The Adventures of Baron Munchausen 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Review
Score: 89
from 4 reviewers
Review Date:
Baron Munchausen's 4K release by Criterion dazzles, with rich extras and widespread acclaim.
Disc Release Date
True 4K
HDR10
Dolby Vision
DTS-HD MA
Video: 95
The Adventures of Baron Munchausen's 4K Blu-ray restoration, supervised by Sony and Gilliam, boasts stunning HDR visuals, detailed textures, and a faithful 1.85:1 presentation.
Audio: 84
The restored 5.1 DTS-HD MA soundtrack of 'The Adventures of Baron Munchausen' impresses with clear dialogue and a vibrant score, despite its modest bass and limited surround effects.
Extra: 91
The Adventures of Baron Munchausen release features a rich array of content, including detailed commentaries, historical essays, behind-the-scenes insights into special effects, and a celebration of its legacy.
Movie: 83
Terry Gilliam's visually stunning 'The Adventures of Baron Munchausen' entertains with a fantastical narrative, enhanced by a Criterion 4K restoration and rich extras.
Video: 95
The 4K UHD Blu-ray presentation of "The Adventures of Baron Munchausen" impresses with its visually stunning restoration, presenting a vivid and lively color palette that breathes new life into Terry Gilliam's fantastical epic. With the original film shot on 35mm film using Arriflex 35BL cameras and spherical Zeiss lenses, framed at 1.85:1, the restoration effort led by Sony Pictures Entertainment has meticulously maintained the film’s cinematic essence. The 4K wet-gate scan of the original camera negative by Cineric, Inc., followed by digital image restoration at Prasad, and HDR color grading under the supervision of Grover Crisp and Terry Gilliam, ensures that every frame reflects the director’s vision. The result is an image that boasts vibrant primaries, clean delineation, and textures that offer depth and clarity rarely seen in films of this era.
The transfer showcases the detailed production design, striking use of color by cinematographer Giuseppe Rotunno, and the imaginative costumes, blending them harmoniously to accentuate the film’s storied visual tapestry. The Dolby Vision HDR implementation enriches scenes with expanded dynamic range, making the visuals pop with a clarity that exceeds standard definitions. Noteworthy is how the transfer adeptly handles the effects shots, integrating them seamlessly into the live-action footage, thus preserving the film's original charm while enhancing it for modern viewing standards.
The Criterion release offers both a 4K Blu-ray and Blu-ray disc, with the former presenting the feature in Dolby Vision HDR, ensuring compatibility across viewing platforms. This restoration not only highlights the technical prowess involved in its undertaking but also solidifies "The Adventures of Baron Munchausen" as a visually captivating work that continues to enchant audiences, making this 4K UHD Blu-ray a paramount example of preserving and celebrating cinematic artistry.
Audio: 84
The audio presentation of "The Adventures of Baron Munchausen" on 4K UHD Blu-Ray features a meticulously restored soundtrack, now presented in a DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 format, refined from its original 2004 upmix. This restoration effort ensures that the film’s auditory experience matches its visual splendor, showcasing sparkling clarity across all channels. The dialogue is particularly noteworthy for its refined quality, blending seamlessly with the front channels to enhance the storytelling. Despite being predominantly front-oriented, the mix adeptly supports the film's dynamic range, from Michael Kamen's whimsical score to the robust soundscapes of battle scenes, without compromising on tonal distinction or immersive quality.
With only one standard audio track available in English DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1, supplemented by optional English SDH subtitles, the release makes clear its commitment to an authentic listening experience. The absence of anomalies and the solidity of the lossless track contribute to a deeply engaging aural journey. Initial and concluding siege sequences benefit from impressive dynamic intensity, yet the overall surround engagement is relatively subdued, focusing on ambient and occasional directional effects without extensive use of deep bass, even during more explosive moments. This restraint does little to detract from the enjoyment of Kamen’s score, which remains a high point of the audio mix.
Despite historical uncertainties regarding the existence of a 6-track mix, the 5.1 track—upmixed from the original 4-track Dolby master—exhibits a clean and adequate mix that pairs well with the visually restored film. The limited low-end response and relatively conservative use of the surround channels might not meet every expectation for blockbuster bombast but serve well to complement the film's fantastical storytelling and visual style. The careful balance between music, dialogue, and effects demonstrates a sound design that, while it may not heavily prioritize immersive depth or extensive directional schoolwork, excels in delivering a coherent and engaging audio experience that respects the original artistic visions of Gilliam and Kamen.
Extras: 91
The special features of "The Adventures of Baron Munchausen" 4K UHD Blu-ray set offer a comprehensive behind-the-scenes look that fans and newcomers alike will find engrossing. From the detailed, reflective audio commentary by Terry Gilliam and Charles McKeown to the extensive three-part documentary "The Madness and Misadventures of Munchausen," viewers are treated to deep dives into the film's tumultuous production history and its creative process. Gilliam's narration of the special effects footage provides fascinating insights into the innovative techniques used, while the deleted scenes with commentary, storyboards for unfilmed scenes, and original marketing materials offer additional layers of context. The inclusion of "Miracle of Flight," an animated short by Gilliam, alongside a new video essay and a 1991 episode of "The South Bank Show," enriches the understanding of Gilliam's career and influences. The set ensures that every extra embellishes the lore and legacy of this fantastical film.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: Featuring Terry Gilliam and Charles McKeown, reflecting on the film's production.
- The Madness and Misadventures of Munchausen: A detailed three-part documentary on the film's history.
- Special Effects: Narrated by Terry Gilliam, showcasing behind-the-scenes footage.
- Deleted Scenes: Four scenes with optional commentary by Gilliam.
- Storyboards for Unfilmed Scenes: Including introductions by Gilliam and McKeown.
- Marketing Munchausen: Original marketing proposals and materials narrated by Gilliam.
- The Astonishing (and Really True) History of Baron Munchausen: A video essay by David Cairns.
- The South Bank Show: A 1991 episode focusing on Gilliam.
- Miracle of Flight: A 1974 animated short film by Gilliam.
- Leaflet: Featuring an essay by Michael Koresky and technical credits.
Movie: 83
Terry Gilliam's The Adventures of Baron Munchausen, presented in a stunning 4K UHD Blu-ray by Criterion, embarks viewers on a journey that transcends the ordinary, whisking them away to a world where the bounds of imagination are limitless. Venturing from tumultuous European cities under siege to the far reaches of the moon and the depths of the ocean within a sea monster, the film showcases Gilliam’s unique ability to blend the fantastical with the visually extravagant. This restoration, supervised and approved by Gilliam himself, breathes new life into the Baron's tall tales, making every frame a testament to the director’s vision and the elaborate production design that brought Munchausen's adventures to vibrant life. The film’s audacity to reimagine and expand upon the legendary exploits of Hieronymus Karl Friedrich, Freiherr von Münchhausen, underscores a fearless creative spirit, supported by Columbia under the aegis of David Puttnam, despite the financial specter that loomed from past ambitious projects.
At its core, The Adventures of Baron Munchausen is more than just a visual feast; it is a poignant narrative about belief, vitality, and the refusal to succumb to the mundane realities of life. With performances that range from John Neville’s titular character to Sarah Polley’s emotionally grounding Sally Salt, alongside a cast of zany, yet endearing characters, the film champions the enduring power of storytelling and imagination. The 4K restoration ensures that every detail, from the intricate set pieces to the dynamic spectrum of colors that adorn Gilliam’s canvas, is displayed with unparalleled clarity. The soundtrack complements the visual artistry by enhancing the film’s exotic and whimsical atmosphere, immersing viewers completely in the Baron’s exaggerated yet heartfelt world.
Criterion’s commitment to preserving cinematic history is evident in this release, which not only serves as a tribute to Gilliam's creative genius but also as a reminder of the film’s undeserved reputation as an over-budget cautionary tale. Instead, this 4K presentation repositions The Adventures of Baron Munchausen as a landmark in fantasy cinema - a film brimming with creativity, ambition, and an infectious spirit of adventure. Delving into the Baron's stories again through this restoration is like rediscovering a world where miracles are not only possible but essential for keeping the spark of life alight. Through its technical excellence and emotional depth, this version of The Adventures of Baron Munchausen encourages viewers to embrace their inner dreamer and revel in the boundless realms of imagination.
Total: 89
The 4K UHD release of "The Adventures of Baron Munchausen" by The Criterion Collection is a delightful presentation that captures the essence and imaginative spirit of Terry Gilliam's fantastical adventure. This release not only stands out for its beautifully restored audio and video quality that breathes new life into the film's stunning visuals and engrossing narrative but also for an extensive collection of extras that cater to both longtime fans and newcomers alike. Despite some notable omissions from its archival material, such as the solo commentary from Gilliam available in the 1992 CAV LaserDisc boxed set, the package compensates with a wealth of other supplemental content including production photographs, sketches, and exhaustive script analyses that deepen the viewing experience.
Critics and viewers alike will find the 4K makeover to be a revelation, showcasing the film’s intricate details and vibrant color palette as never seen before. It retains Gilliam's unique blend of fantasy and adventure, infused with his characteristic quirks and creativity, making it more accessible and resonant with a broader audience. This release does justice to an often underappreciated gem in Gilliam’s oeuvre, presenting it in a format that highlights its visual and narrative complexity. Fans will especially appreciate the inclusion of both new and previously released bonus materials that enrich the context and appreciation for the film.
In conclusion, this 4K UHD Blu-ray edition of "The Adventures of Baron Munchausen" is an exemplary release that showcases The Criterion Collection's dedication to preserving cinematic history while enhancing viewer engagement through superior picture quality and comprehensive bonus features. While some previous materials were missed, the overall package offers enough value to make it a must-have for collectors and cinephiles. It reaffirms the film's status as a timeless piece of cinema, now presented in a manner that ensures it can be appreciated anew by future generations.
Blu-ray.com review by Dr. Svet AtanasovRead review here
Video: 100
So, I was very impressed with the quality of the work that was done during the 4K makeover and its transition to 4K Blu-ray and Blu-ray....
Audio: 100
As you know well, The Adventures of Baron Munchausen has a terrific music score that does plenty to produce various contrasts, so I was very glad to hear how solid the lossless track is....
Extras: 100
The Astonishing (and Really True) History of Baron Munchausen - this exclusive new video essay was created by critic David Cairns in 2022....
Movie: 90
The visuals were so seductive that it felt great to be on the other side, believing and enjoying Baron Munchausen's ridiculous adventures....
Total: 100
Virtually all of the messages that emerge from it easily resonate with me, plus it is a stunningly beautiful tour de force that at times takes my breath away....
The Digital Bits review by Stephen BjorkRead review here
Video: 100
For this 4K version, the original camera negative was wet-gate scanned at 4K resolution by Cineric, Inc. in New York, with restoration work performed by Prasad in Burbank....
Audio: 85
The restoration notes in the Criterion booklet describe the 5.1 track as having been upmixed back in 2004, so presumably that was done from the original 4-track Dolby master, as a 6-track mix wouldn’t...
Extras: 100
It demonstrates why they were able to work together repeatedly despite all of the chaos, as the two of them have a natural, easygoing chemistry with each other, and their senses of humor are certainly...
Movie: 90
At that point during the late Eighties, all of Hollywood was still smarting after the implosion of United Artists over the production of Heaven’s Gate, and Brazil had served as a good reminder that giving...
Total: 94
That’s all of the extras from the 2008 Sony Blu-ray plus plenty more, but oddly enough for a Criterion Collection release, it’s still missing some of their own material from their 1992 CAV LaserDisc boxed...
High-Def Digest review by Justin RemerRead review here
Video: 100
I was struck by the detailed textures of Dante Feretti’s production design, cinematographer Giuseppe Rotunno’s striking use of both drab and sumptuous color palettes in different sections of the story,...
Audio: 80
The soundtrack is not overwhelming in immersive or directional effects, but it is well-supported and offers a nice showcase for the playful score by Gilliam’s music collaborator from Brazil, Michael Kamen....
Extras: 90
The Madness and Misadventures of Munchausen (HD 72:18) - Also brought over from the 2008 Blu, this three-part documentary offers a thorough look into the tumultuous production and release of this film....
Movie: 80
The unnamed 18th Century European city that serves as the film’s main setting is under constant bombardment, which Gilliam stages like a grand, explosion-filled battle epic where no one appears to be winning...
Total: 90
Terry Gilliam’s MAD Magazine-meets-Federico Fellini compositions are reproduced in beautiful detail in this new 4K UHD presentation from Criterion Collection....
AVSForum review by Ralph PottsRead review here
Video: 96
Colors are tonally balanced with lustrous primaries, clean rendering and, delineated secondary hues that all look terrific....
Audio: 86
Similar to the film restoration it is readily apparent that plenty of care went into the redesigned audio....
Extras: 80
Disc 1: The Adventures of Baron Munchausen Ultra HD Blu-ray Disc 2: The Adventures of Baron Munchausen Blu-ray Disc 3: Special Features Blu-ray Audio commentary featuring Gilliam and his coscreenwriter,...
Movie: 80
Inspired by the extravagant exploits of the fabled Baron Munchausen, this spectacle—born of a famously turbulent production—follows the whimsical eighteenth-century nobleman as he embarks on an outlandish...
Total: 86
It comes to Ultra HD in this 4K/Blu-ray offering from The Criterion Collection featuring beautifully restored and faithful audio/video quality mated with a fan friendly supplement set....
Director: Terry Gilliam
Actors: John Neville, Eric Idle, Sarah Polley
PlotIn an 18th-century European city under siege from the Ottoman Empire, a theatrical troupe is performing a play about the legendary Baron Munchausen's fantastical adventures. As the play unfolds, an elderly man claiming to be the real Baron interrupts, insisting that the portrayal is all wrong. To the astonishment of the audience, he begins recounting his incredible life story, offering an entirely different narrative filled with his preposterous exploits. The Baron's tales feature his supernatural companions: a man with superhuman speed, another with incredible strength, a sharpshooter with uncanny accuracy, and one with preternatural lung capacity. During his narrative, the city continues to endure the siege, with danger drawing ever closer. As his story weaves through the past and the present, the Baron's audaciousness captivates the crowd, offering a fleeting glimpse of hope amid despair.
Determined to prove his stories true and to save the beleaguered city, the Baron sets out on a quest to find his old friends. A young girl from the audience named Sally becomes swept up in the Baron's mission, joining him on his journey. Together, they embark through a landscape of myth and wonder, encountering monstrous sea creatures, the Grim Reaper, and the treachery of a sultan. Each encounter presents a test that draws upon the extraordinary abilities of his companions and the Baron's own unyielding spirit. As they venture beyond the confines of reality, their adventures challenge the distinction between myth and truth, blurring the lines of what is genuinely possible.
Writers: Charles McKeown, Terry Gilliam, Gottfried August Bürger
Release Date: 10 Mar 1989
Runtime: 126 min
Rating: PG
Country: United Kingdom, West Germany, Spain, United States
Language: English