Winter's Bone Blu-ray Review
Score: 61
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Winter's Bone on Blu-ray showcases Jennifer Lawrence's career-defining performance with excellent picture and sound quality, though the special features are sparse.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 67
Winter's Bone on Blu-ray features a desaturated, almost monochromatic image in 1080p via an AVC codec, presenting stark visual beauty but with lost details in dark scenes. Shot with Red cameras, it boasts clear images with fine detail and deep blacks that enhance the film's claustrophobic ambiance, despite a lack of filmic grain.
Audio: 57
Winter's Bone's DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track is subtly immersive, blending ambient environmental sounds and traditional folk music beautifully, with precise dialogue prioritization and impressive differentiation in reverb, enhancing both quiet moments and intense scenes with effective dynamics.
Extra: 46
Enriching extras offer an immersive dive into 'Winter's Bone' with insightful commentary, extensive behind-the-scenes footage, deleted scenes, and elegant score excerpts, though Director Granik's understated speaking style may be challenging for some listeners.
Movie: 81
Winter's Bone, directed by Debra Granik, presents a gripping, chilling odyssey of a teenager, Ree Dolly, in the impoverished Ozarks, navigating a world of secretive, menacing hillbillies to rescue her family home. Jennifer Lawrence's performance is exemplary, portraying Ree's resilience and determination amidst male-dominated tyranny.
Video: 67
The video presentation of "Winter's Bone" on Blu-ray delivers an engaging, albeit bleak, visual experience. The film, framed in 1.78:1 aspect ratio and encoded via AVC in 1080p, showcases a chilly palette dominated by grays and pale blues. Director Debra Granik and cinematographer Michael McDonough employ a stark, almost monochromatic aesthetic, leading to a desaturated look that edges the film’s visuals close to black and white. This choice, while enhancing the oppressive atmosphere of the narrative, results in some detail loss, particularly in darker scenes. Nonetheless, outdoor shots benefit from natural lighting, providing good depth of field and crisp fine details in close-ups.
Filmed using Red cameras, "Winter's Bone" is devoid of any traditional filmic grain. Despite lacking a classic cinematic texture, the Blu-ray transfer retains a clean, clear image, brimming with intricate details. The bleak landscapes and dilapidated settings of the Missouri hills are rendered with surprising clarity, highlighting elements such as rust on a refrigerator and the brutal aftermath of physical confrontations. Dark scenes, like those featuring Ree and Teardrop on a nighttime drive, are well-handled by the transfer's deep blacks, offering substantial depth and well-defined shadows. Face scars and wounds remain distinct and visible even in low-light conditions, ensuring that no crucial detail is lost. Overall, for a modestly budgeted Sundance hit, "Winter's Bone" fares exceptionally well in high-definition. Its video quality surpasses many expectations, particularly for an indie film.
Audio: 57
The audio presentation of Winter's Bone on Blu-ray is an intricately nuanced experience that leverages a lossless DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track to create an immersive atmosphere essential to the film’s haunting narrative. The sound design seamlessly integrates ambient environmental sounds such as the rustling of leaves, crackling fires, and the subtle but omnipresent chirping of birds and crickets. This careful curation of ambient noise enriches scenes both visually and emotionally, providing a palpable sense of Ree’s treacherous journey through the wooded hills. There is a marked distinction between the indoor and outdoor acoustics, further emphasizing the film’s varied settings and lending authenticity to each scene.
This audio mix particularly excels in its treatment of dialogue. Given the film's dialogue-heavy nature, the 5.1 DTS-HD Master Audio mix ensures crystal-clear prioritization of voices, maintaining clarity and presence without overshadowing the subtler background sounds. Enhanced by strategically placed reverb and echo, moments such as the tension-filled cattle auction scene gain an added layer of suspense from the reverberating calls of the auctioneer and the unsettling moos of the cattle. When violence breaks out, the track supports these peaks in intensity with increased dynamics and sporadic but effective use of LFE (Low-Frequency Effects), enhancing the overall emotional impact without becoming overbearing.
Incorporating traditional folk music as both underscore and diegetic elements, this DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track subtly yet powerfully contributes to the film's immersive quality, echoing the stark and haunting beauty of the rural Ozarks. Whether capturing quiet moments or sudden bursts of action, this expertly mixed audio presentation complements Winter's Bone, ensuring that every whisper, rustle, and chilling musical note draws viewers deeper into this atmospheric tale.
Extras: 46
The Blu-ray extras for "Winter's Bone" are a thoughtfully curated collection that significantly enhances the viewer's appreciation of the film. The audio commentary by director Debra Granik and cinematographer Michael McDonough offers an insightful deep dive into the filmmaking process, despite Granik's understated narration style. The "Making of 'Winter's Bone’" feature is particularly remarkable, providing a comprehensive 46-minute look behind the scenes, complete with prop discussions and scene setups. The deleted scenes come with informative notes from Granik, adding further context and making it a valuable inclusion. Additionally, the brief alternate opening and the score excerpt titled "Hardscrabble Elegy" contribute to providing a fuller picture of the film’s aesthetic and technical efforts. Although granular tech specifications and equipment mentions are absent, this collection remains a robust supplement for any fan.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: Insightful commentary by Debra Granik and Michael McDonough.
- Making of 'Winter's Bone': In-depth behind-the-scenes feature.
- Deleted Scenes: Contextual notes from director Debra Granik.
- Alternate Opening: Brief alternate opening scene.
- Hardscrabble Elegy: Super 8 footage set to the film’s score.
- Music Credits: Text info on source cues.
- Theatrical Trailer: Original movie trailer.
Movie: 81
Debra Granik's "Winter's Bone" is a stark and gripping portrayal of human resilience set against the unforgiving backdrop of the Ozarks. The film follows Ree Dolly, a 16-year-old girl who confronts an array of menacing characters to track down her missing father, a meth cooker who has disappeared, leaving their family home and land at risk of forfeiture. Jennifer Lawrence's portrayal of Ree is nothing short of revelatory, imbuing the character with an unyielding grit and emotional depth that underscores her quest for survival and familial responsibility. The narrative's resemblance to the Southern Gothic tradition enriches its atmospheric tension while evoking the resilience themes akin to Steinbeck.
Granik’s direction excels at depicting the bleak squalor and desolation of the Ozark backwoods, an environment populated with lawless, distrustful inhabitants ensnared in a patriarchy-driven subculture. Through meticulous attention to detail, the film brings to life an isolated community where an unspoken code of silence and brutality pervades. Each scene is saturated with the palpable tension of Ree navigating through this perilous terrain, encountering relatives bound by blood but severed by trust. Supporting actors such as John Hawkes and Dale Dickey add profound layers to this grim tableau with their fierce performances.
"Winter’s Bone" is both distressing and profound, capturing a visceral sense of human fortitude in dire circumstances. Granik's skillful use of folk music contrasts with the film’s stark visuals, providing a haunting score that mirrors Ree's relentless drive. The movie culminates in an unsettling yet riveting denouement that underscores the lengths to which Ree must go to safeguard her family’s future. This film is a powerful testament to the endurance of the human spirit under extreme duress and is elevated by Lawrence’s outstanding performance, marking her as one of contemporary cinema's most promising talents.
Total: 61
Review of "Winter's Bone" Blu-ray
"Winter's Bone" is an impactful film that intricately balances its grim narrative with a veneer of hope. Jennifer Lawrence's riveting portrayal of Ree Dolly elevates the film, marking her as one of the most promising new talents in recent years. Director Debra Granik's meticulous direction captures the stark realism of the Ozark backwoods without descending into caricature, offering a haunting yet authentic glimpse into a relentlessly unforgiving world.
From a technical standpoint, the Blu-ray presentation of "Winter's Bone" impresses with a sharp, clear transfer that faithfully reproduces the bleak, atmospheric cinematography. The audio quality complements the visuals effectively, embracing the ambient sounds and dialogue with precision. While the disc's special features may be sparse, this is somewhat expected given the film's indie origins. Nevertheless, these minor shortcomings do not detract significantly from the overall high quality of the release.
In conclusion, "Winter's Bone" on Blu-ray is a compelling watch that presents an extraordinary performance by Jennifer Lawrence amidst an unflinching depiction of hardship and resilience. Despite its often somber tone, the film, buoyed by Granik's deft direction and Lawrence’s talent, leaves an indelible impression. For cinephiles and casual viewers alike, "Winter's Bone" is highly recommended.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 90
The many interior shots, which similarly seem lit naturally a lot of the time, are clad in a lot of shadow and intentional murkiness and the low contrast means backgrounds just kind of disappear if they're...
Audio: 90
Winter's Bone offers a very subtle, yet insistently immersive, lossless DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track that benefits both from the ambient environmental sounds which populate the soundtrack, as well as...
Extras: 60
A quietly engaging Commentary by Granik and DP McDonough offers a wealth of background information, though truth be told, Granik's sometimes halting, extremely understated talking style was hard to listen...
Movie: 90
Winter's Bone may not have the subtle intellectualism of Steinbeck, and in fact owes more to the Southern Gothic tradition of Faulkner, Tennessee Williams and even Dickey himself, but the resilience of...
Total: 90
Jennifer Lawrence emerges as one of the most startling new talents in years with a nuanced and provocative portrayal as put upon teen Ree Dolly, and director Debra Granik manages to tread a very fine line...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
From the individual rust flakes that creep down the Dolly's refrigerator on the front porch, to the grotesque detail of a face after a beating, fine detail fares very well here....
Audio: 60
As Ree chases the person she's looking for into the back where all the cattle are stored, the echoing moos of the cows create an almost eerie feeling for the movie....
Extras: 40
They talk about filming the movie, how they adapted it from its source as a novel, and how they had to shoot the movie in freezing cold temperatures....
Movie: 80
She's a strong woman though, and it's always nice to see a movie with a strong female lead that gives all the alpha males a run for their money....
Total: 80
This is one of those performances that launches a career, and for my money, she's one of the best young actresses out there....
Director: Debra Granik
Actors: Jennifer Lawrence, John Hawkes, Garret Dillahunt
PlotIn a remote Ozarks community, a determined 17-year-old girl named Ree Dolly struggles to keep her impoverished family together. Her father, Jessup, has jumped bail after being arrested for manufacturing methamphetamine, putting their house and land up as collateral. To avoid losing their home, Ree must track down her elusive father, navigating a ruthless and tight-knit backwoods society that operates under its own set of codes and secrets. Despite her resilience, Ree faces intimidation and hostility from those who wish to keep Jessup's whereabouts hidden, including her extended family members deeply entwined with the local drug trade.
Ree's search leads her into dangerous encounters with meth dealers and violent relatives, testing her bravery and resolve. She is determined to uncover the truth while caring for her sick mother and younger siblings. As Ree delves deeper, she unearths dark secrets that challenge her perception of family and loyalty. The tension escalates as the stakes become life-threatening, forcing Ree to make hard choices to protect her loved ones and retain a semblance of home. Ree's journey is a raw and unflinching exploration of survival amidst adversity and a stark portrayal of the lengths one will go to for family.
Writers: Debra Granik, Anne Rosellini, Daniel Woodrell
Release Date: 16 Jul 2010
Runtime: 100 min
Rating: R
Country: United States
Language: English