The Sorcerer and the White Snake Blu-ray Review
Bai she chuan shuo
Score: 47
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
The Sorcerer and the White Snake offers an amusing storyline but is ultimately hampered by subpar CGI and only average Blu-ray video and audio quality.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 49
The 1080p/AVC-encoded transfer of "The Sorcerer and the White Snake" balances vibrant colors and fine detail with a dated CGI aesthetic and occasional softness. While the film benefits from warm tones and balanced contrast, flaws in the grainy 35mm source and fluctuating black levels slightly mar the viewing experience.
Audio: 54
The Blu-ray's DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 tracks in both Mandarin and English dub offer clear dialogue and full-bodied mix with effective, though sometimes sporadic, surround speaker use. Ambient and action sequences are engaging, with rich mid-range clarity and occasional deep bass, but the overall immersion falls short of top-tier fantasy sound designs.
Extra: 36
Featuring three behind-the-scenes featurettes on fight choreography with Jet Li, visual effects, and special makeup for the female leads, plus an AXS TV promo and theatrical trailer, these extras provide a comprehensive, technical glimpse into the film's production.
Movie: 41
The Sorcerer and the White Snake, a big-budget fantasy epic inspired by Chinese folklore, is hampered by subpar CGI reminiscent of early 2000s direct-to-video productions, detracting from its promising narrative and martial arts choreography despite Jet Li's presence and Tony Ching's direction.
Video: 49
The Blu-ray presentation of "The Sorcerer and the White Snake" offers a visual experience with notable strengths and weaknesses that demand critical evaluation. Presented in 1080p/AVC MPEG-4, the film absorbs viewers with its unique blend of outdated, often texture-less CGI and grainy 35mm stock. This combination diverges from typical 2013 standards, occasionally giving the film an anachronistic appearance more akin to the 1990s. Despite this, the transfer seems faithfully accurate to its source, maintaining a natural film grain texture, albeit at the expense of reducing fine detail, especially notable on high-resolution displays or when projected on larger screens.
Colors are another striking aspect of this transfer. The Blu-ray's color grading excels in delivering dense, warm tones and vibrant splashes, such as the red gown of the ice harpy early in the film. Primaries are lush and richly saturated, while pastel hues bring warmth and dynamism to the visual palette. Contrast is generally balanced well, avoiding overly dark blacks or distorted skin tones. However, fluctuating contrast levels can be observed throughout, affecting scene-to-scene consistency. While noise reduction and edge enhancement are commendably absent, ensuring a cleaner image without distracting artifacts, the flawed CGI work does hinder overall resolution and sharpness in animated sequences.
Ultimately, while the Blu-ray reproduces a vibrant and mostly clean visual output true to the director’s vision, it can't escape the inherent limitations of its source material. Occasional white specks, faded scenes, and softness due to CGI imperfections downgrading otherwise sharp visuals may distract purists. Nevertheless, for general audiences, the film remains a captivating visual tale in 2D format without significant compression or encoding issues.
Audio: 54
The Blu-ray audio presentation of "The Sorcerer and the White Snake" offers two lossless DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 tracks: the original Mandarin and an English dub. It's worth noting that the English dub suffers from a lack of natural performance, so the original Mandarin track is recommended. The sound design, though not on par with that of blockbuster fantasy epics like "The Lord of the Rings," delivers a satisfying mix overall. Surround speakers are actively utilized in almost every scene, contributing to an appreciable, full-bodied ambiance. Ambient sounds like festival clamor and rustling bamboo enhance the experience, while the action sequences employ cross-channel effects that create dynamic moments.
The front soundstage is particularly robust in this mix, offering a wide and engaging range of activity. Instruments like Chinese violins and flutes resonate impressively up front, complemented by orchestral swells in the rear channels during musical crescendos. Despite these high points, the rear speaker activity is somewhat inconsistent, with ambient noises feeling sporadic and occasionally forced. While the action sequences are energetic, they could benefit from a more immersive surround experience. The dialogue is well-positioned at the top of the mix, ensuring clarity and ease of understanding. Low-end frequencies aren’t overly prominent but do provide notable moments of deep bass during critical sequences.
In summary, the audio track performs well in terms of front soundstage activity and instrumental clarity but falls short in achieving an enveloping surround sound environment. Fans will appreciate the high-resolution qualities and dynamic range, even though immersive elements could be more pronounced. The disc also includes English, English SDH, English Titles and Text, and Spanish subtitles.
Extras: 36
The extras on the Blu Ray of "The Sorcerer and the White Snake" provide a compelling behind-the-scenes look at the film's production. The featurettes are comprehensive and include interviews, on-set footage, and detailed insights into visual effects, production design, and fight choreography. Each segment offers a thorough exploration of various aspects of the movie-making process, making them both informative and entertaining. The inclusion of an AXS TV promotional piece and the original theatrical trailer augment the offering, delivering a well-rounded package for fans and film enthusiasts alike.
Extras included in this disc:
- Behind the Scenes with Jet Li: Fighting, Stunts & Laughs: Insightful look at the fight choreography and stunt work.
- Behind the Scenes: Visual Effects and Production Design: Overview of visual effects, set design, and green-screen work.
- Behind the Scenes: The Beauties and the Beasts: Focus on special makeup effects and stunt work for female leads.
- AXS TV: A Look at The Sorcerer and the White Snake: Promo piece for AXS TV.
- Theatrical Trailer: Original film trailer.
- Also from Magnolia Home Entertainment: Additional trailers from Magnolia.
Movie: 41
"The Sorcerer and the White Snake," while visually ambitious and based on the compelling Chinese legend of Madame White Snake, ultimately underperforms due to subpar CGI and a lackluster plot. The film features Jet Li as Abbott Fahai, a Buddhist exorcist who captures wayward demons, adding a layer of dramatic weight. However, much of the CGI, reminiscent of early 2000s animation, distracts from the narrative rather than enhancing it. The compositing is poorly done and the animation lacks finesse, resembling pre-visualization work rather than polished effects. Despite its grand mythological intentions, the visuals often appear outdated, and the martial arts sequences feel overshadowed by this distracting, artificial spectacle.
At its core, the love story between White Snake (Eva Huang) and Xu Xian (Raymond Lam) has flashes of creativity and emotional depth. Their initial underwater encounter is both imaginative and engaging, setting a romantic tone that could have carried the film. Yet, scenes featuring anthropomorphic animals such as a CG rat, rabbit, and turtle disrupt the narrative flow with their blocky, low-definition animation. These critters feel more suitable for a children's tale rather than enhancing the fantasy world of "The Sorcerer and the White Snake." The narrative, presented in broad strokes without thematic nuance, suffers further from overly theatrical performances, particularly from Huang and Charlene Choi as Green Snake.
Jet Li’s experienced presence in wuxia cinema should provide credibility, but he is underutilized. Fahai's attempts to balance demon hunting with monkish detachment are sabotaged by poor green-screen work and lackluster prop choreography. Frustratingly, the film's climax fails to deliver the impact it promises, hampered by impractical effects and unconvincing battles. Ultimately, while "The Sorcerer and the White Snake" has moments of spectacle and charm, its reliance on outdated CGI and deficient storytelling prevents it from achieving the epic grandeur or emotional resonance it aims for.
Total: 47
"The Sorcerer and the White Snake" on Blu-ray presents a visually ambitious attempt to meld a rich fantasy narrative with modern digital effects. Unfortunately, the film’s execution of these visual elements falls short, with CGI that often appears low-textured and reminiscent of outdated video game cutscenes. This underwhelming quality is compounded by hammy acting and rote martial arts sequences, detracting from the potentially engaging storyline. Despite some creative filmmaking and imaginative plot points, the overall presentation is marred by inconsistently executed visual elements that can be distracting for viewers.
The video quality of the Blu-ray is decent but not without issues, revealing some artifacts and less detailed textures in the effects-heavy scenes. Audio, while better, does not entirely compensate for the visual shortcomings. The soundscape provides clarity but lacks the dynamic range that would elevate the viewing experience to an immersive level. Additionally, the Blu-ray's collection of supplemental features feels lackluster, offering little to enhance the understanding or appreciation of the film.
If you're going to make a spectacle film that puts CGI ahead of story, you'd better make sure the digital effects are actually impressive and not the sort of low-texture, badly animated stuff you remember seeing from late 1990s video game cutscenes. "The Sorcerer and the White Snake" is a big-budget movie that looks like a low-budget movie trying to be a big-budget movie—if that makes any sense—and it doesn't really work on any level, with hammy acting and goofy comedy and rote martial arts action. Fans of cornball kung-fu movies might find something to enjoy here, but this is one of those so-cheesy-it's-possibly-entertaining situations that will be fun for some and torture for others. I'd watch the trailer before considering a blind buy.
Blu-ray.com review by Casey BroadwaterRead review here
Video: 70
Overall, the image is a bit on the soft side�with the heavy grain structure obscuring what might otherwise be fine detail�but from a normal viewing distance this isn't really an issue, unless you're watching...
Audio: 80
Ambience is quiet but welcome�hear the clamor of the village festival, wind rustling through bamboo trees, bubbles gurgling underwater, lapping waves�and there are occasional cross-channel effects during...
Extras: 40
Behind the Scenes with Jet Li: Fighting, Stunts & Laughs (SD, 6:17) Behind the Scenes: Visual Effects and Production Design (SD, 6:50)...
Movie: 50
It would be easier to overlook the technical shortcomings if the rest of the film were better, but The Sorcerer and the White Snake is an all-around subpar effort, 100 minutes of cornball romance and talking...
Total: 50
If you're going to make a spectacle film that puts CGI ahead of story, you'd better make sure the digital effects are actually impressive and not the sort of low-texture, badly animated stuff you remember...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
Primaries, in particular, are luxurious and richly-saturated, but softer pastel hues are also in abundance, adding plenty of warmth and life to the transfer....
Audio: 60
Although back speakers don't add a great deal to these segments, at the least the screen is bursting with lots of life and commotion....
Extras: 0
Behind the Scenes (SD) — Broken into three separate sections, this is a collection of BTS footage, starting with a look at the fight choreography and rehearsals centering around Jet Li (6 min)....
Movie: 40
Lately, however, especially with the genre's rise in popularity and CGI allowing for more creative visuals, the films falling under this category seem to be really pushing the lines of imagination, which...
Total: 40
The Blu-ray arrives with good but mildly troubled video quality and the audio presentation is slightly better but still somewhat less than satisfying....
Director: Siu-Tung Ching
Actors: Jet Li, Shengyi Huang, Raymond Lam
PlotIn a mystical Chinese landscape, a powerful sorcerer named Abbot Fahai dedicates his life to battling evil spirits and protecting humanity. One day, a snake demon named Susu takes the form of a beautiful woman and encounters a kind-hearted herbalist named Xu Xian. The two quickly fall in love, unaware of each other's true nature. Their bond grows stronger, but their relationship inadvertently disrupts the balance between the human and spirit worlds, drawing the attention of Fahai. As the sorcerer senses the disturbance, he sets out to investigate the situation, believing that Susu's presence poses a grave threat to humanity.
Meanwhile, Susu is unaware that her sister, who is also a snake demon, does not approve of the burgeoning love affair and worries about the potential ramifications. Fahai's apprentices aid him in tracking down Susu, leading to multiple confrontations filled with supernatural battles. Xu Xian, caught between his love for Susu and his loyalty to his fellow humans, struggles to understand the calamity unfolding around him. The story progresses with intensifying stakes, as Fahai seeks to uphold his duty, Susu fights to protect her love, and Xu Xian grapples with the revelations that shake his world.
Writers: Tan Cheung
Release Date: 28 Sep 2011
Runtime: 102 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: China, Hong Kong
Language: Mandarin