Ghost in the Shell Blu-ray Review
Score: 72
from 4 reviewers
Review Date:
While 'Ghost in the Shell' dazzles with stunning visuals and immersive audio on Blu-ray, it ultimately falls short of capturing the thematic depth and complexity of its source material, making it more suited for rental.
Disc Release Date
Dolby Atmos
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 88
Ghost in the Shell wows on Blu-ray with stunning 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 encode. From deep, inky blacks and crisp details to vibrant neon hues and dazzling holographic projections, the film's blend of CGI and real-world elements displays razor-sharp precision, with only minimal banding observed.
Audio: 81
Ghost in the Shell's Dolby Atmos track delivers an immersive and technically impressive experience with precise directional sound, deep bass, and expansive use of the soundstage, though it lacks a bit in overhead usage. Action scenes shine with incredible energy, enveloping the listener in a robust aural environment.
Extra: 38
Ghost in the Shell's Blu-ray extras deliver thorough insights with 'Hard-Wired Humanity' offering a 30-minute deep dive into the film's development, 'Section 9: Cyber Defenders' exploring character design in 11 minutes, and 'Man & Machine: The Ghost Philosophy' examining the story's contemporary and future implications in 10 minutes.
Movie: 53
Ghost in the Shell's Blu-ray showcases visually stunning effects and high-paced action, yet falters with a narrative that lacks the soul of its original 1980s anime classic. While Scarlett Johansson’s performance and the cybernetic set pieces are noteworthy, the film’s inconsistency and failure to deeply explore its themes render it a visually impressive but ultimately shallow adaptation.
Video: 88
The Blu-ray presentation of "Ghost in the Shell" is a visual tour de force that delivers an awe-inspiring experience. Featuring an exceptionally detailed 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 encode, it showcases a stunning array of sci-fi-level colors—ranging from neon pinks and reds to vivid blues and somber darker shades. The movie is a testament to the digital prowess with which it was filmed, where the neon holographic projections and Scarlett Johansson’s piercing blue eyes literally pop off the screen. Black levels are deep and inky, adding significant depth to scenes, while CGI seamlessly integrates with the real-world elements, creating a virtually imperceptible differential. Artifacting is absent and color banding issues are non-existent.
The film's digitally enhanced and stylistically dark visuals reveal outstanding image clarity across various environments, whether they are dingy street corners or expansive cityscapes filled with holographic signage. Even in low-light sequences, blacks remain tight and deep while flesh tones stay accurate. Although a slight soft-focus haze is present due to the Arri Alexa 65 camera system used, this adds an intentional dreamlike quality to the film’s aesthetic without compromising on the sharpness of fine details. The contrast is restrained but effective, maintaining clean and brilliant whites that enhance the futuristic vibe of the cinematography. Colors are vibrant, particularly the rich reds of artificial blood which juxtapose against a metallic blue polish prevalent throughout the movie.
Moreover, scenes involving wide aerial shots descending through city structures are particularly noteworthy for their breathtaking detail and immersive three-dimensional quality. The body suit worn by Major, with its reflective and semi-invisible qualities, positively leaps off the screen, demonstrating the impeccable reproduction of textures and intricate detailing. Overall, "Ghost in the Shell" on Blu-ray impresses with its striking visual fidelity, making it an exemplary high-definition presentation.
Audio: 81
The Dolby Atmos audio track for the Blu Ray of "Ghost in the Shell" delivers an exceptional auditory experience with a few notable nuances. While it generally lacks extensive overhead sound utilization, especially thought-provoking for a film brimming with dimensional complexity, its overall execution is mesmerizing. Frenzied action scenes, including whizzing gunfire and mechanical sounds, are reproduced with pinpoint precision and immersive depth. The low-frequency effects (LFE) are especially impressive, delivering profound bass that resonates powerfully throughout the action sequences. The climactic showdown with the spider tank stands out with house-shaking bass drops and realistic mechanical groans that almost feel tangible.
The soundtrack leverages subtle ambient details alongside intense action-driven segments to create an engrossing auditory landscape. Gunfire and explosions are presented with incredible depth and concussive impact, effectively filling the listening space with directional sound elements. Sounds from digital environments and cityscape backgrounds are proficiently woven into the mix, enhancing immersion. The front soundstage demonstrates flawless panning and balanced channel utilization, ensuring that background activities and environmental effects complement the main action seamlessly. The dialogue remains clear and prioritized throughout, ensuring character interactions are never overshadowed by the action.
Additionally, the film’s soundtrack, composed by Lorne Balfe and Clint Mansell, pulsates with a techno-marvel that enlivens the overall aural space. The surround configuration is masterfully executed, effectively placing sounds of electronics and environmental elements around the listener, drawing them into the film's futuristic world. Ambient city noises, including distant voices and traffic hums, are subtly yet convincingly presented, adding to the atmosphere without overwhelming the primary tracks. This well-crafted Dolby Atmos track ensures that each element of "Ghost in the Shell" resonates with clarity, precision, and immersive vigor, providing an exemplary auditory experience.
Extras: 38
The extras included in the Blu-ray release of "Ghost in the Shell" offer a comprehensive and engaging exploration of the film's development and thematic depth. The standout feature, Hard-Wired Humanity: Making Ghost in the Shell, presents a detailed overview, delving into the story's development, visual effects, character performances, and Director Rupert Sanders' contributions. Complementing this is Section 9: Cyber Defenders, an insightful examination of the Section 9 team's intricacies, cybernetic enhancements, and plot revelations. Finally, Man & Machine: The Ghost Philosophy provides a captivating discussion on the film’s philosophical implications and its reflection on contemporary and future societal trends.
Extras included in this disc:
Hard-Wired Humanity: Making Ghost in the Shell: Comprehensive overview covering story themes, development, visual effects, and more.
Section 9: Cyber Defenders: In-depth look at Section 9's characters, designs, and enhancements.
Man & Machine: The Ghost Philosophy: Exploration of the film's themes and their relevance to today's world.Movie: 53
Rupert Sanders' "Ghost in the Shell," an adaptation of the illustrious 1995 anime, is visually resplendent, strategically aligned with complex set designs and CG-driven futuristic landscapes that both mesmerize and provoke thought about the intersection of humanity and technology. Scarlett Johansson stars as Major Mira Killian, a human-brain-in-cyborg-body fusion, heading high-stakes anti-cyberterror missions. The film successfully captures grandiose visuals and the kinetic energy required for a sci-fi action spectacle, yet often feels like a mere shadow of its source material's intellectual depth and soul.
While the narrative adheres to its roots by addressing the continued relevance of cybernetic humanity and the lingering threats within a technologically saturated world, it struggles with internal consistency. Major’s journey to uncover her origins pits her philosophical confrontations against corporate mustache-twirling villains, diluting the complex introspection found in its predecessor. Technical prowess spares no expense; from meticulously crafted cybernetic enhancements to bustling holographic cityscapes, the visual fidelity is impeccable. However, despite these aesthetic triumphs, the film falters in retaining narrative cohesion, yielding to uninspired plot threads and diluted thematic explorations of identity and humanity.
Performances are uneven but noteworthy—Johansson breathes life into Major with a steely precision that mirrors both her previous roles and the character’s cybernetic duality. Supporting actors, including Pilou Asbæk as Batou and Takeshi Kitano as Aramaki, provide commendable portrayals that echo their anime counterparts. Unfortunately, the rich tableau of philosophical musings intrinsic to the original manga and anime is often sidelined for more digestible action tropes and visual opulence. In attempting to balance homage with modernization, "Ghost in the Shell" finds itself in cinematic limbo—visually dazzling yet emotionally and intellectually superficial.
Total: 72
Rupert Sanders' "Ghost in the Shell" is a visually arresting reimagining that, while failing to capture the thematic depth of its Japanese predecessor, still offers an engaging experience. Although it attempts to delve into the original's complex questions about human identity and technological augmentation, its narrative focus often leans more towards kinetic action sequences than philosophical musings. Despite this shift, the film remains satisfactory on its own merits, with strong performances, led by Scarlett Johansson, and breathtaking visuals.
The Blu-ray release shines with impeccable technical specifications. Featuring a 1.78:1 AVC aspect ratio and an English Dolby Atmos audio track, the presentation is nothing short of stunning. Video quality is clear, vibrant, and true to the director's vision, while the atmospheric sound design provides a fully immersive experience. Although extras are sparse and somewhat unremarkable given the potential the rich source material offers, the Blu-ray remains a must-have for sci-fi enthusiasts who appreciate high-quality home theater experiences.
Overall, "Ghost in the Shell" (2017) serves as an adequate standalone film enriched by dazzling visual effects and robust performances. While it falters in exploring the philosophical depths central to past iterations of the story, it still provides a visually spectacular viewing experience. No matter the iteration of the source material, "Ghost in the Shell" houses a dire warning about the future and asks some complex questions about the meaning of being human. "Ghost in the Shell" 2017 has a difficult time really fleshing out these questions, but is an overall satisfactory watch on its own due to the lovely visuals and kinetic action. The Blu-ray itself is technically amazing and is the perfect addition for the sci-fi lover who loves demo-worthy material. However, considering the limited extras, renting before committing might be advisable for those not already fans of Johansson's rendition.
AV Nirvana review by Michael ScottRead review here
Video: 100
Fine details are beyond perfect, seamlessly blending the enormous amount of CGI with real world in near imperceptible differences....
Audio: 90
Surrounds are awash with the hustle and bustle of the giant mega city, and while the overheads aren’t wildly active, there are a few moments where you can catching some whistling wind as Major falls during...
Extras: 40
• Hard-Wired Humanity: Making Ghost in the Shell • Section 9: Cyber Defenders • Man & Machine: The Ghost Philosophy...
Movie: 60
The only thing is, the soul and heart of the Anime and manga are simply gone, replaced with well-worn visual treats and a propensity for trying to mimic the original film AND deviate drastically at the...
Total: 80
No matter the iteration of the source material, Ghost in the Shell houses a dire warning about the future and asks some complex questions about the meaning of being human....
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 90
Everything pops with sufficient depth and punch as it's meant to within the film's stylistic confines, but that blue-gray filtering, so commonplace in today's drab and dreary cinema, prevails....
Audio: 90
Heavier elements -- a monstrous machine chases down and shoots at the heroes in the third act to impressive depth, movement, and room-filling intensity -- are very strong, punctuated by an explosion near...
Extras: 40
Cyber Defenders (1080p, 11:29): A closer look at the details behind Section 9 as well as a further exploration of plot details, character design and qualities, story themes, and more....
Movie: 50
That would seem to make this the perfect time to reintroduce the story to a wider, more contemporary audience and, indeed, the film does just that, promising and delivering a tightly dressed Scarlett Johansson,...
Total: 70
A movie like this that cannot merely dabble in complexity, it must immerse itself in complexity, make it a centerpiece, and it must be made more for the thought provoking elements than anything else, using...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 100
Adding a layer of irony to this dystopic vision of the future is a sumptuous, richly-saturated display of primaries, particularly the red in the artificial blood and muscles of Major while the rest of...
Audio: 80
With convincing off-screen background activity that also moves into the front heights for a satisfying half-dome wall of sound, imaging feels expansive with superb clarity detailing in the mid-range, generating...
Extras: 20
Man & Machine: The Ghost Philosophy (HD, 11 min): An intriguing discussion of the themes explored in the original film and the manga, along with the practicality of making the science a reality....
Movie: 40
Much like the robotic characters featured in the film, the whole thing is a mere show without an ounce of substance to make it all worthwhile....
Total: 60
Aside from any praise for the visuals and a few of the performances, the production only proves itself to be a hollow, vacant body programmed by its corporate overlords....
Home Theater Forum review by Neil MiddlemissRead review here
Video: 100
The brightly colored neon, and the body suit worn by Major, with its reflective/invisibility, positively leap from the screen in 2D. Shots that begin very wide, above the city, swoop down and through building...
Audio: 100
Rupert Sander’s choice of composers, a combination of Lorne Balfe and Clint Mansell, produce a thrilling score, pulsing and throbbing with techno-marvel, suited very well to the film....
Extras: 60
What’s here is good, anchored by the 30 minutes Hard-Wired Humanity: Making Ghost in the Shell, which covers the inspiring source material and the intent behind the adaptation....
Movie: 70
On the first, the faithful adaptation of the source aesthetic using complex and detailed visual effects work, costume, set-design, and practical effects, seemed to boost interest and favor, but on the...
Total: 70
The casting controversy proved too high a hurdle for the film to recover from, though the availability of the home video version (and streaming) will mean that more people will be able to discover the...
Director: Rupert Sanders
Actors: Scarlett Johansson, Pilou Asbæk, Takeshi Kitano
PlotIn a futuristic world where cybernetic enhancement of the human body is commonplace, the story unfolds around a counter-cyberterrorist unit known as Section 9. The protagonist is a female cyborg who leads the task force, her body fully artificial save for her human brain, which contains her consciousness or "ghost." She grapples with her own identity and fragmented memories, uncertain of what remains of her former self. The team is charged with hunting down a mysterious and dangerous extremist, known for hacking into the minds of enhanced humans and compelling them to commit acts of terrorism.
The investigation reveals broader implications as the squad uncovers a conspiracy linked to the protagonist's past and the corporation responsible for her creation. The plot delves into themes of identity, technology, and humanity as the protagonist struggles to discover who she was before becoming a cyborg. All the while, the team faces escalating challenges posed by their target, who seems to be always one step ahead, leading to high-stakes encounters with advanced weaponry and cyber warfare. The pursuit becomes personal as the protagonist confronts questions of self and the morality of artificial existence, against the backdrop of a society wrestling with the ramifications of human augmentation.
Writers: Shirow Masamune, Jamie Moss, William Wheeler
Release Date: 31 Mar 2017
Runtime: 107 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States, India, Hong Kong, China, Canada
Language: English, Japanese