movie: 60
Nevertheless, the tone of the movie allows us to take these oddities at face value, as incredible as they may be, not only because of the fantastical elements of the story, but also because Terry Gilliam...
Total: 70
This disc also features a decent array of supplements that will appeal to fans of the film, while first-time viewers who enjoyed the film may be interested in learning more about it as well....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
Aside from the errant contrast wavering and random picture instability I've grown accustomed to with releases of this nature, the video is hindered by spiking grain fields, noisy nighttime shots, and crushed...
Audio: 60
Explosions and crumbling buildings lack the LFE punch that I've come to expect from a lossless audio mix and, as it stands, low-end support is sorely neutered throughout the film....
Extras: 60
When it's not focused on the war between the studio and Gilliam, this feauturette also details the concepts, designs, and implementation of the intricate effects, as well the on-set atmosphere....
Movie: 60
This film is concerned with flights of the imagination, vivid daydreams, and fantastical adventures that make viewers reflect on a simpler time, a time when they weren't distracted by mortgage payments...
Total: 60
'The Adventures of Baron Munchausen' is a fascinating film that boasts brilliant design and startling imagery -- it may not be as tight as 'Time Bandits' or as ingenious as 'Brazil,' but it's well worth...
Director: Terry Gilliam
Actors: John Neville, Eric Idle, Sarah Polley
PlotIn an 18th-century European city under siege from the Ottoman Empire, a theatrical troupe is performing a play about the legendary Baron Munchausen's fantastical adventures. As the play unfolds, an elderly man claiming to be the real Baron interrupts, insisting that the portrayal is all wrong. To the astonishment of the audience, he begins recounting his incredible life story, offering an entirely different narrative filled with his preposterous exploits. The Baron's tales feature his supernatural companions: a man with superhuman speed, another with incredible strength, a sharpshooter with uncanny accuracy, and one with preternatural lung capacity. During his narrative, the city continues to endure the siege, with danger drawing ever closer. As his story weaves through the past and the present, the Baron's audaciousness captivates the crowd, offering a fleeting glimpse of hope amid despair.
Determined to prove his stories true and to save the beleaguered city, the Baron sets out on a quest to find his old friends. A young girl from the audience named Sally becomes swept up in the Baron's mission, joining him on his journey. Together, they embark through a landscape of myth and wonder, encountering monstrous sea creatures, the Grim Reaper, and the treachery of a sultan. Each encounter presents a test that draws upon the extraordinary abilities of his companions and the Baron's own unyielding spirit. As they venture beyond the confines of reality, their adventures challenge the distinction between myth and truth, blurring the lines of what is genuinely possible.
Writers: Charles McKeown, Terry Gilliam, Gottfried August Bürger
Release Date: 10 Mar 1989
Runtime: 126 min
Rating: PG
Country: United Kingdom, West Germany, Spain, United States
Language: English