The Holcroft Covenant Blu-ray Review
Score: 62
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
The Holcroft Covenant struggles with formulaic detours but remains entertaining, bolstered by Michael Caine's performance and a solid Blu-ray presentation by Kino Lorber.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 67
The Holcroft Covenant's Blu-ray video presentation excels with a bright, clean 1.85:1 1080p transfer, boasting vibrant colors, solid black levels, and detailed close-ups. While reds may slightly oversaturate skin tones, the overall image quality remains top-notch with minimal print damage.
Audio: 67
The Blu-ray's 2.0 DTS-HD MA audio track delivers clear dialogue and a strong sense of spatial atmosphere, although the music sometimes sounds lifeless and tinny. Despite occasional blunt sound effects, the gunfire retains a punchy impact, maintaining an authentic yet nostalgic 80s vibe.
Extra: 46
The Blu-ray extras, particularly the audio commentary by Director John Frankenheimer, provide a mix of scene-specific insights and valuable production anecdotes, complemented by various HD trailers, maintaining an engaging and informative tone.
Movie: 56
The Holcroft Covenant on Blu-ray, directed by John Frankenheimer, while not his finest work, delivers an engaging thriller with Michael Caine's compelling performance. The adaptation struggles with pacing, feeling rushed due to the compression of Ludlum's dense 500-page novel into a 112-minute runtime, impacting suspense and plot cohesion.
Video: 67
The video presentation of the Blu-ray release for "The Holcroft Covenant" stands out with a bright, clean viewing experience provided by an AVC-encoded image in a 1.85:1 aspect ratio. The 1080p HD transfer boasts clear and detailed visuals that allow fine facial features, clothing textures, and the film's diverse international locations to shine. The image maintains a consistent level of detail, enhancing the viewer's ability to appreciate the director's preference for extreme close-ups which reveal intricate pores and aging lines effectively.
Colors in this remaster are bright and bold, with sunlit exteriors enhancing the visual appeal and urban settings bringing out vivid neon lights and street signage. Costumes retain their fibrous textures and skintones generally appear natural, although some instances show reds being slightly pushed, giving the cast a pinkish hue. Black levels are deep and provide an impressive sense of three-dimensional depth, while the source material is impressively clean with only minimal signs of speckling. This high-quality transfer ensures a pleasing visual experience that fans of the film will certainly appreciate.
Audio: 67
The 2.0 DTS-HD MA audio mix of "The Holcroft Covenant" showcases a robust performance, often juggling the film's varied auditory demands with commendable clarity. Dialogue exchanges are delivered crisply, managing accents and suspenseful moments without any loss of intelligibility. Despite some locations with large crowds, the mix achieves a fine sense of imaging and spatial atmosphere, making the track feel expansive and immersive. Sound effects, while blunt and occasionally stiff, retain an authentic 80s vibrancy, giving punch to gunfire and car engines, though they may not always sound entirely realistic.
However, not all aspects of the mix are without faults. The music score by Stanislas Syrewicz, although faithfully reproduced by the track, sometimes appears thin and distorted. This tinny quality is likely due to the original recording techniques rather than the Blu-ray's capabilities. Nevertheless, the surrounding sound elements, including dialogue and effects, consistently maintain their purpose, making this a strong and enjoyable audio experience for fans of the era's distinctive soundscapes.
Extras: 46
The Blu Ray of "The Holcroft Covenant" includes a range of informative and engaging extras that significantly enhance the viewing experience. The standout feature is the audio commentary by director John Frankenheimer. Though he sometimes lapses into describing on-screen events, Frankenheimer offers invaluable insight into the production process and the composition of key shots. This commentary is particularly compelling for those interested in the technical aspects of filmmaking. Additionally, the disc features an array of trailers in high-definition for both "The Holcroft Covenant" and other related films, providing a nostalgic glimpse into the marketing strategies of that era.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: Director John Frankenheimer provides detailed insights into the film's production.
- Theatrical Trailer: Standard definition trailer (2:49) for "The Holcroft Covenant".
- 'Billion Dollar Brain' Trailer: High-definition trailer (2:44).
- 'The Fourth War' Trailer: High-definition trailer (2:07).
- '52 Pick-Up' Trailer: High-definition trailer (1:44).
- 'The Destructors' Trailer: High-definition trailer (2:51).
Movie: 56
Robert Ludlum's engrossing spy thriller, "The Holcroft Covenant," adapted into a 1985 film, reveals the complexity of transforming dense literary works to the big screen. Despite not being director John Frankenheimer's finest work, the film valiant attempts to capture Ludlum's vision of suspense and paranoia. The plot twists through intricate banking schemes and global espionage, starring Michael Caine as Noel Holcroft. Though the film doesn’t quite match the intensity of Ludlum's novels or the more successful Bourne series, Caine's performance undeniably elevates the narrative with his portrayal of a confused architect turned reluctant hero.
The film begins with a black-and-white sequence establishing its WWII roots. Nazi officer Heinrich Clausen devises a conspiratorial will, leaving a $4.5 billion fortune to his son Noel Holcroft and other offspring of his fellow officers, intending for reparations. Noel's ordinary life swiftly unravels upon learning his inheritance, attracting the attention of killers and opportunists. The movie details his struggle navigating this treacherous path across international locales like London, Geneva, and Berlin, while battling assassination attempts and uncovering betrayals that question every alliance.
While Caine’s thespian professionalism brings necessary depth to the character of Holcroft, Frankenheimer’s direction appears occasionally disjointed. The narrative suffers from pacing issues, attempting to condense a novel of over 500 pages into 112 minutes, causing some scenes to feel rushed and underdeveloped. Despite these shortcomings, Frankenheimer injects stylized elements like Dutch angles and a synth-heavy score to heighten tension. Supporting cast members, including Victoria Tennant and Michael Lonsdale, contribute substantial performances, though their potential is somewhat hindered by the script’s brisk pace. "The Holcroft Covenant" is a watchable thriller that intrigues but ultimately could have benefited from a more expanded runtime to fully explore its multifaceted story.
Total: 62
Reviewer 1: The Blu-ray release of "The Holcroft Covenant" features a solid transfer that captures the striking visuals of John Frankenheimer's direction. While the film has its narrative flaws, Michael Caine's performance elevates the material. The supplemental commentary is insightful, offering valuable context to the movie's production. Overall, a respectable release for a mid-tier thriller.
Reviewer 2: "The Holcroft Covenant" on Blu-ray benefits from Kino Lorber's meticulous A/V presentation. Although the film struggles with pacing and some awkward plot points, Michael Caine's charisma and Frankenheimer's directorial flair keep it engaging. The inclusion of a commentary track enriches the viewing experience, making it worth the purchase despite its imperfections.
Reviewer 3: Although not a perfect film, "The Holcroft Covenant" provides an engaging watch, especially due to Michael Caine's compelling lead performance. The Blu-ray transfer is exceptionally done, ensuring that the picture quality is top-notch. The commentary by John Frankenheimer adds an extra layer of appreciation. A worthy addition to any thriller collection.
"The Holcroft Covenant" finds its footing on Blu-ray with an impressive transfer that does justice to John Frankenheimer's visually driven direction. Although the film grapples with narrative weaknesses such as an awkward mid-movie romance and superfluous character inclusions, Michael Caine's magnetic performance uplifts the material. The supplementary commentary track by Frankenheimer offers invaluable insights into the filmmaking process, enhancing the overall experience.
Kino Lorber's Blu-ray release delivers a commendable A/V presentation, capturing the film's subtle nuances and maintaining high picture quality throughout. While some plot elements feel forced or unnecessary, the movie remains entertaining thanks to lively performances and documented production context provided in the special features. Frankenheimer's flair behind the camera is palpable and maintains viewer interest even when the script falters.
In conclusion, "The Holcroft Covenant" plays awkwardly with formula and introduces some missteps in its narrative, but remains passable entertainment largely due to Caine’s performance and Frankenheimer's direction. The Blu-ray edition, enriched with a quality transfer and insightful commentary, makes it a worthwhile consideration for thriller enthusiasts looking for a deeper dive into this mid-tier entry in the genre.
Blu-ray.com review by Brian OrndorfRead review here
Video: 80
Detail is steady throughout, offered unique inspection through the director's love for extreme close-ups, which explore pores and aging to satisfaction, and costumes retain fibrous textures....
Audio: 80
The 2.0 DTS-HD MA sound mix plays a few tricks with listeners, delivering cheap, thin music that sounds distorted at times, but the rough patches appear to be intended....
Extras: 60
...
Movie: 60
The mission is to find the sons of the covenant leaders, taking the architect to London and Geneva, while Berlin provides a special challenge as Noel and Helden try to slip around undetected by mingling...
Total: 70
Limitations are difficult to shake, but "The Holcroft Covenant" is passable entertainment, trying to make a worldwide mess of things as mystery relationships are inspected and near-misses are attempted....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
The print of this film is also in great shape with only some slight speckling here and there....
Audio: 80
One oddity that I don't think is the fault of the track but the original audio mix itself is the score by Stanislas Syrewicz, it can just sound lifeless and tinny at times that makes one wonder how it...
Extras: 40
At times, he can dip into just stating what's on screen, but when he's offering up info about the production or what it took to compose a certain shot, he's a fountain of interesting information....
Movie: 60
It's a monumental task that I don't wish upon anyone, as that poor writer is put in the position of deciding what aspects of the book stay and which ones go, and then what details need to be made up in...
Total: 60
'The Holcroft Covenant' may not be a great film or a perfect adaptation of its source material, but because of the performances and the lively direction under John Frankenheimer the film remains entertaining....
Director: John Frankenheimer
Actors: Michael Caine, Anthony Andrews, Victoria Tennant
PlotNoel Holcroft, an unsuspecting New York architect, discovers his late father’s involvement in a massive financial scheme born from Nazi funds during World War II. He learns that his father, alongside two other high-ranking Nazi officials, had diverted enormous sums of money into a Swiss bank account. Holcroft is approached by a Swiss banker to take charge of the funds, with the intent of using them for humanitarian purposes. The task initially seems straightforward but rapidly becomes perilous as Holcroft dives deeper into the murky past and labyrinthine conspiracy surrounding the money.
As Holcroft faces deadly challenges and startling revelations, he comes to realize that enemies and allies are not always who they appear to be. He is joined by an eclectic group of characters, some driven by greed, others by a genuine desire to rectify past wrongs. The stakes escalate dramatically as Holcroft races against time to outmaneuver those who wish to exploit the fund for nefarious aims. Confrontations, deceptions, and an intricate web of international intrigue propel him toward a climactic confrontation where trust and betrayal intertwine.
Writers: Robert Ludlum, George Axelrod, Edward Anhalt
Release Date: 18 Oct 1985
Runtime: 112 min
Rating: R
Country: United Kingdom
Language: English, German, Serbian