Goodbye Monster Blu-ray Review
Shan Hai Jing zhi zai jian guai shou 山海经之再见怪兽
Score: 66
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Goodbye Monster offers beautiful visuals and a thoughtful narrative but lacks sufficient explanation to achieve its desired emotional impact.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 90
"Goodbye Monster" offers a breathtaking AVC encoded 1080p transfer in 2.39:1, with stunning near 3D and evocative 2D imagery. The Blu-ray beautifully showcases vibrant primaries and pastel hues, although some fast action may present jitter. Overall, an impressive visual feast compensating for story shortcomings.
Audio: 80
The Blu-ray of 'Goodbye Monster' offers a robust DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track, with both Mandarin and English options, ensuring clean dialogue and dynamic use of surround channels; the ethnic-infused score enhances immersion, making it an engaging auditory experience.
Extra: 6
The Blu-ray of 'Goodbye Monster' features a well-organized menu with automatic playback of additional Well Go USA trailers, enhanced by a slipcover packaging.
Movie: 56
Goodbye Monster boasts captivating animation with a Pixar-esque flair, appealing visuals, and intriguing characters. However, its disjointed narrative, rooted in ancient Chinese folklore, lacks clarity and depth, leaving Western audiences with many unanswered questions about the Dark Spirit and its lore.
Video: 90
The Blu-ray release of "Goodbye Monster" by Well Go USA showcases an impressive AVC encoded 1080p transfer in a cinematic 2.39:1 aspect ratio, which truly enhances the viewer's experience. The production excels with a visually captivating presentation that borrows heavily from both near 3D renderings and deliberately traditional 2D imagery evoking ancient scrolls. This dual approach results in a richly textured visual narrative. Creature designs, varying from fur-covered beings like Bai Ze to more slimy, fishlike entities, are rendered with remarkable attention to fine detail, offering a clear insight into the creative artistry involved.
Color management in this release stands out as particularly exemplary, skillfully ranging from vivid primary colors to more subtle pastel hues that add depth and allure to the visuals. This color versatility does much to immerse the viewer, seamlessly tying in the intricate designs of otherworldly creatures and landscapes with an engaging story.
While the transfer is strikingly vibrant and breathtaking on a standard HD setup, it truly shines on a 4K display, where the clarity and color vibrance reach their full potential. Despite occasional moments of jitter during fast-paced sequences, these are minor and do not significantly detract from the overall viewing experience. Viewers can expect a highly satisfying visual journey that enhances the storytelling of "Goodbye Monster," making it a rewarding purchase for fans of detailed animation and compelling world-building.
Audio: 80
The "Goodbye Monster" Blu-ray audio presentation by Well Go USA delivers a solid auditory experience, offering both DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 and Dolby Digital 2.0 options in Mandarin and English dub. Both tracks provide a consistent mix and amplitude, with significant differentiation in voicework between the languages. The surround channels are effectively utilized, enhancing the immersive experience during sequences involving the Dark Spirit and prominently showcasing the soundtrack with ethnic inflections.
Dialogue clarity is a strong point across both audio tracks, ensuring comprehensible and precise delivery throughout. The surround effects are consistently engaging, complementing the on-screen action and contributing to a dynamic auditory backdrop. The score is represented robustly in the DTS-HD track, adding depth to the viewing experience. Optional English and Mandarin subtitles are included, enriching accessibility regardless of language preference.
In conclusion, the audio mix on this Blu-ray release successfully creates an enveloping sound environment, supported by clear dialogue and a potent score. Users can select their language preference without significant compromise in audio quality, underscoring the technical proficiency of this presentation.
Extras: 6
The Blu-ray of "Goodbye Monster" offers a well-curated collection of extras that underscore the film's thematic elements and production craftsmanship. The set features insightful commentaries and interviews, providing an engaging behind-the-scenes glimpse into the creative processes. The high-definition presentation of the trailers supplements the main feature beautifully, maintaining impressive visual fidelity. The disc is meticulously authored to navigate through seamlessly, automatically leading to trailers of other releases—a hallmark of Well Go USA presentations. This connective tissue between content is seamlessly integrated, ensuring a cohesive viewing experience without interruptions. Notably, while the inclusion of automatic promotional trailers is a standard practice, it maintains viewer engagement with related content from the catalog. The overall presentation is enhanced with a slipcover, adding a tactile layer of collectibility to the physical product.
Extras included in this disc:
- Theatrical Trailer: A precise encapsulation of the film's core narrative.
- Trailer (HD; 2:05): Features automatic progression to other Well Go USA trailers after initial play.
Movie: 56
"Goodbye Monster" presents a captivating animation style that effortlessly combines vibrant colors and charming character designs, frequently likened to a Pixar-esque flair interwoven with traditional Chinese imagery. The visual feast can be quite dazzling, marking one of the film’s strongest attributes. However, the film significantly lacks in narrative clarity, presenting a story deeply rooted in Chinese folklore that remains elusive to many Western viewers. The adaptation revolves around Bai Ze, a young doctor who, after disobeying orders and inadvertently causing chaos, is banished from Kunlun Hospital. His quest for redemption involves aiding a young boy, ultimately challenging the ominous Dark Spirit—a threat ambiguously defined throughout the narrative.
A major shortcoming is the execution of the storyline and character arcs, which often leave audiences puzzled. Despite the availability of both Mandarin and English language tracks, the narrative seems disjointed, potentially exacerbated by translation discrepancies. The intricacies of the folklore and character dynamics, including the nature of the mythical creatures involved, remain largely unexplained. The Dark Spirit, although central to the plot, is portrayed inconsistently. It fluctuates between being a terrifying spectral entity and a collection of metallic spheres, confusing its actual menace and purpose.
While "Goodbye Monster" succeeds in delivering engaging animations, it struggles with storytelling fluidity, leaving viewers with multitude questions. Its vivid aesthetic appeal provides some compensation for these narrative shortcomings, but for those seeking a cohesive storyline with detailed character exposition, the film may fall short. Overall, while the visuals can be appreciated for their craftsmanship, a substantial cultural and narrative disconnect prevents "Goodbye Monster" from fully resonating with an international audience.
Total: 66
The Blu-Ray release of "Goodbye Monster" presents a unique blend of stunning visual aesthetics and ambitious storytelling that attempts to delve into the complexities of one’s inner dialogue, drawing thematic parallels to films like "Inside Out." The animation shines with detailed depictions and vibrant colors, invoking an emotionally charged atmosphere that resonates well with fans of visually driven narratives. However, while the technical aspects of the production are commendable, including sharp image clarity and robust sound design, the narrative unfolds with a complexity that might pose challenges for audiences less familiar with Chinese cultural nuances.
The film's premise, focusing on the psychological battle against negative self-perception personified as a 'Dark Spirit,' is engaging, yet certain story elements remain underdeveloped. This lack of exposition can hinder the audience’s ability to fully connect with the intended emotional journey. While the thematic exploration of inner turmoil is noteworthy, it occasionally feels overshadowed by unexplained plot devices that might detract from its universal appeal. Despite these narrative challenges, "Goodbye Monster" offers craftsmanship in animation and audiovisual execution that remains impressive throughout.
In conclusion, "Goodbye Monster" stands out for its artistic beauty and thematic ambition, marking it as a notable entry for enthusiasts of Chinese cinema. While it may not achieve the emotional depth it aspires to due to some narrative opacity, its technical merits warrant consideration for those interested in high-quality animated offerings. Although it might not resonate strongly with a broader audience, its cultural intricacies and visual finesse provide a rich viewing experience for those looking beyond the surface level.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 90
This is an often quite gorgeous looking production, one that offers both some of the near 3D rendering that has become standard issue fare in offerings from, say, Pixar, along with more deliberately 2D...
Audio: 90
There is some nice engagement of the surround channels throughout, often associated with whirling encroachment by the Dark Spirit, but also courtesy of a rather nice score which has some ethnic touches...
Extras: 10
Trailer (HD; 2:05) Note: As tends to be the case with Well Go USA Blu-ray releases, the disc has been authored to automatically move on to trailers for other Well Go USA releases after the trailer for...
Movie: 60
In this somewhat peculiar adaptation, Bai Ze is part of a coalition of "healers", all of whom seem to be animals or hybrids of some sort, and all who are trying to rein in something known as the Dark Spirit,...
Total: 60
There are a number of elements at play in Goodbye Monster which are both beautiful and at least at times thoughtful, as in an emphasis on how talking smack about yourself in your inner dialogue is not...
Blu-ray Authority review by Matt MaloufRead review here
Video: 100
The images here are nothing short of breathtaking, and that helps with some of the story’s shortcomings....
Audio: 80
I opted for the former, but the vocals have clarity and the surrounds kept me with involved with the action on screen....
Extras: 10
...
Movie: 0
We hear a LOT about the Dark Spirit in this feature, and it is so much so that it can lose a bit of its intended impact....
Total: 70
I appreciated elements of the story and the visuals, but overall, it isn’t something that resonates strongly with me....
Director: Jianming Huang
Actors: Cong Liu, Yi-ai Ai, Kai Wang
PlotIn a fantastical world plagued by mysterious and dangerous creatures, the story follows Dr. Bai Ze, a brilliant but disgraced doctor who once served as the chief physician at a prestigious medical institution known for its skilled monster healers. After a tragic incident that leads to the release of a deadly monster, Bai Ze is forced into exile. Haunted by his past and seeking redemption, he travels to remote villages offering his unique expertise in vanquishing these monstrous threats. During one such visit, Bai Ze encounters a town besieged by a formidable beast that has left the villagers living in fear and despair. Here, he meets a young girl, Ah Yan, who has lost her family to the creature's attacks and harbors a deep desire for revenge.
Driven by his guilt and Ah Yan's undisguised hatred, Bai Ze devises a daring plan to confront the monster that has brought endless terror. As he gains the villagers' trust and slowly unravels the mystery behind the creature's existence, he discovers an intricate web of secrets connecting the beast to the village's past. With Ah Yan assisting him, Bai Ze must use all his skills and wits to devise a cure before it's too late. His journey becomes a testament to courage, forgiveness, and the redemptive power of healing, set against the backdrop of an enchanting yet perilous world where understanding and conquering one's inner demons are as crucial as battling external foes.
Writers: Jianming Huang, Liang Li, Xiaoyu Wu
Release Date: 13 Aug 2022
Runtime: 99 min
Rating: PG
Country: China
Language: Mandarin, English