Duel in the Sun Blu-ray Review

The 1.33:1 aspect ratio AVC encoded image for the Blu-ray presentation of "Duel in the Sun" offers a satisfactory visual experience with notable strengths and occasional flaws. Maintaining a film-like quality, the transfer retains a degree of natural grain which enhances the vintage feel of the movie. Details range from strong to soft, with facial textures, costumes, and production design appearing crisp and well-defined in certain scenes, but occasionally wavering into softness, likely due to the original glamour-oriented cinematography. Colors are vibrantly rendered with that characteristic Technicolor pop, especially in the western hues and ornate costumes, though some frames exhibit a slight bleached look.

However, the image is not without its issues. Black levels vary, at times achieving solid depth but often remaining somewhat hazy, impacting the overall contrast and dimensionality. Additionally, the transfer struggles with mild compression artifacts during scenes with limited lighting, resulting in some posturization. Aging signs are present; dust specks, color speckling, mild scratches, and sporadic missing frames are noticeable, particularly around the 90-minute mark. Despite these imperfections, this 1080p transfer manages to deliver a largely engaging visual presentation that, while not perfect, respects the film's historical context and aesthetic aspirations.

The DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mix for "Duel in the Sun" delivers a serviceable but underwhelming auditory experience, especially when matched against the film's grandiose visuals. A consistent issue with audible hiss permeates the track, occasionally causing dialogue to lack precision and clarity. At times, voices sound somewhat fuzzy, muting the sharper exchanges that this epic tale demands. While the score by Dimitri Tiomkin is engaging and provides some auditory thrills, it unfortunately suffers from a lack of definition in certain instrumentation, failing to achieve an ideal balance.

The sound mix exhibits age-related limitations, with dialogue fluctuating between clear and robust to soft and indistinct, particularly when competing with stronger hiss elements. Audio consistency is a notable challenge; Tiomkin’s rousing compositions and the intended impact of sound effects are hampered by a tinny and hollow output, which can diminish the overall dramatic effect. Despite these shortcomings, the mix is acceptably functional for following the film’s narrative but falls short of delivering the immersive power expected from such a cinematic spectacle.

In summary, while this DTS-HD MA 2.0 mono track manages basic functionality, providing a coherent understanding of dialogue and musical motives, it does not fully meet the dynamic potential presented by "Duel in the Sun." Given its age and inherent limitations without extensive restoration, this iteration represents a somewhat flat audio accompaniment to the visual grandeur on display.

The extras on the Blu-ray of "Duel in the Sun" offer a comprehensive and engaging exploration of this historic film. The included commentary by film historian Gaylyn Studlar stands out for its detailed analysis of production nuances, on-screen activities, and contextual historical insights. Complementing this, an interview with Cecilia, Carey, and Anthony Peck provides intimate details about Gregory Peck’s experiences during the production, his relationships with key figures, and his longstanding friendship with co-star Jennifer Jones. The disc also includes a variety of trailers that give insight into the film's promotional history.

Extras included in this disc:

Audio Commentary: Film historian Gaylyn Studlar provides insight into the production and reception. Interview with Cecilia, Carey, and Anthony Peck: Discusses Gregory Peck's involvement and personal anecdotes. Theatrical Trailer: Original promotional material for the film. Trailer Tags: Brief promo clips from various releases. Promo Trailers: Previews of "The Big Country" and "Yellow Sky".

"Duel in the Sun" is a fascinating cinematic endeavor helmed by producer David O. Selznick, aimed at replicating the monumental success of "Gone with the Wind". The film is set against the expansive backdrop of the American West, transporting viewers into a world brimming with intense emotions, multifaceted characters, and the raw magnificence of frontier life. The narrative revolves around Pearl Chavez (Jennifer Jones), a young woman entangled in the familial and romantic turmoils of the McCanles clan, led by the imperious Senator Jackson McCanles (Lionel Barrymore). Gregory Peck and Joseph Cotten deliver compelling performances as the Senator's sons who vie for Pearl's affection, each embodying opposing virtues and vices amidst their father's vast cattle empire.

The film oscillates between moments of superb visual spectacle and instances of overwhelming melodrama. Directed by King Vidor, alongside an ensemble of uncredited directors, "Duel in the Sun" showcases some of the most breathtaking panoramas captured on film. The Technicolor cinematography is particularly splendid, with sweeping vistas and dynamically staged sequences, such as the electrifying bronco busting scenes and dramatic long shots of stampeding cattle and cavalry. However, these visual triumphs often overshadow a somewhat convoluted plot that struggles to sustain its epic length. Themes of romance, betrayal, and racial prejudices are woven through a series of oft-overstated dramatic turns that, while meant to evoke profound pathos, sometimes tip into the realm of high camp.

Despite the film's narrative shortcomings, the cast's performances are captivating. Jennifer Jones breathes fiery life into Pearl, despite an uneven character arc that oscillates wildly between virtue and temptation. Gregory Peck, in a rare villainous role, offers a magnetic portrayal of Lewt, while Joseph Cotten provides a stolid contrast as Jesse. The supporting cast, including Lillian Gish and Walter Huston, imbue their roles with a dignified gravitas. Ultimately, "Duel in the Sun" stands as an ambitious, if imperfect, marvel of Hollywood’s golden age, worthy of appreciation for its audacious scope and the sheer grandeur of its execution.

Kino Lorber’s Blu-ray release of "Duel in the Sun" faithfully captures the grandiosity and spectacle of King Vidor’s infamous Hollywood epic. The Roadshow Cut offered by Kino Lorber reintroduces poignant elements like a lengthy prelude, overture, and exit music, heightening the theatrical experience and mirroring the grandeur of such classics as "Gone with the Wind." This version preserves the film's ambition and offers cinephiles a cinematic extravaganza replete with Technicolor splendor and an engaging score that enriches the overall presentation.

Though "Duel in the Sun" is often criticized for its melodramatic narrative and extravagant production, it provides a captivating look at David O. Selznick's lavish production style. Jennifer Jones and Gregory Peck deliver intriguing performances that anchor the film’s hyperbolic themes of forbidden love and family drama. The film's notorious reputation as a 'bad romance novel brought to life' does little to detract from its entertainment value. Instead, it adds an element of campy charm that, combined with the lush cinematography, makes it a noteworthy inclusion in any classic film collection.

In conclusion, there's no denying that "Duel in the Sun" achieves a unique mood of dangerous behavior and ruinous love, reflecting an intentional mirroring of "Gone with the Wind." Kino Lorber's Roadshow Cut enhances the theatrical experience and compensates for the film's dramatic shortcomings with cineaste delights and an impressive array of bonus features. While it may not be a masterpiece, "Duel in the Sun" remains an entertaining and visually stunning piece worthy of appreciation.