Madame Web 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Review
Score: 69
from 4 reviewers
Review Date:
Despite stellar video and audio quality with Dolby Atmos on Sony's 4K UHD Blu-ray, 'Madame Web' is critically seen as a modern superhero misfire.
Disc Release Date
True 4K
HDR10
Dolby Vision
Dolby Atmos
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 83
Despite some criticisms of its cinematography and visual effects, Madame Web's 4K UHD release offers a beautifully encoded 2160p presentation with rich colors, deep black shadows, and minimal artifacts, bolstered by Dolby Vision and HDR10, though it occasionally appears slightly upscaled.
Audio: 83
Madame Web’s 4K UHD Blu-ray boasts impressive visuals with enhanced shadow detail and sharper textures, especially in Dolby Vision. The Dolby Atmos audio track excels with spatial realism, vibrant jungle sounds, and precise directional effects, though LFE output is occasionally lacking. Mid-tier extras complete the package.
Extra: 41
The 4K UHD Blu-ray of 'Madame Web' features various standard extras, including a gag reel, deleted scenes, and brief featurettes on casting, source comics, and action sequences, though none offer substantial content, leaving the overall package underwhelming for a Marvel release.
Movie: 26
"Despite being armed with a notable cast and special effects, 'Madame Web' tragically suffers from an inept script, abysmal acting, and uninspired direction, rendering it an incoherent and historically dreadful addition to the superhero genre."
Video: 83
The 4K UHD Blu-ray presentation of "Madame Web" is a noteworthy release that succeeds in delivering a crisp and technically robust 2160p visual experience. Utilizing HEVC/H.265 encoding and presented in a 2.39:1 aspect ratio on a BD-66 layer, the UHD presentation captures the film's intended look with remarkable precision. Rich colors are rendered vividly, with primary hues popping against deep, inky black shadows, thereby enhancing the overall detail. Despite some subtle digital noise and banding in the background effects, the transfer maintains color consistency and clarity, ensuring that essential details, such as facial textures and environment depth, are presented with high fidelity.
The black levels are well-handled, with no signs of crushing in indoor or nighttime scenes. However, despite the technical strengths of the 4K encode, some visual choices detract from the overall presentation. The cinematography is filtered through an amber haze, leading to slightly pallid flesh tones and an unnatural hue across the board. This results in an intentional but sometimes murky and dry appearance. Additionally, the presence of edge sharpness gives the image an occasionally artificial sharpness without significant gains in texture or fidelity.
Comparisons to the standard Blu-ray demonstrate marked improvements with the UHD release, thanks to enhancements like Dolby Vision and HDR10. The contrast is dialed in perfectly, ensuring a faithful representation of the source material while avoiding common issues such as macroblocking or errant noise. Ultimately, while "Madame Web" may not present a groundbreaking visual masterpiece, it stands out as a technically sound and aesthetically effective 4K UHD Blu-ray release that holds up well under scrutiny.
Audio: 83
The Dolby Atmos audio track on the 4K UHD Blu-ray of "Madame Web" delivers an immersive and detailed sonic experience, even if the film itself leaves much to be desired. The atmospheric soundscapes, particularly in the jungles of Peru, effectively utilize overhead channels to create a vivid auditory environment teeming with leaf-rustling winds and insect buzz. Dialogue remains crisp and clear, perfectly integrated within the mix, ensuring that even the more mundane conversations maintain clarity. Cassie's visions are deftly handled with precise directional effects that envelop the listener in a convincing spatial reality. However, while the LFE output is present and potent in climactic moments, it sometimes lacks the punch needed in early action sequences.
The audio dynamics of "Madame Web" are notable, with strong contributions from all speakers, but especially impactful in action scenes. The sound design captures intricate details—from doors opening and closing during industrial fire scenes to the realistic scattering of glass in a car crash—and adds to the film's overall immersion. Cassie's visions and key scenes, such as those in the subway, make excellent use of rear and height channels to enhance the spatial depth of the soundstage. However, despite these high points, there are areas where low-frequency effects could have been more consistently robust.
While the film’s script may falter, Sony’s technical execution of the Dolby Atmos track ensures that listeners are treated to a superior auditory experience. The audio format includes English Dolby Atmos and DTS-HD TrueHD 7.1, among others, providing options for high-quality playback. Overall, despite some deficiencies in LFE consistency, the audio presentation maintains a high standard that enhances the viewing experience through its rich and well-balanced soundscapes.
Extra: 41
The 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "Madame Web" does not boast a particularly extensive range of extras, potentially due to the film's lackluster box office performance. While it includes a few featurettes, these offerings do not delve deeply into substantial behind-the-scenes material. The supplemental features are primarily composed of a series of standard EPK-style interviews and brief insights into various elements of the film, such as casting, action sequences, and comic origins—each presented with typical talking head interviews from the cast and crew. Unfortunately, the absence of a commentary track or a more comprehensive examination of the film's production leaves much to be desired for avid fans and collectors.
Extras included in this disc:
- Gag Reel: Humorous outtakes from filming.
- Easter Eggs: Hidden references and Easter eggs in the movie.
- Oracle Of The Page: Short insight into the comics that inspired the film.
- Fight Like A Spider: Overview of the film's action sequences.
- Future Vision: Filming techniques for Madame Web's visions.
- Casting The Web: Examination of the casting choices for key roles.
- Deleted Scene: A cut scene from the film.
Movie: 26
"Madame Web" represents a misguided attempt by Sony to expand the Spider-Verse without solid narrative or directional grounding. The film stars Dakota Johnson as Cassandra Webb, a paramedic in 2003 New York who discovers she has latent superpowers from a magic spider venom that her mother, a Peruvian scientist, was searching for. Directed by S.J. Clarkson and written by the team behind "Morbius," the movie falls victim to similar pitfalls with poorly crafted dialogue, uneven pacing, and an illogical plot. Despite having a talented cast that includes Sydney Sweeney, Isabela Merced, and Celeste O’Connor, the film fails to deliver meaningful character development or engaging interactions.
Technically, the film suffers from a host of issues. The action sequences are lackluster, marred by subpar special effects and repetitive time-traveling gimmicks that quickly wear thin. The climax is comically anticlimactic, with the villain Ezekiel Sims (Tahar Rahim) being defeated under a poorly executed product placement—a Pepsi sign—a moment that encapsulates the film's lack of gravitas. Cinematography and production design do little to help, offering hoodies and jackets as superhero garb which contrast sharply against audiences' expectations set by other MCU films. This visual austerity further detracts from the narrative immersion.
The disjointed storytelling cobbles together an origin story filled with clichés and overwrought dialogue, making it difficult for viewers to become invested. The inconsistency is not helped by the film's confused setting; nominally set in 2003, various anachronisms suggest a lack of coherent vision from the creative team. Moreover, the film's incessant reliance on hallmarks from other superhero movies—whether it's characters echoing Yoda-like aphorisms or poorly executed nostalgic nods—makes "Madame Web" appear derivative rather than innovative. Overall, this cinematic misfire highlights Sony's continued struggle to carve a niche within the superhero genre landscape.
Total: 69
"Madame Web" in 4K UHD Blu-Ray offers a mixed bag of technical prowess and cinematic shortcomings. The film, headlined by an impressive cast including Dakota Johnson and Sydney Sweeney, struggles under the weight of its many imperfections. Directed by S.J. Clarkson and shaped by the pen of Matt Sazama, Burk Sharpless, and Claire Parker, this PG-13 rated film aims to expand Sony's Spider-Man-less universe but falls flat in most storytelling aspects. Yet, the 2.39:1 HEVC video presentation is notably sharp, showcasing fine details and vibrant colors, and the Dolby Atmos (Dolby TrueHD 7.1 Core) audio mix delivers an immersive soundscape that enhances the viewing experience significantly. With runtime clocking in at 116 minutes, viewers may find some solace in its visual and auditory competence.
Despite its technical achievements, "Madame Web" suffers from a lack of coherent direction and narrative strength. The movie seems lost, making numerous missteps in character development and plot execution, much to the dismay of even the most forgiving fans. It stands with notorious anti-classics such as "Batman and Robin" and "Catwoman," cementing its place in the worst modern superhero flicks category. Additionally, the disc's extras provide little to no added value, making it difficult to recommend this film even in the form of a 4K UHD purchase.
So for all of you who have not seen this film, take warning. And for all of those who HAVE seen this movie, I’m so so so sorry. There is a support group for us, and it meets at 3:00 PM every Wednesday. We have cookies, and we’ll try to help you through this time. I’m pretty sure at this point that Sony’s attempt to start a non Spider-Man Spider-verse is pretty much dead, but I have this terrifying nightmare that Sony hasn’t got that memo yet, and we might be in for a sequel or re-attempt (despite the incredible box office bomb of making $80 million worldwide on a $100 million budget). The Sony 4K UHD looks and sounds great though, with medium tier extras. My recommendation? Do I really have to say it out loud? I think you get the hint.
AV Nirvana review by Michael ScottRead review here
Video: 90
Honestly, it feels like a slightly tweaked version of the 5.1 mix, with more space on the back end with the rear channels, some directional shifting being more noticeable, and a few instances near the...
Audio: 90
Past that this is one of the most incredibly bad films I have ever seen, and this comes from someone who had to see The Marvels and Morbius multiple times to review....
Extras: 50
• Gag Reel • Easter Eggs • Oracle Of The Page • Fight Like A Spider • Future Vision • Casting The Web • Deleted Scene...
Movie: 30
Past that this is one of the most incredibly bad films I have ever seen, and this comes from someone who had to see The Marvels and Morbius multiple times to review....
Total: 60
I’m pretty sure at this point that Sony’s attempt to start a non Spider-Man Spider-verse is pretty much dead, but I have this terrifying nightmare that Sony hasn’t got that memo yet, and we might be in...
Blu-ray.com review by Kenneth BrownRead review here
Video: 100
Detail is spot on as well, with razor-sharp edge definition, exceedingly refined textures (has Adam Scott's skin ever looked as real as it does in the screenshot above?), and a fine, filmic touch of grain...
Audio: 90
I actually found LFE output to be a tad lacking at times (particularly in early action sequences), though it certainly makes its presence known on the whole as well as amidst the destruction of the third...
Extras: 40
The 2-disc 4K release of Madame Web includes all of its special features with the standard Blu-ray copy of the film, not that there's all that much to dig through......
Movie: 30
Imagine for a moment, if you'll indulge me, that Madame Web was the sort of time-bending stand-out that featured scenes of Cassie "learning" from future Spideys, Peter among them; or the risk that Ezekiel's...
Total: 70
But it will most likely continue to stand as the worst modern superhero flick in recent memory, finding better company in the anti-classics of yesteryear (Batman and Robin, Catwoman, 2015's Fantastic Four,...
DoBlu review by Matt PaprockiRead review here
Video: 60
That gives Madame Web a consistent look of digital-ness, including noise that tends to fill the backgrounds (that’s handled decently by the encode).Color is a strange one, filtered through an amber haze,...
Audio: 80
There’s a great simple moment where Cassie drifts a taxi after smashing through the window, and glass left on the hood flies off in every direction....
Extras: 40
...
Movie: 20
This is such an obviously disjointed movie, set in 2003 apparently for the nostalgic soundtrack, but also trying to mimic the twisty, nauseating camera work that defined much of the decade....
Total: 50
A truly astonishing failure, Madame Web makes countless errors in every aspect of its filmmaking....
Why So Blu? review by Aaron NeuwirthRead review here
Video: 90
There are a lot of indoor settings and nighttime scenes that speak to seeing an optimal amount of steady black levels, and it’s true....
Audio: 80
The end of this film has some areas to go in this regard, as the attempts to pull off action that pushes characters around the screen and uses Cassie’s visions decently enough from an audio perspective....
Extras: 40
Future Vision (HD, 7:02) – A standard EPK with the cast and crew Casting the Web (HD, 8:59) –...
Movie: 30
Detached in a way that suggests “this isn’t the film I signed on for,” Johnson hits a few necessary beats early on, only to become a character either annoyed by those around her or making a choice to leave...
Total: 60
However, if you go forth and watch this film, it looks and sounds solid on 4K, even if the extras leave much to be desired....
Director: S.J. Clarkson
Actors: Dakota Johnson, Sydney Sweeney, Isabela Merced
PlotIn a bustling metropolis teeming with heroes and criminals alike, Julia Carpenter, a brilliant but overlooked scientist, discovers a mysterious artifact that grants her extraordinary psychic abilities, including precognition and telepathy. The artifact’s power draws her into a hidden world of supernatural powers and ancient secrets. Initially overwhelmed by her newfound abilities, Julia struggles with her transformation and the isolation it brings. Her life takes a dramatic turn when she uses her powers to save a stranger, drawing unwanted attention from both malevolent and benevolent forces seeking to control or exploit her abilities.
As Julia delves deeper into the labyrinth of her own power, she forms an unlikely alliance with a group of young women, each harboring secrets and abilities of their own. Together, they navigate the intricate web of their pasts, uncovering connections that bind them in unexpected ways. Their journey reveals a conspiracy that threatens to disrupt the balance between the human and supernatural worlds. Faced with escalating dangers, Julia must learn to master her powers to protect herself and her newfound allies. Her quest not only challenges her understanding of reality but also forces her to confront questions about destiny, free will, and the true meaning of heroism in a world where the lines between good and evil are blurred.
Writers: Matt Sazama, Burk Sharpless, Claire Parker
Release Date: 14 Feb 2024
Runtime: 116 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States
Language: English