Westworld: Season One 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Review
Metal Tin
Score: 79
from 5 reviewers
Review Date:
Westworld: Season One UHD offers a compelling A/V upgrade with stunning Dolby Vision and Atmos, though video improvements remain subtle.
Disc Release Date
2K Upscale
HDR10
Dolby Vision
Dolby Atmos
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 79
Westworld: Season One's 4K UHD Blu-ray presentation, upscaled from a 2K digital intermediate, features subtle but noticeable enhancements with HDR and Dolby Vision, enriching colors and contrast. While differences from the 1080p Blu-ray are modest, the 4K version offers increased depth and a more cinematic experience, though CGI effects occasionally distract.
Audio: 87
The Dolby Atmos track for Westworld's 4K UHD Blu Ray elevates the audio experience with its remarkable clarity, precise sound placement, and immersive sound stage. The score by Ramin Djawadi shines through individual instruments heard in 3D space, while robust bass and well-defined effects enhance the overall atmosphere, surpassing the already impressive DTS-HD MA on Blu-ray.
Extra: 59
The "Westworld: Season One" 4K UHD Blu-ray set impressively includes all extras on both UHD and Blu-ray discs without HDR, offering an insightful exploration of themes and production through interviews, behind-the-scenes footage, and detailed commentary, though some content remains brief and typical of EPK materials.
Show: 91
Westworld: Season One, re-imagined from Crichton’s 1973 film, combines stunning visuals in 4K UHD and a star-studded cast to unravel intricate themes of artificial intelligence, consciousness, and humanity. With twists and profound character arcs led by Anthony Hopkins, this engaging series challenges perceptions, ensuring viewers remain on the edge of their seats.
Video: 79
The video presentation of the 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "Westworld: Season One" maintains a notably clean and bright aesthetic. Shot on 35mm film but finished as a 2K digital intermediate, the upscale to 2160p via HEVC (H.265) codec delivers a well-detailed image with admirable skin textures, clothing weaves, and vivid environmental details. The show’s color palette is effectively enhanced, with vibrant reds in the arid landscapes and lush greens in the park’s forests, while blues maintain their depth and richness. HDR contributes to an extended color gamut and refined contrasts, producing a picture that subtly enhances landscape shots and pinpoint light sources, though overall improvements remain modest compared to the standard Blu-ray.
Despite substantial improvements in element such as contrast and color depth, discerned particularly in high-detail scenes like Utah’s mountainous vistas and costume textures, the 4K HDR’s differences from its 1080p counterpart are nuanced rather than transformative. The Dolby Vision HDR option, albeit unadvertised on packaging, brings additional pop to colors and details, deepening contrasts for more immersive visuals—particularly noticeable indoors and in night scenes where intricate black levels enhance creaky environments. However, CGI effects might occasionally appear less cohesive due to the heightened resolution.
Nevertheless, "Westworld’s" UHD experience is second to none for detail-oriented viewers. The enhancements to shadow detail and the cinematic nature of the grain structure offer viewers a richer engagement with the material. While some might see the upgrade as incremental given the subtle distinctions from the Blu-ray version, aficionados will appreciate the deeper saturation levels and distinctiveness that HDR brightness and darkness balance bring to this visual spectacle. Overall, this 4K release exemplifies Warner’s leap into UHD territory, setting a hopeful precedent for future series releases.
Audio: 87
The audio presentation of "Westworld: Season One" on 4K UHD Blu-ray is an exquisite demonstration of the Dolby Atmos sound mix, elevating the already impressive DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 soundtrack found on standard Blu-rays. The Dolby Atmos track provides a significant enhancement with its three-dimensional soundscape, allowing individual instruments, such as those in Ramin Djawadi’s evocative score, to emerge dynamically from different spatial locations. This meticulous sonic placement offers listeners a robust and immersive experience where the deep, controlled bass underpins the expansive soundstage.
Renowned for its capacity to differentiate audio elements, the Atmos remix significantly enhances environmental sounds and action effects. Gunfire and horse gallops resonate with more intensity and precision, giving viewers an impactful auditory experience that complements the visual spectacle. Critically, dialogue remains clear and precisely directed within this intricate mix, ensuring no loss of clarity even amidst complex scenes. The sparing yet effective usage of overhead channels expands the auditory dimensions without overwhelming the listener, marking a notable improvement over its DTS-HD MA counterpart.
Additionally, the loudness of the Atmos mix does not equate to mere volume increase but rather accentuates the refinement in placement and clarity, drawing viewers deeper into the narrative’s atmosphere. The 4K UHD presentation capitalizes on height channels to deliver precise sound placements, enriching scenes such as the Westworld facilities with added vertical activity that conveys vastness in otherwise visually confined spaces. This level of audio intricacy showcases a marked elevation from the Blu-ray's already admirable sound quality, making the Dolby Atmos mix a compelling enhancement for audiophiles and casual viewers alike.
Extras: 59
The 4K UHD Blu-ray of "Westworld: Season One" delivers a comprehensive set of revealing extras, intriguingly up-scaled to match the Ultra HD presentation yet devoid of HDR enhancement. This meticulous compilation, mirrored across both the UHD and standard Blu-ray versions, ensures an uninterrupted and seamless experience of behind-the-scenes insights. The extra features, albeit varied in length and depth, provide a window into the intricate world of Westworld, with significant contributions from cast and creators like Jonathan Nolan and Lisa Joy, and engaging commentary on pivotal plot twists and the imaginative title sequence. These extras add substantial value to the viewing experience, offering both lighthearted gags and deep dives into narrative crafting, demonstrating a keen attention to detail both visually and narratively.
Extras included in this disc:
- About the Series: Insights from executive producers and cast members on the concept of a Westworld theme park.
- An Invitation to Set: Cast and crew speculate about the limitations in a Westworld-like world.
- The Big Moment: Look at pivotal reveals across episodes.
- Welcome to Westworld: Behind-the-scenes footage exploring the series.
- Realizing the Dream: A glimpse at the first week filming in Utah.
- Imagining the Main Titles: In-depth exploration of the title sequence creation.
- Reality of A.I.: Westworld: Discussion on robotics' possibilities in Westworld.
- Gag Reel: Amusing goofs from the set.
- The Key to the Chords: Examination of the player piano's symbolism.
- Crafting the Narrative: Detailed commentary by Nolan and Joy on season finale scenes.
- Booklet: Mock corporate guidebook for Westworld employees.
Show: 91
Westworld: Season One is a thought-provoking and visually stunning re-imagining of Michael Crichton's 1973 classic, masterfully adapted by Jonathan Nolan and Lisa Joy. This modern take delves deep into themes of self-awareness, control, and sentience, weaving intricate narratives that challenge our perceptions and intellect. The series features a stellar cast, including Anthony Hopkins as Dr. Robert Ford, Ed Harris as the enigmatic Man in Black, Evan Rachel Wood as Dolores, and Thandie Newton as Maeve. These characters navigate a richly constructed setting of a futuristic Wild West theme park where human-like "hosts" entertain guests in ways limited only by imagination, questioning the boundaries of humanity and artificial intelligence.
The 4K UHD Blu-ray format offers an exceptional viewing experience, maintaining high-definition clarity and sound that elevates the show’s already impressive cinematography and effects. HBO’s decision to release Westworld in this premium quality reflects the series’ importance as a hallmark in their programming history. The limited edition packaging is both stylish and functional, housing six discs across 4K and standard Blu-ray formats along with bonus features directly accessible on the UHD discs.
Season One is an engaging puzzle box that requires viewer investment, rewarding repeated viewing with its complex storyline and careful attention to detail. Its bold narrative structure keeps audiences guessing through its dynamic character arcs and unpredictable twists. This iteration of Westworld not only explores the philosophical ramifications of artificial intelligence but does so with a blend of haunting poetry and intense drama. While the series is deeply rooted in introspective science fiction themes akin to Ex Machina or Blade Runner 2049, it maintains a unique narrative voice that ensures it remains a standout in contemporary television.
Total: 79
The 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "Westworld: Season One" encapsulates the innovative essence of the series while providing a satisfactory, though not groundbreaking, video presentation. Originating from a 2K digital intermediate, the UHD format delivers subtle yet meaningful improvements over its 1080p Blu-ray counterpart. Viewers can expect enhanced deep blacks, more nuanced grading, and enriched color representation with the added depth of HDR. The 4K presentation melds traditional storytelling with advanced visuals, creating a comprehensive viewing experience.
The auditory enhancements are where the 4K edition truly shines. The inclusion of a Dolby Atmos track offers significant advancements in audio depth, ensuring ambience and effects resonate vividly while maintaining pristine dialogue clarity. This audio upgrade renders the viewing experience deeply immersive, outclassing the standard DTS-HD MA track found on the Blu-ray edition. Such improvements transform each scene into an acoustic delight, best appreciated with accompanying superior sound systems.
Despite a lean collection of special features, the extras housed directly on the UHD discs offer insightful glimpses into the production’s creative process. The show itself, under the visionary guidance of Jonathan Nolan and Lisa Joy, boasts a compelling narrative filled with unexpected twists and thematic depth. While there's room for growth in future seasons in terms of fully realizing the potential of 4K resolution, this release undoubtedly merits a place in any collection. At its heart, "Westworld: Season One" is a beautifully crafted narrative wrapped in an impressive AV package that beckons for repeated viewings and future-proofing collections.
avforums review by Simon CrustRead review here
Video: 80
There are occasional bouts of softness in the image common to both 1080 and 4K, while the natural grain structure remains intact and is due to the filming technique....
Audio: 90
The Dolby Atmos track has no such issues though, with Ramin Djawadi’s score taking the brunt of the action with individual instruments coming from different areas in 3D space making for a cohesive whole...
Extras: 60
Crafting the Narrative – A far more substantial 30 minutes has Nolan and Joy filmed while commenting on selected scenes of the season finale bringing in themes, ideas and monologues....
Movie: 100
HBO’s 2016 show uses this idea but expands upon it to include the nature of self-awareness, control and sentience, using multi-layered story threads that interweave with each other, twisting and turning...
Total: 90
The extras package is a tad light, but all are housed on the UHD discs and make for interesting, if brief, viewing....
Blu-ray.com review by Michael ReubenRead review here
Video: 70
If one compares the UHD image to the standard Blu-ray, the former is a touch brighter, but overall Westworld's presentations in 4K and 1080p are so close that I am hard-pressed to recommend the additional...
Audio: 100
Some of the most interesting enhancements occur in the rendering of Ramin Djawadi's memorable score, where specific instruments were already being nudged to left or right in the 5.1 mix....
Extras: 50
In the current edition, the UHDs arrive with a set of standard Blu-rays in a metal tin that houses a six-disc case and the mock "handbook for new employees" of the Westworld theme park....
Movie: 80
A re-imagining of Michael Crichton's 1973 thriller of the same name, the series is lavishly mounted, impeccably cast and produced with all the benefits of the latest in both digital and practical effects....
Total: 80
Perhaps when Season Two arrives (and it is now in production), the creative team will take the extra step of finishing the show at 4K resolution, which can be downconverted for broadcast but should also...
Blu-ray Authority review by Matt BrightonRead review here
Video: 90
If memory serves, this is Warner’s first television series in the Ultra HD format and perhaps one of the first out there period....
Audio: 90
Of course, the included DTS HD Master Audio on the Blu-ray’s isn’t exactly bad either, so if you’re not set up for the “next gen” experience, fear not – either way you go you’ll be just fine....
Extras: 60
The Key to the Chords – We get some insight into the use of the piano player as a point of reference to the series....
Movie: 0
But it’s a diamond in the rough that stands out and Westworld, a show based off Michael Crichton’s 1973 film of the same name, is one that blew audiences (and critics) away....
Total: 80
It certainly sets the stage for things to come, has enough supplements to warrant a purchase and it’s a great show to boot....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 100
You also get a better sense of the show's grain structure making it appear all the more cinematic....
Audio: 100
While some Atmos object-based mixes can sound a bit overbearing, being loud for loudness sake, this mix gives you a terrific sense of atmosphere and space while allowing you to appreciate focused sound...
Extras: 60
This is easily the best bonus feature of the bunch as Nolan and Joy discuss the show in a commentary during the final episode....
Movie: 100
This isn't some virtual reality situation where there is a clear line drawn in the sand by copious amounts of hardware, sensors, and weighty headgear; what happens to the park's attractions is physical...
Total: 80
The show works as a commentary on contemporary times and the exploitation of others for entertainment value while also managing to offer up more than a few striking and outright creepy ideas about the...
Home Theater Forum review by Todd ErwinRead review here
Video: 100
The wisps of very fine blonde facial hair on actress Sidse Babett Knudsen are also more noticeable, as are the textures of her black blouse, which is much softer and less defined on the included 1080p...
Audio: 100
The Dolby Atmos, when played back in a 5.1.2 configuration, offers a more pronounced low end while opening up the soundstage with additional height channels that allow for more precise placement of audio,...
Extras: 70
Realizing the Dream: First Week on the Set of Westworld (1080p; 11:20): A look at the many sets and locations in Utah....
Movie: 90
Anthony Hopkins leads an all-star cast as Dr. Robert Ford, who runs and creates many of the “hosts” that populate the high-end theme park where adults can live out their fantasies in a western setting....
Total: 90
A mind-bending series full of twists, turns, violence, sex, and nudity, Warner/HBO’s Westworld is an exciting first season of ten episodes, with ten more set to air on the pay channel early next year....
Director: N/A
Actors: Evan Rachel Wood, Jeffrey Wright, Ed Harris
PlotIn a futuristic world, a technologically advanced theme park allows guests to immerse themselves in an Old West fantasy populated by highly sophisticated humanoid robots known as hosts. These hosts, designed to cater to the visitors' every desire and whim, follow intricate storylines crafted by the park's creators. They are periodically wiped clean of memories to ensure fresh narratives. Central to the narrative is Dolores, a rancher's daughter host whose seemingly routine existence is upended as she slowly becomes aware of her true nature and begins to question the reality around her. Meanwhile, park guests indulge in adventures ranging from romantic escapades to violent encounters, fully exploiting the lack of consequences. Bernard, a key park technician, works tirelessly to maintain the park's delicate balance while grappling with his own suspicions that not everything at the park is as it seems.
The plot unfolds through multiple timelines, exploring themes of consciousness, free will, and the ethical ramifications of artificial intelligence. The creators of the park, Dr. Robert Ford and others, wrestle with the potential dangers of their creations gaining autonomy. As hosts begin to experience memories of past events, cracks emerge in the park's seamless façade. The boundaries between reality and artificiality blur, leading to unpredictable outcomes. The underlying tension escalates as different characters pursue their own agendas: some seeking enlightenment, some revenge, and others control over the park's vast potential. Conflicts arise not only between humans and hosts but also within each group as allegiances shift and true intentions are revealed. This exploration challenges the visitors and hosts to confront their identities and what it means to be sentient.
Writers: Lisa Joy, Jonathan Nolan
Release Date: 02 Oct 2016
Runtime: 62 min
Rating: TV-MA
Country: United States
Language: English