Relentless Enemies Blu-ray Review
Score: 46
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Relentless Enemies: A visually stunning, detailed dive into unique lions' lives on Blu-ray.
Disc Release Date
Video: 53
Relentless Enemies" impresses with its VC-1 1080p details and vivid colors, offering an exemplary high-definition wildlife documentary experience despite minor inconsistencies and mastering quirks.
Audio: 48
Despite its Dolby Digital 5.1 mix, the Blu-ray's audio is criticized for heavy center channel use and a lack of immersion, contrasting with 'Relentless Enemies'' balanced, organic sound with an active surround presence.
Extra: 16
The 'Relentless Enemies' Blu-ray disappoints with few extras, including a subpar 'Cheetah Chase' featurette and standard-def trailers, lacking depth or high-quality visuals.
Movie: 71
Relentless Enemies captivates with stunning HD footage and intense lion-buffalo dynamics, balancing the harsh realities of nature with deep admiration for African wildlife.
Video: 53
'Relentless Enemies' presents a visually compelling journey into the wild, captured in a stunning 1.78:1 widescreen 1080p/VC-1 encode that averages around 15 Mbps. This National Geographic documentary, simultaneously released on Blu-ray and HD DVD, showcases the power of high-definition video to bring viewers closer to nature. Encoded using VC-1, the video quality exhibits a range of sharp, film-like sequences with preserved fine detail and grain, particularly noticeable in scenes filled with lush landscapes and vibrant wildlife. Despite some inconsistencies, likely due to the challenges of filming in varying environmental conditions, the detail and depth in most of the documentary are exceptional. Close-ups of the big cats and the landscapes of Africa are particularly impressive, revealing individual hairs and the intricate patterns of the environment with clarity that is almost otherworldly.
The documentary benefits from National Geographic's judicious use of film over HD video, offering a superior visual experience that outshines other high-profile documentaries. Despite encountering softer sequences and slight posterization in light reflections, these minor setbacks do not detract significantly from the overall immersive viewing experience. 'Relentless Enemies' takes full advantage of its format, showcasing brilliant sunsets, striking color palettes, and fast-paced action without succumbing to macroblocking, even in scenes abundant with water splashes and rapid movements.
While night shots exhibit more grain and appear flatter compared to the vivid daylight scenes, they still surpass standard-definition quality and contribute to the documentary's dynamic visual range. The commitment to high-quality video production is evident in the meticulous capture and presentation of both serene and intense moments within the Okavango watershed. This release offers a glimpse into the capabilities of high-definition documentaries to render wildlife and natural settings with an unprecedented level of detail and realism.
Audio: 48
The audio presentation of "Relentless Enemies" on Blu-ray leaves a mixed impression, primarily due to its reliance on a Dolby Digital 5.1 mix. This choice is somewhat disappointing given the rich potential for immersive audio in nature documentaries. The mix heavily favors the center channel, with Jeremy Irons' narration and a surprising majority of the environmental sounds, including animal vocalizations and ambient noises, being anchored here. This focus results in an audio experience that feels unbalanced and less dynamic than expected. The use of the center channel for such a wide array of sounds limits the scope for immersion, as the side and rear channels are underutilized, save for some ambiance and the occasionally stirring musical score.
Despite these criticisms, the soundtrack has its merits. The Dolby Digital 5.1 surround track, running at 640kbps, manages to create an organic and balanced soundscape when it fully utilizes its surround capabilities. The audible presence of nature’s subtleties, from thunder rolling through the rear channels to the startling clarity of localized animal cries, adds layers to the viewing experience. The narration by Jeremy Irons is crisp and authoritative, complementing the natural sounds and the generic yet fitting percussive score that gains depth from the surround sound mix.
It's evident that with more consistent use of all audio channels and perhaps a transition to a lossless format, the audio quality of "Relentless Enemies" could have been significantly enhanced. The elements for a truly enveloping nature documentary experience are there – from the detailed on-location sound recordings to Irons' compelling narration and an effective score. Yet, the overall execution falls short of its potential, primarily due to an over-reliance on the center channel and a missed opportunity to fully engage with a more modern, lossless audio codec.
Extras: 16
The extras on the "Relentless Enemies" Blu-ray could best be described as sparse, yet somewhat intriguing for enthusiasts of wildlife documentaries, offering a closer peek behind the curtain of nature's untamed dramas. The highlight, a 26-minute featurette titled "Cheetah Chase," takes viewers into the Botswana bush alongside National Geographic photographer Chris Johns and colleague Dave Hamman. Despite being presented in a less-than-ideal 480p standard definition, this piece offers an engaging look at the challenges faced while capturing the fleet-footed cheetah. However, the choice of extras raises questions, particularly the inclusion of "Cheetah Chase" over potentially more insightful behind-the-scenes content regarding the Blu-ray's main feature. Other supplements include trailers and TV spots for National Geographic productions, such as "Eternal Enemies," "The Eye of the Leopard," and "In Search of the Jaguar," which, despite their standard definition quality, may pique the interest of wildlife aficionados.
Extras included in this disc:
- Cheetah Chase: Follows photographer Chris Johns and Dave Hamman in their quest to document cheetahs in the wild.
- Trailers and TV Spots: Include promotional content for National Geographic channels and services, alongside previews for other wildlife documentaries like "Eternal Enemies," "The Eye of the Leopard," and "In Search of the Jaguar."
Movie: 71
'Relentless Enemies' emerges as a standout documentary amidst a sea of nature films, primarily owing to its concentrated focus on the extraordinary lives of the Tsaro lionesses and their buffalo adversaries in the Okavango Delta. The film provides an intimate look into the adaptable strategies and unique characteristics of these lions, hallmarking a narrative that divests from the typical portrayal of African wildlife. The meticulous two-year filming span, employing high-definition technology, enriches the viewing experience with crisp and detailed visuals, accentuating the raw and unfiltered essence of nature at its most primal. The sheer dedication of the crew, led by the esteemed husband-and-wife team Dereck and Beverly Joubert, exemplifies the commendable yet often underappreciated rigor involved in capturing such breathtaking wildlife footage.
The narrative is further elevated by Jeremy Irons' compelling narration, whose timbre adds a dramatic layer, reminiscent at moments of a real-life 'Lion King.' Despite certain critique points regarding its protracted focus and somewhat repetitive narration, the documentary does not fail to engage. The intimacy of the lion prides' battles, hunts, and familial bonds crafts a story that surpasses simple animal observation, inviting audiences into a world where survival hinges on strength, strategy, and resilience.
Technical prowess aside, 'Relentless Enemies' transcends mere documentation, touching upon deeper themes of evolution, adaptation, and survival in harsh conditions. The specificity of its focus, paired with superior cinematography, makes it a compelling watch unlike any generic nature documentary. While it may not reinvent the genre wheel, its execution and deeply immersive storytelling herald a remarkable viewing experience that both educates and enthralls, ensuring that its subjects' relentless spirits are captured with both grace and grit.
Total: 46
"Relentless Enemies" on Blu-ray presents an exceptional viewing experience that merges educational content with captivating visuals, making it a must-have for aficionados of nature documentaries, as well as enthusiasts of African wildlife and landscapes. The film delves into the unique existence of the Tsaro lionesses, providing a narrative that is as enlightening as it is visually entrancing. Narrated by the acclaimed Jeremy Irons, the documentary excels in delivering a profound script with superior camerawork, showcasing the splendor of the African terrain and its majestic inhabitants in high definition. This release by National Geographic not only meets but surpasses expectations with its exceptional video and audio quality, bringing the allure of the wild into the comfort of one's home.
While "Relentless Enemies" stands out for its breathtaking cinematography and educational value, it maintains a balance that might not cater to those in search of a thriller. However, it compensates with its plethora of stunning visuals and engaging insights into the lives of one of nature's most fascinating predators. The Blu-ray edition also surprises with an in-depth featurette, shedding light on the creative forces behind the scenes, offering viewers a comprehensive package that enhances their viewing experience.
In conclusion, "Relentless Enemies" on Blu-ray is a commendable addition to any collection, blending the beauty of African landscapes with the compelling story of survival among the Tsaro lionesses. Its superb video and audio presentation, coupled with Jeremy Irons' narration and the additional featurette, make it an indispensable resource for educators, wildlife enthusiasts, and fans of quality documentaries. Whether it's for the educational content or the sheer visual feast, this release proves to be a valuable and insightful exploration of nature's relentless dynamics.
Blu-ray.com review by Lindsay MayerRead review here
Video: 70
Despite its minor fallbacks, the picture quality really is quite stellar, and is the first opportunity to see a dedicated lion documentary as it has never been seen before....
Audio: 60
Overall, the audio is uneven and distracting during playback, with far too much leaning front and center to really "immerse" the viewer into the leonine experience....
Extras: 20
One would suppose it's really the same as any wildlife filming, though; sit around for agonizing stretches of time with the cameras poised and hope something interesting happens....
Movie: 90
The African Lion is undoubtedly the most thoroughly filmed cat of any; their social behavior, hunting techniques, and relationship to man and beast have been exhaustively covered on camera in the last...
Total: 70
What is refreshing about Relentless Enemies, however, is the film's portrait of a unique group of specimens carving out a specialized niche, and all the benefits and fallbacks it brings them....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
The notes from National Geographic indicate that 'Relentless Enemies' was shot on film, not HD video, and as such, I now feel somewhat guilty that I gave such a high video rating recently to 'March of...
Audio: 80
But this mix sounds pretty organic and balanced, without the narration and dialogue overwhelming the natural elements....
Extras: 20
Johns spends a great deal of time in Africa, and the doc offers good insight on the considerable challenges and physical obstacles he faces in photographing some of the world's most dangerous animals....
Movie: 60
It takes a rare breed of doc to rise above the dreaded "educational" label, and unless you're really telling a captivating story, all the fabulous shots of rampaging buffalo and toothy tigers quickly blur...
Total: 60
But if you love big cats, or African landscapes, this is some pretty fantastic eye candy -- in fact, this film is filled with so many gorgeous images and magnificent creatures that it is easy to forget...
Director: Beverly Joubert, Dereck Joubert
Actors: Jeremy Irons
PlotIn the heart of the Okavango Delta in Botswana, an extraordinary and unique conflict unfolds. The narrative is centered around the intense and ongoing struggle for survival between two of nature's most formidable predators: a pride of lions and a herd of buffalo. This remote wilderness serves as the backdrop for a brutal and relentless battle of strength, endurance, and cunning. Both species are pushed to their limits, as the lions seek to secure a meal to sustain their pride, while the buffalo fight to protect their own from becoming the lions' prey. Each confrontation and strategy employed by these animals highlights the harsh realities of life in the wild and the relentless drive to survive.
As the seasons change, so too does the dynamic of this perpetual conflict. The film explores the intricacies of animal behavior and the deep-seated instincts that drive these creatures. It delves into the strategies employed by the lions as they hunt and the counter-strategies of the buffalo in their attempts to evade capture. The viewer gains an intimate glimpse into the lives of these animals, witnessing their moments of triumph and tragedy. The ongoing cycle of life and death in the Okavango Delta is presented as a testament to the resilience of nature and the unending struggle for dominance and survival in the animal kingdom.
Writers: Dereck Joubert
Release Date: 27 Mar 2007
Runtime: 90 min
Rating: N/A
Country: USA
Language: English