Halloween Blu-ray Review
Score: 73
from 4 reviewers
Review Date:
Halloween's iconic status shines in its latest Blu-ray, despite minor upgrade flaws.
Disc Release Date
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 73
After controversy, Anchor Bay's new Blu-ray of 'Halloween' with Dean Cundey’s input offers a definitive, more true-to-vision presentation, vastly improving colors, details, and film texture.
Audio: 69
Halloween's Blu-ray release wows with a new Dolby TrueHD 7.1 track enhancing its iconic score with unmatched clarity and presence, though it falls short in fully revamping some effects and the original mono's warmth.
Extra: 68
Halloween's 35th Anniversary Blu-ray packed with a detailed DigiBook, insightful audio commentary, engaging extras like 'The Night SHE Came Home,' vintage featurettes, and a mix of old and new supplements, lacks only a retrospective documentary.
Movie: 92
John Carpenter's 'Halloween' merges low budget with high impact, creating an iconic slasher that's skillfully crafted and atmospheric, becoming a defining force in horror cinema.
Video: 73
The latest 4K UHD Blu-Ray release of "Halloween" presents a significant visual upgrade that both addresses and transcends previous controversies regarding color timing and overall picture quality. Supervised and approved by the film's original Director of Photography, Dean Cundey, this transfer aims to deliver the movie as it was initially intended. Colors are notably more balanced, showcasing a move away from the excessively warm hues of earlier releases toward a palette that feels authentic to the chilling autumn setting of Haddonfield. Skin tones are natural, and the iconic orange of the opening titles pops without overwhelming, allowing for an image that is true to life and inviting to the viewer. Although some have noted the persistent appearance of springtime greenery inconsistent with the film's Fall setting, this release still offers considerable improvement in terms of contrast, black levels, and clarity, enhancing the cinematic appeal.
Detail and texture receive due attention in this remaster, with fine elements like hair strands and clothing textures appearing crisp and well-defined. The film grain remains preserved, contributing to a filmic texture that enhances the movie's atmospheric qualities without detracting from its clarity. However, slight imperfections such as minor speckling and a brief appearance of a stray hair indicate that while the transfer is markedly superior to its predecessors, it is not without its minor flaws. These issues do little to mar an otherwise impressive presentation that significantly benefits from less digital correction and an overall sharper image.
Despite these largely positive strides, there continues to be discussion among fans and purists about the authenticity of the seasonal depiction, with some critiquing the still too lively greenery supposedly misrepresenting the Illinois fall. Additionally, minor aliasing issues on certain objects suggest room for perfection. Nonetheless, this release, particularly when compared to its 2007 predecessor, represents a monumental step forward. It embraces a cooler color scheme that aligns more closely with the envisioned atmospheric conditions of a Midwestern fall, thereby enhancing the overall mood and tension integral to the film's success. This 4K UHD edition not only satisfies long-standing demands for a truer representation of Dean Cundey's cinematographic vision but also revitalizes John Carpenter's classic for both new and seasoned audiences, offering an unparalleled viewing experience that is as close to cinematic perfection as has been achieved for this landmark horror film.
Audio: 69
The audio presentation of the 4K UHD Blu-ray edition of "Halloween" introduces an impressive Dolby TrueHD 7.1 lossless soundtrack, an ambitious step up from older iterations. This new offering enhances the legendary score with sharply defined piano notes and a foreboding low end, providing unparalleled clarity and presence. Ambient sounds, like the chilling October breeze, driving rain, and booming thunder, are effectively utilized, elevating the film's atmospheric tension. Despite this auditory feast, certain limitations are apparent. Not all effects benefit from this upgrade; some retain their original lack of definition or sound unnaturally sharp, particularly in high-intensity scenes. Dialogue is generally clear, albeit with occasional inconsistencies, underscoring the intricate balance struck between preserving original elements and embracing modern audio advancements.
Anchor Bay’s efforts have injected a new lease of life into the "Halloween" soundscape with this Dolby TrueHD 7.1 mix. While the much-discussed original mono track remains unchanged in its legacy format, falling short of purists’ expectations for a lossless version, the 7.1 mix broadens the auditory experience significantly. The iconic score thrives across this expansive soundstage, though mid-range dynamics and certain action sequences don’t see equivalent enhancement, likely due to limitations of the source material. Vocals sometimes emerge as flat, reflecting a challenging transition from mono to multi-channel sound without sacrificing the film's original auditory essence.
Despite some criticisms surrounding the necessity of such an ambitious remix and the handling of legacy audio tracks, the effort to celebrate "Halloween" with modernized audio is evident. The soundtrack offers a mixed bag: an impressive elevation of Carpenter's score and key atmospheric elements, juxtaposed with less impactful lows and occasional flatness in vocals and action sequences. Yet, for fans and new audiences alike, this reimagined auditory experience provides a captivating way to experience the classic horror film, even if it simultaneously highlights the complexities of modernizing historical soundtracks for contemporary home theaters.
Extras: 68
The "Halloween" 35th Anniversary 4K UHD Blu-ray extras package impressively balances nostalgic content with insightful, newly recorded materials, catering to both long-time fans and technically inclined viewers. The detailed and enthusiastic audio commentary by Director John Carpenter and Actress Jamie Lee Curtis is a standout, offering in-depth perspectives on the filmmaking process, casting, and the film's enduring legacy, complemented by a pleasant dynamic between the contributors. "The Night She Came Home!!," a heartfelt documentary showcasing Curtis's charity work within the fandom community, further humanizes the franchise. Historical insights are preserved in "On Location: 25 Years Later," while the inclusion of TV version footage and promotional material (trailers, TV, and radio spots) broadens the appeal. Despite lacking a comprehensive retrospective documentary—which would have made for a perfect inclusion—the extras provide a well-rounded exploration of "Halloween's" impact and production, though some may find the exclusions a missed opportunity for deeper exploration.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary With Writer/Director John Carpenter And Actor Jamie Lee Curtis: A new track offering insights into the film's production and legacy.
- The Night SHE Came Home!!: A documentary on Jamie Lee Curtis's charity work and fan interactions.
- On Location: 25 Years Later: A look back at the filming locations with contributions from the late Debra Hill and actress PJ Soles.
- TV Version Footage: Additional scenes included in the television broadcast version.
- Trailer: The original theatrical preview.
- TV Spots: Three vintage television commercials for the film.
- Radio Spots: Three promotional radio spots, each with a distinct runtime.
Movie: 92
The 4K UHD Blu-ray presentation of John Carpenter's "Halloween" revitalizes the seminal horror classic, reaffirming its monumental stature in the horror genre and its undying influence across the cinematic landscape. With a frugal budget of around $320,000, Carpenter's craftsmanship transcends financial constraints, delivering a masterclass in tension, atmosphere, and storytelling. "Halloween" unfurls in the sleepy town of Haddonfield, Illinois, where Michael Myers, after escaping confinement, resumes his gruesome vendetta on Halloween night. The narrative ingeniously balances the menacing pursuit by Dr. Samuel Loomis and the unsuspecting teenage lives, particularly Laurie Strode’s, thereby setting a benchmark for suspense and horror.
At its core, Carpenter's work is a testament to visionary filmmaking, weaving simplicity with profound terror. The film's potency lies not in its premise—a masked killer stalking babysitters—but in its execution: a relentless build-up of dread punctuated by Carpenter's iconic score. The use of perspective, notably through voyeuristic shots and the haunting presence of "The Shape," enhances the film's eerie atmosphere. This sense of omnipresent danger lurking in the banal elevates "Halloween" above countless imitators. Despite the advent of gorier and more explicit horror films, "Halloween" maintains its grip on audiences with its restrained yet effective scares and the palpable sense of doom crafted by Carpenter's deft directorial hand.
Critically, "Halloween" endures as a paragon of the slasher genre due to its innovative cinematography, memorable performances—highlighted by Jamie Lee Curtis's breakout role—and its pivotal influence on subsequent horror narratives. It’s a film that skilfully plays upon primal fears with minimalistic yet hauntingly effective elements—girl, monster, knife, devoid of gratuitous gore. As Carpenter coaxes genuine empathy for Myers' prey, juxtaposing dread with juvenile preoccupations, he cements "Halloween" as not merely a film but an essential horror experience that remains unparalleled in its ability to terrify while commanding respect for its artistry and enduring legacy.
Total: 73
"John Carpenter's 'Halloween' endures as a monumental classic in the horror genre, celebrated by fans and critics alike for its groundbreaking storytelling and innovative filmmaking. The 35th Anniversary 4K UHD Blu-ray release by Anchor Bay elevates this iconic film to new heights, offering a presentation that nearly mirrors the original cinematic experience championed by its fervent advocates. Despite the mixed reception regarding the Blu-ray's supplemental material and audio enhancements, the overall package presents a significantly improved picture quality. This edition has been supervised and approved by cinematographer Dean Cundey, ensuring an authentic representation of the movie's visual aesthetics, with enhanced contrast and brightness that deliver a more natural and immersive viewing experience.
However, the release does not come without its criticisms. Enthusiasts may find the Dolby TrueHD soundtrack lacking in comparison to the film’s original mono design, characterizing the upmix as flat and less dynamic. Additionally, while there are enjoyable new exclusive supplements, the absence of more comprehensive extras and a definitive collection of previous releases’ bonus content leaves a noticeable gap. Despite these shortcomings, Anchor Bay has provided fans and newcomers alike with an indispensable addition to their collections. With this release, 'Halloween' remains as compelling and terrifying as it was upon its debut, reaffirming its place as the pinnacle of slasher films with its unrivaled suspense and the chilling presence of Michael Myers.
In conclusion, while this 35th Anniversary 4K UHD Blu-ray of 'Halloween' may not be the conclusive version fans ardently desire, it stands as a testament to the film's enduring legacy. It successfully captures the quintessence of Carpenter's masterpiece through superior picture quality and a handful of enjoyable extras. Despite certain areas where it falls short—most notably in its audio presentation and the breadth of supplemental content—this release is ultimately a worthwhile acquisition for both die-hard enthusiasts and those new to the chilling allure of Haddonfield. Its ability to reinvigorate interest in a timeless classic affirms that 'Halloween' will continue to captivate audiences for generations to come."
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 90
Halloween's original Blu-ray release has been subjected to a rather large amount of controversy and criticism for its color timing, turning off some would-be buyers, angering purists, and leaving diehard...
Audio: 90
The track doesn't always require environmental elements thereafter, but the occasional chilly late October breeze, driving rain, and booming thunder -- the latter of which grows in intensity the closer...
Extras: 60
The piece also features discussions of the requirements of the film's shooting locales, the actors' presences on set, Carpenter's filmmaking style, character dynamics, and making use of location dynamics....
Movie: 100
Carpenter masterfully manipulates the characters and his audience with the contrast between the happy-go-lucky "everything's fine" mentality of most of his characters -- the ones who will die, primarily,...
Total: 80
It's not the perfect package most fans probably wanted -- there are too few supplements for that and plenty that haven't carried over from previous home video releases -- but it's certainly worth adding...
The Digital Bits review by Dr Adam JahnkeRead review here
Video: 95
Audio: 90
Either way, it’s a bit of a moot point because neither release features the original 1978 mono track, which is what audio purists want anyway....
Extras: 75
Movie: 95
The Friday the 13th series started as junk and remained junk, albeit entertaining junk for those of us who enjoy watching teens get sliced and diced by a machete-wielding, hockey-mask-wearing maniac....
Total: 89
If the extras were as definitive as the transfer, this would in fact be the only Halloween disc you need to own....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
During the course of those small corrections, it would also seem as if Cundey must have forgotten about the correct color timing, which to date is only available on the Criterion Collection laserdisc and...
Audio: 60
While I do appreciate Anchor Bay releasing this dearly beloved flick with the latest and greatest in digital sound, the effort is rather needless without a lossless option for the original mono design....
Extras: 0
On Location: 25 Years Later (SD, 10 min) — A tour of the shooting locations and the Pasadena neighborhood, and the brief featurette also includes a few comments on the production....
Movie: 80
It is the one American franchise horror film of the past three decades to rightly earn comparisons not only to Browning, Whale, Hitchcock and Murnau , but as one of the true greats of a ill-reputed genre....
Total: 60
For neophytes and those who didn't buy the previous disastrous Blu-ray, this is the one to purchase, but devoted fans will have to continue waiting for a proper high-definition presentation of this beloved,...
Why So Blu?Read review here
Video: 100
And with this color timing, the atmosphere in John Carpenter’s legendary film is even scarier than I could ever remember it....
Audio: 90
There are some really really neat things done with the score throughout the speakers here....
Extras: 80
While I miss having Debra Hill’s contributions, this new commentary is full of energy and positive vibes as both Carpenter and especially Curtis are excited to relive this time in their lives for 91 minutes....
Movie: 100
While not very possible it could work out, its cool as hell and Nick Castle sells Michael’s creepiness with just the turn of the head....
Total: 100
A big thank you to Anchor Bay for once again releasing a version of my favorite film that I’ve seen a zillion times and making it feel like the first time all over again....
Director: John Carpenter
Actors: Donald Pleasence, Jamie Lee Curtis, Tony Moran
PlotOn a cold Halloween night in 1963, in the small town of Haddonfield, Illinois, a six-year-old boy named Michael Myers inexplicably stabs his sister to death in their family home. Convicted and sent to a mental institution, he becomes the patient of Dr. Sam Loomis. Fifteen years later, on the eve of Halloween, Michael escapes from the institution. Driven by inscrutable motives, he returns to Haddonfield, with Dr. Loomis in pursuit, intent on preventing Michael from committing any more atrocities. The town, oblivious to the impending danger, prepares for its Halloween celebrations as Michael quietly stalks the residential streets.
Among the local residents is Laurie Strode, a high school student who spends her time babysitting and navigating teenage life. As the day turns into night, Laurie and her friends become the focus of Michael's menacing attention. Unbeknownst to them, he watches from the shadows, his presence signaled only by his heavy breathing and the fleeting glimpse of a masked figure. When friends begin to experience unsettling occurrences, Laurie senses that something is terribly amiss. The evening descends into a harrowing sequence of events as the true horror of Michael Myers' return to Haddonfield unfolds. Dr. Loomis desperately tries to track down his former patient, but whether he can arrive in time to stop Michael's silent rampage remains uncertain.
Writers: John Carpenter, Debra Hill
Release Date: 27 Oct 1978
Runtime: 91 min
Rating: R
Country: United States
Language: English