Creature with the Blue Hand Blu-ray Review
Die Blaue Hand
Score: 74
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
A captivating Krimi classic, 'Creature with the Blue Hand' shines in this Blu-ray edition with solid remastering; a must for genre enthusiasts.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 76
Film Masters' Blu-ray of 'Creature with the Blue Hand' impressively displays an AVC encoded 1080p transfer from 4K scans of 35mm elements, offering commendable detail in close-ups and vivid reds. Despite color timing variabilities and blue-green hues, the digital cleanup minimizes dirt and scratches, retaining natural grain.
Audio: 71
Creature with the Blue Hand offers a DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 Mono track, delivering clear dialogue and sharp music, despite its limited dynamic range and boxy sound. While the English dubbing may seem substandard, the soundtrack effectively supports effects, albeit without original German or Italian tracks.
Extra: 86
The Blu-ray extras for "Creature with the Blue Hand" are commendably rich: engaging commentary by Stephen Jones and Kim Newman, insightful features on Edgar Wallace and "Krimis," plus both original and recreated trailers. The bonus film, "The Bloody Dead," is a gore-enhanced cut with archival extras, all complemented by optional English subtitles.
Movie: 56
Film Masters' Blu-ray of 'Creature with the Blue Hand' deftly revives the cult classic with a vivid restoration and comprehensive extras, including a dynamic Klaus Kinski performance as twins amidst a thrilling plot, resonating with Mario Bava's stylistic flair and a jazzy, reminiscent score.
Video: 76
"Creature with the Blue Hand" is presented on Blu-ray by Film Masters, utilizing an AVC encoded 1080p transfer from a scan in 4K of 35mm archival elements. The aspect ratio is set at 1.67:1. The transfer lacks detailed technical specifications, yet it stands significantly improved over prior versions, including bootlegs. Color timing is notably variable; several scenes possess a blue to blue-green tint, particularly noticeable in early sequences, while other areas gravitate towards a green or yellow-green hue. Despite these inconsistencies, there are extended segments where the colors appear more natural, if not consistent overall. Detailing is generally impressive; close-ups frequently reveal commendable levels of detail, although shadow detail remains limited with darker sequences exhibiting blue or purplish blacks.
The digital cleanup executed by Film Masters is laudable, resulting in an image nearly devoid of dirt or scratches. The texture is enhanced, with intricate details such as lace curtains and hair strands popping off the screen. The remastering efforts have yielded vivid reds and skin tones, enhancing the visual appeal significantly from the original 35mm prints. Although grain is present, it is mottled rather than overtly intrusive, indicating minimal digital scrubbing. Contrast remains a variable attribute with some darker segments lacking depth in shadow detail.
Overall, while "Creature with the Blue Hand" undergoes variances in color timing and contrast, the effort put into creating a sharper and cleaner presentation from its archival origins shines through. The transfer effectively showcases the film with improved detail and texture, granting it a refreshed visual presence.
Audio: 71
The audio presentation of "Creature with the Blue Hand" on Blu Ray features a DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 Mono track, accompanied by a Dolby Digital option. The dubbing might be perceived as substandard by some, potentially affecting the overall experience. However, the audio quality is surprisingly commendable for a film of its era, with music and sound effects delivered with noteworthy sharpness and clarity. Despite this, some may find the track slightly boxy and lacking an extensive dynamic range.
Dialogue is presented cleanly and coherently across the track, maintaining clarity throughout, which contributes positively to the viewing experience. A noticeable advantage is the provision of optional English subtitles, which are useful for those who prefer text to accompany the well-preserved audio dialogue.
It’s important to note that original language tracks—German for "Creature" and Italian for "Web of the Spider"—are absent, as these versions focus on the American releases. While the track for "Creature with the Blue Hand" is robust in its support for scoring and sound effects, providing an engaging albeit retro soundscape, its counterpart "Web of the Spider" is less fortunate, marked by harsher music and voices that reflect constraints likely inherent to its original mix. Overall, the technical presentation succeeds in preserving the historic audio quality while meeting modern standards adequately.
Extra: 86
The Blu-ray extras for "Creature with the Blue Hand" provide an engaging blend of insights and retrospectives that elevate the viewing experience for film enthusiasts. The audio commentary by Stephen Jones and Kim Newman stands out as both entertaining and informative, dissecting differences across various cuts of the film. The featurette "A Man of Mystery: Inside the World of Edgar Wallace" offers a nuanced overview of the prolific writer's career, while "Kinski Krimis: Inside the Rialto Film Adaptations" delves into the German film adaptations with expert commentary by C. Courtney Joyner. In addition to the original and re-created trailers, "The Bloody Dead" alternate cut includes added archival insights and raw footage that unfold the intricate details of its re-edit.
Extras included in this disc:
- Commentary with Stephen Jones and Kim Newman: Insightful discussion accompanied by subtitles.
- A Man of Mystery: Exploration of Edgar Wallace’s literary impact.
- Kinski Krimis: Examination of Rialto Film's series adaptations.
- Original 1967 Trailer
- Re-created Trailer
- The Bloody Dead Bonus Film: Alternate cut with additional commentary.
- The Bloody Dead Raw Footage: Contains behind-the-scenes gore inserts.
Movie: 56
Film Masters' Blu-ray release of "Creature with the Blue Hand," a West German adaptation of Edgar Wallace's "The Blue Hand," expertly captures the campy essence of the 1960s Rialto Krimi genre. Klaus Kinski delivers a captivating dual performance as identical twins, introducing an intriguing dynamic where one twin, Dave, is portrayed as a lunatic consigned to an asylum, only to escape with sinister intentions to impersonate the ostensibly sane Richard. This narrative twist unfolds within an atmosphere reminiscent of Mario Bava's stylistic touches, complete with ominous castles and vividly colored lighting that compounds even minor suspense with a peculiar visual allure. Despite its splintered mystery and occasional narrative incoherence—partially attributed to edits for its English-language version—the film surprises viewers with its inherent entertainment value and its bizarre yet captivating performances.
The interaction between performances and production design contributes significantly to the film's far-reaching appeal beyond its primary audience. The portrayal of chaos amidst a family laden with secrets sets against a pervasive sense of gothic eeriness, where betrayals and preposterously mounted traps create an enigmatic viewing experience, delightfully excessive in nature. While the plot may unravel in a disjointed fashion, particularly as it skews away from the traditional detective story elements of the genre, it further invites cult interest due to its almost absurdist overtones—most notably through Kinski's exaggerated expressions and physicality.
The Film Masters release augment this cinematic oddity with pristine remastering and a fascinating collection of extras, including commentary by B-movie luminary Sam Sherman. Psychologically complex yet comically overwrought sequences ensure "Creature with the Blue Hand" stands as both emblematic of its genre's peculiarities and an engaging spectacle, enriched by its compelling score reminiscent of John Barry's 60s work, offering viewers both an auditory and visual throwback experience that remains invigorating amidst today's remastered releases.
Total: 74
"Creature with the Blue Hand" on Blu-ray is a compelling entry into the Krimi genre, attracting attention for its unique narrative and iconic performances, particularly from Klaus Kinski. The film, which holds a notable position within the Rialto Krimi series, offers a rich ensemble of eccentric supporting characters that enhance its entertainment value. Technical aspects are generally satisfactory, though some viewers may take note of peculiarities in the color timing. Despite this, the film's restoration is praiseworthy, with significant effort evidenced in the meticulous remastering and cleanup processes.
The Blu-ray edition of "Creature with the Blue Hand" further distinguishes itself through its high-quality supplements. These include intriguing content such as a gory remake, which adds additional layers of interest for enthusiasts and collectors. The extra features elevate the package into a realm similar to that of the esteemed Criterion Collection, specifically within the B-movie domain. This level of care in presentation and additional material makes it a valuable acquisition for fans of the genre.
In conclusion, "Creature with the Blue Hand" is a recommended Blu-ray purchase, particularly for those interested in exploring the Krimi series. While there are minor technical caveats regarding color timing, the overall presentation, supported by extensive extras, makes it a worthy addition to any film collection. The Krimi series merits more recognition from Blu-ray labels, offering a treasure trove of material for avid consumers.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 70
Contrast is another variable issue, and some of the darkest material while also offering kind of blue or purplish blacks, don't deliver much in the way of shadow detail....
Audio: 70
The dubbing here is probably going to strike many as substandard, but aside from that issue the track is noticeably boxy and without a ton of dynamic range....
Extras: 80
Inside the Rialto Film Adaptations (HD; 17:42) offers C. Courtney Joyner discussing this series which was huge in Germany, but which never received a ton of attention in the United States....
Movie: 70
While commentators Kim Newman and Stephen Jones probably understandably concentrate on this production as one of the innumerable so-called "Rialto Krimi" films (something that's also addressed in this...
Total: 70
The Krimi series certainly deserves more attention from Blu-ray labels, and there is certainly no dearth of material to offer interested consumers in that regard....
Home Theater Forum review by Patrick McCartRead review here
Video: 90
While it is also very clean, it can be a bit grainy at times and it seems like less success was obtained recovering faded color from the image....
Audio: 80
The track on Web of the Spider doesn’t fare as well, with harsher music and boxier voices, which are most likely just how the original track was mixed....
Extras: 100
Disc Two: Audio commentary by film historians Stephen Jones and Kim Newman Castle of Blood theatrical trailer (1:42 SD) – trailer for the English language dub of the 1964 film remade as Web of the Spider....
Movie: 50
From some research online, there seems to be a minor following of these series of “Krimis” since there were quite a lot of these made in the 60s and 70s....
Total: 90
I found Creature with the Blue Hand to be the more entertaining of the two films, just the excellent remastering and cleanup of the films, plus the trademark Film Masters extras making these special editions...
Director: Alfred Vohrer, Samuel M. Sherman
Actors: Harald Leipnitz, Klaus Kinski, Carl Lange
PlotIn a grim, foreboding atmosphere, a high-security mental institution plays host to a chilling scenario. The story begins when the notorious serial killer, David Emerson, deemed insane, is accused of horrific murders. Despite being declared mad, Emerson consistently claims innocence, maintaining that a mysterious "Blue Hand" is the true culprit. His twin brother Richard, who closely resembles him, is concerned and skeptical of the accusations laid against David. Meanwhile, an inexplicable escape from the institution sets off a series of macabre events, triggering the authorities to launch an investigation. Suspicion looms over the entire Emerson family, especially as secrets and tensions simmer beneath their respectable facade.
As bodies start piling up around an old ancestral estate owned by the Emerson family, it's clear that no one can be trusted. The investigation circles back to David and this enigmatic Blue Hand figure. Both themes of identity and madness envelop the narrative, with long-held family mysteries coming to light. The eerie atmosphere grows tense as the detectives must unravel the twisted threads connecting the Emerson family history with the grim sequence of killings. Motives blend with madness, and deception hides within the shadowy corridors of power and relationships, leaving everyone questioning who might possess motives to kill. Amid suspense and suspicion, the fluid dynamic between familial loyalty and distrust comes to a harrowing head halfway through, leaving audiences on edge.
Writers: Herbert Reinecker, Edgar Wallace, Fred Denger
Release Date: N/A
Runtime: 87 min
Rating: GP
Country: West Germany
Language: German