Punisher: War Zone Blu-ray Review
Score: 63
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Punisher: War Zone blends zany action with dark humor, a hit for fans but divisive for critics.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 61
Punisher: War Zone on Blu-ray offers a dark, gritty 1080p presentation with strong black levels and vivid detail, though marred by occasional heavy grain and softness, reflecting its comic-book roots.
Audio: 74
The 'Punisher: War Zone' Blu-ray excels with a bass-heavy DTS-HD MA 7.1 track, immersing viewers in relentless action through clear dialogue, dynamic sound effects, and thematic music.
Extra: 47
Punisher: War Zone Blu-ray extras feature a mix of in-depth and brief content, highlighting directorial insights, technical aspects, character and weapon analyses, with additional trailers and a digital copy, catering mostly to fans.
Movie: 63
Punisher: War Zone, a visceral and faithful comic adaptation, delivers relentless action and gore but falters in depth and dialogue, appealing mainly to die-hard fans and action lovers.
Video: 61
"Punisher: War Zone" makes its way onto Blu-ray with a presentation that, despite some shortcomings, showcases the film’s gritty aesthetic and comic book origins effectively in its original 2.35:1 widescreen aspect ratio. The 1080p High Definition transfer brings out fine details in the foreground, especially notable in facial close-ups, complemented by deeply solid blacks and a nuanced color palette that veers towards dark and moody tones, faithfully mirroring the comic's style. The use of a limited color scheme, aimed at evoking the feel of the source material, occasionally gives skin tones a golden hue due to the lighting, adding to the film’s unique visual character. Scenes are mostly sharp, although a slight softness and heavy grain are noticeable in parts, which doesn't detract from the detail but adds a layer of grittiness.
The video quality stands out for its avoidance of digital pitfalls like smearing or noise reduction artifacts, maintaining the natural texture of the film. However, the presence of occasional white speckles and minor softness in some scenes indicates that while impressive, the transfer is not without its flaws. The strong black levels and retention of detail in most scenarios create a visually engaging picture that remains faithful to the dark atmosphere the filmmakers intended, reminiscent of works like "The Crow". Despite these nitpicks, such as region-locking constraints and inconsistent grain, the Blu-ray does an admirable job at preserving the cinematic essence of "Punisher: War Zone".
Lionsgate's release on a BD-50 disc with an MPEG-4 AVC encode does justice to the film's stark aesthetics, with an effective balance between the comic-book-inspired color restrictions and the need for visual clarity. Digital noise is kept at bay, ensuring that even in dimly lit scenes or those dominated by shadow, the image retains its integrity without succumbing to common digital issues. While some scenes may not leap out with striking detail compared to today's reference-quality transfers, "Punisher: War Zone" on Blu-ray offers a solid video presentation that supports both its narrative and stylistic ambitions.
Audio: 74
The Blu-ray audio presentation of "Punisher: War Zone" delivers an auditory experience as forceful and dynamic as its titular character, powered by an engrossing DTS-HD Master Audio 7.1 lossless soundtrack. This meticulously crafted audio track envelops the listener in a world where the cacophony of gunfire, the shattering of glass, and the chaos of urban mayhem take precedence, creating an immersive soundscape that extends far beyond the spoken word. Ambient sounds from the bustling streets of New York to the tense atmosphere of a police precinct are rendered with clarity, making every background noise contribute to the film's gritty realism. The dialogue, when it appears, is crisp and well-balanced against the relentless action, ensuring that every word is as impactful as the visuals it accompanies.
The sound design excels in delivering a bass-heavy, room-filling experience that showcases the broad range of audio capabilities, from the subtlest whisper of a bullet casing hitting the ground to the explosive roar of a .50 caliber gun firing. The LFE channel works overtime, giving life to every explosion and gunshot, making them feel incredibly close and personal. The soundtrack, while thematic and fitting to the comic-book genre, blasts through with authority, adding an additional layer of intensity to an already electrifying auditory experience. Percussion-heavy moments and nuanced musical scores play out with a mixture of grace and ferocity, enhancing the overall mood and keeping the audience on the edge of their seats.
In terms of technical specifics, aside from the dominating English DTS-HD Master Audio 7.1 track, the Blu-ray also offers a French Dolby Digital 5.1 option along with English SDH, English, and Spanish subtitles, catering to a wide array of preferences and ensuring accessibility. This audio presentation doesn't just complement the visual feast that is "Punisher: War Zone"; it elevates it, creating a fully-rounded sensory experience that is relentless, unforgiving, and perfectly suited to the film's intense action and dark atmosphere.
Extras: 47
The "Punisher: War Zone" Blu-ray extras offer a reasonable mix of content that leans heavily towards the technical and behind-the-scenes aspects of filmmaking. The standout feature is the audio commentary by Director Lexi Alexander and Cinematographer Steve Gainer, which, despite its occasional dryness, provides insightful details on the action sequences' production and technical challenges. Interestingly, Alexander uses her commentary to self-critique and share some missed opportunities in the filmmaking process. The featurettes, while brief and somewhat standard, still manage to delve into the film’s style, weaponry, character makeup, especially Jigsaw’s, and the rigorous training that Ray Stevenson underwent to embody The Punisher. These bonuses are complemented by a collection of HD trailers for "Punisher: War Zone" and other Lionsgate titles, but the overall package might leave enthusiasts wanting more depth or unrevealed secrets from the film's production.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary by Director Lexi Alexander and Cinematographer Steve Gainer: A detailed, albeit occasionally dry, commentary track.
- The Making of Punisher: War Zone: Cast and crew interviews focusing on the film’s style and action sequences.
- Meet Jigsaw: Examination of Dominic West's character makeup.
- Weapons of The Punisher: Overview of the firearms used in the film.
- Training to Become The Punisher: Insights into Ray Stevenson's combat and weapons training.
- Creating the Look of The Punisher: Discussion on the film's visual style and color scheme.
- Theatrical Trailer: Official trailer for ‘Punisher: War Zone’.
- Also From Lionsgate: Trailers for various Lionsgate films.
- Digital Copy: A digital version of the movie for portable devices.
Movie: 63
"Punisher: War Zone" emerges as a cinematic endeavor that unabashedly dives into the depths of ultra-violence, served with a side of comic book flair and tongue-in-cheek brutality, targeting the 18-35 year-old male demographic with precision. Set in a universe far bleaker and more unforgiving than Gotham City, the film follows Frank Castle, A.K.A. The Punisher, played with gritty realism by Ray Stevenson. Castle's world, devoid of the moral checks of Batman, revels in his quest for vengeance against those who have wronged him and the city, utilizing an arsenal featuring Beretta 92s and the formidable Smith & Wesson .500 revolver with deadly proficiency. Unlike previous adaptations, this iteration stands out for its sheer commitment to portraying Castle's war on crime without diluting its intensity for broader audience appeal.
Directed by Lexi Alexander, "Punisher: War Zone" does not shy away from its source material's more gruesome aspects, maintaining a relentless pace of action choreographed amidst a backdrop of perfectly flawed video quality and a soundtrack that, while lacking depth, complements the on-screen carnage effectively. From shotgun blasts to the head at point-blank range to a man gruesomely killed in a glass crusher, the film delivers an all-out assault on the senses. Yet, amidst this chaos, Stevenson's portrayal of Castle adds a layer of depth, portraying a man tormented by his actions yet driven by a twisted sense of justice, bearing the weight of each kill with a silent resilience.
Character dynamics further enrich the narrative with Jigsaw and Loony Bin Jim providing the villainous counterpoints to Castle's anti-hero. These characters introduce a psychopathic charm to their roles, simultaneously horrifying and entertaining in their schemes and motivations. Despite its unapologetically over-the-top violence and sometimes cringe-inducing dialogue and character actions, the movie manages to straddle the fine line between absurdity and entertainment without succumbing to the pitfalls of becoming a farcical caricature of itself. "Punisher: War Zone," though not groundbreaking in the realms of drama or action cinema, confidently occupies its niche - delivering an action-packed, blood-soaked spectacle that adheres faithfully to its comic book roots while engaging its audience in a merciless symphony of vengeance.
Total: 63
"Punisher: War Zone" emerges as a unique spectacle in the action film realm, comfortably occupying a niche that skirts the edges of parody without fully committing to it, much like "Shoot 'Em Up," yet retaining enough gravitas to keep it from becoming pure farce, unlike the unapologetically serious tone of "Dirty Harry." This balance is punctuated by an unrelenting barrage of violence that is both its signature and a point of contention among viewers. The film features a protagonist who, despite the hard exterior, shows glimpses of vulnerability, pitted against villains who are as devoid of moral compasses as they are rich in comedic value. In this dichotomy, "Punisher: War Zone" finds its stride, offering an entertainment value that, while may not compete with Hollywood's finest, stands out for its boldness and audacity. Lionsgate's Blu-ray release elevates this experience with video and audio quality that, while not consistently stellar, delivers where it counts, backed by a satisfactory array of bonus content.
Critically, "Punisher: War Zone" dives into divisive territory; it’s a film that polarizes audiences, firmly captivating fans of the genre while simultaneously repelling critics. The film encapsulates the essence of The Punisher franchise, albeit not flawlessly, as it navigates through some narrative and stylistic pitfalls that may deter purists. The Blu-ray presentation shines with commendable video and audio quality, enhancing the visceral impact of the film's action sequences. Although the mindless entertainment mantra may deter some, for those seeking an unfiltered adrenaline rush, it hits the mark, underscored by an adequate compilation of bonus features that enrich the viewing experience.
In conclusion, "Punisher: War Zone" on Blu-ray triumphs as a celebration of excessive yet engaging action cinema. It's a commendation of the film's willingness to embrace its exaggerated essence without falling into the trap of self-parody fully. With quality technical presentation and a suite of extras that please without overwhelming, this release is a solid recommendation for those seeking to indulge in a film that breaks the mold with its unashamed embrace of ultraviolence and dark humor. For viewers with an open mind and a penchant for the extreme, "Punisher: War Zone" offers a satisfactorily raucous viewing experience.
avforums review by Casimir HarlowRead review here
Video: 80
The gritty look of the film can sometimes, however, be unforgiving, and whilst some scenes look both dark and clinically clean, others are peppered with a heavy grain that is clearly way beyond that which...
Audio: 80
A few explosions also give the LFE channel something to do apart from just enhance some of the more powerful gunshots and this track really showcases what loud, bullet-based action movies can do in terms...
Extras: 60
We get just under ten-minutes' worth of behind the scenes comments and footage with The Making Of The Punisher: War Zone, a brief five minute look at Training to Become The Punisher, which shows us the...
Movie: 70
On Blu-ray the video flips from perfect to flawed, mostly falling in the former category, and the noisy soundtrack certainly packs a punch, even if it has little depth....
Total: 70
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 80
Grain is rather heavy in some scenes; a hazy mob meeting in chapter two looks good if not a bit dim, with both the off-kilter color scheme and the rather heavy grain making their presence known....
Audio: 100
Sound effects are played all over the listening area; radio chatter, police sirens, or the beating on a steel hospital door are heard in one corner or another of the listening area, discretely and effectively,...
Extras: 50
The Making of 'Punisher: War Zone' (1080p, 9:02) is another generic supplement that offers cast and crew interviews talking up the film's style, the action sequences, and the performances of the lead actors...
Movie: 70
That's not to say that this or either of the two previous films are particularly great outings on the same level as the best of Batman, for example, but from a purely superficial perspective, appreciating...
Total: 70
The result is a movie that isn't intended to stand next to the best Hollywood has to present, but it offers fine entertainment in its own right, particularly when viewed while in the proper frame-of-mind....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
What we have isn’t a very colorful picture by any means, but as noted in the commentary as well as one of the featurettes, the goal was to use a palette that essentially mirrored the comics....
Audio: 100
Even though Frank himself doesn't actually say a word until over twenty minutes into the movie, the dialogue is still perfectly balanced with the rest of the picture....
Extras: 40
The Making of Punisher: War Zone (HD, 9:02) – A short and straightforward featurette analyzing the characters, stunts, and more....
Movie: 60
It was almost as if the director, Lexi Alexander, was so focused on the style and action sequences that she overlooked some of the other important details....
Total: 60
On the other hand, there are still a few major missteps that can really rub viewers the wrong way....
Director: Lexi Alexander
Actors: Ray Stevenson, Dominic West, Julie Benz
PlotFrank Castle, a vigilante known as the Punisher, relentlessly continues his quest to eradicate organized crime in New York City. His war against the mob intensifies when he inadvertently kills an undercover FBI agent during a mission. Consumed by guilt, Castle considers hanging up his Punisher persona, until he learns that the slain agent's widow and daughter are in danger of being targeted by the mob as retribution. Despite the FBI's disapproval of his methods, Castle decides to protect the family and continue his mission, but now with a personal vendetta against those who caused the agent's death.
Mobilizing to take down the criminal syndicates, Castle faces a disfigured mob boss, Billy Russotti, who survives one of the Punisher’s attacks. Russotti, seeking vengeance and adopting the moniker Jigsaw, rallies his gang and assembles an army of criminals to wage war against Castle. As the city's gangsters unite under Jigsaw's command, the stakes are raised, and the Punisher must confront not only a formidable enemy but also the law enforcement agencies determined to apprehend him. The streets become a battlefield as Castle employs his lethal skills to fight a war on multiple fronts.
Writers: Nick Santora, Art Marcum, Matt Holloway
Release Date: 05 Dec 2008
Runtime: 103 min
Rating: R
Country: United States, Canada, Germany
Language: English