Madame Web Blu-ray Review
Score: 64
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Madame Web disappoints as a superhero film but shines in Blu-ray quality.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 81
Despite bland visuals, Sony's 1080p Blu-ray of Madame Web shines with lifelike colors, sharp details, and a consistent filmic grain, earning high praise for its video quality.
Audio: 81
Sony's DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 delivers immersive, clear audio with superb soundstage and separation, although slightly behind the 4K's Dolby Atmos and TrueHD 7.1. Engaging rear action and a solid LFE, despite some early underperformance, complement an excellent yet flawed movie."
Extra: 26
The Blu-ray extras, including behind-the-scenes insights and cast interviews, offer an unremarkable glimpse into Madame Web's making, casting, and action, without diving deep into its comic origins or delivering compelling content.
Movie: 21
Madame Web is a disastrously bad addition to the Spider-Man Universe, plagued by poor execution, lackluster effects, and nonsensical plots, making it a strong contender for worst MCU film.
Video: 81
Sony's release of "Madame Web" on Blu-ray delivers a notably polished 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 encode, in which the visual presentation is a distinct highlight despite criticism towards its cinematography and effects. The transfer shines with lifelike colors, exemplary skin tones, and well-defined details, ensuring that the textures—from costume stitching to urban architecture—stand out with clarity and precision. The original 2.39:1 aspect ratio augments this clarity, contributing to a genuinely filmic experience with a consistent fine grain and absence of digital flaws such as macroblocking or banding. Although there is a notable crush in the shadows possibly detracting from the overall definition compared to its 4K UHD version, this Blu-ray manages to present a visual feast that faithfully reproduces the theatrical experience.
The video quality consistently impresses with its sharpness, particularly in close-ups where facial textures and minor flaws become evident, adding to the film’s realism. Color reproduction is another area where this release excels; despite a predominance of teal-orange cinematography that could overwhelm, the transfer maintains vibrant and saturated primaries. Scenes are bathed in fiery oranges and warm golden yellows without sacrificing the richness of reds and blues. Even in lower lighting conditions, blacks remain deep and inky, contributing to an image with significant depth and a cinematic appeal that keeps viewers engaged.
In terms of dynamic range, although contrast is slightly muted—possibly a creative choice—the blacks are still profound, aiding in the creation of an image that boasts admirable depth and dimension. The consistent contrast ensures that whites remain brilliant without bleeding over, especially noticeable in daylight scenes, which altogether supports an attractive representation on Blu-ray. Sony’s effort on the "Madame Web" Blu-ray thus showcases a transfer that captures and presents the film with meticulous attention to detail and a strong commitment to preserving the movie's visual integrity.
Audio: 81
The Blu-ray audio presentation of "Madame Web" impresses with its Sony DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround track, which compensates for the visual elements by injecting a vivid energy into the overall experience. The sound quality, while not reaching the full dynamic range or immersive impact of the 4K release's Dolby Atmos or the Dolby TrueHD 7.1 options, offers a commendably clear and balanced audio experience. Dialogue remains crisp and well-prioritized against a backdrop of chaotic superhero action, ensuring that voices are never lost amidst the auditory spectacle. The mix effectively uses the rear channels, providing an aggressively engaging soundscape with precise directionality and smooth transition between scenes, though it occasionally suffers from a less than potent LFE channel, particularly noticeable in earlier action scenes.
The soundstage is broad and continuously engaging, marked by excellent channel separation that brings to life the atmospheric layers of the audio track. Background sounds fill the environment with a vibrant variety of noises—from bustling cityscapes to the intense cacophony of action sequences—crafting an immersive experience that extends well beyond the visual confines of the screen. The mid-range is particularly noteworthy for its clarity during high-volume scenes, allowing the soundtrack and sound effects to complement each other without overwhelming the listener. Moreover, the low-end provides a robust foundation that enhances both the music and the physicality of on-screen events, contributing to a more tangible sense of immersion.
Overall, despite "Madame Web" enduring as a somewhat excessively verbose narrative that occasionally detracts from the auditory experience, the sophisticated use of sound design and mixing triumphs in creating a compelling audiovisual journey. This DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track showcases meticulous attention to detail in its sound field reproduction and directionality, bolstered by a solid low-frequency performance that, even with occasional shortcomings, ensures an impactful and enveloping listening environment.
Extra: 26
The Blu-ray extras for "Madame Web" offer a blend of behind-the-scenes insights and fluff that might only partly satisfy hardcore fans. With features like "Casting the Web," providing a superficial look at the casting process, and "Future Vision," showcasing the film's vision sequences with commentary from cast and filmmakers, the content feels underwhelming and lacks depth. "Oracle of the Page" and "The Many Threads of Madame Web" tease fans with comic book inspirations and hidden Easter eggs, but leave viewers wanting more. The action sequences get a brief spotlight in "Fight Like a Spider," which doesn't quite capture the excitement one would expect. A standard gag reel and a solitary deleted scene round out the offerings, making the whole package feel like a missed opportunity to delve deeper into the world of Madame Web.
Extras included in this disc:
- Future Vision: Filming Madame's visions with cast and filmmaker commentary.
- Casting the Web: A look at the casting process.
- Oracle of the Page: Exploration of the comics that inspired the film.
- The Many Threads of Madame Web: Reveals Easter eggs found in the movie.
- Fight Like a Spider: Discusses the movie's action sequences.
- Gag Reel: Outtakes from filming.
- Deleted Scene: A single cut scene from the film.
Movie: 21
The cinematic venture into Sony's Spider-Man Universe hits a bewildering nadir with "Madame Web," a film that daringly embarks on exploring the lesser-known corridors of the Spiderverse, only to find itself ensnared in a web of its own making. The decision to spotlight Madame Web, a character far removed from the front ranks of Marvel's storied heroes, paired with a stellar cast led by Dakota Johnson, unfortunately, culminates in disappointment. The film's ambition is undercut by a mishmash of perplexing script choices, underdeveloped plot points, and an underwhelming utilization of visual effects and action sequences, leaving audiences to navigate through a narrative morass that is devoid of the dynamic energy typically associated with the genre.
At the heart of "Madame Web" lies a confusing tale that scrambles through time, from South America in 1973 to the turn of the millennium, presenting a jarring origin story interwoven with clunky dialogue and questionable character motivations. The inclusion of references to established Spider-Man lore, such as the inexplicable involvement of Ben Parker and overt nods to the broader Marvel universe, feels more like an attempt to anchor the film within a recognizable framework than serve any narrative necessity. Moreover, S.J. Clarkson's directorial effort fails to rescue the film from the quagmire of its convoluted storyline and awkwardly staged action, further hampered by a color palette that exaggerates rather than enhances, courtesy of cinematographer Mauro Fiore.
The ensemble cast, despite their commendable efforts, is tethered to a script that oscillates between attempting profundity and veering into the absurd, with dialogue that frequently induces more cringes than awe. Production values and costume design similarly falter, offering little in the way of visually arresting superhero iconography, instead opting for an aesthetic that feels uncomfortably pedestrian for a film aspiring to stand alongside its Marvel counterparts. "Madame Web" ultimately emerges as a confounding addition to the superhero genre, characterized by missed opportunities and a palpable disconnect between its ambitious vision and the underwhelming reality it presents on screen.
Total: 64
"Madame Web," Sony's latest venture into its Spider-Man Universe, not only fails to spin a captivating web of the superhero narrative but also lands itself among the notable disappointments within the genre, reminiscent of infamous titles such as "Batman and Robin," "Catwoman," and others that have similarly missed the mark. Despite featuring a cast led by Dakota Johnson, Sydney Sweeney, and Tahar Rahim, the film's execution from script to production fumbles, rendering it a bizarre spectacle that might only be appreciated as an unintentional satire rather than a genuine superhero flick. However, its Blu-ray release offers a silver lining with an outstanding video and impressive DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround track that partially redeems the viewing experience.
The Blu-ray edition, presented by Sony Pictures Home Entertainment, demonstrates the industry's capacity to salvage what can only be dubbed as a cinematic misadventure through technical excellence. The visual and auditory presentation is striking, ensuring that the film's action sequences and visual dynamics are enjoyed to their fullest even if the narrative underwhelms. This dichotomy of poor storytelling juxtaposed with superior technical delivery makes the Blu-ray a curious case of good disc, bad flick. Nonetheless, the package is marred by a lackluster collection of supplements, which further cements its status as a missed opportunity rather than a collector's item.
In conclusion, "Madame Web" on Blu-ray stands as a testament to the notion that even the most disappointing films can offer something of value in terms of home entertainment technology. While the movie fails to enthrall or engage on nearly all fronts, the Blu-ray version affords a visually and audibly impressive experience that might marginally salvage an otherwise forgettable viewing. Viewers tempted by the allure of high-definition may find it "Worth a Look," but should adjust expectations accordingly, approaching with caution and perhaps a sense of humor about the journey they're about to embark on.
Blu-ray.com review by Kenneth BrownRead review here
Video: 90
Detail is spot on as well, with crisp edge definition, nicely refined textures, and a fine, filmic touch of grain that remains consistent....
Audio: 90
I found the LFE channel to be a tad lacking at times (particularly in early action sequences), though it certainly makes its presence known on the whole as well as amidst the destruction of the third act's...
Extras: 40
Casting the Web (HD, 9 minutes) - It might surprise you to learn casting for Madame Web extended beyond the requisite "looks hot", but not so much further that I buy into the claim that deep thought was...
Movie: 30
Imagine for a moment, if you'll indulge me, that Madame Web was the sort of time-bending stand-out that featured scenes of Cassie "learning" from future Spideys, Peter among them; or the risk that Ezekiel's...
Total: 60
But it will most likely continue to stand as the worst modern superhero flick in recent memory, finding better company in the anti-classics of yesteryear (Batman and Robin, Catwoman, 2015's Fantastic Four,...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Presented in its original 2.39:1 aspect ratio, black levels are accurate and inky rich, providing the image with appreciable depth and an attractive cinematic appeal....
Audio: 80
The atmospherics flawlessly move through the surrounds with discreteness and convincing effectiveness, nicely expanding the soundfield and enveloping the listening area....
Extras: 20
Casting the Web (HD, 9 min) Future Vision (HD, 7 min) Fight Like a Spider (HD, 6 min) Oracle of the Page (HD, 5 min) The Many Threads of Madame Web (HD, 4 min) Gag Reel (HD, 5 min) Deleted Scene (HD, 1...
Movie: 20
From the script and dialogue to the entire production itself, just about everything is wrong with Madame Web — better enjoyed as an unintentional comedy rather than a genuine superhero actioner....
Total: 60
Sony Pictures Home Entertainment brings the superhero flick to Blu-ray with an impressive audio and video presentation, but with a mediocre collection of supplements, the overall package is just another...
Director: S.J. Clarkson
Actors: Dakota Johnson, Sydney Sweeney, Isabela Merced
PlotIn a bustling metropolis teeming with heroes and criminals alike, Julia Carpenter, a brilliant but overlooked scientist, discovers a mysterious artifact that grants her extraordinary psychic abilities, including precognition and telepathy. The artifact’s power draws her into a hidden world of supernatural powers and ancient secrets. Initially overwhelmed by her newfound abilities, Julia struggles with her transformation and the isolation it brings. Her life takes a dramatic turn when she uses her powers to save a stranger, drawing unwanted attention from both malevolent and benevolent forces seeking to control or exploit her abilities.
As Julia delves deeper into the labyrinth of her own power, she forms an unlikely alliance with a group of young women, each harboring secrets and abilities of their own. Together, they navigate the intricate web of their pasts, uncovering connections that bind them in unexpected ways. Their journey reveals a conspiracy that threatens to disrupt the balance between the human and supernatural worlds. Faced with escalating dangers, Julia must learn to master her powers to protect herself and her newfound allies. Her quest not only challenges her understanding of reality but also forces her to confront questions about destiny, free will, and the true meaning of heroism in a world where the lines between good and evil are blurred.
Writers: Matt Sazama, Burk Sharpless, Claire Parker
Release Date: 14 Feb 2024
Runtime: 116 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States
Language: English