The Smurfs 2 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Review
Score: 77
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
'Smurfs 2' lacks original's charm but shines in UHD, pleasing for families.
Disc Release Date
True 4K
HDR10
Dolby Atmos
DTS-HD MA
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 87
The Smurfs 2 UHD Blu-ray dazzles with vibrant colors & sharp details, improving upon the already excellent 1080p version, making it a demo-worthy showcase.
Audio: 87
The Smurfs in Paris UHD release dazzles with a reference-quality, flawless Dolby Atmos mix, enhancing dialogue, effects, and providing an immersive soundscape.
Extra: 60
The Smurfs 2 Blu-ray supplements include unremarkable extras and character highlights in 2160p with Dolby Atmos, but lack new features, offering only a mix of deleted scenes, featurettes, and a short film, without substantial additions from its first release.
Movie: 37
While 'Smurfs: The Lost Village' revives animated charm, prior movies offer a mix of joy and disappointment, with technical upgrades like UHD Blu-ray enhancing viewing. Yet, sequels struggle with freshness and depth.
Video: 87
The 4K UHD Blu-ray presentation of "The Smurfs 2" showcases an exquisite upgrade from its already impressive 1080p counterpart, reinforcing its status as a reference-quality visual spectacle. Despite originating from a 2K Digital Intermediate (DI), the upscale to 2160p in the film's original 1.85:1 theatrical aspect ratio delivers an eye-popping visual feast. Enhanced by HDR and WCG, colors burst with vibrancy, showcasing varied shades of blue among the Smurfs and rendering detailed textures in their clothing and environments with striking clarity. The attention to detail extends to subtle nuances in fabric weaves of the Smurfs' attire and the textured complexity of Gargamel's robe, revealing intricate stitches and frays not discernible in previous releases. This presentation benefits from an HEVC (H.265) encoding, boasting deep, inky blacks and a broadened color spectrum that breathes life into every scene, from the lush greenery to the vividly imagined candy store, making each frame a testament to the power of UHD technology.
Detail enhancement is a significant highlight, with the Ultra HD version uncovering layers of complexity in textures and fabrics that were previously overlooked. Scenes are imbued with a newfound depth, allowing for a more immersive viewing experience. The precision in rendering facial features and backgrounds contributes to an overall image that appears more three-dimensional, even without 3D technology. The improvements in resolution and color handling are particularly evident when comparing the UHD disc to its Blu-ray counterpart, with finer shading and more pronounced details across the board.
This UHD release sets a new standard in home video presentation quality. The meticulous detail, combined with the dynamic range of colors, elevates "The Smurfs 2" beyond its digital origins, offering an unparalleled viewing experience. From the enhanced clarity in the Smurfs' clothing to the richer, more nuanced color palette, every aspect of the visual presentation has been refined. Moreover, the absence of common digital artifacts ensures a pristine picture that will impress even the most discerning viewers. For those seeking to showcase the capabilities of their 4K UHD setups, this release of "The Smurfs 2" represents a prime example of how far home entertainment technology has come, making it a must-own for enthusiasts and newcomers alike.
Audio: 87
Sony's UHD Blu-ray release of "The Smurfs 2" features an exceptional Dolby Atmos track, which significantly elevates the audio experience over its predecessor, the DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track from the previous Blu-ray release. This upgraded Atmos soundtrack provides a fully immersive listening environment, especially when experienced through a 7.1.4 speaker setup, incorporating traditional seven-channel surround sound with a subwoofer and adding four overhead speakers for a complete multidimensional audio experience. The Atmos mix excels in delivering both subtle ambiance and dynamic action, creating a vibrant soundscape that ranges from the delicate flapping of pigeon wings to the thunderous roar of a giant ferris wheel detaching and ominously rolling down the street. Such sequences not only showcase the track's exceptional use of the overhead channels but also its ability to seamlessly blend these effects with the core surround sound, producing a cohesive and compelling audio bubble that envelops the listener.
Dialogue is consistently clear and well-prioritized, anchored firmly in the center channel and supplemented by strong ADR work, ensuring that conversations are always intelligible amidst the bustling Parisian backdrop and magical mayhem. The mix's dynamic range is further enhanced by its varied and ambitious sound effects, which include everything from magical portals swirling to cars swooshing by from a Smurf's eye view. These elements are complemented by a robust bass response and a well-integrated score that, while perhaps not memorable to all listeners, supports the film's energetic pace without overwhelming it.
In terms of technical quality, the Dolby Atmos track is impeccable, with no detectable pops, cracks, hiss, or shrillness. Ambient sounds, such as bustling cityscapes and nature sounds from the Smurf world, are delivered with exceptional clarity across all channels. The soundtrack maintains a precise sound definition throughout, ensuring that every note of music and sound effect is crisp and authoritative. Whether it's the weighty impact of action sequences or the more nuanced sound of ambient environmental details, the audio presentation of "The Smurfs 2" on 4K UHD Blu-ray stands as a reference-quality achievement, demonstrating what is possible with modern home theater audio technology.
Extras: 60
Maintaining the tone and technical focus from the inputs, the 4K UHD Blu-ray extras for "The Smurfs 2" are relegated to the Blu-ray disc, offering a mix of character highlights in superior 2160p video quality and Dolby Atmos audio, and a smattering of other features that delve into the animation and character development. Notably, the Character Specific Highlights section provides a new way to engage with the film through individual explorations of Smurfette, Gargamel, The Winslows, and The Naughties. However, beyond this innovation, the extras fall into familiar territory with deleted scenes, featurettes on specific characters like Smurfette and Azrael, and the standout short film, "The Legend of Smurfy Hollow." While presenting no new supplements exclusive to the UHD disc itself, the inclusion of a sleek new menu system hints at a possible standard for future Sony UHD releases.
Extras included in this disc:
Character Specific Highlights: Scenes featuring key characters in full 2160p and Dolby Atmos audio.
Daddy's Little Girl: The Journey of Smurfette: A featurette discussing Smurfette's role and Katy Perry's contribution.
Animating Azrael: Focuses on the effects used for Gargamel's cat.
Deleted Scenes: Five short scenes that were cut from the final film.
Trailers: Previews for other films.
The Smurfs: The Legend of Smurfy Hollow: A short film reverting to classic 2D animation style.
Evolution of the Naughties: Explores the creation of new characters Hackus and Vexy.
The Puurrfect Companion: Azrael's Tail: Looks at the production of Gargamel's cat, including live-action and CGI elements.
The Naughties! The Tale of Hackus and Vexy: Discusses the new characters' roles, design, and voice talent.
Movie: 37
"The Smurfs 2," presented in 4K UHD Blu-ray, revisits the antics of the beloved blue creatures in a sequel that, while visually pleasing, struggles to capture the charm and humor of its predecessor. The transfer to 4K (3840x2160p resolution) showcases bright colors and detailed animations, making the Parisian backdrop and the chaotic yet fun scenes within Smurf Village pop with vivacity. The attention to visual detail is commendable, providing a crisp and immersive viewing experience. However, the enhancements in visual quality are sometimes overshadowed by less engaging narrative elements and musical selections that might not universally appeal.
Narratively, the film shifts gears to Paris, attempting to infuse novelty by expanding Gargamel's nefarious schemes and introducing new characters such as the Naughties. Despite standout performances by Hank Azaria as Gargamel and Brendan Gleeson in a comedic role, the return of the live-action cast feels somewhat obligatory, lacking the freshness of the first installment. The plot meanders, leaning heavily on slapstick humor and a rehashed storyline that fails to innovate beyond its foundational elements. Additionally, the 3D presentation is criticized for its lack of depth and clarity, detracting from the overall cinematic experience.
Technical aspects of this release deserve mention; alongside the standard 50GB Blu-ray Disc, the UHD 4K Blu-ray Disc enhances the film's visual appeal. However, despite high expectations attached to Sony's UHD Blu-ray releases, "The Smurfs 2" falls short in delivering a compelling narrative. The sequel manages to entertain its target demographic with vibrant visuals and a handful of engaging moments but struggles to resonate beyond a youthful audience, reflecting a missed opportunity to build upon the enchanting world of the Smurfs.
Total: 77
In reviewing the 4K UHD Blu-ray presentation of "The Smurfs 2," it becomes evident that while the film itself may not capture the same level of freshness and charm as its predecessor, it stands out for its technical prowess in the home cinema space. The narrative, exploring a decent origin tale for Smurfette, might have been overshadowed by subsequent animated features like "The Lost Village," yet it holds an innocent charm and humor, resonating well with a family-friendly audience. This release shines in showcasing the capabilities of UHD and Dolby Atmos systems, making it a significant asset for early adopters looking to impress with their home entertainment setups.
The video and audio quality of "The Smurfs 2" on 4K UHD are consistently lauded as reference-quality, indicating that the film's technical team has made substantial efforts to ensure this release offers a visually stunning and sonically immersive experience. The utilization of UHD technology not only enhances the vividness of the animation but also envelops the audience in an encompassing sound stage, thanks to its Dolby Atmos track. Despite the lackluster array of extras—which appears to be a carryover from previous editions without any new additions—the overall package is highly recommended for those aiming to demonstrate the prowess of their cutting-edge home cinema systems.
In conclusion, "The Smurfs 2," while not exceeding its inaugural film in terms of narrative creativity or freshness, firmly establishes itself as a must-own title for its exceptional 4K UHD presentation. Its superb video and audio quality provide an optimal showcase for the latest in home entertainment technology, offering a compelling reason for families and early adopters alike to add this to their collection. The film serves as a testament to how advancements in technology can breathe new life into existing content, making it a valuable acquisition despite its cinematic shortcomings.
avforums review by Casimir HarlowRead review here
Video: 100
The Smurfs 2 already made for a fantastic reference title on standard 1080p Blu-ray, and it only looks better here, bringing forth impressive precision and razor-sharp fine object detail, facial observations,...
Audio: 100
A tremendous audio track which is close to flawless Dialogue, predominantly provided by strong ADR work, comes across clearly and coherently throughout, delivered with precision, whilst the effects are...
Extras: 50
As with the release of the first film, and the frustrating general norm for Ultra HD Blu-ray discs, all of the extras are left to the accompanying Blu-ray disc, although, unlike the first film, there isn't...
Movie: 50
Even taking the action to Paris for a new backdrop doesn't really give it any flavour, with much of the lightweight frivolity and easy fun of the first outing replaced by forced, leaden laughs, and vapid,...
Total: 70
Still, it makes for an even more impressive Ultra HD Blu-ray release, with reference video and audio, even if the extras are less than impressive....
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 100
Neil Patrick Harris' heavily textured sweater seen at 28:44 is more complex than it is on 1080p Blu-ray, but perhaps more notable in the same shot is the improvement in raw facial features, another example...
Audio: 100
When Gargamel is introduced at the theater, the announcer's voice seems to emanate from well above the listening position and offers a naturally wide spread reflective of the scene's cavernous auditorium...
Extras: 100
While The Smurfs 2 contains no new "supplements" on the UHD disc, it does offer a slick new menu system (and presumably the early standard for Sony UHD releases) in which different pages are selected by...
Movie: 50
Watch for more reviews for these Sony UHD Blu-rays in the coming days and, of course, Blu-ray.com will be covering every UHD release in the future....
Total: 50
Wonderful picture and involved sound will give the equipment a workout while treating the eyes and ears alike to one of the best, if not the best, UHD releases right out of the gate, considering its technical...
High-Def Digest review by Bryan KlugerRead review here
Video: 100
The scene in the candy store is simply out of this world, color-wise, as each primary and pastel simply pops right off screen and makes each object seem full of life....
Audio: 100
Extras: 40
The Tale of Hackus and Vexy (HD, 6 mins) - The cast and crew discuss the two new characters in this sequel, their roles, the design, and the voice talent....
Movie: 20
One of the only decent things to come out of this sequel is Gleeson, who seems to give it his all in a comedic role, whereas the other actors seem bored to be there and are underused, with the exception...
Total: 70
Picture and sound wise, this film is reference quality up and down the board, so if you have a new UHD set up, make this release a big purchase to show of to your friends and family....
Director: Raja Gosnell
Actors: Neil Patrick Harris, Jayma Mays, Katy Perry
PlotEvil wizard Gargamel is at it again, creating chaos and concocting plans for world domination. After his previous defeat at the hands of the Smurfs, this time he's out for revenge and concocts a devilish plan that brings him to Paris. Gargamel creates a pair of mischievous Smurf-like creatures called the Naughties, Vexy and Hackus, who he hopes will help him harness the magical Smurf-essence. However, Gargamel discovers that only a real Smurf can give him what he needs and his plot takes a wicked turn when he kidnaps Smurfette, the only Smurf who knows a secret spell capable of turning the Naughties into real Smurfs.
Smurfette finds herself in Paris, facing the temptation of the Naughties' mischievous ways. Meanwhile, the Smurfs band together to rescue their dear friend. Papa Smurf takes a bold move and creates a portal to the human world, leading a few select Smurfs to their friends from the past, Patrick and Grace Winslow. The Winslows, joined by their son and Patrick's stepfather, team up with the Smurfs in a race against time. They must navigate the challenges of a bustling Paris and the allure of Gargamel's persuasive offers to Smurfette. As the bonds of family and friendship are tested, they all must work collectively to thwart Gargamel's scheme and save Smurfette before his nefarious plan comes to fruition.
Writers: J. David Stem, David N. Weiss, Jay Scherick
Release Date: 31 Jul 2013
Runtime: 105 min
Rating: PG
Country: United States, France, Canada, Belgium
Language: English, French