Passengers Blu-ray Review
Score: 56
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
The Blu-ray of 'Passengers' boasts stunning video and excellent TrueHD audio, but the film's weak script and slow pacing can't lift it above average.
Disc Release Date
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 59
"Passengers" offers an excellent 1080p/AVC-encoded transfer with clean rendering of a subdued color palette, impressive clarity, and meticulous detail, although some scenes exhibit subtle softness. Black levels and contrast are well-executed, with a modest grain adding to its lifelike quality.
Audio: 62
The Dolby TrueHD 5.1 surround track for 'Passengers' offers a balanced and immersive audio experience, with clear dialogue, dynamic sound effects, and precise surrounds. While it may have minor inconsistencies, the mix excels in atmospheric details and low frequency impact, particularly during intense scenes.
Extra: 43
The Blu-ray extras for 'Passengers' include insightful audio commentary by director Rodrigo Garcia and actor Patrick Wilson, an in-depth plane crash analysis, and a featurette on the film's production, all presented in high definition. Despite some overuse of film clips and a few less compelling deleted scenes, the package offers a satisfying behind-the-scenes look into the making of the film.
Movie: 50
Passengers navigates familiar mystery and supernatural thriller tropes with mixed success, delivering strong performances and a compelling twist finale that somewhat redeems its confusing plot and character development issues. However, it ultimately struggles to maintain suspense and coherence throughout its runtime.
Video: 59
The Blu-ray presentation of "Passengers" delivers a visually striking experience, albeit with a blend of flat color palette and meticulous detailing. Utilizing a palette dominated by black, grays, whites, and greens, the video maintains a subdued aesthetic that aligns with the film's intentionally dreary atmosphere. This choice of colors effectively supports the thematic elements while rendering them with exceptional clarity and clean texture. Close-ups benefit significantly from this approach, revealing subtle nuances in skin textures, stubble, and delicate peach fuzz, lending an appreciably lifelike quality to the cast. The grain is present yet restrained, contributing to a pristine quality without intrusiveness.
Technically, the 1080p/AVC-encoded transfer showcases excellent detail retention, with foreground objects rendered meticulously and textures preserved to maintain remarkable overall clarity. Black levels exhibit rich depth, and contrast is generally impeccable, though it varies from excellent to moderate depending on the scene. Noteworthy is the lack of significant artifacting, source noise, crowding, or banding issues. Skin tones are stable and true, capturing the varied complexities of the actors’ complexions beautifully. However, a slight softness clouds the picture at times, contributing to a less stunning but solid clarity that fits well with the film's eerie ambience.
In terms of visual fidelity, the transfer successfully evokes the feel of celluloid through fine grain overlay that enhances the cinematic quality. Despite the subdued colors, moments of vibrancy do occur, notably in specific elements such as Hathaway’s lips, which stand out against the overall muted tones. The discernible absence of digital enhancements further emphasizes the dedication to authenticity in image quality. Overall, while this Blu-ray transfer may not provoke overt astonishment, it delivers a consistently appealing and technically robust viewing experience that aligns well with the film's artistic vision.
Audio: 62
The Dolby TrueHD 5.1 soundtrack of "Passengers" offers a precisely articulated and immersive audio experience. Dialogue is rendered with exceptional clarity and natural weight, ensuring every line is easily understandable despite the actors' often subdued deliveries. The mix expertly utilizes the entire soundstage to create an enveloping atmosphere, balancing hushed conversations and gentle piano music against moments of dynamic energy. The low frequency effects (LFE) provide a deep impact, adding solidity to both sound effects and the film's score, making key scenes resonate with fuller-bodied presence and emotional weight.
The rear speakers seamlessly envelop the listener, crafting an engrossing and believable soundfield. Specific scenes, such as flashbacks to the plane crash, deliver impressive sonic jolts filled with hefty bass, pushing the surround track to its limits with crisp effects and powerful directional accuracy. Atmospheric elements like wind and flame are convincingly rendered, further enhancing the sense of immersion. Despite some minor normalization inconsistencies in a few scenes, the overall technical proficiency and nuanced balance of highs and lows ensure a continually engaging auditory experience. Highs and lows sit comfortably within perceptible limits, ensuring that nothing feels jarring or out of place.
Front channel separation expands the soundscape noticeably, enhancing the film's unsettling atmosphere. Environments feel tangibly real, with delicate accents clearly conveyed across the rear channels. This Dolby TrueHD track successfully delivers an admirable presentation, filled with well-defined, nicely modulated audio throughout. The final minutes of the film notably leverage the full potential of the track, thrusting us into action with an array of effects from all directions. Overall, it is a proficient and engaging lossless audio track that complements the film's narrative and visual elements effectively.
Extras: 43
The Blu-ray extras for "Passengers" offer a substantial yet concise collection, aptly suited for fans of the film. Highlighted by a relaxed and insightful commentary from Director Rodrigo Garcia and actor Patrick Wilson, the disc delves into the nuanced production process and character interplay with engaging anecdotes and humor. The high-definition featurettes cover the making and manifest of the film, providing a behind-the-scenes look at the cast and production design. One notable featurette dissects the plane crash sequence, focusing on both the technical elements and character reactions. Although the deleted scenes add little, the package remains an informative supplement to the film.
Extras included in this disc:
- Commentary by Director Rodrigo Garcia and Actor Patrick Wilson: Exploring script, on-set atmosphere, and character study.
- In the Night Sky: The Manifest & Making of Passengers: Behind-the-scenes insights focusing on characters, production design, and color palette.
- Analysis of a Plane Crash: Detailed look at special effects, set construction, and CGI.
- Deleted Scenes: Three cuts that would have slowed the pace.
- Theatrical Trailers: A selection of various trailers.
Movie: 50
"Passengers," directed by Rodrigo Garc�a and penned by Ronnie Christensen, ventures into the psychological thriller domain, blending elements of mystery, romance, and the supernatural. However, this stylistic amalgamation often leads to a confused narrative that struggles with identity and coherence. Anne Hathaway portrays Claire Summers, a psychologist assigned to aid the five survivors of a devastating plane crash, each presenting conflicting stories about the incident. The film's pacing is sluggish, as it awkwardly combines slow-burn horror with romantic drama, and attempts to maintain intrigue with disjointed supernatural elements that occasionally feel more contrived than compelling.
The cast performances are noteworthy, with Hathaway delivering an understated portrayal of Claire and Patrick Wilson as the enigmatic survivor Eric. Despite their efforts, and those from a capable supporting cast including David Morse, Andre Braugher, and Clea DuVall, they are hampered by stilted dialogue and underdeveloped characters. The film's execution relies heavily on its climactic twist, which while providing a fresh perspective and some resolution, does little to redeem the bulk of its uneven narrative. Key scenes seem to channel inspirations from "Lost," "The Sixth Sense," and "Final Destination," yet fail to cohesively integrate these influences into a compelling story.
The final act does provide a redeeming clarity to earlier plot points that seemed nonsensical, grounding bizarre interactions and loose motivations. Notably, Hathaway and Wilson infuse their roles with more depth than the script offers, striving to keep the audience engaged amidst Garcia's sometimes cumbersome direction. Ultimately, "Passengers" hinges on its concluding revelation to deliver the emotional impact it promises but falls short of the craftsmanship needed to fully engage and satisfy its viewers throughout its runtime. The big reveal, though impactful, is not sufficient to elevate the film from being anything more than a curious blend of familiar tropes.
Total: 56
"Passengers" offers a complex viewing experience that has divided critics, as evidenced by the film's polarizing initial reception. While the storyline hinges on a pivotal third-act twist, the slow pacing and derivative elements detract from its overall impact. Yet, upon repeated viewings, the intricacies of its plot and thematic nuances can offer deeper appreciation. Technically speaking, the Blu-ray edition excels, featuring an impeccable video transfer that vividly captures every visual detail and an outstanding TrueHD audio track that enhances the atmospheric qualities of the film.
Despite the film's shortcomings—specifically its meandering script and unoriginal plot—the Blu-ray release distinguishes itself through its high production quality. The video transfer displays a level of clarity and color accuracy that elevates the visual experience. Audio-wise, the TrueHD track ensures that every sound effect and snippet of dialogue is rendered with pristine clarity, making for an immersive auditory experience. The included supplemental package, although limited, provides valuable insights into the film's production and conceptual layers.
In conclusion, while "Passengers" may falter in its narrative execution, its Blu-ray presentation is nothing short of exceptional. For those willing to look past the film’s narrative flaws, the disc offers a technically superior experience that might just reveal the film’s subtler, bleak charms upon multiple viewings. It stands as a worthwhile addition for collectors, though casual viewers may still prefer to opt for a rental.
Blu-ray.com review by Kenneth BrownRead review here
Video: 90
A moderate veneer of grain settles in overtop the image, but it never hinders or disrupts the exceedingly polished presentation....
Audio: 80
A handful of scenes suffer from minor normalization inconsistencies -- an early car-window exchange between Hathaway and Wilson is initially pinched, an encounter between Hathaway and Morose on a porch...
Extras: 50
Once again, talking heads and film clips abound, but it was nice to see that the director and designers were more concerned with how the characters reacted to the crisis rather than the particulars of...
Movie: 70
Through it all, she grows close to Eric, crosses ethical lines, and is forced to make a choice: continue her pursuit of the truth or risk being crushed by a mystery beyond her understanding....
Total: 70
Passengers is a tricky film to review: I hated it for at least seventy of if its plodding ninety-three minutes, the story itself hinges entirely on a multi-layered third-act twist, and the overall experience...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
Fine grain complements the image, evoking the feel of celluloid, but I expected more dimensionality from such a recent release....
Audio: 80
Front channel separation is noticeable enough to expand the soundscape and enhance the unsettling atmosphere that pervades the film, and highs and lows sit well within comfortable parameters....
Extras: 40
This well-produced piece begins by examining each of the main characters individually, and detailing their personality and motivations through interviews with the actors, producers, and director....
Movie: 40
The climactic twist, though hardly a shocker and not at all unique, still packs a punch, and the elegant denouement puts a fresh spin on a tired theme, but it's all too little too late, and can't compensate...
Total: 60
Endings can make or break films, and though the best moments of 'Passengers' come during its final 10 minutes, they're not potent enough to lift this twisty psychological thriller out of the average realm....
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 86
This photography doesn't lend the video to being highly polished and three dimensionally resolute however images are detailed and sharp which provides appreciable depth and dimension....
Audio: 84
This is not a film that requires heavy use of surround sound to deliver its message but it does rely on the entire soundstage for proper atmosphere and low frequency detail from time to time....
Extras: 50
Commentary by Director Rodrigo Garcia and Actor Patrick Wilson (HD) Analysis of a plane crash - 16 minute featurette (HD) In the night sky: The manifest & making of Passengers - 23 minute featurette 3...
Movie: 50
Now Eric (Patrick Wilson, Lakeview Terrace), a surviving passenger she has grown dangerously close to, may hold the key to unlocking the truth about the tragic incident in this shocking psychological thriller....
Total: 68
Marantz DV7001 Universal Disc Player Denon AVR 5308CI THX Ultra 2 Preamp/Video Processor Sherbourn Technologies - 7/200 Seven Channel Amplifier Philips TSU9400 Pro Series Touch Panel Remote Control Canton...
Director: Rodrigo García
Actors: Anne Hathaway, Patrick Wilson, David Morse
PlotA young therapist is assigned to counsel a group of survivors after a commercial airplane crash. Leading the group therapy, she tries to help the passengers cope with their trauma and piece together their memories of the incident. Among her patients is a particularly enigmatic man who seems to have an unusually positive outlook despite the crash. As she delves deeper into their recollections and personal stories, she encounters inconsistencies in their accounts and begins to notice unsettling gaps and contradictions.
While trying to uncover the truth, she forms a closer bond with the enigmatic man, who exhibits both charm and perplexing knowledge about her life. Her investigation leads her to clash with the airline, which is keen on maintaining a specific narrative about the accident. Her determination to uncover what really happened puts her at odds with other passengers and triggers a series of disturbing events, pushing her to question the nature of reality and her own perceptions.
Writers: Ronnie Christensen
Release Date: 26 Sep 2008
Runtime: 93 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States, Canada
Language: English