The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Review
Score: 77
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
The Fellowship of the Ring's 4K release enhances its timeless fantasy, despite aging visuals.
Disc Release Date
2K Upscale
HDR10
Dolby Vision
Dolby Atmos
DTS-HD MA
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 77
The 4K UHD release of Fellowship of the Ring enhances fine detail, color, and contrast, offering a visually stunning experience despite minor CGI and noise reduction flaws.
Audio: 91
The new Dolby Atmos mix, akin to recent 4K discs, enriches the home theater experience with demo-worthy soundscapes, precise channel separation, and robust LFE, elevating both action sequences and subtler moments while maintaining crystal-clear dialogue and music.
Extra: 47
This 4K movie-only disc lacks bonus features, offering only theatrical and extended versions, with plans for a feature-rich edition in 2021.
Movie: 86
Peter Jackson's Lord of the Rings trilogy, a cultural and technical marvel, thrives on its timeless appeal, blending epic storytelling with groundbreaking effects, resonating with audiences in any era.
Video: 77
Warner Bros.' 2160p transfer of "The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring" for its 4K UHD Blu-ray release offers a significant visual upgrade that breathes new life into this early 2000s masterpiece. The application of HDR10 enhancement delivers a consistently excellent color boost without over-saturation. The lush greens of the Shire, the blue moonlight, and the fiery depths of Mount Doom are just a few examples where hues pop, enhancing the film’s magical atmosphere. Skin tones remain true to life, supporting the authenticity of scenes across diverse landscapes. Additionally, the transfer achieves remarkable improvements in contrast levels, from the enhanced mid-range contrast that adds depth to scenes to the deep blacks and glowing whites that elevate the visual drama.
The true highlight of this presentation lies in its incredible increase in detail and texture, making every scene a spectacle of fine craftsmanship. From the intricate designs of clothing and armor to the rugged landscapes of Middle Earth, the clarity and depth presented are unparalleled. This is evident right from the opening sequence, with close-ups and medium shots revealing nuances previously unseen on home video formats. The robust, film-like appearance maintained throughout the movie, coupled with a clean transfer free from perceivable compression issues, ensures a premium viewing experience. However, despite these advancements, some inherent limitations of early digital effects become apparent, revealing minor issues like noise reduction and the occasional softness in CGI deployment.
While digital compositions and CGI effects sometimes lack refinement, resulting in less polished scenes, these moments are few and far between. The 4K release successfully mitigates previous color grading concerns, particularly the intrusive green tint of earlier editions, allowing a more natural palette to emerge. Dolby Vision enhances the visual experience further by adding dimension to darker scenes without losing the subtlety in color variance and shadow detail. This release represents a monumental improvement over previous editions, offering fans a near-definitive visual experience that honors the epic scale and detailed craftsmanship of "The Fellowship of the Ring."
Audio: 91
The 4K UHD Blu-ray audio presentation of "The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring" with its new Dolby Atmos mix takes an already superb auditory experience to unprecedented heights, proving itself a standout amongst peers like "300" and "V for Vendetta". The meticulous remix encompasses an expansive array of demo-worthy sequences that showcase the impeccable use of discrete channel separation, panning effects, and the unique height channel that Dolby Atmos brings to the table. Particularly notable are the authentic atmospheric layers added to the immersive battles, the echoing depths of caverns, and even the serene moments like Bilbo's festive fireworks or the rush of the Falls of Rauros. The dynamic range is stunning, delivering crystal-clear dialogues, a robust LFE that brings volcanic eruptions and battles to vivid life, and sweeping musical cues that coalesce to craft a truly palpable Middle-earth. For those without Atmos capability, the included 7.1 track ensures no fan is left behind, maintaining a high-quality immersive experience.
Further enhancing the inclusivity of this cinematic marvel is a range of optional dubs and subtitles in various languages, alongside the thoughtful inclusion of forced subtitles for Elvish exchanges, primarily between Aragorn and Arwen. This attention to detail ensures a meticulously crafted auditory journey that is accessible to a wide audience. The sonic landscape of this film, from ambient environmental sounds like rustling leaves in overhead channels to the directional voicing and movement of characters and objects across the soundscape, exhibits a fluid, natural transition that impeccably captures every nuance of this epic tale.
Moreover, the audio mix excels in its dynamic handling of both action-packed scenes and quieter moments, with LFE channels reaching awe-inspiring depths that can only be described as "earthquake…ous". Whether it's the thunderous roar of a cavalry charge or the subtler sounds of Middle-earth, the audio presents an overwhelming sense of immersion. The purity and intensity of each sound element, be it the clash of swords or the harmonious score that underscores the journey, contributes to a richly layered audio experience that turns "The Fellowship of the Ring" into an unparalleled auditory spectacle. Through this exceptional audio technique, viewers are not just watching a film; they are being transported into the heart of Tolkien's world.
Extras: 47
The 4K UHD Blu-ray edition of "The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring" presents a unique case where the focus is squarely on the movie itself, offering both the theatrical and extended versions across three discs. Notably, this edition does not include any bonus features, a clear departure from standard home video releases that typically come packed with extras. Warner has indicated plans for a more feature-rich edition in 2021, which suggests that this release is aimed at purists and those prioritizing the highest possible fidelity in video and audio quality without the distraction of additional content. Consumers pondering over this edition should weigh their preference for immediate ownership against the anticipation of a more comprehensive package.
Extras included in this disc:
- There are no bonus features included on this 4K movie-only disc.
Movie: 86
In the realm of cinematic spectacle and narrative depth, Peter Jackson's "The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring," particularly its 4K UHD Blu Ray presentation, stands as a monumental achievement in film history. The adaptation of J.R.R. Tolkien's masterpiece took an ambitious leap by shooting all three films back-to-back, a risky endeavor that took over eight years and nearly $300 million to complete. This first chapter introduces audiences to the richly detailed and expansive world of Middle-Earth, capturing the essence and grandeur of its source material with fidelity. The 4K edition, devoid of any altered special effects, enhances this experience significantly, offering an exceptional 2160p transfer accompanied by a dynamic Dolby Atmos audio mix, thereby revitalizing Middle Earth for both longtime fans and new audiences without compromising on visual authenticity.
The film's release post-9/11 introduced it to a world fraught with anxiety and uncertainty, rendering its themes of unity, friendship, and the resistance against greed not just timely but timeless. "The Fellowship of the Ring" transcends the confines of its genre, appealing to a wide audience through its compelling narrative of diverse races uniting against a common foe. Its depiction of friendship and moral fortitude amidst adversity speaks volumes, resonating across different eras and reflecting societal challenges, be it the Red Scare of the '50s or the global uncertainties of the early 2000s. Moreover, the technical prowess of the movie, despite the passage of time, continues to captivate. While improvements in resolution reveal the limitations of early digital effects, they do not detract from the film's epic quality. Instead, they highlight the enduring power of storytelling that can embrace imperfections, much like the imagination does when engaging with Tolkien's written word.
In essence, "The Fellowship of the Ring" in 4K UHD is not merely a visual upgrade but a reaffirmation of the film’s iconic status. It brings to life Tolkien’s intricate world with unparalleled clarity and sound design, allowing both old fans and newcomers to experience Middle Earth in ways previously unimagined. The preservation of original special effects ensures authenticity, while the 4K resolution invites viewers to dive deeper into the textures of this fantastical world. Despite its age, the film remains a poignant narrative rich with themes that continue to resonate, establishing it as a timeless epic whose appeal only broadens with each viewing.
Total: 77
The 4K UHD Blu-Ray presentation of "The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring" continues to enchant and capture the hearts of both long-time fans and new audiences alike. Warner Bros. has meticulously transferred this cinematic gem into a 2160p resolution that remains faithful to its original visual splendor, ensuring that both the theatrical and extended cuts retain their immersive quality. Accompanied by a robust Dolby Atmos soundtrack, the audiovisual experience is nothing short of spectacular, providing an auditory punch that complements the film’s epic scale. Despite the absence of extras in The Motion Picture Trilogy 4K set, the pure quality of the film’s presentation stands as a testament to its enduring legacy.
However, it is worth noting that while the visual effects may have aged since its initial release in 2001, the core essence and raw fantasy that define "The Fellowship of the Ring" have not diminished. This release underscores the film's ability to transcend time, still resonating with viewers for its storytelling and craftsmanship. The dedication to preserving the quality of both the theatrical and extended versions ensures that every frame invites viewers into Middle-earth as vividly as possible.
In conclusion, Warner Bros.’ 4K UHD Blu-Ray release of "The Fellowship of the Ring" is an essential addition for collectors and fans, alike preserving the magic and majesty of one of cinema's most beloved fantasys. While it may lack additional content, the outstanding audiovisual presentation redefines what viewers can expect from home entertainment. This edition not only pays homage to the film's original allure but also enhances it for current and future generations to appreciate its unparalleled storytelling.
Blu-ray.com review by Randy Miller IIIRead review here
Video: 90
For starters, the UHD disc's HDR10 enhancement does a consistently excellent job of tastefully boosting certain hues into very appealing territory without going overboard, from the lush greens of the Shire...
Audio: 0
This is a tastefully remixed but extremely powerful track that shares a lot in common with other recent 4K discs like 300 and even V for Vendetta, showcasing countless demo-worthy sequences that are filled...
Extras: 100
...
Movie: 100
As of this writing, this title is only available as part of The Lord of the Rings: The Motion Picture Trilogy 4K. Peter Jackson's The Lord of the Rings trilogy broke new ground in the fantasy genre by...
Total: 0
Although it's not quite as "breathable" as its extended edition counterpart, the theatrical cut of The Fellowship of the Ring is still a top-tier fantasy film that will remain special to those first introduced...
DoBlu review by Matt PaprockiRead review here
Video: 80
Those inherent faults aside, the rest bestows Fellowship of the Ring with significant definition, certainly bettering a murky, processed Blu-ray....
Audio: 100
Sound takes up position as needed, whether something minor like a fireworks display or massive, clashing battles where mounted armies charge forward, and arrows sling between speakers....
Extras: 2
Both theatrical and extended versions (extended taking up two discs) and nothing else, but Warner plans a loaded edition in 2021....
Movie: 80
Then the ring itself, a representative of ruthless greed, less a power symbol as in other sword and sorcery fiction than a meaningful call to find those capable of resisting the urge....
Total: 66
While time sapped the visual effect’s prowess, at its heart, The Fellowship of the Ring maintains its raw fantasy, and works in the now as it did when first published....
Director: Peter Jackson
Actors: Elijah Wood, Ian McKellen, Orlando Bloom
PlotIn the peaceful Shire of Middle-earth, young hobbit Frodo Baggins inherits a seemingly innocuous ring from his elderly cousin Bilbo Baggins. However, the wizard Gandalf reveals that this is no ordinary ring—it is the One Ring, an instrument of unimaginable power forged by the Dark Lord Sauron to bend all of Middle-earth to his will. When it becomes evident that Sauron's forces are mobilizing to search for the ring, with the intent to restore Sauron to his full might, Frodo accepts the perilous task of taking the ring to the fires of Mount Doom, where it can be destroyed. He is joined by his loyal friends, fellow hobbits Sam, Merry, and Pippin, who decide to share in Frodo’s dangerous quest.
Setting out from the Shire, the quartet quickly encounters danger, leading them to the elven haven of Rivendell. Here, representatives of Middle-earth's various peoples—the humans Aragorn and Boromir, the elf Legolas, the dwarf Gimli, and Gandalf—come together and form the Fellowship of the Ring. This unlikely alliance pledges to protect Frodo on his journey to Mordor, the land where Mount Doom lies. As the Fellowship commences their trek across diverse and treacherous landscapes, they must contend with external threats from Sauron's minions and internal strife sparked by the ring's corrupting influence, which tests the bonds of their alliance and the resolve of their mission.
Writers: J.R.R. Tolkien, Fran Walsh, Philippa Boyens
Release Date: 19 Dec 2001
Runtime: 178 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: New Zealand, United States
Language: English, Sindarin