The Mandela Effect Blu-ray Review
Score: 55
from 1 reviewers
Review Date:
The Mandela Effect impresses with its high-concept ideas and emotional depth, delivering a solid Blu-ray experience with commendable video, audio, and commentary.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 61
Gravitas Ventures’ Blu-ray of 'The Mandela Effect' on a burned BD-R disc, while not exemplary, offers a clear, watchable image with good detailing and balanced colors, despite some noise and mild banding. Black levels are nearly perfect.
Audio: 61
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 lossless soundtrack is satisfactory, providing nicely defined music and clear dialogue, though it lacks potent surround support and full immersion.
Extra: 26
The Blu-ray of "The Mandela Effect" features a sharply insightful audio commentary by the film’s creators, supplemented by a HD trailer, but lacks a slipcover and additional digital content, maintaining a focused yet minimalistic approach to extras.
Movie: 66
The Mandela Effect explores philosophical and existential questions about reality and human perception through a grieving father's journey into parallel universes. While it occasionally veers into conspiracy theory territory, it remains grounded with solid storytelling, relatable emotions, and impressive sci-fi accessibility.
Video: 61
The Blu-ray presentation of "The Mandela Effect" by Gravitas Ventures, though delivered on a burned BD-R disc instead of a pressed disc, offers satisfactory visual quality. As expected from a lower-budget production, the image clarity is sufficient if not remarkable, providing a watchable experience. The fundamental detailing is appreciable, with good definition in essential areas such as skin textures and various environmental elements. For instance, the beach sands in the opening scenes and denser home interiors demonstrate commendable detail and clarity.
Color reproduction is balanced yet subdued, lacking the vividness and pop characteristic of higher-definition formats like 4K UHD or HDR. However, the film maintains pleasing contrast and temperature settings throughout, albeit with occasional adjustments for specific filmmaker effects. Black levels are nearly perfect, contributing depth to darker scenes, while white balance remains consistently decent. Skin tones appear natural, and while there is some noise and mild banding present, these artifacts are minimal and generally do not detract from the overall viewing experience.
Despite its limitations and the inherent constraints of its production budget, the Blu-ray video quality of "The Mandela Effect" meets an acceptable standard for casual viewing. It is clear that significant effort has been made to maximize the visual presentation within these constraints, resulting in a product that, while not exemplary, is effectively satisfying for its intended audience.
Audio: 61
The Blu-ray of "The Mandela Effect" features a DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 lossless soundtrack. While not overly ambitious, this track is competent and reliable, mirroring the strengths and weaknesses of the video presentation. The audio mix begins strong with well-defined music, seamlessly integrated and effectively spread across the front channels. Although the surround channels provide limited support, the essential clarity of the track remains consistent, making basic sound effects like rolling waters feel spacious and mildly immersive.
However, the audio mix notably centers around dialogue, maintaining clear, centered, and well-prioritized spoken words throughout the film. This steadfast focus on dialogue ensures that even in the absence of potent surround effects, the critical element of speech is always rendered with precision and reliability. Overall, while some might find the surround ambiance sparse, the track satisfactorily upholds its foundational qualities without distraction from its core auditory elements.
Extras: 26
The Blu-ray release of "The Mandela Effect" offers a solid range of extras that enhance the viewing experience and provide deeper insight into the film. The audio commentary is particularly noteworthy, featuring contributions from Writer, Producer, and Director David Guy Levy; Writer and Producer Steffen Schlachtenhaufen; and Producer Josh Fruehling. Their discussion is both insightful and occasionally humorous, offering valuable behind-the-scenes context and elucidating the film’s thematic nuances. The inclusion of a trailer is a nice touch, although basic. This release omits any DVD or digital copies and does not come with a slipcover.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: Insightful discussion by the writer, producer, and director team.
- Trailer: Standard promotional clip of the film.
Overall, the extras are well-curated, albeit somewhat minimalistic.
Movie: 66
"The Mandela Effect" explores complex philosophical and existential queries, pondering whether reality is an immutable construct or a fluid perception shaped by the human mind. Through the lens of the Mandela Effect—a phenomenon that attributes collective false memories to alternate realities—the film delves into the grieving journey of a father named Brendan (Charlie Hofheimer). After losing his daughter Sam (Madeleine McGraw) in a beach accident, Brendan becomes fixated on instances where his memories diverge from reality, such as misremembering the spelling of “Berenstain Bears.” These oddities spur him into a quest steeped in both hard science and speculative fiction, leading him to unorthodox theories about parallel universes and potential resurrection via a supercomputer.
Brendan’s occupation as a video game designer provides a grounded yet speculative framework for the film’s high-tech and high-concept underpinnings. His exploration intersects with heavy emotional themes of loss and hope, making the outlandish ideas surprisingly relatable. The narrative weaves in elements of conspiracy theories and late-night speculative discussions but balances them with earnest storytelling and profound character moments. The presence of an ostracized scientist (Clarke Peters) and the technical plausibility the film affords to its speculative elements add layers of believability, ensuring that the blend of fantasy and reality remains engaging and cohesive.
While "The Mandela Effect" may not boast the breathtaking intensity or creativity of films like "The Matrix," it succeeds through its disciplined pacing, competent acting, and a grounded approach to high-end sci-fi concepts. The movie’s strength lies in its ability to juxtapose grandiose existential dilemmas with relatable human emotions, making it a thoughtful exploration of grief, memory, and the often-blurred line between perception and reality.
Total: 55
The Mandela Effect on Blu-ray offers a thought-provoking cinematic experience rooted deeply in high-concept storytelling and emotional resonance. The film attracts viewers with its exploration of the complex psychological phenomenon, often raising intriguing questions about memory and reality. Its low-budget origins don't hinder its ability to captivate; rather, they enhance the focus on narrative and character development over visual spectacle. The performances are compelling, particularly in the lead role, driving the heartfelt nature of the story forward effectively.
Technically, the Blu-ray presentation is commendable. The video quality showcases a well-balanced color palette and sharp detail, preserving the director's vision without any noticeable artifacts or inconsistencies. The sound design, while not groundbreaking, serves the film well, presenting clean dialogue and subtle ambient sounds that complement the overall immersive experience. The disc includes a valuable commentary track that provides deeper insights into the filmmakers' intentions and creative process.
The Mandela Effect is a concept film that works as a low-budget release because of its intense focus on story and idea and less so on dazzle and delight. The film is propelled by high-concept ideas and relatable emotional content, and it does a very good job of making a movie from old-fashioned qualities and characteristics rather than trying to hide a lack of story with overwhelming visual and aural supports. This is not a classic, but it's a nice change of pace from a fairly vapid modern-day cinema landscape. Gravitas Ventures' Blu-ray is solid enough, offering satisfactory video and audio presentations in addition to a good commentary track. Recommended.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 70
Colors are pleasing, lacking authoritative pop and vividness but finding good balance and satisfying contrast and temperature settings, though at times the latter two are adjusted a bit for filmmaker effect....
Audio: 70
The track proves its worth from the outset, offering nicely defined music which is always well engaged and nicely spaced along the front, though surround support is sparse rather than potent....
Extras: 30
This Blu-ray release of The Mandela Effect includes a commentary track and a trailer, the former of which is found under the "bonus" menu tab while the latter is simply a part of the main menu text....
Movie: 70
The film looks at the impact death has on a grieving father and how the possibility that things really might be different, for the better, somewhere else, leads him down a rabbit hole of possibilities,...
Total: 60
The film is propelled by high concept ideas and relatable emotional content, and it does a very good job of making a movie from old fashioned qualities and characteristics rather than trying to hide a...
Director: Benjamin Epps, David Guy Levy
Actors: Charlie Hofheimer, Aleksa Palladino, Robin Lord Taylor
PlotAfter the sudden and tragic death of his young daughter, Brendan begins to notice discrepancies in his memories and the world around him, leading him to uncover the concept of the Mandela Effect. Obsessed with the idea that something larger is manipulating reality, he dives deep into research, discovering various instances where collective memories of historical events, products, and cultural phenomena differ from actual historical records. His wife, Claire, struggles to reconcile his growing obsession with their shared grief. As Brendan's fixation intensifies, he encounters others who share similar experiences and questions if their altered memories point to parallel universes or a simulated reality.
Brendan's relentless search for the truth leads him to a reclusive scientist who suggests drastic measures to expose the potential manipulation of reality. Desperate for answers, Brendan navigates a series of increasingly disorienting and surreal experiences, pushing the boundaries of his perception and sanity. As he delves further into the nature of existence, his relationships strain under the weight of his discoveries and his spiraling mental state. The story weaves an intricate tapestry of reality and illusion, questioning the very fabric of what is real as Brendan battles to make sense of his new understanding of the world.
Writers: Benjamin Epps, David Guy Levy, Steffen Schlachtenhaufen
Release Date: 06 Dec 2019
Runtime: 79 min
Rating: TV-MA
Country: United States
Language: English, Spanish